University of Sao Paulo
History
In the first millennium BC, communities in Italy underwent crucial transformations which scholars have often subsumed under the heading of ‘state formation’, namely increased social stratification, the centralisation of political power... more
In the first millennium BC, communities in Italy underwent crucial transformations which scholars have often subsumed under the heading of ‘state formation’, namely increased social stratification, the centralisation of political power and, in some cases, urbanisation. Most research has tended to approach the phenomenon of state formation and social change in relation to specific territorial dynamics of growth and expansion, changing modes of exploitation of food and other resources over time, and the adoption of selected socio-ritual practices by the ruling élites in order to construct and negotiate authority. In contrast, comparatively little attention has been paid to the question of how these key developments resonated across the broader social transect, and how social groups other than ruling élites both promoted these changes and experienced their effects. The chief aim of this collection of 14 papers is to harness innovative approaches to the exceptionally rich mortuary evidence of first millennium BC Italy, in order to investigate the roles and identities of social actors who either struggled for power and social recognition, or were manipulated and exploited by superior authorities in a phase of tumultuous socio-political change throughout the entire Mediterranean basin. Contributors provide a diverse range of approaches in order to examijne how power operated in society, how it was exercised and resisted, and how this can be studied through mortuary evidence.
Section 1 addresses the construction of identity by focusing mainly on the manipulation of age, ethnic and gender categories in society in regions and sites that reached notable power and splendour in first millennium BC Italy. These include Etruria, Latium, Campania and the rich settlement of Verucchio, in Emilia Romagna.
Section 2 offers a counterpoint to Section 1 by focusing on the concepts of ‘periphery’, marginality and the frailty of élite (or sub-élite) power in phases of dramatic socio-political change. Moreover, this Section approaches the idea of identity construction in ‘fringe’ geographical areas that are sometimes overlooked in Anglophone scholarship, such as the Veneto, Samnium, western Emilia and Trentino–South Tyrol. With its overall emphasis on scholarly multivocality, this volume is one of the first ever to strongly advocate for a study of social exclusion and extreme social marginality in late prehistoric and proto-historic Italy.
Section 1 addresses the construction of identity by focusing mainly on the manipulation of age, ethnic and gender categories in society in regions and sites that reached notable power and splendour in first millennium BC Italy. These include Etruria, Latium, Campania and the rich settlement of Verucchio, in Emilia Romagna.
Section 2 offers a counterpoint to Section 1 by focusing on the concepts of ‘periphery’, marginality and the frailty of élite (or sub-élite) power in phases of dramatic socio-political change. Moreover, this Section approaches the idea of identity construction in ‘fringe’ geographical areas that are sometimes overlooked in Anglophone scholarship, such as the Veneto, Samnium, western Emilia and Trentino–South Tyrol. With its overall emphasis on scholarly multivocality, this volume is one of the first ever to strongly advocate for a study of social exclusion and extreme social marginality in late prehistoric and proto-historic Italy.
This article addresses the meaning of community in an area of the ancient world that is normally seen to diverge from the paradigm of the classical city-state, by examining the role of sanctuaries in the articulation of identity and... more
This article addresses the meaning of community in an area of the ancient world that is normally seen to diverge from the paradigm of the classical city-state, by examining the role of sanctuaries in the articulation of identity and belonging. The focus is on Samnium (central Italy) in the last four centuries BC, where archaeological and historical evidence, including a wealth of recent discoveries, supports a dynamic view of a region that is traditionally associated with a cohesive ethnic group. Whilst it is true that the major sanctuary at Pietrabbondante fostered the construction of Samnite ethnic identity as a form of resistance to Roman expansion, this article highlights the importance of other types and levels of belonging in light of a broader range of cult sites. The concept of ‘nested identities’ (a scenario where individuals identify simultaneously with overlapping groups) can bring about a more nuanced view of how cult served to negotiate belonging on ethnic and non-ethnic levels. I hope to show that local communities, and particularly the local elites, were able to function independently rather than simply as the building blocks of the Samnite ethnos.
