Copyright (c) 2010 University of Michigan Law School Michigan Telecommunications and Technology L... more Copyright (c) 2010 University of Michigan Law School Michigan Telecommunications and Technology Law Review. Spring, 2010. 16 Mich. Telecomm. Tech. L. Rev. 279. LENGTH: 36005 words THERE IS A TIME TO KEEP SILENT ...
PSA: Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association, 1994
David Marr's theory of vision has been a source of both fascination and confusion for many in... more David Marr's theory of vision has been a source of both fascination and confusion for many in cognitive science. There has, of course, been substantial technical interest in the particulars of Marr's model. But beyond this we have seen his work cited in debates about the nature of mental representation and computation, the structure of cognition, the role of theoretical knowledge in perception, how and indeed whether one ought to apply results from cognitive science to antecedent questions in epistemology. Marr's theory is cited in such debates because it is widely seen as a successful, rigorous account of a large scale cognitive/perceptual process (if not as the successful such account). But it has been suggested that Marr's theory might be mistaken as a whole; that Marr might have been wrong not just about one or several of the sub-mechanisms of vision, and not just in offering an incomplete account, but wrong in his basic approach to the study of vision.
PSA: Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association, 1990
Page 1. Observation: An Empirical Discussionl Daniel Gilman Pennsylvania State University 1. Intr... more Page 1. Observation: An Empirical Discussionl Daniel Gilman Pennsylvania State University 1. Introduction Of the many controversial claims in Thomas Kuhn's The Structure of Scientific Revolutions perhaps none are more troublesome ...
ABSTRACT. David Marr's theory of vision has been a rich source of inspiration, fascina-tion ... more ABSTRACT. David Marr's theory of vision has been a rich source of inspiration, fascina-tion and confusion. I will suggest that some of this confusion can be traced to discrepancies between the way Man" developed his theory inpractice and the way he suggested such a the-ory ...
Block (1995t) has argued for a noncognitive and non- representational notion of phenomenal consci... more Block (1995t) has argued for a noncognitive and non- representational notion of phenomenal consciousness, but his putative examples of this phenomenon are conspicuous in their representational and functional properties while they do not clearly possess other phenomenal properties.
From the Publisher: Biomedicine has become one of the best-modeled domains from several perspecti... more From the Publisher: Biomedicine has become one of the best-modeled domains from several perspectives - artificial intelligence, psychology, and the social sciences; yet few studies have combined these points of view. In this book, the interdisciplinary strengths of cognitive science offer fresh insights into biomedical problem solving. Cognitive Science in Medicine presents current research that focuses on issues and results in applying techniques from cognitive science to problems in biomedicine. It includes material by researchers who have worked in both areas and is unique in linking models of physician knowledge with models of physician behavior. David Evans discusses issues of cognitive science in medicine in his introduction; and in a chapter with Cindy Gadd and Harry Pople, deals with the problem of managing coherence and context in medical problem-solving discourse. Vimla Patel, Evans, and Guy Groen provide experimental data that illuminates the role of biomedical knowledge in clinical reasoning; and Patel, Evans, and David Kaufman offer a cognitive science framework for analysis of clinical interviews. Other contributors and subjects include Clark Glymour on the empirical and representational issues in cognitive and medical science; Alan Lesgold on multilevel models of expertise; Arthur Elstein, James Dodd, and Gerald B. Holzman on the analysis of estrogen replacement decisions among residents; Kenneth R. Hammond, Elizabeth Frederick, Nichole Robillard, and Doreen Victor on the features of the student-teacher dialog in medicine; Naomi Rodolitz and William J. Clancey on tutoring for strategic knowledge; Paul J. Feltovich, Rand J. Spiro, and Richard L. Coulson on the foundationsof misunderstanding in established medical knowledge; John K. Vries, Evans, and Peretz Shoval on the development of semantic networks for medical information retrieval; and John Bruer, with a preface on the implications of cognitive-scientific studies for medical education. David A. Evans is Assistant Professor of Linguistics and Computer Science at Carnegie-Mellon University and Vimla L. Patel is Associate Professor of Medicine and Educational Psychology at McGill University. A Bradford Book.
... Gerard O'Brien completed his D.Phil. ... In sections 3 and 4, we examine the nature of i... more ... Gerard O'Brien completed his D.Phil. ... In sections 3 and 4, we examine the nature of infor-mation coding in classicism and connectionism, respec-tively, in an effort to determine whether either of these conceptions of cognition ... The same does not apply to connectionists, however ...
Paul Churchland has recently argued that empirical evidence strongly suggests that perception is ... more Paul Churchland has recently argued that empirical evidence strongly suggests that perception is penetrable to the beliefs or theories held by individual per-ceivers (1988). While there has been much discussion of the sorts of psycho-logical cases he presents, little has been ...
