Tag: history

A Change of Tune

With a flick of a long ago editor’s pencil, she disappeared from the parish history. The 1940 parish anniversary book began its choir story with the arrival of the “distinguished” Albert J. Dooner in 1921. The 1989 parish anniversary book looked back further to claim “Tudor Strang” as first choirmaster at St. Francis de Sales in 1911 — but he was actually an organist/choirmaster for several local Episcopal churches, who played in a single organ concert at SFDS. It’s time to restore Margaret Marie Marshall to her proper place in the parish chronicles!

Margaret Marie Marshall, the original organist/choirmaster at St. Francis de Sales, left the parish quietly, without acknowledgement of her twenty years or more of service, around the time that Monsignor Crane became Bishop in 1921. “Did she fall or was she pushed?” Did she resign or was she let go? The answer to the question of how she left is probably “yes,” a bit of both, due, in part, to a new movement in church music centered in Philadelphia.

Up into the early 1900s, music offered a rare oppourtunity for Catholic women to contribute to the male-dominated liturgy. Margaret Marie Marshall was personally and professionally invested in all the possibilities, as a church organist and “concert and oratorio soprano,” who sang and also taught other soloists, first from her home at 2126 Vine Street, and later, when she moved to 3413 Baring Street. Her life seemed dedicated to her work: she lived with her father, a retired grocer, and several sisters, until they all passed away. One of her sisters was known for dramatic readings, and the other was also a church organist. It is unclear where Marshall received her training: she was listed in the Musical Blue Book of America, but, according to the U.S. Census data, her formal education ended with eighth grade.

Marshall’s musical programmes at St. Francis de Sales initially included both men and women. According to family records, golf champion J.J. McDermott’s mother sang in St. Francis de Sales Choir in the early 1900s. At General Mulholland’s funeral in 1910, Marshall’s “augmented choir” included a female soloist, Anna Elizabeth Kelley, who sang Gounod’s “Ave Maria” and Koenan’s “Come Unto Me.” A quartet sang “Nearer My God to Thee.”

An article in Adoremus claims that Philadelphia-German composer Albert RoSewig, who delighted in “the florid and sentimental style of the classical music of his day,” set the tone for music in Philadelphia around the turn of the century — and Marshall’s ambitious programmes seemed to follow that lead. In December 1902, her “special Christmas program for both morning Masses” included Eduardo Marzo’s Mass at the first; and “Hayden’s Mass No. 6, Huntzer’s ‘Veni Creator,‘” and the “Angel’s Messenger” by Homer Bartlett at the second. In 1904, the Blessing of the School included “an augmented choir of selected voices under the direction of Miss Margaret Marie Marshall, organist.” A 1912 listing for Easter services noted that she would be directing a “vested choir of sixty voices” with works including the “Grand Verdi March” and pieces by Harry Rowe Shelley, Alban Lipp, Victor Hammerl, and Édouard Batiste – all romantic 1800s composers. A Solemn Pontifical Mass commemorating the fifth anniversary of the dedication of the church in 1916 featured an “augmented choir under the direction of Miss Margaret Marie Marshall, the organist,” rendering Gounod’s St. Cecilia Mass. 

But the end of the Victorian era of embellished music, sentimental hymns, and women’s voices was already in sight. In 1903, Pope Pius X had issued an Apostolic Letter on the simplification and reform of church music, which, as Anne L. Silverberg notes, “restricted both the style of appropriate liturgical music and its execution.” It expressed a strong preference for Gregorian chant — in which all the singers follow one melodic line in Latin based on medieval modes rather than modern scales — and multipart singing “unaccompanied by instruments, a decided change from the nineteenth century when orchestras and soloists were frequently heard in American and European churches.” She notes that “The Motu Proprio also forbade women from singing liturgical music and called for boy choirs to sing music with high vocal parts.”

Philadelphia would become a centre for a new American Catholic musical movement embracing the changes, when “Nicola Montani led the nation in reform” and “founded the St. Gregory Guild in Rittenhouse Square to spread the message of the Motu Proprio and to furnish suitable musical publications.” Lucy E. Carroll notes that “From 1906 to 1923 he served at St. John the Evangelist in Philadelphia, with terms as music director at Hallahan High School, West Philadelphia Catholic Girls High School, and St. Mary’s Academy.” He worked as an editor for two music company publishers, founded the Society of St. Gregory in 1914, began the Catholic Choirmaster magazine, then published his St. Gregory Hymnal and Catholic Choir Book in 1920, renewed in 1947. The young Albert J. Dooner was among his avid pupils.

