Skip to content

Omnivorous Reader

Golf’s Greatest

A list of the unforgettables

By Jim Moriarty

If it’s possible to turn an intellectual exercise into a quasi-coffee table book, Mike Purkey has done that just in time for the holidays with The Immortals of American Golf. It’s the latest in the “Immortals” series that includes boxing, motocross and, for all you Richard Petty fans out there, NASCAR.

Purkey hails from Gastonia, where he broke into the newspaper business about a thousand years ago as a teenager answering phones in the sports department. I can say that because I’ve known Mike for almost that long. We worked opposite sides of the street as competitors and comrades for most of our careers in golf, he for Golf magazine and me for Golf Digest/Golf World. He also did time at the Charlotte Observer, was one of the founding editors of Global Golf Post and worked for the ill-fated Saudi-backed experiment, LIV Golf, for three years. And I can say without fear of exaggeration that Purkey was always among the best of us.

The book doesn’t tip the traditional coffee table scales at the weight of, say, the Wannamaker Trophy — the silver PGA Championship swag that winners typically have to powerlift at the prize giving — but it’s beautifully displayed with fine art selections and Purkey’s insightful writing.

As golf exercises are wont to do, this one is broken into the traditional set of 18 (players, of course, not holes) and follows more or less in chronological order, with the customary amount of overlap, since the game has been fortunate enough to be graced with more than one immortal at a time. Quibble about his selections if you will; of the 18 American players he picks and makes the case for, there isn’t one that you would throw out without thinking long and hard about it. And in the off chance you want to discard a name or two, he offers a group of honorable mentions you can draft from to fill the slots.

I won’t pretend to be a golf historian — many of my colleagues know much more about the history of the game and of its great champions than I do — which is another reason I found Purkey’s list of immortals so engaging. I learned something I didn’t know, or had forgotten, about almost all of them.

The book begins with Walter Hagen, and Purkey finds a classic quote from the great Charles Price to pull off the perfect portrait. “He (Hagen) was supremely confident, and he knew the virtue of the grand gesture. Bumptious, sparkling, with wisecracks, dressed in bandbox clothes, Hagen played the game with the aplomb of a man who held the mortgage on the club.”

Hagen is followed by his two rivals of the 1920s, Gene Sarazen and Bobby Jones. Purkey quotes Sarazen: “I’d never seen my name in print before,” he said. “I’d look at it and look at it. Eugenio Saraceni. It looked to me like a violin player, not a golfer. So, I changed it to Gene Sarazen, because there was no such name in the whole world, not even in Afghanistan.” If Sarazen had the “shot heard round the world” in the 1935 Masters (then the Augusta National Invitation Tournament), Jones had the “impregnable quadrilateral” comprised of the U.S. and British Amateurs and the U.S. and British Opens — the Grand Slam — in 1930. The Emperor Jones was greeted with his second ticker tape parade in New York City and retired from competitive golf. 

The first of the great female players Purkey lists is the incomparable Babe Didrikson Zaharias, perhaps the finest true athlete ever to play the game. The Babe won two golds (in the hurdles and javelin, setting world records in both) and a silver (in high jump, though she actually tied for first) in the 1932 Olympics in Los Angeles. As an aside, I once visited the neighborhood where Babe grew up in Port Arthur, Texas. The hedges separating the yards — her training ground for the hurdles — were still there.

The other two women Purkey includes in his list of 18 are Mickey Wright and Nancy Lopez. You certainly can’t carp about the woman who possessed one of the greatest golf swings ever, Wright, or the woman who won five LPGA tournaments in a row in 1978 as a 21-year-old rookie. In fact, I’d argue (and if you have a list, aren’t you supposed to argue?) that somehow or other room needs to be made for another woman, Kathy Whitworth. All she did was win 88 times. But, of course, to make room for Whit, you’d need to oust one of the guys. No easy task.

After Jones, Purkey turns to the triumvirate that proved 1912 was one of the greatest years in the history of the game. That was the year Byron Nelson, Ben Hogan and Sam Snead were all born. And, like George Hamilton says in Doc Hollywood (exactly 35 years ago if you’re into anniversaries), you’d have to be a “bovine, clodpated, citified moron” not to list them among the immortals.

In one of the great successions of all time, The Big Three — Arnold Palmer, Gary Player and Jack Nicklaus — join the list just as Nelson, Hogan and Snead are exiting the stage. The oft overlooked name of that generation is Billy Casper, but Purkey is quick to include the man who won 51 PGA Tour events and enlists Johnny Miller to defend the choice. “There should never have been just the Big Three,” said Johnny Miller, himself a Hall of Fame player. “It should have been the Big Four. That was an absolute crime.”

North Carolinian Raymond Floyd serves as the bridge from Nicklaus to Tom Watson, the five-time Champion Golfer of the Year. The immortals who began in golf with wooden drivers and finished in the era of titanium include Payne Stewart and Phil Mickelson. And, of course, Tiger Woods is the book’s finishing hole.

The criteria Purkey describes to make the list are, almost by definition, gossamer. “The questions that must be asked where immortality is concerned are: Were they the best at their craft in their own era? Did they have a particular accomplishment — or multiple — that separates them from the rest? Were they significantly influential or did they make a singular difference in the game? Was their entire body of work broad and deep? Is there something distinctive about them that people have always remembered or will remember?” says Purkey. The whole point is that there is nothing cut or dried about any of it. It’s an amusing exercise, like trying to imagine how Tiger Woods would fare in a match against Bobby Jones.

And, of course, time marches on. What are we to do with, say, Brooks Koepka and Scottie Scheffler? I suppose we’ll have to wait for the next edition.  PS

Jim Moriarty is the editor of PineStraw. He can be reached at  [email protected]