[Review] F4 The Withered Crag (AD&D 1e 3PP); Craftsmanship

[Adventure]F4 The Withered Crag (2019)Guy Fullerton (Chaotic Henchman Productions)Lvl 1-2 The hunt is on. My Sandbox campaign is starting to operate, and with that one is on the hunt for new materials. It strikes me that, while there is a superabundance of top tier low level material in the OSR in general, poor AD&D is … More [Review] F4 The Withered Crag (AD&D 1e 3PP); Craftsmanship

[Review] U1 Sinister Secret of Saltmarsh (AD&D 1e); Scooby-doo

[Adventure]U1 The Sinister Secret of Saltmarsh (1981)David J. Browne & Don Turnbull (TSR)Lvl 1-3 TSR UK’s first full length entry and the beginning of the U series. During this time, adventure technology was rapidly developing but was still largely reflective of the underlying fantasy gaming ethos. So although this adventure is already a few steps … More [Review] U1 Sinister Secret of Saltmarsh (AD&D 1e); Scooby-doo

[Review] Rogues in Remballo (S&W); City-Adventure

[Adventure]Rogues in Remballo (2015)Matt Finch (Frog God Games)Lvl 1 City-adventures. The liminal model, protean, not fully codified, neither fully dungeon nor fully wilderness. Some combination of stealth, interaction and skullduggery is required to succeed. There is no standard format. Classic City Adventure modules are few and far between. B6? Can Matt Finch make a good … More [Review] Rogues in Remballo (S&W); City-Adventure

[Review] Lotfp Adventure #2; Avant-Garde

[Adventure](Untitled Lotfp promotional Adventure #2James Edward Raggi IV (Lamentations of the Flame Princess Adventures)Lvl ?!?! (1-3 or something LEVEL RANGE YOU FUCK) Disclaimer: Sponsored content. The second promotional adventure in the grand Lotfp sales event. James Raggi is an interesting subject to review for any number of reasons; He is wildly experimental, he oscillates between … More [Review] Lotfp Adventure #2; Avant-Garde

[Review] Lotfp Adventure #1; Rollercoaster

[Adventure](Untitled Lotfp promotional Adventure #1)James Edward Raggi IV (Lamentations of the Flame Princess Adventures)Lvl ?!?! (1-3 or something LEVEL RANGE YOU FUCK) Disclaimer: New promotional Raggi adventures to go along with the LOTFP SALE EVENT. A superlative marketeer by nature, Raggi sent me the adventures and asked me to review them. So what are we … More [Review] Lotfp Adventure #1; Rollercoaster

[Review] Psychedelic Fantasy #3 – The Fungus that came to Blackeswell (OD&D 3PP)

[Adventure]The Fungus that came to Blackeswell (2013)Yves Green (Psychedelic Fantasies)OD&DLvl ??? (probably 2-4) Psychedelic fantasy was a series comissioned and published by Geoffrey Mckinney in the early-mid OSR that attempted to foster creativity by serving as a sort of reverse NAP; every spell, item and creature in it, had to be unique. They were also … More [Review] Psychedelic Fantasy #3 – The Fungus that came to Blackeswell (OD&D 3PP)

[Review] Souls for Qovahe (OSE 3PP); Redemption Ark

[Adventure]Souls for Qovahe (2024)AB Andy (Adventure Bundles)Lvl 2-3 Disclaimer: Sponsored Content A while back, a creator by the name of AB Andy put out a series known as Adventure Bundles, a (patreon?) subscription service where he aspired to create one 5th edition adventure every month. A, frankly, murderous rate and recipe for burning out. He … More [Review] Souls for Qovahe (OSE 3PP); Redemption Ark

[Review] Temple of 1000 Swords (OSE 3PP); Fruits of a Bronze Age

[Adventure]Temple of 1000 Swords (2021)Brad KerrLvl 3 As the OSR changed in composition from a tight-knight, high-investment community to a larger loose-knit, low-investment community, and a community of practice to a community of consumerism, the inevitable result is a decline in complexity. Setting posts and play reports become shelfies and reddit.In order to accomodate the … More [Review] Temple of 1000 Swords (OSE 3PP); Fruits of a Bronze Age

[Review] UK1 Beyond the Crystal Cave (AD&D 1e); Combat is a Failure State :(

[Adventure]UK1 Beyond the Crystal Cave (1983)David J. Browne, Tom Kirby & Graeme Morris (TSR)Lvl 4 – 7 (the inside states levels 3-6 instead) “Combat is a Failure State,” is one of the more damaging memes to have come out of the later OSR and should be correctly lambasted for giving entirely the wrong impression about … More [Review] UK1 Beyond the Crystal Cave (AD&D 1e); Combat is a Failure State 😦