Montani crusaded for his own ideas of pure Renaissance style music without any of what he perceived as “operatic,” “theatrical,” or “balletic” elements. An article in Adoremus reports that “Montani’s voice was a strong one, and his determination to rid the liturgy of anything that even smelled of the profane was his driving force.  Masses by Charles Gounod, August Durand, and Luigi Cherubini were black-listed, with many traditional hymn collections.” These would include much of the music in Marshall’s repertoire.

Montani also had strong views on women, which Albert Dooner shared. Dooner would write in 1926 that women’s voices lacked a purity and spiritual quality of boys’ voices, and their singing was far too dramatic for the liturgy. He also maintained that the proper place for a choir was in the front of the church. Since women were prohibited in the sanctuary, they were therefore disqualified from being in the choir, even though most American choirs sang from a choir loft at the back of the church.

Montani’s stern influence gradually made itself felt in the archdiocese, and Marshall may have felt the pressure. The Solemn Papal Mass commemorating the anniversary of the dedication of St. Francis de Sales Church in 1917 was tersely described as featuring a “male choir of forty voices under the direction of Margaret M. Marshall,” with no musical programme listed.

As church music changed, Marshall turned her energy to other channels. The Catholic Standard and Times reported her war work in July 1918: “Margaret Marie Marshall, Division No. 22, has started ‘liberty sings’ in the different divisions of the Auxiliary, and each Friday night she instructs the members of the chapter in patriotic songs. The meetings close, each night with the singing of the ‘Star Spangled Banner.’” In August, the paper observed that “The ‘community sing’ movement is being enthusiastically received among Catholic societies and organizations. This was evidenced by the fact that 1,500 persons attended the community sing of the Knights of Columbus Red-Cross last Monday night at the Knights of Columbus Hall, Thirty-eighth and Market streets. These ‘sings’ are being conducted under the direction of Miss Margaret Marie Marshall, organist of St. Francis de Sales’ Church, assisted by her sister, Miss Mary Agnes Marshall, organist of St. Anthony’s Church. The former is organizing the movement among the various divisions of the Ladies’ Auxiliary of the A. O. H. (Ancient Order of Hibernians).

Was there friction over music at de Sales? In November, Margaret continued her community outreach – from Most Blessed Sacrament Parish: “For the entertainment of men in the nation’s fighting forces, an elaborate fall and winter programme has been prepared by the Women’s Auxiliary of the Archbishop Ryan Catholic Association, with headquarters at Fifty-fourth street and Chester avenue, in the Most Blessed Sacrament parish. Beginning with a big community sing on Friday night of this week, under the direction of Margaret Marie Marshall, affairs will be held every two weeks and possibly more frequently, according to the committee in charge.“

Marshall may have become less enthusiastic about her musical endeavors at St. Francis de Sales. In November 1918, for the Solemn Pontifical Mass commemorating the seventh anniversary of the dedication of St. Francis de Sales Parish, The Catholic Standard and Times reported simply that “The music of the Mass will be rendered under the direction of Margaret Marie Marshall, organist and choir leader.” When the memorial tablet “to men and women of the parish who served in the late world war” was unveiled at a Solemn Military Mass in 1920, “The musical programme was in charge of Margaret M. Marshall.” And when the church was consecrated with a Solemn Pontifical Mass in November 1920, it was reported that “A splendid musical programme will be rendered on the occasion of the Thanksgiving Mass and Vespers, under the leadership of Margaret Marie Marshall, Organist and director,” but none of the musical works were listed.

Marshall’s last mention at St. Francis de Sales appears to have been at a reception for newly-installed Cardinal Dougherty, just back from Rome in May 1921, when “A chorus of welcome was sung by the children, who formed a pretty picture as they stood grouped on the steps and displaying the Cardinal’s colors, American flags and emblems of welcome. After the chorus, which was rendered under the direction of the Sisters, Servants of the Immaculate Heart of Mary, assisted by Miss Margaret Marshall and Miss Sophia E. Maley, Natalie McElroy, one of the little pupils, delivered a touching address of welcome in splendid style.”

It was a delightful image, indeed, though it suggested that Marshall had been relegated to working with the schoolchildren, under the direction of the IHM Sisters.

