The War on Terror post-9/11 television drama, docudrama and documentary, Lacey, S. & Paget, D. (eds.). Cardiff: University of Wales Press, pp. 65-80, Jun 30, 2015
Reflecting on the predominantly solemn cinematic response to the September 11th attacks, Ryan Gil... more Reflecting on the predominantly solemn cinematic response to the September 11th attacks, Ryan Gilbey observes that ‘defiant comedy is surely one of the sharpest weapons at our disposal’ (Gilbey, 2011, 52). Within the deluge of popular representations generated by the war on terror, however, a small number of comic and satiric film and accounts have emerged, including Harold and Kumar Escape from Guantanamo (2008, Hurwitz, Schlossberg), In the Loop (Iannucci, 2009), Four Lions (Morris, 2010) and Team America: World Police (Parker, 2004). This chapter discusses the UK TV comedy, Gary’s War and the three subsequent series, Gary: Tank Commander. Focusing on Gary McLintoch, a camp Scottish soldier who has fought in Iraq and Afghanistan, and his interaction with officers, colleagues, and friends, the programmes parody the conventions of both sober documentary television, embedded reportage and those realist dramas that privilege the first-hand experience of the soldier.
This chapter asks what the function of comedy is in the face of the atrocities and quotidian horrors of the war on terror, and whether comedy offers a platform for subversion and criticism in its refusal to take seriously and reproduce the liberal anxieties, melodramatic urgency and ideological conservatism and earnest documentary realism of dramas such as Generation Kill, Occupation and Britz, or documentaries such as Armadillo: Frontline Afghanistan (Pedersen, 2010), Our War and Restrepo (Hetherington, Junger, 2010) . This piece also asks whether the foregrounding of a camp protagonist can be understood as a parodic critique of the consensual retrenchment of reactionary masculinities that underpin many ‘war on terror’ dramas. The TV series can be situated in a tradition of comedies about reluctant and incompetent soldiering and the everyday homosocial experience of (army) camp life that encompasses Shoulder Arms (Chaplin, 1918), Carry on Sergeant (Thomas, 1958), The Phil Silvers Show (1955-59), Dad’s Army (1968-77), and It Ain’t Half Hot, Mum (1974-81). In concentrating upon the trivial frustrations, tensions and tedium of life on a military base in Scotland, the programmes also eschew the breathless, sensational fascination with the immersive spectacle of battle, and in doing so, prompt reflections upon questions of national and regional identity, class relations, and the normalcy of militarisation and heightened security. The discussion of these series is framed by the broader question of the ‘social signification’ (Bergson) of comedy in the face of terror and the extent to which laughter in response to what Freud terms ‘tendentious jokes’ is here a potential mode of intellectual and political resistance. The chapter explores whether, in their refusal to reproduce the solemnities of ‘serious’ film and TV drama, and the refusal of certain taboos these TV comedies constitute a valuable critique of the limited and restrictive terms of representation that have emerged as the dominant conventions through which this global conflict is depicted in mainstream media representations.
-
Bergson, H, ‘Laughter: An Essay on the meaning of the comic’, trans. Brereton, C.
Freud, S. 1976, Jokes and their Relation to the Unconscious, trans. James Strachey, Middlesex: Penguin
Gilbey, R. 2011, ‘How to tell a horror story’, New Statesman, 5 Sept. 2011, 51-2
Uploads
Books by Bruce Bennett
Cycling and Cinema explores the history of the bicycle in cinema from the late nineteenth century through to the present day. In this new book from Goldsmiths Press, Bruce Bennett examines a wide variety of films from around the world, ranging from Hollywood blockbusters and slapstick comedies to documentaries, realist dramas, and experimental films, to consider the complex, shifting cultural significance of the bicycle.
The bicycle is an everyday technology, but in examining the ways in which bicycles are used in films, Bennett reveals the rich social and cultural importance of this apparently unremarkable machine. The cinematic bicycles discussed in this book have various functions. They are the source of absurd comedy in silent films, and the vehicles that allow their owners to work in sports films and social realist cinema. They are a means of independence and escape for children in melodramas and kids' films, and the tools that offer political agency and freedom to women, as depicted in films from around the world.
In recounting the cinematic history of the bicycle, Bennett reminds us that this machine is not just a practical means of transport or a child's toy, but the vehicle for a wide range of meanings concerning individual identity, social class, nationhood and belonging, family, gender, and sexuality and pleasure. As this book shows, two hundred years on from its invention, the bicycle is a revolutionary technology that retains the power to transform the world.
Cycling and Cinema explores the history of the bicycle in cinema from the late nineteenth century through to the present day. In this new book from Goldsmiths Press, Bruce Bennett examines a wide variety of films from around the world, ranging from Hollywood blockbusters and slapstick comedies to documentaries, realist dramas, and experimental films, to consider the complex, shifting cultural significance of the bicycle.
