Tag: Timothy Wholey

Cardinal Dougherty’s 1922 Non-clave

When Pope Benedict XV died on January 22, 1922, Bishop Crane, pastor of St. Francis de Sales and Assistant Bishop of Philadelphia, made the official archdiocesan announcement from St. Francis de Sales Rectory, advising that “Priests and people are earnestly requested to pray for the happy repose of his soul…” and “The Reverend Pastors are further directed to drape their churches in black for thirty days.”

Cardinal Dougherty, Bishop Crane’s boss, was out of town on a “vacation voyage to the West Indies,” and had to quickly leave his cruise and make his way home to Philadelphia to prepare for a trip to Europe, arriving in a blizzard Friday evening January 27 to leave again on Saturday morning January 28. According to the rules of the time, the conclave to elect a new Pope had to occur within ten days of the Pope’s death, so, in an era of steamship travel, the timing was very tight for the Cardinal to be at the Vatican by February 2. (Airplane travel was, as yet, impractical: Alcock and Brown of Britain had made the first historic and perilous nonstop transatlantic flight from Newfoundland to Ireland in a biplane just three years before, in 1919, and Charles Lindbergh would not make his famous New York to Paris solo flight until 1927).

Let us not imagine the Cardinal rushing about frantically on his way, however. Travel by ship was a grave and ceremonial affair, whatever the occasion, and this was the first time that a cardinal from Philadelphia was eligible to vote – one of two American cardinals — so it was a big event.

The Catholic Standard and Times reported that when His Eminence arrived in Philadelphiaon Friday evening, “He was met at Broad Street Station (Pennsylvania Railroad Station was at Broad and Market St.) at 8 o’clock by a committee of priests headed by the Right Rev. Bishop Crane.” Early the next morning, after his summer gear was hurriedly unpacked and replaced with sombre Vatican formals, a “private car was attached to the 8 o’clock express from Philadelphia to New York…and placed at the disposal of the Cardinal and his party. When His Eminence arrived at Broad Street Station a few minutes before 8 o’clock, a number of priests were assembled to wish him ‘bon voyage’ At the request of the newspaper men, the Cardinal stepped to the observation car and posed for a photograph…” He also granted an interview to the Catholic Standard and Times while aboard the train.

A large group of clergy rode with the Cardinal on the train to New York – among them, Bishop Crane and Reverend Hugh Lamb (another future assistant bishop and pastor of SFDS who would manage the Philadelphia end of things from SFDS when Cardinal Dougherty participated in the 1939 conclave). Upon arrival, they were met by representatives of “the Mayor’s Committee for the Reception of Distinguished Visitors.” Then, “Headed by a squad of motorcycle police, the Cardinal’s party entered automobiles at the station, which were provided through the courtesy of Rodman Wanamaker (heir to the Wanamaker’s Department Store fortune), of New York, and were driven to Pier 57, where the Lorraine was docked. It was precisely 10.30 o’clock when His Eminence boarded the ship. As the Cardinal strode down the gangplank of the liner he faced a battery of cameras and motion picture machines, and at the request of the photographers posed for pictures.”

The Very Rev. Joseph A. Whitaker, S. T. L., chancellor, accompanied Cardinal Dougherty to Rome as his assistant, and Cardinal Begin, the Cardinal-Archbishop of Quebec, travelled to the Conclave as a fellow passenger aboard the same ship. Bishop Crane would return to Philadelphia to keep things running until the cardinal’s return.

Cardinal Dougherty “graciously” granted more newspaper interviews in his stateroom once aboard, admitting that “It is very improbable that we shall reach Rome in time to enter the Conclave, the likelihood being that by the time we arrive a new Pope will have been elected.” The cardinal’s pessimism was justified: the record speed for a transatlantic crossing was 4.5 days and the conditions this time were not ideal. It had snowed heavily through the night, the snow was predicted to continue with gale force winds, and news reports alarmed “many ships caught in worst storm of years along coast.”  (The blizzard would later be memorialized as the “Knickerbocker Storm,” after the roof of the Knickerbocker Theatre in Washington DC, collapsed under the weight of snow on the evening of January 28, killing 98 people and injuring 133)

U.S. Weather Bureau Weather map for United States East Coast January 28, 1922 (wikimedia)

At 11:30 AM, the newspaper men were shooed away, the decks were cleared, then, finally, “The shrill notes of the siren announced at 12 o’clock that the Lorraine, was departing and at that time she left the port of New York,” scheduled to arrive at Havre in France on February 5.

