Fundamental and applied toxicology : official journal of the Society of Toxicology, 1995
Recently, most attention on the application of benchmark dose (BMD) techniques to toxicology data... more Recently, most attention on the application of benchmark dose (BMD) techniques to toxicology data has focused on quantal measures of response. Before the advantages of the BMD approach can be exploited in the risk assessment process, it is important that continuous measures of response also be modeled appropriately. In this study, we examined a variety of approaches to estimating BMDs for a change in fetal weight following chemical exposure from a total of 85 developmental toxicity experiments. We modeled the change in the mean fetal weight of a litter in response to treatment using a continuous power model, as well as reductions in the weight of individual fetuses within litters (defined as falling below a preset level) using a log-logistic model which incorporates litter size as a covariable and considers intralitter correlations. For the litter-based approach, several methods of defining a benchmark effect (BME) were considered, including a percentage change in mean litter weight...
Twenty-eight compounds of known teratogenic potential were assayed by an in vivo screening proced... more Twenty-eight compounds of known teratogenic potential were assayed by an in vivo screening procedure. Postnatal growth and viability of prenatally exposed offspring was used as a measure of developmental toxicity. Gravid CD-1 mice were administered maximum tolerated doses of the compounds for up to 5 consecutive days during the period of major organogenesis. The dams were allowed to give birth, and litter size and weight on postpartum d 1 and 3 were recorded and compared with concurrent controls. All 15 compounds that were teratogenic by standard teratology test criteria exhibited some form of developmental toxicity. Four chemicals known to produce only fetal toxicity (reduced weight or supernumerary ribs) were tested and the screen successfully identified those that reduced weight. Finally, of the 9 compounds that show no effect in standard tests, 6 were also negative in the screen and 3 demonstrated either reduced viability or weight.
Journal of toxicology and environmental health, 1983
Three chemicals, known either to alter renal development when administered during fetal developme... more Three chemicals, known either to alter renal development when administered during fetal development or to affect renal function when administered to adult rats, were administered to Sprague-Dawley rats at critical periods of renal development. Chlorambucil (CHL) was administered ip on d 11 of gestation at doses of 0, 3, and 6 mg/kg; nitrofen (2,4-dichlorophenyl p-nitrophenyl ether) (NIT) was given po on d 8-16 of gestation at 0, 4.17, 12.5, and 25 mg/kg . d; and mercuric chloride (MER) was given sc on postnatal d 1 at 0, 14, and 28 micrograms/pup. To assess the effects of these toxicants on the functional development of the kidneys, a diuresis test with and without antidiuretic hormone was applied on postnatal d 3 (PD 3); a hydropenia test on PD 6; and kidney weights, glomerular counts in midhilar cross sections, and the specific activity of renal alkaline phosphatase were determined on PD 3 and 6. Data from pups with obvious malformations of the kidneys was eliminated from the stat...
Journal of Toxicology and Environmental Health, 1979
The potential of the fungicide maneb and two of its metabolites, ethylenebisisothiocyanate sulfid... more The potential of the fungicide maneb and two of its metabolites, ethylenebisisothiocyanate sulfide (EBIS) and ethylene thiourea (ETU), to induce perinatal toxicity in four species of rodents was investigated. The compounds were admininistered to rats and mice during the period of organogenesis, and ETU was also administered to rats and mice during the period of organogenesis, and ETU was also administered by oral gavage for a similar period to hamsters and guinea pigs. Treatment also continued through the lactational period in groups of rats that were allowed to give birth. Fetuses were examined for signs of toxicity, including terata, and neonates for reflex developement and open-field behavior. Maneb produced hydrocephalus in fetuses in litters of rats receiving 480 mg/kg . d. No fetotoxic effects were noted in litters of rats receiving EBIS at doses at high as 30 mg/kg . d. ETU proved to be a potent teratogen in the rat. Among the effects seen at doses of 40 mg/kg . d or greater were hydrocephalus, encephalocele, kyphosis, and various defects of the digits. Neither maneb (up to 1500 mg/kg . d), ETU (up to 200 mg/kg . d), nor EBIS (up to 200 mg/kg . d) elicited signs of fetal toxicity in the mouse. ETU also failed to result in fetal toxicity when administered to the hamster (100 mg/kg . d) or the guinea pig (100 mg/kg . d). Neither maneb nor EBIS produced significant dose-related alterations in the behavioral development of perinatally exposed rat neonates. At doses that also produced neonatal hydrocephalus, ETU produced significant increases in the open-field activity of the neonates. In addition to the perinatal effects noted above, both maneb and EBIS caused maternal limb paralysis in the rat, an effect not noted in the mouse at much higher doses.