The bicycle is an everyday technology, but in examining the ways in which bicycles are used in films, Bennett reveals the rich social and cultural importance of this apparently unremarkable machine. The cinematic bicycles discussed in this book have various functions. They are the source of absurd comedy in silent films, and the vehicles that allow their owners to work in sports films and social realist cinema. They are a means of independence and escape for children in melodramas and kids' films, and the tools that offer political agency and freedom to women, as depicted in films from around the world.
In recounting the cinematic history of the bicycle, Bennett reminds us that this machine is not just a practical means of transport or a child's toy, but the vehicle for a wide range of meanings concerning individual identity, social class, nationhood and belonging, family, gender, and sexuality and pleasure. As this book shows, two hundred years on from its invention, the bicycle is a revolutionary technology that retains the power to transform the world.
filmmaker Michael Winterbottom explores
the thematic, stylistic, and intellectual
consistencies running through the whole
of his eclectic and controversial work.
The volume undertakes a close analysis of
fifteen Winterbottom films ranging from
television dramas to transnational coproductions
featuring Hollywood stars, and from
documentaries to costume films. The critique
is centered on Winterbottom’s collaborative
working practices, political and cultural
contexts, and critical reception. Arguing
that his work delineates a “cinema of
borders,” the book examines Winterbottom’s
treatment of sexuality, class, ethnicity, and
national and international politics, as well
as his quest to adequately narrate inequality,
injustice, and violence.
Contents:
Introduction: Bruce Bennett, Marc Furstenau & Adrian Mackenzie
PART 1: FORMAT
Peter Lester, 'The Perilous Gauge: Canadian Independent Film Exhibition and the 16mm Mobile Menace'
Andrew Clay, 'BMW Films and the Star Wars Kid: 'Early Web Cinema' and Technology'
James Elkins, 'On Some Limits to Film Theory (Mainly From Science)'
PART 2: NORMS
Paul Moore, 'Socially Combustible: Panicky People, Flammable Films, and the Dangerous New Technology of the Nickelodeon'
Jan Harris, 'Cinema and its Doubles: Kittler vs. Deleuze'
Kate O'Riordan, 'Genomic Science in Contemporary Film: Institutions, Individuals and Genre'
PART 3: SCANNING
Aylish Wood, 'Cinema as Technology: Encounters with an Interface'
Maja Manojlovic, 'Demonlover: Interval, Affect and the Aesthetics of Digital Dislocation'
Chris Rodrigues, ''Into the décor': Attention and Distraction, Foreground and Background'
Bruce Bennett, 'Children, Robots, Cinephilia and Technophobia'
PART 4: MOVEMENT
Michelle Langford, 'Lola and the Vampire: Technologies of Time and Movement in German Cinema'
Bill Schaffer, 'Inbetweening: Animation, Deleuze, Film Theory'
Marie-Luise Angerer, 'Affective Troubles and Cinema'
Thomas Elsaesser, 'Afterword: Digital Cinema and the Apparatus: Archaeologies, Epistemologies, Ontologies'
Papers by Bruce Bennett
Cycling and Cinema explores the history of the bicycle in cinema from the late nineteenth century through to the present day. In this new book from Goldsmiths Press, Bruce Bennett examines a wide variety of films from around the world, ranging from Hollywood blockbusters and slapstick comedies to documentaries, realist dramas, and experimental films, to consider the complex, shifting cultural significance of the bicycle.
The bicycle is an everyday technology, but in examining the ways in which bicycles are used in films, Bennett reveals the rich social and cultural importance of this apparently unremarkable machine. The cinematic bicycles discussed in this book have various functions. They are the source of absurd comedy in silent films, and the vehicles that allow their owners to work in sports films and social realist cinema. They are a means of independence and escape for children in melodramas and kids' films, and the tools that offer political agency and freedom to women, as depicted in films from around the world.
In recounting the cinematic history of the bicycle, Bennett reminds us that this machine is not just a practical means of transport or a child's toy, but the vehicle for a wide range of meanings concerning individual identity, social class, nationhood and belonging, family, gender, and sexuality and pleasure. As this book shows, two hundred years on from its invention, the bicycle is a revolutionary technology that retains the power to transform the world.
Cycling and Cinema explores the history of the bicycle in cinema from the late nineteenth century through to the present day. In this new book from Goldsmiths Press, Bruce Bennett examines a wide variety of films from around the world, ranging from Hollywood blockbusters and slapstick comedies to documentaries, realist dramas, and experimental films, to consider the complex, shifting cultural significance of the bicycle.
The bicycle is an everyday technology, but in examining the ways in which bicycles are used in films, Bennett reveals the rich social and cultural importance of this apparently unremarkable machine. The cinematic bicycles discussed in this book have various functions. They are the source of absurd comedy in silent films, and the vehicles that allow their owners to work in sports films and social realist cinema. They are a means of independence and escape for children in melodramas and kids' films, and the tools that offer political agency and freedom to women, as depicted in films from around the world.