Cardinal Dougherty and Cardinal Begin received the news of the new Pope’s election by radio a week later while still at sea. By then it was predicted that after arriving at Le Havre they would reach Paris on Tuesday, February 7, and Rome on the 9th. So it was Bishop Crane of St. Francis de Sales who, on February 6, 1922, announced to the Philadelphia archdiocese that “‘Habemus Pontificem.’ With profound gratitude to God, we announce to you the glad news that a successor to the late Pope Benedict XV has been elected in the person of His Eminence, Achille Cardinal Ratti, Archbishop of Milan, who has chosen the name of Pius XI” and reminded the clergy “P. S.—Please remove mourning draperies from the church and have this letter- read at all the Masses on Sunday, February 12. “+M. J. C.”

Cardinal Dougherty was not the only one to miss the Conclave. In total, three Europeans were ill; the Brasilian cardinal knew he didn’t have time to get there and didn’t attempt the journey; and the two Americans and the Canadian tried but didn’t arrive in time. Of the fifty-three cardinals who were able to vote, thirty were Italian; five French; four Spanish; three German; two each from the United Kingdom, Austria, and Poland; and one each from Belgium, the Netherlands, Hungary, and Portugal. (By contrast, in 2025, the 135 cardinal electors eligible to vote for the successor to Pope Francis now represent seventy one countries spread across Europe, Asia, Africa, Oceania, and all of the Americas).

Some placating was, apparently, in order when Cardinal Dougherty returned to Philadelphia on April 1. Bishop Crane arranged for him to be met in New York by a large reception committee of clergy and distinguished laity – among them Bishop Crane, Reverend Hugh Lamb, various current and former SFDS assistant priests, and several SFDS parishioners including Thomas Slattery (one of the Sponsors at the blessing of the church bells in 1916), Timothy Wholey (who donated the statues of St. Anne and St. Francis de Sales to the parish), and Joseph Durkin (early pew-holder) — among many others from around the city. When the cardinal’s train pulled in to Broad Street Station in Philadelphia, he was greeted by cheering, flag-waving crowds, city dignitaries, a squad of police, a full military band, a procession of flags, and several hundred Knights of Columbus marching before him in procession.

In a fulsome speech at the Cathedral, Bishop Crane carefully framed the trip as a victory:

“After witnessing the magnificent demonstration along the Parkway and looking into the happy and contented faces of this immense congregation, need I tell Your Eminence that throughout the length and breadth of this diocese there is universal rejoicing tonight upon your safe return to your beloved people, both clergy and laity. When the death of the late and lamented Pope Benedict XV was announced to a grief-stricken world, you promptly obeyed the call of the duty which belongs to your exalted office. You at Once made speedy preparations for the journey to Rome. On that stormy Saturday morning when you left your home to board the steamship La Lorraine, you were accompanied by the. prayers of your loyal and faithful children…We had hoped against hope that the deliberations of the Conclave might be prolonged so as to enable you to take part in the election of the successor to the saintly Pope Benedict XV. Rut on account of the long distance to the Eternal City and the brief, duration of the Conclave you were doomed to disappointment. We shared in your disappointment…” However, “You had the unique honor of assisting at the Coronation of the new pontiff; you had the intimate privilege of private conversation with him. It put you in close touch with the aims, the aspirations and the ideals of the Chief Shepherd of Christ’s flock on earth. Yours was a splendid opportunity of welding even closer, if possible, the ties that bind this diocese to the centre of unity, the Holy Roman Apostolic See…”

Bishop Crane’s speech was followed by another lengthy address, highlighting every important moment thus far in the Cardinal’s illustrious career, culminating in his personal audience with the new Pope.

Curiously, there’s a postscript. A few years later, in 1927, Cardinal Dougherty felt a need to use the Catholic Standard and Times to publicly denounce an obscure news item that he said he had recently been shown. The Catholic Standard and Times offered the background, that “A copyrighted Universal Service cablegram dated at Rome, September 19, and published in a local paper (where?) on September 20,” had reportedly claimed that, “…only the Pope’s intervention dissuaded Cardinal Dougherty, of Philadelphia, from offering his resignation as a Prince of the Church in 1922” after he was unable to participate in the conclave “although he used the fastest ocean liner and although the special train placed at his disposal by the Italian Government made the trip from Naples to Rome in record time…” The Catholic Standard and Times then emphasized that “His Eminence Characterizes Recent Newspaper Articles, That There Was Opposition to Sacred College Meeting in Conclave Before Arrival of American Cardinals, as Falsehood Out of Whole Cloth and as Calculated to Do Harm.”

