Why Is My Heating Bill So High?

The first real heating bill of the season tends to land in November, and it tends to land hard. You ran the heat for three weeks, the number came back noticeably bigger than October’s, and now you’re wondering whether something is wrong with the system or whether this is just what winter costs.

Usually it’s some of both. Here’s how to tell which parts you can fix yourself, which parts are worth a service call, and which parts are simply the season.

Some of the Increase Is Just Winter

Start with the honest part. Heating a house takes more energy than cooling one in most Middle Tennessee months, and November is the first month your system runs in earnest. A bill that goes up is expected.

What’s worth paying attention to is the shape of the increase. Pull last year’s November bill if you can get it from your utility’s online account. Most providers show 12 or 24 months of usage history, and many show average temperature alongside it. If this November was colder than last November, some of the difference is weather, not equipment.

A bill that’s modestly higher than the same month last year is normal. A bill that’s dramatically higher, with similar weather and no change in who lives in the house, is telling you something.

Start With the Filter

It’s the first thing to check because it’s the cheapest and the most commonly neglected.

A clogged filter restricts airflow. The system has to run longer to move the same amount of heat, and a furnace fighting restricted airflow runs hotter than it was designed to. You pay for the extra runtime now and potentially for a repair later.

If you can’t remember the last time you changed it, that’s your answer. Check it monthly during heating season and replace it when it looks loaded, which for most households means somewhere between one and three months depending on pets, dust, and how many people are coming and going.

The Thermostat Habits That Cost the Most

There are two worth naming.

Cranking the thermostat to heat the house faster. Setting it to 80 when you want 70 doesn’t make the heat arrive quicker. The system produces heat at one rate regardless of the number on the wall. All you’ve done is guarantee it keeps running past the point you were comfortable.

Big setbacks on a heat pump. This one is counterintuitive. With a gas furnace, turning the heat down while you’re out and back up when you return generally saves money. With a heat pump, dropping it eight degrees overnight can backfire, because recovering that much ground often triggers auxiliary heat, which costs more to run than the heat pump does on its own. Smaller setbacks, or none at all, are usually cheaper on a heat pump.

If you’re not sure which system you have, a quick tell: if your thermostat has an “emergency heat” or “aux heat” setting, it’s a heat pump.

If You Have a Heat Pump, Check for Auxiliary Heat

This is the single biggest bill surprise in Middle Tennessee, and it’s worth its own section.

A heat pump moves heat rather than creating it, which is why it’s efficient. When it can’t keep up, backup electric resistance heat kicks in. That backup produces heat the same way a toaster does, and it costs considerably more per unit of warmth than the heat pump’s normal operation.

Auxiliary heat is supposed to run occasionally, during a real cold snap or a defrost cycle. It is not supposed to run constantly.

Here is what that costs. A typical backup heat kit is 10 kW, which pulls about 10 kilowatt-hours for every hour it runs. Residential electric rates across Middle Tennessee land somewhere around 12 to 13.5 cents per kilowatt-hour depending on your provider, so an hour on the strips runs about $1.30. The heat pump delivering that same amount of heat on its own costs closer to 45 or 50 cents an hour. If aux heat runs an extra six hours a day for a month, that is roughly 1,800 kilowatt-hours, or about $230. The heat pump would have done the same work for around $85. That is a $150 swing on one bill, which is exactly the kind of jump that sends people looking for an explanation.

If your thermostat shows aux or emergency heat for hours at a stretch in 40-degree weather, something is wrong: low refrigerant, a failing reversing valve, a defrost control problem, a thermostat miswired or misconfigured, or someone flipped the emergency heat switch last winter and nobody flipped it back.

That last one happens more than you’d think, and it can quietly double a bill for an entire season.

Where the Heat Is Going Before It Reaches You

Your system might be working fine and still be losing a third of what it produces on the way to the room.

Duct leaks. Supply ducts running through a crawl space or attic lose conditioned air through disconnected joints, failed tape, and crushed flex. You paid to heat that air and it’s warming the crawl space instead. Return-side leaks are worse, because they pull cold crawl space air into the system and your furnace spends its day reheating it.

Crawl space conditions. A damp, uninsulated, open crawl space makes everything above it harder to heat. If that’s the situation under your house, it’s affecting the bill alongside everything else it affects.

Insulation and air sealing. Attic insulation that has settled or was never adequate, gaps around recessed lights and attic hatches, and unsealed rim joists all let heat out faster than the system can replace it.

These are the expensive-to-fix items, but they’re also the ones that keep costing you every winter until they’re addressed.

When the System Itself Is the Problem

Equipment loses efficiency as it ages, and a system in its late teens is often costing noticeably more to run than it did when it was new. TVA rebates and financing can change that math, so it is worth seeing what a new system qualifies for before putting money into another repair. That’s a replace-or-repair conversation rather than a quick fix, and it’s worth having with real numbers rather than a guess.

Shorter-term signs the equipment is the culprit: the system runs constantly without reaching the setpoint, it short cycles on and off every few minutes, or the house is comfortable in some rooms and cold in others.

What to Do This Week

  1. Change the filter. Takes five minutes and rules out the most common cause.
  2. Pull your usage history. Compare this month to the same month last year rather than to last month. It’s the only comparison that means anything.
  3. Look at what your thermostat is actually doing. Specifically, whether aux or emergency heat is on, and whether someone left emergency heat engaged.
  4. Walk the vents. Blocked registers and closed-off rooms force the system to work against itself.

If those don’t explain it, the answer is usually in the ductwork, the refrigerant charge, or the equipment, and those take instruments to diagnose rather than guesswork.

Find Out What’s Actually Driving It

A high bill is worth taking seriously, because the causes that aren’t the weather tend to get worse rather than better. The good news is that most of them are fixable, and some of them are fixable this week for the price of a filter.

Roscoe Brown has been working on Middle Tennessee heating systems since 1940. Our technicians can check airflow, refrigerant charge, duct integrity, and whether auxiliary heat is running when it shouldn’t be, then tell you plainly what’s driving the number on your bill.

Schedule heating maintenance or call us at (615) 203-3874.

Share the Post:

Related Posts