The EEOC Rescinded Its Background Check Guidance. Here’s What Employers Should Do Now.
- The EEOC rescinded its 2012 arrest and conviction records guidance on October 29, 2026, effective immediately.
- No replacement guidance has been issued.
- Title VII, the FCRA and state and local fair chance laws still apply, and applicants can still sue.
- Avoid blanket bans and run checks after a conditional offer.
- Use the Green factors and an individualized assessment for every record.
- Follow every FCRA disclosure, authorization and adverse action step.
On October 29, 2026, the EEOC rescinded its 2012 guidance on using arrest and conviction records in hiring, effective immediately. No replacement has been issued. The law behind it did not change: Title VII, the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) and state and local fair chance laws still apply, and applicants can still sue. Keep screening after a conditional offer, judge each record against the job, give candidates a chance to respond, and follow every FCRA step.
What changed Green factors Individualized assessment FCRA steps Checklist
On October 29, 2026, the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) rescinded its 2012 enforcement guidance on using arrest and conviction records in hiring. The Commission voted 2 to 1 on October 28, and the change took effect immediately.
For more than a decade, that guidance was the go-to playbook for background checks. It told employers how to screen candidates with a criminal record without running afoul of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act. Now it’s gone, and the EEOC has not issued anything to replace it.
So what should you do? If you’re an HR team of one, a business owner or an HR leader, the short answer is: keep doing what you’ve been doing. Here’s why, and what to double-check this month.
What changed, and what didn’t
The guidance is gone, but the law behind it is not. Rescinding guidance does not change Title VII, state law or the FCRA. The EEOC said so itself: the rescission “does not restore policy statements superseded by the 2012 Guidance,” and it does not require employers to abandon lawful practices they adopted because of it. Chair Andrea Lucas added that rescinding the guidance “does not give employers license to engage in unlawful discrimination.”
| What changed | What stayed the same |
|---|---|
| The EEOC’s 2012 guidance no longer applies and has been taken off the agency’s website | Title VII still bans hiring practices that discriminate based on race, color, religion, sex or national origin |
| No replacement guidance has been issued | Disparate impact is still written into Title VII, and screening must still be job-related and consistent with business necessity |
| The rescission does not bring back older EEOC policy statements on arrest and conviction records | Applicants can still bring discrimination claims on their own, without the EEOC |
| Legal commentators expect the EEOC to focus on intentional discrimination (disparate treatment) rather than disparate impact | State and local fair chance laws and the FCRA are still enforced by other agencies and by private plaintiffs |
In other words, less federal guidance does not mean less risk. A blanket “no felonies” policy can still lead to a lawsuit, even if the EEOC itself never brings the case.
Why the EEOC made the change
The move follows a June 9, 2026 opinion from the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel that questioned the constitutionality of disparate impact liability under Title VII and addressed background checks directly. It is part of a broader federal shift away from disparate impact enforcement. That shift changes who is likely to bring a case. It does not change what the statute says, and several states have signaled they may step in where federal enforcement steps back.
Consistency matters more than ever
If the EEOC shifts toward intentional discrimination, the question it will ask is whether you treated similar candidates the same way. I tell employers this all the time: you don’t have to run the same check for every job, but if you check one truck driver, check every truck driver the same way. Your office roles can have a different package. What gets employers in trouble usually isn’t anything dramatic. It’s the one-off exception, like an owner asking you to skip the process for a friend’s relative. You can make exceptions, but put that person through the same steps first.
The Green factors: still your best starting point
The Green factors come from a 1975 federal appeals court case, Green v. Missouri Pacific Railroad, not from the EEOC guidance. The guidance borrowed them, which is why they still matter after it’s gone. They give you a simple, defensible way to decide whether a conviction is relevant to the job.
- How serious was the offense? Consider the nature and gravity of the conviction. A decades-old misdemeanor is not the same as a recent violent felony conviction.
- How much time has passed? Look at how long it has been since the conviction or the end of the sentence. Risk generally drops as time goes on without new offenses.
- How does it relate to the job? Ask whether the offense connects to the duties of this specific role. A theft conviction matters more for a cash-handling job than for a warehouse role with no access to money.