The news item that infuriated the cardinal was not widely circulated and does not appear to have been archived, but it seems to have hit a sensitive nerve. One detail stands out, however: Cardinal Dougherty should have recalled that his ship had docked at Havre in 1922. It was the other American, Cardinal O’Connell of Boston, who landed in Naples then raced across the country, heartbreakingly arriving at the Vatican just one hour after the doors had been sealed. At the time, it was reported that Cardinal O’Connell’s “fortitude and resignation in a most trying situation” were “commented upon favourably by all the Italian newspapers” – which is an entirely different use and meaning of the word “resignation”! Cardinal O’Connell certainly could have had reason for despair: due to the unpredictability of travel, he had likewise arrived a day late and was shut out of the previous conclave in 1914. One of the first acts of the new Pope in 1922, was to extend the travel period before future conclaves to make it more feasible for non-Europeans to participate.

The 1922 conclave was notable for another reason, when it was reported that “For the first time in history women will be permitted to be present in the quarters occupied by the conclave. They are Sisters of Mercy, who will preside over the destinies of the cardinals’ kitchens, which heretofore have been supervised by monks.”

Car Trouble

Does it seem as though roads are becoming more hazardous? In the early days of our church, when cars were still a novelty, our second Pastor, Reverend Crane, thought so. And vehicles moved a lot slower back then!

As the number of motorcars began to increase in the city — intermingling with horse carts, carriages, trolleys, bicycles, and others sharing the roads – officials took some odd advice in the struggle to keep everyone safe. In June 1912 – a year after our church building was finished – The Philadelphia Inquirer reported that our Reverend Crane was asked by the coroner to serve on a jury “composed of clergymen” ruling on an “automobile fatality” case, in which a man driving a “motor truck” ran down and killed a woman pedestrian. Six clergymen of different (Christian) faiths “were asked to serve on the jury as a result of a recommendation made a few months ago at the national convention of coroners, the object being to give the clergy an opportunity to impress upon members of their congregation, as well as upon chauffeurs and the owners of automobile and other vehicles, the dangers from the careless driving of motorcars” (The driver in the case was held responsible for the death and remanded for trial).

January 1916 brought traffic issues a little closer to home when the Inquirer ran a short news item headed “Auto Runs Down Aged Man.” In that incident, an SFDS parishioner, John F. Wholey, of 4822 Windsor Ave. (whose father Timothy Wholey would donate our St. Francis de Sales statue in 1920) “was taking a party of friends in an automobile to a wedding in Merchantville” when a man “stepped in front of the machine” at Day and Federal Streets, Camden; was knocked over; and suffered a “probable fracture of the skull.”

Not all automotive troubles were accident related. A different danger made the news in February 1919, with the headline “Motor Bandits Get Furs Worth $5000; Terrorize W. Phila.” The Inquirer reported that a woman who lived next door to the fur store of SFDS parishioner Henry T. Amlung, at 4810 Baltimore Avenue (today, an empty lot behind a wooden fence),  heard a noise one evening, looked out from an upstairs window, and “was struck speechless by witnessing one man tossing furs out of the window, and into the arms of an accomplice, who was putting them into a limousine automobile.”

Fast-moving motor bandits quickly became a significant class of criminals, so police – still on foot – had to invest in vehicles and equipment in order to keep up. On December 23, 1920, the Inquirer reported that “Philadelphia’s Christmas presents for motor bandits are ready. Here they are: One hundred and fifty armed motorcycles, most of them with sidecars. Six fast automobiles for bandit-chasing owned by the city and a fleet of privately owned automobiles at the call of the police. A stack of short-range sawed-off shotguns, each pumping six shells of buck shot in rapid succession…” (The shotguns were thought to be a kinder and gentler approach to crimefighting than the submachine guns proposed in New York City to deal with a similar automotive crime wave). Speedy police vehicles might have discouraged automotive crime, but were unlikely to improve safety for pedestrians or other traffic!

As to Reverend (by then Bishop) Crane, the hazards of the new automobile age soon became very personal. On Nov. 11, 1922, Catholic News Service reported that “Rev. Cornelius X. Leahy, pastor of the Church of SS. Peter and Paul at Tower City, died last Sunday as a result of a fracture of the skull sustained in an automobile accident. This accident occurred when Father Leahy was driving with a party, including Bishop Crane, of this city, from Tower City to Tremont, where Bishop Crane was to administer Confirmation.” Curiously, there is no further information on what caused the accident or whether any of the other passengers were injured. We know only that the funeral took place in “St. Canicus’ Church, Mahanoy City” and began “with Divine Office at 10 o’clock. The Right Rev. Bishop Crane presided.”