Biologically based dose-response (BBDR) modeling represents a novel approach for quantitative ass... more Biologically based dose-response (BBDR) modeling represents a novel approach for quantitative assessment of health risk by incorporating pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic characteristics of a chemical and by relating the immediate cellular responses to a cascade of aberrant biological actions that leads to detectable adverse outcomes. The quantitative relationship of each of the intervening events can be described in mathematical forms that are amenable for adjustment and extrapolation over a range of doses and across species. A team of investigators at the Reproductive Toxicology Division of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency has explored the feasibility of BBDR modeling by examining the developmental toxicity of a known teratogen, 5-fluorouracil. A panel of researchers from academic and industrial laboratories, biomathematical modelers, and risk assessment scientists was convened in a workshop to evaluate the approaches undertaken by the EPA team and to discuss the future prospects of BBDR modeling. This report summarizes the lessons learned from one approach to BBDR modeling and comments from the panelists: while it is possible to incorporate mechanistic information into quantitative dose-response models for the assessment of health risks, the process is enormously data-intensive and costly; in addition, the confidence of the model is directly proportional to our current understanding of basic biology and can be enhanced only through the ongoing novel discoveries. More importantly, the extent of "uncertainty" (inher-ent with the default assumptions associated with the NOAEL or benchmark approach) reducible by BBDR modeling requires further scrutiny and comparison.
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) is developing methods for utilizing computational ... more The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) is developing methods for utilizing computational chemistry, high-throughput screening (HTS), and various toxicogenomic technologies to predict potential for toxicity and prioritize limited testing resources toward chemicals that likely represent the greatest hazard to human health and the environment. This chemical prioritization research program, entitled "ToxCast," is being initiated with the purpose of developing the ability to forecast toxicity based on bioactivity profiling. The proof-of-concept phase of ToxCast will focus upon chemicals with an existing, rich toxicological database in order to provide an interpretive context for the ToxCast data. This set of several hundred reference chemicals will represent numerous structural classes and phenotypic outcomes, including tumorigens, developmental and reproductive toxicants, neurotoxicants, and immunotoxicants. The ToxCast program will evaluate chemical properties and bioactivity profiles across a broad spectrum of data domains: physical-chemical, predicted biological activities based on existing structure-activity models, biochemical properties based on HTS assays, cell-based phenotypic assays, and genomic and metabolomic analyses of cells. These data will be generated through a series of external contracts, along with collaborations across EPA, with the National Toxicology Program, and with the National Institutes of Health Chemical Genomics Center. The resulting multidimensional data set provides an informatics challenge requiring appropriate computational methods for integrating various chemical, biological, and toxicological data into profiles and models predicting toxicity.
Developmental toxicity risk assessment currently relies on the estimation of reference doses (RfD... more Developmental toxicity risk assessment currently relies on the estimation of reference doses (RfDDTs) or reference concentrations (RfCDTS) based on the use of no observed adverse effect levels (NOAELs) and uncertainty factors. The benchmark dose (BMD) has been proposed as an alternative basis for reference value calculations. A large database of 246 developmental toxicity experiments (Segment II-type studies) representing 1825 data subsets for various endpoints was compiled for use in comparing NOAEL and BMD approaches to developmental toxicity risk assessment. This paper describes the characteristics of the database used and the estimation of NOAELs using several approaches. For each endpoint evaluated, two NOAELs were calculated using the NOSTASOT procedure (Tukey et al., 1985). The first NOAEL calculation, the QNOAEL, was based on a quantal response where a litter was defined as "affected" if one or more fetuses or implants in the litter had the endpoint of interest. The second NOAEL calculation, the CNOAEL, was based on the proportion of fetuses or implants affected within each litter and was treated as a continuous response variable. Fifty-seven percent of the 246 experiments had at least one endpoint that showed a significant trend with dose. A total of 386 data sets were significant with respect to both the quantal and continuous test of trend. An additional 44 data sets were identified with significant trend only by the quantal approach whereas 177 additional data sets were identified with significant trend tests only by the continuous approach. Thus, the continuous approach appeared to be more powerful in detecting dose-related toxicity, but the patterns detected by the two approaches differed.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