In recounting the cinematic history of the bicycle, Bennett reminds us that this machine is not just a practical means of transport or a child's toy, but the vehicle for a wide range of meanings concerning individual identity, social class, nationhood and belonging, family, gender, and sexuality and pleasure. As this book shows, two hundred years on from its invention, the bicycle is a revolutionary technology that retains the power to transform the world.
filmmaker Michael Winterbottom explores
the thematic, stylistic, and intellectual
consistencies running through the whole
of his eclectic and controversial work.
The volume undertakes a close analysis of
fifteen Winterbottom films ranging from
television dramas to transnational coproductions
featuring Hollywood stars, and from
documentaries to costume films. The critique
is centered on Winterbottom’s collaborative
working practices, political and cultural
contexts, and critical reception. Arguing
that his work delineates a “cinema of
borders,” the book examines Winterbottom’s
treatment of sexuality, class, ethnicity, and
national and international politics, as well
as his quest to adequately narrate inequality,
injustice, and violence.
Contents:
Introduction: Bruce Bennett, Marc Furstenau & Adrian Mackenzie
PART 1: FORMAT
Peter Lester, 'The Perilous Gauge: Canadian Independent Film Exhibition and the 16mm Mobile Menace'
Andrew Clay, 'BMW Films and the Star Wars Kid: 'Early Web Cinema' and Technology'
James Elkins, 'On Some Limits to Film Theory (Mainly From Science)'
PART 2: NORMS
Paul Moore, 'Socially Combustible: Panicky People, Flammable Films, and the Dangerous New Technology of the Nickelodeon'
Jan Harris, 'Cinema and its Doubles: Kittler vs. Deleuze'
Kate O'Riordan, 'Genomic Science in Contemporary Film: Institutions, Individuals and Genre'
PART 3: SCANNING
Aylish Wood, 'Cinema as Technology: Encounters with an Interface'
Maja Manojlovic, 'Demonlover: Interval, Affect and the Aesthetics of Digital Dislocation'
Chris Rodrigues, ''Into the décor': Attention and Distraction, Foreground and Background'
Bruce Bennett, 'Children, Robots, Cinephilia and Technophobia'
PART 4: MOVEMENT
Michelle Langford, 'Lola and the Vampire: Technologies of Time and Movement in German Cinema'
Bill Schaffer, 'Inbetweening: Animation, Deleuze, Film Theory'
Marie-Luise Angerer, 'Affective Troubles and Cinema'
Thomas Elsaesser, 'Afterword: Digital Cinema and the Apparatus: Archaeologies, Epistemologies, Ontologies'
This chapter asks what the function of comedy is in the face of the atrocities and quotidian horrors of the war on terror, and whether comedy offers a platform for subversion and criticism in its refusal to take seriously and reproduce the liberal anxieties, melodramatic urgency and ideological conservatism and earnest documentary realism of dramas such as Generation Kill, Occupation and Britz, or documentaries such as Armadillo: Frontline Afghanistan (Pedersen, 2010), Our War and Restrepo (Hetherington, Junger, 2010) . This piece also asks whether the foregrounding of a camp protagonist can be understood as a parodic critique of the consensual retrenchment of reactionary masculinities that underpin many ‘war on terror’ dramas. The TV series can be situated in a tradition of comedies about reluctant and incompetent soldiering and the everyday homosocial experience of (army) camp life that encompasses Shoulder Arms (Chaplin, 1918), Carry on Sergeant (Thomas, 1958), The Phil Silvers Show (1955-59), Dad’s Army (1968-77), and It Ain’t Half Hot, Mum (1974-81). In concentrating upon the trivial frustrations, tensions and tedium of life on a military base in Scotland, the programmes also eschew the breathless, sensational fascination with the immersive spectacle of battle, and in doing so, prompt reflections upon questions of national and regional identity, class relations, and the normalcy of militarisation and heightened security. The discussion of these series is framed by the broader question of the ‘social signification’ (Bergson) of comedy in the face of terror and the extent to which laughter in response to what Freud terms ‘tendentious jokes’ is here a potential mode of intellectual and political resistance. The chapter explores whether, in their refusal to reproduce the solemnities of ‘serious’ film and TV drama, and the refusal of certain taboos these TV comedies constitute a valuable critique of the limited and restrictive terms of representation that have emerged as the dominant conventions through which this global conflict is depicted in mainstream media representations.
-
Bergson, H, ‘Laughter: An Essay on the meaning of the comic’, trans. Brereton, C.
Freud, S. 1976, Jokes and their Relation to the Unconscious, trans. James Strachey, Middlesex: Penguin
Gilbey, R. 2011, ‘How to tell a horror story’, New Statesman, 5 Sept. 2011, 51-2