Copyright (c) 2010 University of Michigan Law School Michigan Telecommunications and Technology L... more Copyright (c) 2010 University of Michigan Law School Michigan Telecommunications and Technology Law Review. Spring, 2010. 16 Mich. Telecomm. Tech. L. Rev. 279. LENGTH: 36005 words THERE IS A TIME TO KEEP SILENT ...
PSA: Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association, 1994
David Marr's theory of vision has been a source of both fascination and confusion for many in... more David Marr's theory of vision has been a source of both fascination and confusion for many in cognitive science. There has, of course, been substantial technical interest in the particulars of Marr's model. But beyond this we have seen his work cited in debates about the nature of mental representation and computation, the structure of cognition, the role of theoretical knowledge in perception, how and indeed whether one ought to apply results from cognitive science to antecedent questions in epistemology. Marr's theory is cited in such debates because it is widely seen as a successful, rigorous account of a large scale cognitive/perceptual process (if not as the successful such account). But it has been suggested that Marr's theory might be mistaken as a whole; that Marr might have been wrong not just about one or several of the sub-mechanisms of vision, and not just in offering an incomplete account, but wrong in his basic approach to the study of vision.
PSA: Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association, 1990
Page 1. Observation: An Empirical Discussionl Daniel Gilman Pennsylvania State University 1. Intr... more Page 1. Observation: An Empirical Discussionl Daniel Gilman Pennsylvania State University 1. Introduction Of the many controversial claims in Thomas Kuhn's The Structure of Scientific Revolutions perhaps none are more troublesome ...
ABSTRACT. David Marr's theory of vision has been a rich source of inspiration, fascina-tion ... more ABSTRACT. David Marr's theory of vision has been a rich source of inspiration, fascina-tion and confusion. I will suggest that some of this confusion can be traced to discrepancies between the way Man" developed his theory inpractice and the way he suggested such a the-ory ...
Block (1995t) has argued for a noncognitive and non- representational notion of phenomenal consci... more Block (1995t) has argued for a noncognitive and non- representational notion of phenomenal consciousness, but his putative examples of this phenomenon are conspicuous in their representational and functional properties while they do not clearly possess other phenomenal properties.
From the Publisher: Biomedicine has become one of the best-modeled domains from several perspecti... more From the Publisher: Biomedicine has become one of the best-modeled domains from several perspectives - artificial intelligence, psychology, and the social sciences; yet few studies have combined these points of view. In this book, the interdisciplinary strengths of cognitive science offer fresh insights into biomedical problem solving. Cognitive Science in Medicine presents current research that focuses on issues and results in applying techniques from cognitive science to problems in biomedicine. It includes material by researchers who have worked in both areas and is unique in linking models of physician knowledge with models of physician behavior. David Evans discusses issues of cognitive science in medicine in his introduction; and in a chapter with Cindy Gadd and Harry Pople, deals with the problem of managing coherence and context in medical problem-solving discourse. Vimla Patel, Evans, and Guy Groen provide experimental data that illuminates the role of biomedical knowledge in clinical reasoning; and Patel, Evans, and David Kaufman offer a cognitive science framework for analysis of clinical interviews. Other contributors and subjects include Clark Glymour on the empirical and representational issues in cognitive and medical science; Alan Lesgold on multilevel models of expertise; Arthur Elstein, James Dodd, and Gerald B. Holzman on the analysis of estrogen replacement decisions among residents; Kenneth R. Hammond, Elizabeth Frederick, Nichole Robillard, and Doreen Victor on the features of the student-teacher dialog in medicine; Naomi Rodolitz and William J. Clancey on tutoring for strategic knowledge; Paul J. Feltovich, Rand J. Spiro, and Richard L. Coulson on the foundationsof misunderstanding in established medical knowledge; John K. Vries, Evans, and Peretz Shoval on the development of semantic networks for medical information retrieval; and John Bruer, with a preface on the implications of cognitive-scientific studies for medical education. David A. Evans is Assistant Professor of Linguistics and Computer Science at Carnegie-Mellon University and Vimla L. Patel is Associate Professor of Medicine and Educational Psychology at McGill University. A Bradford Book.
... Gerard O'Brien completed his D.Phil. ... In sections 3 and 4, we examine the nature of i... more ... Gerard O'Brien completed his D.Phil. ... In sections 3 and 4, we examine the nature of infor-mation coding in classicism and connectionism, respec-tively, in an effort to determine whether either of these conceptions of cognition ... The same does not apply to connectionists, however ...
Paul Churchland has recently argued that empirical evidence strongly suggests that perception is ... more Paul Churchland has recently argued that empirical evidence strongly suggests that perception is penetrable to the beliefs or theories held by individual per-ceivers (1988). While there has been much discussion of the sorts of psycho-logical cases he presents, little has been ...
Uploads
Papers by Daniel Gilman