- by Rafael Scopacasa
- •
This article approaches gender as a means of understanding cultural identity in Italy before the Roman conquest. Most scholars have assumed based on written sources that the ancient inhabitants of Samnium, who are noted for their fierce... more
This article approaches gender as a means of understanding cultural identity in Italy before the Roman conquest. Most scholars have assumed based on written sources that the ancient inhabitants of Samnium, who are noted for their fierce resistance to Rome, shared a gender system in which men were primarily regarded as warriors and women as caretakers of the household. Archaeological support for this view has been sought in the contrast between burials containing weapons (assumed to belong to men) and those containing jewelry or personal ornaments (attributed to women). In line with recent studies that challenge such a view, I employ statistical methods to verify correlations between grave goods, sex, age, and social status. Results reveal that cultural attitudes toward gender among the Samnites were complex. In many cases, gender configurations were structured in such a way that both men and women performed similar social activities and may have participated as equals in commensal politics. These findings demonstrate the potential for quantitative archaeological analysis to enhance our knowledge of cultural identity and social organization in an area of the ancient world for which there is very little written evidence.* introduction Ancient Samnium, which corresponds to presentday Molise, south Abruzzo, and north Campania (fig. 1), is described in ancient historical writing as the homeland of the Samnites. Authors such as Livy,
- by Rafael Scopacasa
- •
Rome’s encroachment on Italy is often seen as the process by which a unique city-state conquered the entire peninsula in a surprisingly short period of time. Yet in many ways the Roman expansion was an Italian phenomenon, in the sense... more
Rome’s encroachment on Italy is often seen as the process by which a unique city-state conquered the entire peninsula in a surprisingly short period of time. Yet in many ways the Roman expansion was an Italian phenomenon, in the sense that Italian communities and institutions had a decisive impact on the development of Roman hegemony from the outset. The Roman drive towards expansion can to some extent be understood as a product of the harsh interstate environment of Archaic Italy, where constant warfare encouraged aggressive competition (Eckstein 2006). The city’s expansion was possible because Italian communities supplied the necessary manpower and resources, fought the wars, and participated in colonisation schemes of various kinds (Cornell 1989; Bradley and Wilson 2006). The means by which Rome maintained its dominance with the cooperation of Italian aristocracies owed much to earlier forms of elite collaboration from the Archaic period (Gabba 1989), and helped to preserve the social structure of many Italian communities (Terrenato 2007). It was not inevitable that Rome should emerge as the sole hegemonic power. In the fourth and early third centuries the Romans encroached on Italy almost as much as Italians encroached on Rome and on each other. It was only after the Hannibalic war (202 BC) that Rome became the political hub of the peninsula, but even then we have evidence that many Italian states behaved as independent partners rather than dependents.
For much of the twentieth century, the Roman expansion in Italy was seen as a steady process of unification, not just in a political sense but socio-cultural as well (e.g. Sherwin-White 1973, 159). This view can be traced back to nineteenth-century Germany, and particularly to the work of Theodor Mommsen. His idea that Italian communities almost inevitably converged under Roman leadership was probably influenced by the atmosphere of German national unification in his own day, and the modern expectations of nation building under the guidance of a dominant state, in this case Prussia (Mouritsen 2006).
Yet on a deeper level, this teleological view of Roman encroachment reflects the surviving historical narratives from antiquity, which were the chief sources available to Mommsen. The ancient historical accounts portray the Roman “conquest” of Italy as the first stage in the city’s inevitable rise to world domination. Whilst such narratives offer an invaluable basis for understanding how Rome extended its territory and power, they also pose serious challenges. With the exception of Polybius, most of the surviving texts were written from the mid-first century BC onwards, at least 200 years after the events that they describe. These authors wrote about the mid-Republican past in view of their own political agendas and anxieties as upper-class Romans of the late Republic and Principate (Dench 2005, 152 ff; Kraus and Woodman 1997). Although individuals such as Livy were eager to understand how Roman hegemony had come about, they were mostly unconcerned with social and administrative transformations. They offer vivid accounts of battles and wars, but only faint sketches of the political settlements between Rome and Italian communities.
On the other hand, a growing body of epigraphic, numismatic, and archaeological sources – from survey data to ceramics and architecture – offer a rich evidence base that is contemporaneous with the process of Roman encroachment. This material allows us to explore the social and cultural transformations that Italian communities experienced, ultimately supporting alternative histories of Republican Italy. Yet the fragmentary nature of the archaeological and epigraphic record also makes for very challenging problems of interpretation, as we shall see below.