Many chemicals in commerce today have undergone limited or no safety testing. To reduce the numbe... more Many chemicals in commerce today have undergone limited or no safety testing. To reduce the number of untested chemicals and prioritize limited testing resources, several governmental programs are using high-throughput in vitro screens for assessing chemical effects across multiple cellular pathways. In this study, metabolic clearance and plasma protein binding were experimentally measured for 35 ToxCast phase I chemicals. The experimental data were used to parameterize a population-based in vitro-to-in vivo extrapolation model for estimating the human oral equivalent dose necessary to produce a steady-state in vivo concentration equivalent to in vitro AC 50 (concentration at 50% of maximum activity) and LEC (lowest effective concentration) values from the ToxCast data. For 23 of the 35 chemicals, the range of oral equivalent doses for up to 398 ToxCast assays was compared with chronic aggregate human oral exposure estimates in order to assess whether significant in vitro bioactivity occurred within the range of maximum expected human oral exposure. Only 2 of the 35 chemicals, triclosan and pyrithiobac-sodium, had overlapping oral equivalent doses and estimated human oral exposures. Ranking by the potencies of the AC 50 and LEC values, these two chemicals would not have been at the top of a prioritization list. Integrating both dosimetry and human exposure information with the high-throughput toxicity screening efforts provides a better basis for making informed decisions on chemical testing priorities and regulatory attention. Importantly, these tools are necessary to move beyond hazard rankings to estimates of possible in vivo responses based on in vitro screens. Downloaded from FIG. 4. Box plots of AC 50 values across the 398 ToxCast assays for the 35 ToxCast chemicals analyzed. The median, upper, and lower 95% confidence intervals with circles indicating points outside the 95% span are indicated as in Figure 3. The chemicals are presented in the same order as Figure 3 for comparison purposes. DOSIMETRY IN HIGH-THROUGHPUT TOXICITY SCREENS 355
Advances in computer sciences and hardware combined with equally significant developments in mole... more Advances in computer sciences and hardware combined with equally significant developments in molecular biology and chemistry are providing toxicology with a powerful new tool box. This tool box of computational models promises to increase the efficiency and the effectiveness by which the hazards and risks of environmental chemicals are determined. Computational toxicology focuses on applying these tools across many scales, including vastly increasing the numbers of chemicals and the types of biological interactions that can be evaluated. In addition, knowledge of toxicity pathways gathered within the tool box will be directly applicable to the study of the biological responses across a range of dose levels, including those more likely to be representative of exposures to the human population. Progress in this field will facilitate the transformative shift called for in the recent report on toxicology in the 21st century by the National Research Council. This review surveys the state of the art in many areas of computational toxicology and points to several hurdles that will be important to overcome as the field moves forward. Proof-of-concept studies need to clearly demonstrate the additional predictive power gained from these tools. More researchers need to become comfortable working with both the data generating tools and the computational modeling capabilities, and regulatory authorities must show a willingness to the embrace new approaches as they gain scientific acceptance. The next few years should witness the early fruits of these efforts, but as the National Research Council indicates, the paradigm shift will take a long term investment and commitment to reach full potential.
Exposure of mice to the herbicide 2,4-dichlorophenyl-p-nitrophenyl ether during gestation produce... more Exposure of mice to the herbicide 2,4-dichlorophenyl-p-nitrophenyl ether during gestation produces abnormalities that are not readily apparent at birth but become obvious as the pups mature. By 2 weeks after birth there are severe intraorbital defects resulting from destruction of the Harderian glands behind the eyes. This effect is noticeable only postnatally because the Harderian gland does not grow or function until after birth.
The ontogenetic profile of several parameters of neonatal renal development in the rat is present... more The ontogenetic profile of several parameters of neonatal renal development in the rat is presented. Nephrogenesis was observed to continue at a rapid pace between birth and 8 days of age and to be virtually complete by 11 days of age. The activity of alkaline phosphatase, a brush border enzyme, declined during this time period relative to organ growth as a whole. The ability to elaborate a concentrated urine when presented with a period of fluid deprivation was barely present at birth and increased dramatically with age. Finally, the diuresis response to an orally administered water load was detected on the second postnatal day, while the response to antidiuretic hormones was present to a slight degree on the first postnatal day.