The world keeps moving. A century later, cars are old news, but the car troubles are still familiar – and now we face challenges Bishop Crane never could have imagined, as we navigate hazards of life online in the new age of the internet!

A Visit From Saint Nick

The above news item appeared in the December 1925 Parish Bulletin. The Sodality of the Blessed Virgin Mary was an organization of parish women, and Father McGinley was its Spiritual Director, but who was that man with the beard?

Timothy (T.J.) Wholey was a well-known member of the parish, who might be remembered today as the donor of the statues of St. Anne and St. Francis de  Sales.

Wholey’s story covers a tumultuous historical period. He started as a beer bottler on Passyunk, and moved into the saloon business. In 1905, he bought a building on the southeast corner of  52nd and Market, with a bar on the ground floor and an upstairs apartment for his family. Close to retirement age, Wholey sold the liquor license, just as the Temperance (anti-alcohol) movement gathered momentum (the Eighteenth Amendment to the Constitution, prohibiting the sale of alcohol, was proposed in 1917 and became effective in 1920).

Wholey moved in with his son-in-law, James Alderice, of 4822 Windsor Avenue. Alderice was a railroad foreman in a busy age when both the Reading Railroad and the Pennsylvania Railroad were headquartered in Philadelphia. Wholey registered a patent on a piece of railroad equipment soon after – possibly inspired by his son-in-law’s work, or, perhaps, as a proxy. Meanwhile, Wholey’s son John went to fight in the First World War.

T.J. Wholey was very active in the parish: his name appears on an assortment of event and committee lists from the period — as above, when he played Santa. Or when he contributed “most generously” to a children’s picnic and outing to Willow Grove Park, with his grandchildren among the participants. In May 1926 – right before the corner stone was laid for the Farragut Terrace addition to the school — he contributed $500 (a very large amount just a few years before the Great Depression) to the School Building Fund.

Is there a Santa Claus? Yes, there is – in all the generations of people, like Wholey, whose names may no longer be known, but whose spirit of generosity helped to build and shape our parish. So let us hereby celebrate all those, through our history, who have, through good times and bad, offered their energy, time, talents, and facial hair – because every effort is important to the strength of our community and to its lasting legacy in our neighbourhood.

Door Number Three

sfds statue now (2)

As you enter the church vestibule through the recently-re-opened main doors, look to your right, and you’ll see a former interior doorway (note the transom window above it) transformed into a golden shrine to St. Francis de Sales – and, incidentally, to the spirit of Vatican II!

The statue appears to be the one donated to the parish by Timothy J. Wholey in 1920. For its first  forty-five years, it stood proudly in the sanctuary at the front of the church, beside the St. Joseph altar, overseeing countless richly choreographed solemn high masses.

By 1965, Vatican II and changing tastes dictated that venerable ornate churches were “fussy” and “old-fashioned.” Our parish celebrated its 75th Diamond Jubilee Anniversary that year with a modern streamlined blue-tiled-wall redecoration of the main part of the church (four years before the Venturi neon lights!). Parishes were also urged to “clear the clutter” in the sanctuary, so freestanding statues including our patron saint were banished.

Meanwhile, as rituals simplified, architectural usage adjusted. The Baptistry, the small room at the back of the church where baptismal ceremonies were held (today’s Adoration Chapel), was designed with three doors: an entrance from outdoors; a door from the vestibule; and a door leading into the main church. In old tradition, the first part of a baptism, which involved an exorcism, was supposed to take place outside the church, or symbolically in the church vestibule, before formal admittance into the Baptistry. When the ceremony changed, the vestibule door became superfluous.

The doorway space did turn out to be a convenient place to relocate the statue of St. Francis de Sales. Its modern shrine would also brighten the parish entrance and make it more welcoming. The family of Eugene F. White, a longtime parishioner who had died in 1962  (his family ran the J.J. White Funeral Home at 4700 and later 4701 Springfield), funded the construction as a memorial. Its trendy gold colored tiles and white marble base were slipped in with the other work, and casually mentioned in a single sentence in the Monthly Bulletin related to the Jubilee renovations.

Now, fifty years later, with the main doors of the church and vestibule re-opened after the latest phase of our 125th Anniversary restoration, we can welcome our patron saint’s statue out of  construction dust into another new chapter of our parish history!