This chapter discusses the role of Italian communities in Rome’s rise as a hegemonic power between the fifth and early second centuries BC, and how this process transformed Italy as a result. I begin by sketching a narrative of events that mark the extension of Roman territory and power in Italy, from the founding of the Republic (509 BC) to the start of the first Punic war (264 BC) – seeking, whenever possible, to reconstruct the Italian perspective on these events. The second part of the chapter discusses the social and political impact of Roman dominance between the late fourth and early second centuries. I emphasise the current shift towards a new narrative of Roman hegemony in third-century Italy, where colonisation, extensions of citizenship, and alliances are being approached not simply as instruments of Roman oppression, but also as complex and changing phenomena in which Italians as well as Romans played a key role. Whilst colonisation surely helped to consolidate Roman territorial expansion at the expense of Italian communities, the colonies themselves were autonomous communities with permeable borders, which included large numbers of Italians – both locals and migrants (Bradley and Wilson 2006; Coles 2009). Colonies and the extension of citizenship promoted new patterns of integration and mobility across the peninsula through trade, intermarriage, and army service, which affected Rome as well as Italy (Roselaar, ed. 2012). Growing knowledge of such mobility allows us to rethink the link between Roman hegemony and the cultural changes that we see in the material record of Italy in the fourth-second centuries, which is discussed towards the end of this chapter.
For much of the twentieth century, the Roman expansion in Italy was seen as a steady process of unification, not just in a political sense but socio-cultural as well (e.g. Sherwin-White 1973, 159). This view can be traced back to nineteenth-century Germany, and particularly to the work of Theodor Mommsen. His idea that Italian communities almost inevitably converged under Roman leadership was probably influenced by the atmosphere of German national unification in his own day, and the modern expectations of nation building under the guidance of a dominant state, in this case Prussia (Mouritsen 2006).
Yet on a deeper level, this teleological view of Roman encroachment reflects the surviving historical narratives from antiquity, which were the chief sources available to Mommsen. The ancient historical accounts portray the Roman “conquest” of Italy as the first stage in the city’s inevitable rise to world domination. Whilst such narratives offer an invaluable basis for understanding how Rome extended its territory and power, they also pose serious challenges. With the exception of Polybius, most of the surviving texts were written from the mid-first century BC onwards, at least 200 years after the events that they describe. These authors wrote about the mid-Republican past in view of their own political agendas and anxieties as upper-class Romans of the late Republic and Principate (Dench 2005, 152 ff; Kraus and Woodman 1997). Although individuals such as Livy were eager to understand how Roman hegemony had come about, they were mostly unconcerned with social and administrative transformations. They offer vivid accounts of battles and wars, but only faint sketches of the political settlements between Rome and Italian communities.
On the other hand, a growing body of epigraphic, numismatic, and archaeological sources – from survey data to ceramics and architecture – offer a rich evidence base that is contemporaneous with the process of Roman encroachment. This material allows us to explore the social and cultural transformations that Italian communities experienced, ultimately supporting alternative histories of Republican Italy. Yet the fragmentary nature of the archaeological and epigraphic record also makes for very challenging problems of interpretation, as we shall see below.
This chapter discusses the role of Italian communities in Rome’s rise as a hegemonic power between the fifth and early second centuries BC, and how this process transformed Italy as a result. I begin by sketching a narrative of events that mark the extension of Roman territory and power in Italy, from the founding of the Republic (509 BC) to the start of the first Punic war (264 BC) – seeking, whenever possible, to reconstruct the Italian perspective on these events. The second part of the chapter discusses the social and political impact of Roman dominance between the late fourth and early second centuries. I emphasise the current shift towards a new narrative of Roman hegemony in third-century Italy, where colonisation, extensions of citizenship, and alliances are being approached not simply as instruments of Roman oppression, but also as complex and changing phenomena in which Italians as well as Romans played a key role. Whilst colonisation surely helped to consolidate Roman territorial expansion at the expense of Italian communities, the colonies themselves were autonomous communities with permeable borders, which included large numbers of Italians – both locals and migrants (Bradley and Wilson 2006; Coles 2009). Colonies and the extension of citizenship promoted new patterns of integration and mobility across the peninsula through trade, intermarriage, and army service, which affected Rome as well as Italy (Roselaar, ed. 2012). Growing knowledge of such mobility allows us to rethink the link between Roman hegemony and the cultural changes that we see in the material record of Italy in the fourth-second centuries, which is discussed towards the end of this chapter.