The Deepwater Horizon oil spill has led to the use of &am... more The Deepwater Horizon oil spill has led to the use of >1 M gallons of oil spill dispersants, which are mixtures of surfactants and solvents. Because of this large scale use there is a critical need to understand the potential for toxicity of the currently used dispersant and potential alternatives, especially given the limited toxicity testing information that is available. In particular, some dispersants contain nonylphenol ethoxylates (NPEs), which can degrade to nonylphenol (NP), a known endocrine disruptor. Given the urgent need to generate toxicity data, we carried out a series of in vitro high-throughput assays on eight commercial dispersants. These assays focused on the estrogen and androgen receptors (ER and AR), but also included a larger battery of assays probing other biological pathways. Cytotoxicity in mammalian cells was also quantified. No activity was seen in any AR assay. Two dispersants showed a weak ER signal in one assay (EC50 of 16 ppm for Nokomis 3-F4 and 25 ppm for ZI-400). NPs and NPEs also had a weak signal in this same ER assay. Note that Corexit 9500, the currently used product, does not contain NPEs and did not show any ER activity. Cytotoxicity values for six of the dispersants were statistically indistinguishable, with median LC50 values approximately 100 ppm. Two dispersants, JD 2000 and SAF-RON GOLD, were significantly less cytotoxic than the others with LC50 values approaching or exceeding 1000 ppm.
Exposure to environmental chemicals adds to the burden of disease in humans and wildlife to a deg... more Exposure to environmental chemicals adds to the burden of disease in humans and wildlife to a degree that is difficult to estimate and, thus, mitigate. The ability to assess the impact of existing chemicals for which little to no toxicity data are available or to foresee such effects during early stages of chemical development and use, and before potential exposure occurs, is a pressing need. However, the capacity of the current toxicity evaluation approaches to meet this demand is limited by low throughput and high costs. In the context of EPA's ToxCast project, we have evaluated a novel cellular biosensor system (Factorial (1) ) that enables rapid, high-content assessment of a compound's impact on gene regulatory networks. The Factorial biosensors combined libraries of cis- and trans-regulated transcription factor reporter constructs with a highly homogeneous method of detection enabling simultaneous evaluation of multiplexed transcription factor activities. Here, we demonstrate the application of the technology toward determining bioactivity profiles by quantitatively evaluating the effects of 309 environmental chemicals on 25 nuclear receptors and 48 transcription factor response elements. We demonstrate coherent transcription factor activity across nuclear receptors and their response elements and that Nrf2 activity, a marker of oxidative stress, is highly correlated to the overall promiscuity of a chemical. Additionally, as part of the ToxCast program, we identify molecular targets that associate with in vivo end points and represent modes of action that can serve as potential toxicity pathway biomarkers and inputs for predictive modeling of in vivo toxicity.
Teratogenesis, Carcinogenesis, and Mutagenesis, 1985
The effects of acute alterations in maternal health status upon fetal development were assessed f... more The effects of acute alterations in maternal health status upon fetal development were assessed following exposure of pregnant CD-1 mice on day 8 of gestation to one of ten chemicals at doses calculated to exert either a low or a moderate degree of maternal lethality. The dams were killed on day 18 of gestation, and the fetuses were examined by routine teratological techniques. The chemicals were cacodylic acid, caffeine, deltamethrin, dinoseb, ethylene bisisothiocyanate sulfide (EBIS), endrin, guthion, kepone, sodium salicylate, and toxaphene. Three (cacodylic acid, EBIS, and kepone) produced dose-related increases in the incidence of dams with completely resorbed litters. Prenatal mortality in litters that contained live fetuses at term was elevated only for one chemical (cacodylic acid). Fetal weight was reduced in three instances (cacodylic acid, endrin, and guthion), while the incidence of terata was markedly elevated for two (cacodylic acid and kepone). For two other chemicals (endrin and sodium salicylate), a low incidence was found of defects that were similar to defects induced by those chemicals in other species. These effects appear to be chemospecific in nature and not the result of some indirect maternal action. Thus, maternal health status, as measured by the incidence of lethality in the treated groups and by the magnitude of maternal weight gain in surviving females, presents no simple explanation for many manifestations of fetal toxicity. However, for seven chemicals (excluding deltamethrin, EBIS, and kepone) an increased incidence of supernumerary ribs was observed. For three of these seven chemicals (caffeine, dinoseb, and toxaphene), supernumerary ribs was the only observed fetal effect. There was a significant linear inverse relationship between maternal weight gain during gestation and the incidence of extra ribs in the treated groups compared to their respective controls. Under the experimental conditions of this study, it appears that the incidence of supernumerary ribs increased in response to a nonspecific maternal toxicity.
