Mr. Cadaverous has left me legacy. The good man is dead, but he has left me his note-books. This morning I opened one of them, and found it full of ghost stories. There was a note, written in Greek and Latin, on the last page, which, being interpreted, says: “Of all that comes before this page I believe not one single word.” I was angered as I read, for why should any man collect a mass of narratives which he looks upon not as mere fiction but as mere lies? This arid scepticism makes me hate my generation.
— Augustus Jessopp, “The Dying Out of the Marvelous“
The rest of Rev. Jessopp’s rant is enjoyable, but I do think he exaggerates a bit. For one thing, it’s my opinion that Mr. Cadaverous protesteth too much: why write down all these ancient ghost stories if you don’t enjoy them? And to enjoy them, you have to suspend your disbelief, at least for the duration of the telling, or in this case, the writing. Loudly proclaming your scepticism after the fact doesn’t fool anyone.

For another thing, I doubt that Rev. Jessopp believed them either. I think he just wished, at least sometimes, they could be true. In other words, he enjoyed them.
Most of “The Dying out of the Marvellous” is a sampler of tales from Mr. Cadaverous’s notebook. But at the end, Jessopp teases us with stories he won’t tell us:
You must not expect that I should tell you all my chronicler’s stories. No! I must leave out the story of the devil of Danbury…
…and the hobgoblins of Biggleswade, and the dragon of Sudbury. Foo!! You know I have try to hunt down at least some of these. The Devil of Danbury first.