- by Rafael Scopacasa
- •
Ideological obsolescence, faltering powers and accelerated socio-political change: Case studies from Iron Age Italy SESSION 3 RECKONING WITH ROME Dr FRANK DAUBNER (Universität Stuttgart) Continuity and change in Macedonian society after... more
Ideological obsolescence, faltering powers and accelerated socio-political change: Case studies from Iron Age Italy SESSION 3 RECKONING WITH ROME Dr FRANK DAUBNER (Universität Stuttgart) Continuity and change in Macedonian society after the Roman conquest Dr MAURIZIO BUORA (Società Friulana di Archeologia) and Dr STEFANO MAGNANI (Università degli Studi di Udine) Forms of interaction and integration between indigenous and Roman settlers in the territory of Aquileia during the second and first centuries BC SESSION 4 (UN)STABLE ÉLITES Dr GUY BRADLEY (Cardiff University) Fluidity, mobility and social crisis in archaic central Italian élites Dr VERA ZANONI (University of Pavia) Beyond the graves. Crisis and continuity in the Hellenistic funerary contexts from the Calvario cemetery (Tarquinia, VT) Prof. MARIASSUNTA CUOZZO (Università del Molise) (TO BE CONFIRMED) Dialettica interculturale, dinamiche di interazione e resistenza nelle comunità della Campania al passaggio tra Prima età del Ferro e Orientalizzante
- by Rafael Scopacasa
- •
The aim of this workshop is to explore localized phenomena of crisis, unrest and survival in the central Mediterranean during the first millennium BC.
R. Scopacasa and E. Perego (2016) The Samnite State of Emergency: approaching crisis events and resolution strategies in Republican Italy (400-80 BC). Invited talk delivered at the State of the Samnites conference, held in January 2016 at... more
R. Scopacasa and E. Perego (2016) The Samnite State of Emergency: approaching crisis events and resolution strategies in Republican Italy (400-80 BC). Invited talk delivered at the State of the Samnites conference, held in January 2016 at KNIR (Rome)
Seminário de apresentação do campo de pesquisa da linha "Ciência e Cultura na História" do Programa de Pós-Graduação em História da UFMG. 9, 16, 23 e 30 de abril de 2018 [Fafich – UFMG]
- by Mauro Condé and +3
- •
- Historia da Ciência
In the present-day world order, political disintegration, the faltering of economic systems, the controversial and yet dramatic consequences of global warming and pollution, and the spread of poverty and social disruption in Western... more
In the present-day world order, political disintegration, the faltering of economic systems, the controversial and yet dramatic consequences of global warming and pollution, and the spread of poverty and social disruption in Western countries have rendered ‘collapse’ one of the hottest topics in the humanities and social sciences. In the frenetic run for identifying the global causes and large-scale consequences of collapse, however, instances of crisis taking place at the micro-scale are not always explored by scholars addressing these issues in present and past societies, while the ‘voices’ of the marginal/non-élite subjects that might be the main victims of collapse are often silenced in ancient history and archaeology. Within this framework Collapse or Survival explores localised phenomena of crisis, unrest and survival in the ancient Mediterranean, with a focus on the first millennium BC. In a time span characterised by unprecedented high levels of dynamism, mobility and social change throughout that region, the area selected for analysis represents a unique convergence point where states rise and fall, long-distance trade networks develop and disintegrate, and patterns of human mobility catalyse cultural change at different rates. The central Mediterranean also comprises a wealth of recently excavated and highly contextualised material evidence, casting new light on the agency of individuals and groups who endeavoured to cope with crisis situations in different geographical and temporal settings. Contributors provide novel definitions of ‘collapse’ and reconsider notions of crisis and social change by taking a broader perspective that is not necessarily centred on élites. Individual chapters analyse how both high-status and non-élite social agents responded to socio-political rupture, unrest, depopulation, economic crisis, the disintegration of kinship systems, interruption in long-term trade networks, and destruction in war.
Resumo: Grupos étnicos, tanto no mundo antigo como no atual, não são entidades fixas e claramente definidas, mas agrupamentos fluidos, unidos por ideias de origem comum e semelhanças culturais percebidas. Que este era o caso dos povos... more
Resumo: Grupos étnicos, tanto no mundo antigo como no atual, não são entidades fixas e claramente definidas, mas agrupamentos fluidos, unidos por ideias de origem comum e semelhanças culturais percebidas. Que este era o caso dos povos itálicos é evidente a partir dos relatos antigos. Este artigo discutirá alguns aspectos da representação dos samnitas nos textos greco-romanos, atentando especialmente à construção de estereótipos culturais sobre esse povo itálico e propondo uma análise preliminar dos mesmos, em vista dos contextos históricos em que eles foram produzidos.
Este artigo demonstra como uma abordagem contextual à cultura material pode ajudar-nos a compreender o impacto cultural da hegemonia romana. O foco será colocado nos ex-votos anatômicos de terracota, considerados por muitos estudiosos... more
Este artigo demonstra como uma abordagem contextual à cultura material pode ajudar-nos a compreender o impacto cultural da hegemonia romana. O foco será colocado nos ex-votos anatômicos de terracota, considerados por muitos estudiosos como indicadores da "disseminação" de cultura romana ou latina pela Itália. Embora o uso desses ex-votos possa ter começado nas proximidades de Roma, comunidades em outras partes da Itália ativamente ressignificaram esses artefatos segundo as suas próprias disposições e prioridades culturais. Esses resultados enfatizam como práticas culturais locais definem o impacto de mudanças políticas aceleradas na vida quotidiana.