Fundamental and applied toxicology : official journal of the Society of Toxicology, 1995
Recently, most attention on the application of benchmark dose (BMD) techniques to toxicology data... more Recently, most attention on the application of benchmark dose (BMD) techniques to toxicology data has focused on quantal measures of response. Before the advantages of the BMD approach can be exploited in the risk assessment process, it is important that continuous measures of response also be modeled appropriately. In this study, we examined a variety of approaches to estimating BMDs for a change in fetal weight following chemical exposure from a total of 85 developmental toxicity experiments. We modeled the change in the mean fetal weight of a litter in response to treatment using a continuous power model, as well as reductions in the weight of individual fetuses within litters (defined as falling below a preset level) using a log-logistic model which incorporates litter size as a covariable and considers intralitter correlations. For the litter-based approach, several methods of defining a benchmark effect (BME) were considered, including a percentage change in mean litter weight...
Twenty-eight compounds of known teratogenic potential were assayed by an in vivo screening proced... more Twenty-eight compounds of known teratogenic potential were assayed by an in vivo screening procedure. Postnatal growth and viability of prenatally exposed offspring was used as a measure of developmental toxicity. Gravid CD-1 mice were administered maximum tolerated doses of the compounds for up to 5 consecutive days during the period of major organogenesis. The dams were allowed to give birth, and litter size and weight on postpartum d 1 and 3 were recorded and compared with concurrent controls. All 15 compounds that were teratogenic by standard teratology test criteria exhibited some form of developmental toxicity. Four chemicals known to produce only fetal toxicity (reduced weight or supernumerary ribs) were tested and the screen successfully identified those that reduced weight. Finally, of the 9 compounds that show no effect in standard tests, 6 were also negative in the screen and 3 demonstrated either reduced viability or weight.
Journal of toxicology and environmental health, 1983
Three chemicals, known either to alter renal development when administered during fetal developme... more Three chemicals, known either to alter renal development when administered during fetal development or to affect renal function when administered to adult rats, were administered to Sprague-Dawley rats at critical periods of renal development. Chlorambucil (CHL) was administered ip on d 11 of gestation at doses of 0, 3, and 6 mg/kg; nitrofen (2,4-dichlorophenyl p-nitrophenyl ether) (NIT) was given po on d 8-16 of gestation at 0, 4.17, 12.5, and 25 mg/kg . d; and mercuric chloride (MER) was given sc on postnatal d 1 at 0, 14, and 28 micrograms/pup. To assess the effects of these toxicants on the functional development of the kidneys, a diuresis test with and without antidiuretic hormone was applied on postnatal d 3 (PD 3); a hydropenia test on PD 6; and kidney weights, glomerular counts in midhilar cross sections, and the specific activity of renal alkaline phosphatase were determined on PD 3 and 6. Data from pups with obvious malformations of the kidneys was eliminated from the stat...
Journal of Toxicology and Environmental Health, 1979
The potential of the fungicide maneb and two of its metabolites, ethylenebisisothiocyanate sulfid... more The potential of the fungicide maneb and two of its metabolites, ethylenebisisothiocyanate sulfide (EBIS) and ethylene thiourea (ETU), to induce perinatal toxicity in four species of rodents was investigated. The compounds were admininistered to rats and mice during the period of organogenesis, and ETU was also administered to rats and mice during the period of organogenesis, and ETU was also administered by oral gavage for a similar period to hamsters and guinea pigs. Treatment also continued through the lactational period in groups of rats that were allowed to give birth. Fetuses were examined for signs of toxicity, including terata, and neonates for reflex developement and open-field behavior. Maneb produced hydrocephalus in fetuses in litters of rats receiving 480 mg/kg . d. No fetotoxic effects were noted in litters of rats receiving EBIS at doses at high as 30 mg/kg . d. ETU proved to be a potent teratogen in the rat. Among the effects seen at doses of 40 mg/kg . d or greater were hydrocephalus, encephalocele, kyphosis, and various defects of the digits. Neither maneb (up to 1500 mg/kg . d), ETU (up to 200 mg/kg . d), nor EBIS (up to 200 mg/kg . d) elicited signs of fetal toxicity in the mouse. ETU also failed to result in fetal toxicity when administered to the hamster (100 mg/kg . d) or the guinea pig (100 mg/kg . d). Neither maneb nor EBIS produced significant dose-related alterations in the behavioral development of perinatally exposed rat neonates. At doses that also produced neonatal hydrocephalus, ETU produced significant increases in the open-field activity of the neonates. In addition to the perinatal effects noted above, both maneb and EBIS caused maternal limb paralysis in the rat, an effect not noted in the mouse at much higher doses.
