
Imagine a hot, sunny summer day in the 1930s with nothing much to do. A band of seven boys – siblings and friends ranging in age from seven to eleven – are tempted by running water in a nearby park. They know it’s forbidden, but they take off their shoes, roll up their trousers, and step into a deliciously cool stream. For half an hour or so (who’s keeping track of time on this glorious day!) they go wading – laughing, shouting, splashing, poking things with sticks, hunting for crayfish, skipping stones, and finding tin can “treasures” hidden among the rocks.
A few days later, on August 6, 1932, the Philadelphia Inquirer reports that “An 11 year old honor pupil and altar boy is dead and three other children ill after wading hip high in Cobbs Creek near 59th St and Whitby Ave. a week ago in a group of seven laughing, vacationing boys. An investigation of the cases led to statements by physicians that scores of children had been made ill throughout the city this summer as a result of bathing and streams, swimming holes and under fire plugs.”
The Inquirer noted that “The dead child, John Martin of 5130 Hatfield Ave., had been promoted with an average of .88 into the 7th grade of the Saint Francis De Sales parochial school in June and was third highest in his class. His youngest brother Hugh, 7, who was taken to Misericordia Hospital on Tuesday in a dying condition but was said to be improved yesterday, will enter the third grade in the same school in the fall.” The Parish Monthly Bulletin printed a full-page eulogy as John Martin’s classmates laid him to rest in his red altar server robes.
“The sewage saturated waters of concrete of Cobbs Creek are an unhealthy place for children to swim, Doctor Lamp declared with emphasis, and should be red flagged by park guards like the ice in winter time.”
He wasn’t wrong. Adam Levine once detailed the waterway’s industrial history for Phillyh20: in the early 1800s, it was crowded with textile mills “with clusters of factories in the Angora section of West Philadelphia (near 60th Street and Baltimore Avenue)…Water used in various industrial processes, such as paper-making and textile dyeing and bleaching, was dumped directly back into the creek, untreated, which certainly had an adverse affect on water quality and aquatic life….” In the early twentieth century, as neighborhoods grew, “rampant development” caused more problems as stream tributaries were paved over or rerouted, and “sewers from the new neighborhoods in the watershed emptied directly into the creek and its tributaries, polluting the water with raw sewage.” By the 1930s, most of the mills had moved out, but toxins remained and “in more recent times, polluted stormwater runoff and inadequate drainage systems, leaking and inadequate septic tanks, lack of open space and adequate recreation, illegal dumping, and an array of other urban ills have also taken their toll on the quality of human and natural life in the watershed”.
The boys had been told the water was unsafe, but they were children, and they were careful to look out for hazards they could see: bugs and creatures, sharp objects in the water, and a fast-moving current. Chemical poisons, trash dumps, and pollution-borne infectious diseases were outside their understanding. Problems caused by water issues were also beyond the scope of medicine at the time: antibiotics such as penicillin would not be available until the 1940s. Routine childhood vaccinations against diseases such as tetanus and diptheria would not begin until the late 1940s, and polio vaccination in the 1950s.
It has long been observed that “the more things change, the more they stay the same…” Medical knowledge has advanced considerably since the 1930s — ironically to a point where overuse of antibiotics is now limiting their effectiveness, and disease outbreaks are recurring as parents choose to reject available vaccinations for their children. At the same time, within our environment, “rampant development” and water quality issues continue to be in the news even as Pope Francis pleads with us to take better care of our “common home.” In an interview with an Argentine news agency, he observed that “Everything is connected, it is harmonious…The lives of men and women take place in an environment. I think of a Spanish saying, I hope it is not too vulgar: ‘He who spits toward the sky is spitting on his own face’. This is what abusing nature is about. Nature will pay us back. Again: nature never forgives, not because it is vengeful, but because we set in motion processes of degeneration that are not in harmony with our being.” The wording is picturesque; the warning is real.