Bishop Crane sang his first Solemn Pontifical Mass at St. Francis de Sales in September 1921, with the proud notice that “Special musical programmes will be rendered at the Mass and at Vespers by the parish choir of thirty-five boys and thirty men, under the direction of Albert J. Dooner, organist and choirmaster.” The younger brother of prominent parishioner Edward J. Dooner, Albert had received a degree in music from the University of Pennsylvania in 1912, continued his studies under Montani, and was already acclaimed as an organist and composer for the new church music. He would find his place as founder of the parish’s renowned pre-Vatican II boy choir, and would preside as its celebrated organist and choir director from 1921 to 1957.

After leaving St. Francis de Sales, Margaret Marie Marshall appears to have focused on the pupils of her own music studio for several years, before becoming organist and choir director at the recently-built chapel/school of St. Ambrose at Roosevelt Boulevard and C Street, far away from the city centre, around 1929. She was buried from St. Agatha’s Church (38th and Spring Garden) in 1952 — three years before Pope Pius XII cracked open the door to re-allow women’s choir participation in his Musicæ Sacræ encyclical of December 25, 1955.

Votes for Women 1915

Philadelphia Inquirer October 23, 1915

At 7:00 PM on the crisp Autumn evening of October 22, 1915, thousands of women from across Philadelphia and its suburbs gathered downtown at Broad and Mifflin Streets. Their plan was to march to City Hall, in a grand parade and “Festival of Light,” hoping to convince voting men to support a Pennsylvania state constitutional amendment permitting women to become their full partners in democracy.

Reasons for women wanting the vote ranged from idealistic notions of equality and justice for everyone, to the practical: “women who inherited family farms needed the vote to protect their interests, and mothers needed the vote to protect children’s health and education.”

They planned an impressive display.

The Philadelphia Inquirer described the scene: “The parade formed on Broad Street, south of Dickinson, promptly on time, but it reached the reviewing stand on the North Plaza of the City Hall just five minutes before nine o’clock…” with a squadron of mounted police leading “the advance guard of automobiles. There were about 150 of these cars, most of them big, costly limousines…” which, in 1915, when automobiles were still somewhat exotic, would have been a thrilling sight!  “Most of the cars were decorated with yellow plumes and banners. From one of the cars, ‘Miss Mumford,’ the official mascot, a toy fox terrier…barked lustily at the crowd.“

Then, “one hundred women, attired in pure white and in the strong daffodil yellow of the suffragists, each bearing a flower-shaped torch with an electric bulb in it” – electricity was another modern marvel in 1915 – “drew a similar colored triumphal car on which rested the ‘Justice Bell.’”

The Justice Bell, on its brilliantly lighted float, was a replica of the Liberty Bell, commissioned by activist Katharine Wentworth Ruschenberger and cast in bronze by the Meneely Bell Company of Troy, NY (The same name, but a confusingly different family branch and a rival company to the Old Meneely Bell Foundry of West Troy, NY that would cast the chime of bells installed in the St. Francis de Sales church tower in 1916). The words “Establish Justice” were engraved on the side of the Justice Bell and its clapper was chained to its side, to symbolize women’s silenced political voices. In the months before appearing in the parade, the bell toured the state to promote awareness of, and support for, the 1915 referendum on a state constitutional amendment allowing women to vote.

The Inquirer report continued: “Around the bell itself, as a guard of honor, were women attired to typify the virtues…” followed by several other floats depicting “historic and legendary characters.” Numerous women’s groups from across the region moved forward in orderly ranks of several hundred marchers at a time, preceded by banners, and carrying glowing lanterns and torches to light the way. Then, “Miss Dora Keene, athlete and mountain climber, on horseback, in full riding habit, led the College Equal Suffrage Society, most of the women wearing their caps and gowns. These were followed by the women physicians, and these in turn by the graduate and district nurses, in their distinctive uniforms.” The Inquirer noted that “Every profession or occupation open to women, every condition of society, every creed, had its representatives.” The parade culminated at the Academy of Music with a mass meeting and program of speakers.

What did all of this have to do with St. Francis de Sales Parish?