Biologically based dose-response (BBDR) modeling represents a novel approach for quantitative ass... more Biologically based dose-response (BBDR) modeling represents a novel approach for quantitative assessment of health risk by incorporating pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic characteristics of a chemical and by relating the immediate cellular responses to a cascade of aberrant biological actions that leads to detectable adverse outcomes. The quantitative relationship of each of the intervening events can be described in mathematical forms that are amenable for adjustment and extrapolation over a range of doses and across species. A team of investigators at the Reproductive Toxicology Division of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency has explored the feasibility of BBDR modeling by examining the developmental toxicity of a known teratogen, 5-fluorouracil. A panel of researchers from academic and industrial laboratories, biomathematical modelers, and risk assessment scientists was convened in a workshop to evaluate the approaches undertaken by the EPA team and to discuss the future prospects of BBDR modeling. This report summarizes the lessons learned from one approach to BBDR modeling and comments from the panelists: while it is possible to incorporate mechanistic information into quantitative dose-response models for the assessment of health risks, the process is enormously data-intensive and costly; in addition, the confidence of the model is directly proportional to our current understanding of basic biology and can be enhanced only through the ongoing novel discoveries. More importantly, the extent of "uncertainty" (inher-ent with the default assumptions associated with the NOAEL or benchmark approach) reducible by BBDR modeling requires further scrutiny and comparison.
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) is developing methods for utilizing computational ... more The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) is developing methods for utilizing computational chemistry, high-throughput screening (HTS), and various toxicogenomic technologies to predict potential for toxicity and prioritize limited testing resources toward chemicals that likely represent the greatest hazard to human health and the environment. This chemical prioritization research program, entitled "ToxCast," is being initiated with the purpose of developing the ability to forecast toxicity based on bioactivity profiling. The proof-of-concept phase of ToxCast will focus upon chemicals with an existing, rich toxicological database in order to provide an interpretive context for the ToxCast data. This set of several hundred reference chemicals will represent numerous structural classes and phenotypic outcomes, including tumorigens, developmental and reproductive toxicants, neurotoxicants, and immunotoxicants. The ToxCast program will evaluate chemical properties and bioactivity profiles across a broad spectrum of data domains: physical-chemical, predicted biological activities based on existing structure-activity models, biochemical properties based on HTS assays, cell-based phenotypic assays, and genomic and metabolomic analyses of cells. These data will be generated through a series of external contracts, along with collaborations across EPA, with the National Toxicology Program, and with the National Institutes of Health Chemical Genomics Center. The resulting multidimensional data set provides an informatics challenge requiring appropriate computational methods for integrating various chemical, biological, and toxicological data into profiles and models predicting toxicity.
Developmental toxicity risk assessment currently relies on the estimation of reference doses (RfD... more Developmental toxicity risk assessment currently relies on the estimation of reference doses (RfDDTs) or reference concentrations (RfCDTS) based on the use of no observed adverse effect levels (NOAELs) and uncertainty factors. The benchmark dose (BMD) has been proposed as an alternative basis for reference value calculations. A large database of 246 developmental toxicity experiments (Segment II-type studies) representing 1825 data subsets for various endpoints was compiled for use in comparing NOAEL and BMD approaches to developmental toxicity risk assessment. This paper describes the characteristics of the database used and the estimation of NOAELs using several approaches. For each endpoint evaluated, two NOAELs were calculated using the NOSTASOT procedure (Tukey et al., 1985). The first NOAEL calculation, the QNOAEL, was based on a quantal response where a litter was defined as "affected" if one or more fetuses or implants in the litter had the endpoint of interest. The second NOAEL calculation, the CNOAEL, was based on the proportion of fetuses or implants affected within each litter and was treated as a continuous response variable. Fifty-seven percent of the 246 experiments had at least one endpoint that showed a significant trend with dose. A total of 386 data sets were significant with respect to both the quantal and continuous test of trend. An additional 44 data sets were identified with significant trend only by the quantal approach whereas 177 additional data sets were identified with significant trend tests only by the continuous approach. Thus, the continuous approach appeared to be more powerful in detecting dose-related toxicity, but the patterns detected by the two approaches differed.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