The 2012 guidance gave employers two ways to show a criminal history screen was job-related: validate it statistically, or use a targeted screen built on the Green factors plus an individualized assessment. In my experience, validation isn’t realistic for most employers. North Carolina alone has more than 2,000 criminal statutes on top of common law crimes, and you would have to validate each one against each job in each state where you hire. That leaves the targeted screen, and nothing about the rescission makes it less useful.
The third factor is often the most important. If you can’t explain how a conviction relates to the job, it probably shouldn’t disqualify the candidate.
How to run an individualized assessment
An individualized assessment means looking at the person, not just the record. It’s one of the best ways to show your decision was fair and job-related.
- Wait for the right time. Run the background check after a conditional offer, not at the application stage. Many state and local laws require this.
- Look only at what’s relevant. Use the Green factors to decide whether a conviction connects to the role. An arrest without a conviction generally should not be the basis for a decision.
- Tell the candidate what you found. Let them know the record may affect your decision, and share a copy of the report.
- Give them a chance to respond. Ask about the circumstances, their age at the time, rehabilitation, work history since, and references.
- Weigh it and decide. Consider their response alongside the Green factors before making a final call.
- Write it down. Document what you considered and why. Consistent records are your best defense if a decision is ever challenged.
How I run the conversation
I think of the individualized assessment as the candidate’s chance to show you or convince you that they’ve changed. Here’s how I handle it:
- Send the pre-adverse action packet first, then call the candidate, tell them you’ve sent the report, and offer to set up time to talk through it. Most will want to talk right away.
- Expect one of two outcomes. The conversation will either make you more comfortable with the hire or less comfortable.
- If you’re less comfortable, thank them, wait at least a day after the call, and then send the final adverse action notice. Waiting the full five business days is the safest choice.
- If you’re more comfortable, ask for proof of rehabilitation, such as letters from counselors, religious leaders or community and civic leaders who can speak to how the person has changed. You may have just widened your candidate pool.
Don’t forget state, local and FCRA rules
Federal guidance is only one layer. For many employers, state and local rules are stricter.
Fair chance and “ban the box” laws. Many states, counties and cities limit when and how you can ask about criminal history. Some ban the question on applications. Others require an individualized assessment or specific notices before you can withdraw an offer. If you hire in more than one location, check the rules for each one. Most ban the box laws have grown into broader second chance laws that delay or limit when you can run a check, so the application question is only part of it.
The Fair Credit Reporting Act. This is where employers get sued most. FCRA lawsuits rose 37.4% in the first 11 months of 2025 compared with the same period in 2024, according to WebRecon data. The good news is that it’s easy to stay compliant, as long as you follow the steps in order.
If you use a third-party background check company, the FCRA applies no matter what the EEOC does (15 U.S.C. 1681b and 1681m). You must:
- Give the candidate a clear written disclosure, in a document that consists only of that disclosure, that you’ll run a background check.
- Get their written permission before running it.
- Send a pre-adverse action notice with a copy of the report and A Summary of Your Rights Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act before making a final decision.
- Wait a reasonable amount of time so they can respond or dispute errors. The law doesn’t set a number of days; many employers wait at least five business days.
- Send a final adverse action notice if you decide not to hire.
A few practical points from my years of running screens:
- Keep the release form clean. A line on your job application saying a background check may be required does not count as permission. The disclosure and authorization can share one document, but nothing else can go on it: no liability waivers and no at-will language.
- Count business days the way the mail does. Count Monday through Friday, skip mail holidays, and add time when delivery is likely to be slow, for example after a hurricane.
- Don’t make disputes hard. If a candidate says the report is wrong, take notes, point them to the background check company named in your letter, and give the company a heads-up yourself.
- A clean report ends the FCRA process. So does a finding you decide doesn’t matter for the job. The extra steps only start when something in the report might change your decision.
For more on running a compliant process from start to finish, see Catapult’s background check services and background check pricing.
Your background check checklist
Use this list to make sure your process still holds up:
- ☐ Our policy does not use blanket bans on anyone with a criminal record
- ☐ We run background checks only after a conditional offer
- ☐ We use the Green factors to judge whether a conviction relates to the job
- ☐ Candidates get a chance to explain before we make a final decision
- ☐ We don’t base decisions on arrests that didn’t lead to a conviction
- ☐ We follow every FCRA disclosure, authorization and adverse action step
- ☐ We’ve checked the fair chance laws in every state and city where we hire
- ☐ Hiring managers are trained on our policy and apply it the same way every time
- ☐ We document every decision and the reasons behind it
Questions about your policy? Talk to Catapult.