One of the marching groups in the 1915 parade had a direct association. The newly formed Suffrage League of Catholic Women was an offshoot of the American Catholic Historical Society (ACHS) Auxiliary, which had been involved with voting issues for many years under “pioneer Catholic suffragist” Jane Campbell of Germantown. When she retired, one of her supporters, Laura Blackburne , formed the new organization which included SFDS parishioners among its members. Blackburne herself had a special SFDS connection, as she had donated the large cross-shaped eternal lamp that hung as a beacon in the middle of the St. Francis de Sales sanctuary, from its construction until the 1950s (Bishop McShea replaced it with a pair of red sanctuary lamps, still in use, on the two side walls, and a pair of hanging lights).

SFDS also had an inspirational standard-bearer in the parade. A columnist for The Catholic Standard and Times, reminiscing some years later about the event, recalled that “our league made the finest showing in the suffrage parade, held in 1915… Banners with legends describing heroic Catholic women of the past were carried in line…Three young girls in accurate historical costumes were preceded by banner-bearers. Miss Catherine Forsythe represented St. Catherine of Siena, the famous publicist of the Middle Ages; Ethel de Barth (now Mrs. William P. O’Neill) was an ideal Joan of Arc in shining armor, and Frances Tobin appeared as Margaret Brent, niece of Lord Baltimore and the first advocate of woman suffrage in the New World.” (A laudable role model: according to the Maryland State Archive, Margaret was denied the courtesy of a vote when Maryland faced a “severe crisis” in 1647, though in the end “Margaret’s decisive actions in such troubled times ensured the survival of the settlement.”) Frances de Sales Tobin, age 24, was then the Executive Secretary of the Suffrage League of Catholic Women. A well-known daughter of the parish, her father worked for the Catholic Standard and Times, and her family, who lived at 5033 Cedar Ave., were very active in church activities.

Ultimately, the efficiently-organized 1915 parade was a powerful — perhaps intimidating — demonstration of women’s fitness to have a voice — and a choice — in government. But local politicians, who were concerned about the unpredictable effect of a large mass of new voters with different perspectives and priorities, pressed their mostly white male electorate to reject the amendment.

Voting men were directly responsible for the defeat, but it’s important to note that not all women had supported getting the vote. It’s hard now, to imagine that any woman would actively campaign to limit women’s opportunities, and yet some did. In 1910, the Philadelphia Inquirer published an entire page of commentary headed “Society Leaders Head Opposition to Woman Suffrage,” with photos of several prominent, wealthy, local women — wives of those comfortably in power — who opined that allowing women of every social class the right to vote would be “dangerous.” In 1913, the Washington headquarters of the National Association Opposed to Women Suffrage , an anti-voting organization, printed a letter from a woman who proudly stated “I am such an ardent anti-suffragist that I never go to bed without pinning the colors of the national organization on my night gown.” A curious mental picture indeed.

Philadelphia Inquirer February 20, 1910

World War I and the Influenza epidemic next filled the newspaper headlines and took over the nation’s attention. Then, in 1919, the controversial Eighteenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution — instituting Prohibition and making “the production, transportation, and sale of alcohol illegal” — was ratified by the relatively small segment of the population which then qualified as voters. The Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia notes that although the Eighteenth Amendment took effect nationally in 1920, Pennsylvania actually enacted Prohibition earlier, on February 25, 1919. Once that happened — perhaps in reaction to it — on June 24, 1919, Pennsylvania became the seventh state to ratify the Nineteenth Amendment, allowing women to add their input to the local and national decision-making process.

In an article about the Justice Bell, Laurie Rofini writes: “After the ratification of the Nineteenth Amendment, the Justice Bell’s clapper was unchained in a ceremony on September 25, 1920, at Independence Square in Philadelphia…A wide range of women’s organizations and local clubs were represented…” supporting a broad spectrum of voices. The Encyclopedia of Greater Philadelphia then reports that “Over one million women in Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and Delaware voted in a national election for the first time on November 2, 1920. It had taken well over one hundred years for women to win that right and to push the nation forward toward living up to the ideals put forth at its founding.“

Afterwards, Frances de Sales Tobin would continue to address women’s groups on the importance of exercising their new rights. In 1921, she became the Leader of the first St. Francis de Sales Girl Scout Troop, tasked with preparing young women of the parish — now future voters — to embrace civic responsibility.

A Postscript:

Damaged in 2020, and restored in 2023, the Valley Forge Washington Memorial Chapel website now reports that “The Justice Bell is on permanent display at its home at Washington Memorial Chapel.” Check it out.