- by Revista Phoînix and +1
- •
- Ancient History, Historia Antiga, Romanização, Itália
This pdf of your paper in Burial and social change in first-millennium BC Italy: approaching social agents belongs to the publishers Oxbow Books and it is their copyright. As author you are licenced to make up to 50 offprints from it, but... more
This pdf of your paper in Burial and social change in first-millennium BC Italy: approaching social agents belongs to the publishers Oxbow Books and it is their copyright. As author you are licenced to make up to 50 offprints from it, but beyond that you may not publish it on the World Wide Web until three years from publication (November 2019), unless the site is a limited access intranet (password protected). If you have queries about this please contact the editorial department at Oxbow Books
- by Patrizia von Eles and +1
- •
Este artigo visa analisar o histórico e os atrasos referentes à implantação da linha 4-Amarela do Metrô de São Paulo, que, além de considerada estruturante dentro do planejamento de transporte da capital por se conectar às demais linhas,... more
Este artigo visa analisar o histórico e os atrasos referentes à implantação da linha 4-Amarela do Metrô de São Paulo, que, além de considerada estruturante dentro do planejamento de transporte da capital por se conectar às demais linhas, a sua criação é considerada a primeira Parceria Público Privada do Brasil, que objetiva a rapidez na implantação dos serviços, saindo da esfera pública. A linha ainda é marcada por sucessivos atrasos referentes à sua inauguração em suas fases, sendo postergada pelo governo diversas vezes, ora por problemas técnicos, políticos ou econômicos.
The present study aims to analyze the actions of the Ministry of Cities in the theme of urban mobility, under the management of the National Secretariat of transit and of urban mobility-SEMOB-in the Metropolitan Region of São Paulo (MRSP)... more
The present study aims to analyze the actions of the Ministry of Cities in the theme of urban mobility, under the management of the National Secretariat of transit and of urban mobility-SEMOB-in the Metropolitan Region of São Paulo (MRSP) during its 15 years of existence (2003-2018). The mobility gained notoriety in recent years due to social pressure exerted by sectors of civil society that fought for improvements and expansion of the system of national urban public transport. The mobility enters the agenda of government as an issue to be discussed and resolved before the bottlenecks faced by the population, mainly the poorest workers, in major Brazilian cities. The displacements rights in cities along with other bottlenecks faced by most marginalized populations (housing and sanitation) formed set of guidelines that culminated in the creation of the Ministry of Cities, in 2003, the first Lula government (2003-2006).The Ministry fulfilled the real function of management and supervision of the urban policies neglected by the Union since the end of military dictatorship (1964-1985), segmented into various departments without a specific folder. In the case of paulista public transport, major changes after the decade of 2000 aimed at improving the transport, since the expansion to the modernization of the system. Investments of the most varied sources reconciled with the promulgation of the National Policy of Urban Mobility-PNMU (2012), the choice of São Paulo to be the host city of World Cup 2014, the protests of June 2013 against the increase of bus tickets and the promulgation of the Statute of the Metropolis in 2015 contributed in addition to the expansion of the metropolitan transport system, but a new vision of mobility, founded under new means of locomotion, especially the collective motorized, non-motorized and electrical (VASCONCELLOS, 2012, 2015). Even with such advances, we still inserted in an urban logic based on the car, where the city was molded to cars and not the reverse, leading the formation of a metropolis scattered, unequal and excluding, made for the elite and the middle class, and extensive peripheral areas deprived of public services, locus of labor employed worker, dependent on the collective transport.
Este artigo visa analisar o historico e os atrasos referentes a implantacao da linha 4 – Amarela do Metro de Sao Paulo, que, alem de considerada estruturante dentro do planejamento de transporte da capital por se conectar as demais... more
Este artigo visa analisar o historico e os atrasos referentes a implantacao da linha 4 – Amarela do Metro de Sao Paulo, que, alem de considerada estruturante dentro do planejamento de transporte da capital por se conectar as demais linhas, a sua criacao e considerada a primeira Parceria Publico Privada do Brasil, que objetiva a rapidez na implantacao dos servicos, saindo da esfera publica. A linha ainda e marcada por sucessivos atrasos referentes a sua inauguracao em suas fases, sendo postergada pelo governo diversas vezes, ora por problemas tecnicos, politicos ou economicos.