Many chemicals in commerce today have undergone limited or no safety testing. To reduce the numbe... more Many chemicals in commerce today have undergone limited or no safety testing. To reduce the number of untested chemicals and prioritize limited testing resources, several governmental programs are using high-throughput in vitro screens for assessing chemical effects across multiple cellular pathways. In this study, metabolic clearance and plasma protein binding were experimentally measured for 35 ToxCast phase I chemicals. The experimental data were used to parameterize a population-based in vitro-to-in vivo extrapolation model for estimating the human oral equivalent dose necessary to produce a steady-state in vivo concentration equivalent to in vitro AC 50 (concentration at 50% of maximum activity) and LEC (lowest effective concentration) values from the ToxCast data. For 23 of the 35 chemicals, the range of oral equivalent doses for up to 398 ToxCast assays was compared with chronic aggregate human oral exposure estimates in order to assess whether significant in vitro bioactivity occurred within the range of maximum expected human oral exposure. Only 2 of the 35 chemicals, triclosan and pyrithiobac-sodium, had overlapping oral equivalent doses and estimated human oral exposures. Ranking by the potencies of the AC 50 and LEC values, these two chemicals would not have been at the top of a prioritization list. Integrating both dosimetry and human exposure information with the high-throughput toxicity screening efforts provides a better basis for making informed decisions on chemical testing priorities and regulatory attention. Importantly, these tools are necessary to move beyond hazard rankings to estimates of possible in vivo responses based on in vitro screens. Downloaded from FIG. 4. Box plots of AC 50 values across the 398 ToxCast assays for the 35 ToxCast chemicals analyzed. The median, upper, and lower 95% confidence intervals with circles indicating points outside the 95% span are indicated as in Figure 3. The chemicals are presented in the same order as Figure 3 for comparison purposes. DOSIMETRY IN HIGH-THROUGHPUT TOXICITY SCREENS 355
Advances in computer sciences and hardware combined with equally significant developments in mole... more Advances in computer sciences and hardware combined with equally significant developments in molecular biology and chemistry are providing toxicology with a powerful new tool box. This tool box of computational models promises to increase the efficiency and the effectiveness by which the hazards and risks of environmental chemicals are determined. Computational toxicology focuses on applying these tools across many scales, including vastly increasing the numbers of chemicals and the types of biological interactions that can be evaluated. In addition, knowledge of toxicity pathways gathered within the tool box will be directly applicable to the study of the biological responses across a range of dose levels, including those more likely to be representative of exposures to the human population. Progress in this field will facilitate the transformative shift called for in the recent report on toxicology in the 21st century by the National Research Council. This review surveys the state of the art in many areas of computational toxicology and points to several hurdles that will be important to overcome as the field moves forward. Proof-of-concept studies need to clearly demonstrate the additional predictive power gained from these tools. More researchers need to become comfortable working with both the data generating tools and the computational modeling capabilities, and regulatory authorities must show a willingness to the embrace new approaches as they gain scientific acceptance. The next few years should witness the early fruits of these efforts, but as the National Research Council indicates, the paradigm shift will take a long term investment and commitment to reach full potential.
Exposure of mice to the herbicide 2,4-dichlorophenyl-p-nitrophenyl ether during gestation produce... more Exposure of mice to the herbicide 2,4-dichlorophenyl-p-nitrophenyl ether during gestation produces abnormalities that are not readily apparent at birth but become obvious as the pups mature. By 2 weeks after birth there are severe intraorbital defects resulting from destruction of the Harderian glands behind the eyes. This effect is noticeable only postnatally because the Harderian gland does not grow or function until after birth.
The ontogenetic profile of several parameters of neonatal renal development in the rat is present... more The ontogenetic profile of several parameters of neonatal renal development in the rat is presented. Nephrogenesis was observed to continue at a rapid pace between birth and 8 days of age and to be virtually complete by 11 days of age. The activity of alkaline phosphatase, a brush border enzyme, declined during this time period relative to organ growth as a whole. The ability to elaborate a concentrated urine when presented with a period of fluid deprivation was barely present at birth and increased dramatically with age. Finally, the diuresis response to an orally administered water load was detected on the second postnatal day, while the response to antidiuretic hormones was present to a slight degree on the first postnatal day.