This area of the law is still changing. The best move right now is to stay consistent, keep your process fair, and make sure your policy matches the laws where you hire.
The background screening experts behind this guide
Catapult’s background checks are run by its own licensed investigative agency, not a reseller. The same team that manages your screens answers your questions about the FCRA, adverse action and fair chance rules.
Kevin von der Lippe
Director, HR Products & Technologies
Qualifying agent, NC private investigator license PI 2891
Brielle Earley
Background Screening Specialist
Summer Milton
Background Screening Specialist
Catapult Services Corporation is licensed by the North Carolina Private Protective Services Board (BPN 001473P11M) and is a member of the Professional Background Screening Association (PBSA). See how our background checks work.
My team and Catapult’s HR experts can review your background check policy, update your release and adverse action forms and train your managers. Call us at (704) 966-7607 or reach out online to get started.
Talk to an HR advisor
Frequently asked questions about the EEOC background check guidance
Is the EEOC’s 2012 background check guidance still in effect?
No. The EEOC rescinded its Enforcement Guidance on the Consideration of Arrest and Conviction Records in Employment Decisions on October 29, 2026, effective immediately. It has not issued replacement guidance.
Can employers still run criminal background checks?
Yes. Background checks are still legal. You still have to follow Title VII, the Fair Credit Reporting Act if you use a screening company, and any state or local fair chance laws where you hire.
Can I now refuse to hire anyone with a felony?
It’s risky. Title VII still prohibits practices that have a disparate impact on protected groups unless they are job-related and consistent with business necessity, and applicants can sue without the EEOC. Many state and local laws also require an individualized assessment before you withdraw an offer.
What are the Green factors?
They are three questions from the 1975 case Green v. Missouri Pacific Railroad: how serious the offense was, how much time has passed, and how the offense relates to the job. They are still a sound way to decide whether a conviction is relevant.
Is a background check notice on the job application enough?
No. The FCRA requires a clear disclosure in a document that consists only of the disclosure, plus the candidate’s written authorization. The two can be on one form, but it can’t include anything else, such as liability waivers or at-will statements.
How long should I wait after sending a pre-adverse action notice?
The FCRA requires a reasonable amount of time but doesn’t set a number of days. Many employers wait at least five business days so the candidate can respond or dispute errors. Some state and local laws set their own waiting periods.
Sources
This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Talk with an employment attorney about your specific situation. Current as of November 2026.
- U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, EEOC Votes to Rescind Enforcement Guidance on Arrest and Conviction Records (October 29, 2026)
- U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Legal Counsel, Constitutionality of Disparate-Impact Liability Under Title VII (June 9, 2026)
- 42 U.S.C. 2000e-2, Unlawful employment practices, including disparate impact at subsection (k)
- 15 U.S.C. 1681b, Permissible purposes of consumer reports, including employment disclosure, authorization and pre-adverse action rules
- 15 U.S.C. 1681m, Requirements on users of consumer reports (adverse action notices)
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Appendix K to Part 1022: A Summary of Your Rights Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act
- Green v. Missouri Pacific Railroad Co., 523 F.2d 1290 (8th Cir. 1975)
- Catapult, The Latest in Background Screening Trends for NC Employers, webinar with Kevin von der Lippe (November 2024)
- Catapult, FCRA Lawsuits Are Rising, Kevin von der Lippe (June 2026)
- Bloomberg Government, Credit Reporting Litigation to Rise Further Given State Laws, citing WebRecon FCRA filing data for January to November 2025
- Ogletree Deakins, EEOC Rescinds Criminal Background Check Guidance
- National Law Review, EEOC Pulls Criminal History Guidance: Employers Must Not Overcorrect
- Duane Morris, EEOC Rescinds Its Long-Standing Criminal History Guidance In 2-1 Vote (November 2, 2026)

Kevin von der Lippe is Director, HR Products & Technologies at Catapult and leads HR technology strategy, background screening operations and workforce technology solutions. Kevin is the licensed qualified agent (PI 2891) for Catapult's background screening services.



