This post is about the
Second Episode of the Big Painting Challenge 2018 which focused on:
- Nature - painting dogs and trees
- Alternative ways of handling paint
 |
| The group and tutors ready for The Big Painting Challenge Episode 2 |
It follows on from my earlier posts:
This episode is available to watch on BBC iPlayer for the next 27 days.
Nine painters continue in the artistic bootcamp, which this week sees themworking with their professional mentors, Diana Ali and Pascal Anson, to conquer paint-handling techniques to depict nature in all its glory. BBC website
Continuing issues for me
Before I start I want to thank all those who took the trouble to comment on the blog posts and also on my Facebook Page where I post my blog posts once finished. It's always really good to see if my comments resonate with others and also to get your own perspectives on how things are going - which might be summed up as Sky Arts 1 BBC 0.
Episode 2: Coherent or discontinuity
I'm having major problems with the format for the individual episodes. Last week we had two awful abortions masquerading as still life set-ups and went from those via two fast (but useful) exercises to a vast interior which was in some way supposed to be 'a big still life'.
Absolutely no teaching of perspective in the content of the programme - and then somebody gets sent home for not grasping that her perspective changes when her eyeline changes.
This week we have:
- the reverse of still life - the two teams each had a dog to paint, neither of which was still for very long
- exercises about how to use tools other than brushes to handle paint and make different sorts of marks
- a discussion by Fraser Scarfe (who has morphed into a replacement of Lachlan Goudie)
- a big challenge about painting lots of trees - and leaves - and how best to represent these through the handling of paint
Teaching: Imperative vs. interrogative
I've still got my hackles raised over Diana's teaching style and tried this week to try and find the reason why.
I concluded that she instructs in a very imperative way - essentially "
don't do that, do this" a.k.a. "
my way is best". Plus she's just plain RUDE and says some completely outrageous things - a bit like a "shock jock"!
(This coming from somebody who is renowned for being somewhat direct!)
It's not very energising - I'd absolutely hate to be in her group - in fact I'd walk and/or insist on being in the other one.
 |
| Diana's group gets its dressing down about the dog pics |
It was interesting how Ray was swopped to Pascal this week after the the "don't use watercolour, use acrylic' imperative last week.
By way of contrast Pascal's instruction is much more carefully scripted and articulated - plus he asks questions "
May I show you?" I'm very definitely warming to him in this series.
Again, Daphne who everybody seems to think is an ogre - and who I think is just a plain-speaking who makes intelligent comments - is very interesting in the way she asks members of the group questions as she goes round the group.
At some point they will realise that she's actually asking them whether they have considered an aspect that might be worthy of consideration. There's an awful lot that both participants and the audience can learn from the questions she asks. She's very perceptive and perspicacious ie. almost always spot on!
I do think those who "parrot" comments about "her unfortunate manner" might want to bear in mind that their experience to date of painting tutors might be limited to those who say nice things to them all the time because they'd like them to keep paying fees for tuition!
Give me Daphne's feedback any time if you want to make some serious improvement as an amateur artist!
I liked
Fraser Scarfe who stepped in for an absent Lachlan (of whom there was no mention). He also provided some sound assessment and judgement and was a nice foil for Daphne.
(PS Do take a look at his website - he's got some paintings of trees featured!) His book is called
How to Paint Atmospheric Landscapes in Acrylics
- I've not seen it or read it - but it looks like the sort of book Ray might find very useful! :)
The First Challenge - doggies!
Ostensibly the next step up from painting something very still is painting something that moves.