The Deepwater Horizon oil spill has led to the use of &am... more The Deepwater Horizon oil spill has led to the use of >1 M gallons of oil spill dispersants, which are mixtures of surfactants and solvents. Because of this large scale use there is a critical need to understand the potential for toxicity of the currently used dispersant and potential alternatives, especially given the limited toxicity testing information that is available. In particular, some dispersants contain nonylphenol ethoxylates (NPEs), which can degrade to nonylphenol (NP), a known endocrine disruptor. Given the urgent need to generate toxicity data, we carried out a series of in vitro high-throughput assays on eight commercial dispersants. These assays focused on the estrogen and androgen receptors (ER and AR), but also included a larger battery of assays probing other biological pathways. Cytotoxicity in mammalian cells was also quantified. No activity was seen in any AR assay. Two dispersants showed a weak ER signal in one assay (EC50 of 16 ppm for Nokomis 3-F4 and 25 ppm for ZI-400). NPs and NPEs also had a weak signal in this same ER assay. Note that Corexit 9500, the currently used product, does not contain NPEs and did not show any ER activity. Cytotoxicity values for six of the dispersants were statistically indistinguishable, with median LC50 values approximately 100 ppm. Two dispersants, JD 2000 and SAF-RON GOLD, were significantly less cytotoxic than the others with LC50 values approaching or exceeding 1000 ppm.
Exposure to environmental chemicals adds to the burden of disease in humans and wildlife to a deg... more Exposure to environmental chemicals adds to the burden of disease in humans and wildlife to a degree that is difficult to estimate and, thus, mitigate. The ability to assess the impact of existing chemicals for which little to no toxicity data are available or to foresee such effects during early stages of chemical development and use, and before potential exposure occurs, is a pressing need. However, the capacity of the current toxicity evaluation approaches to meet this demand is limited by low throughput and high costs. In the context of EPA's ToxCast project, we have evaluated a novel cellular biosensor system (Factorial (1) ) that enables rapid, high-content assessment of a compound's impact on gene regulatory networks. The Factorial biosensors combined libraries of cis- and trans-regulated transcription factor reporter constructs with a highly homogeneous method of detection enabling simultaneous evaluation of multiplexed transcription factor activities. Here, we demonstrate the application of the technology toward determining bioactivity profiles by quantitatively evaluating the effects of 309 environmental chemicals on 25 nuclear receptors and 48 transcription factor response elements. We demonstrate coherent transcription factor activity across nuclear receptors and their response elements and that Nrf2 activity, a marker of oxidative stress, is highly correlated to the overall promiscuity of a chemical. Additionally, as part of the ToxCast program, we identify molecular targets that associate with in vivo end points and represent modes of action that can serve as potential toxicity pathway biomarkers and inputs for predictive modeling of in vivo toxicity.
Teratogenesis, Carcinogenesis, and Mutagenesis, 1985
The effects of acute alterations in maternal health status upon fetal development were assessed f... more The effects of acute alterations in maternal health status upon fetal development were assessed following exposure of pregnant CD-1 mice on day 8 of gestation to one of ten chemicals at doses calculated to exert either a low or a moderate degree of maternal lethality. The dams were killed on day 18 of gestation, and the fetuses were examined by routine teratological techniques. The chemicals were cacodylic acid, caffeine, deltamethrin, dinoseb, ethylene bisisothiocyanate sulfide (EBIS), endrin, guthion, kepone, sodium salicylate, and toxaphene. Three (cacodylic acid, EBIS, and kepone) produced dose-related increases in the incidence of dams with completely resorbed litters. Prenatal mortality in litters that contained live fetuses at term was elevated only for one chemical (cacodylic acid). Fetal weight was reduced in three instances (cacodylic acid, endrin, and guthion), while the incidence of terata was markedly elevated for two (cacodylic acid and kepone). For two other chemicals (endrin and sodium salicylate), a low incidence was found of defects that were similar to defects induced by those chemicals in other species. These effects appear to be chemospecific in nature and not the result of some indirect maternal action. Thus, maternal health status, as measured by the incidence of lethality in the treated groups and by the magnitude of maternal weight gain in surviving females, presents no simple explanation for many manifestations of fetal toxicity. However, for seven chemicals (excluding deltamethrin, EBIS, and kepone) an increased incidence of supernumerary ribs was observed. For three of these seven chemicals (caffeine, dinoseb, and toxaphene), supernumerary ribs was the only observed fetal effect. There was a significant linear inverse relationship between maternal weight gain during gestation and the incidence of extra ribs in the treated groups compared to their respective controls. Under the experimental conditions of this study, it appears that the incidence of supernumerary ribs increased in response to a nonspecific maternal toxicity.
Uploads
Papers by Robert Kavlock