One of numerous untitled polkas from the Sussex anglo-concertina player Scan Tester. I think this one’s been labelled ‘Polka 5’ by Topic Records simply as a matter of convenience, as it’s the fifth untitled polka to appear on the CD reissue of the double LP I Never Played To Many Posh Dances. It’s a tune I’ve always liked, yet I hardly ever seem to think of it when I’m in a session. One time I did give it an outing was about 10 years ago in a small session where Reg Hall and another fiddle-playing friend had been playing a whole bunch of tunes from Scan – quite a lot of which I had no recollection of having heard before. I played this polka and when I’d finished Reg said “I don’t think I know that one”. Which made me laugh, as I’d learned the tune from a recording made by Reg himself – and on which he plays melodeon, alongside Scan on concertina, and Scan’s daughter Daisy on piano.

Scan with his daughter Daisy, on piano, and Reg Hall on melodeon,1957. From the Musical Traditions website.
That recording, made in July 1965, is on I Never Played To Many Posh Dances. I’d first heard the tune on the classic Topic LP The Boscastle Breakdown (compiled, and with sleevenotes by, Reg Hall). The recording on that LP, of Scan Tester with Rabbidy Baxter on a great big tambourine, was made by Ken Stubbs in June 1962. It was subsequently included on Voice of the People, Volume 9: Rig-A-Jig-Jig.
I’ve been listening to these old recordings this afternoon, and I really don’t think my interpretation of the tune differs too far from what Scan played.
It’s another one of those tunes where I’m not sure if I prefer to play it on anglo or one-row melodeon (although I don’t need you to point out that I’m much better at playing it on the concertina than the melodeon!). So, as is customary in such cases, here it is on each instrument in turn.
Scan Tester’s Polka No. 5
Played on C/G anglo-concertina
Played on four-stop one-row melodeon in C