Myth Busting
Trading videos often present a strategy through a handful of winning examples. In Myth Busting, we take one of these claims, write its rules as code and run them on fixed historical data across several markets. We keep every trade, not only the good ones.
Each episode is a video on our YouTube channel and an article here. The article shows the claim, the rules as code, the results before and after trading costs, and what the test can and cannot tell you. It also links the Pine Script source and the result tables, so you can reproduce the test or try your own variant.
Watch all episodes in the Trading Myth Busting playlist.
Episode 06: The "BEST MACD Trading Strategy [86% Win Rate]", Tested: 38%, and a Coin Flip Finished Ahead
A popular video promises an 86% win rate from a MACD, a 200 EMA and a support line. We coded the rules and ran them on 5 years of Ethereum and 12 more tests: the strategy won 38% of its trades, short of the 40% it needs to break even, and random directions did better.
Read more →Episode 05: The ORB One-Candle Strategy, "Backtested 1,000 Times", Tested: 34% Before Costs, 27% After the Spread
A popular opening range breakout video shows a 59% win rate and a profit factor of 4.15. We coded its rules and ran them on almost 3 years of 1-minute candles on AMD, Tesla, Apple and Nvidia: 33.9% won before costs, no better than a coin flip, and the spread took almost half of every trade's risk.
Read more →Episode 04: The "Sneaky Pivot" Strategy, Tested: No Better Than a Coin Flip
A popular video promises one candle and 15 minutes a day. We coded its Sneaky Pivot rules, matched the creator's own example trade and ran them on 14 markets: before costs the rules beat only 86.5% of random coin-flip directions, and at 5 basis points per round trip they lose.
Read more →Episode 03: Can an EMA Strategy Really "Never Lose"?
We turned a popular lesson on three EMA strategies that "never lose" into code and tested it on four markets. One tactic is a definition, one makes a measurable promise that fails, and the only complete strategy placed 5 trades in 2 years and 9 months.
Read more →Episode 02: Does One Candle Scalping Work on Stocks?
We turned the Quick Flip Scalper into code and tested it on six stocks and an index. The showcased Nvidia trade reproduces exactly, but it is the 11th best of 76, the gross edge on three stocks rests on their best three trades, and none survives a 5-basis-point cost.
Read more →Episode 01: Does the "Best" 5-Minute Scalping Strategy Work?
A popular false-breakout scalping setup shows 23 examples and 16 winners. We turned the rules into code and ran 3,414 trades on bitcoin, gold and EUR/USD: the hit rate was 32.92%, below even the 33.33% a 2R target needs before costs.
Read more →