The catch composition of bottom trawls is commonly refined and improved through changes in codend... more The catch composition of bottom trawls is commonly refined and improved through changes in codend design. Measures like reducing the number of meshes in codend circumference or turning diamond netting by 90 degrees are well known to improve the size selectivity of fish species with rounded cross-sectional shape. Based on this we speculated whether the same measures, if applied in other parts of a bottom trawl, would provide similar benefits as in the codend. Therefore, experiments were carried out by deploying these changes to the trawl extension piece in a Mediterranean bottom trawl fishery. However, for European hake and monkfish, results showed no indication of improved selectivity or catch pattern compared to the standard extension piece in the trawl. Contrary, for red mullet, one of the most important species in this fishery, reducing the number of meshes in the circumference of the extension piece jeopardized the size selection obtained in the trawl with a standard extension p...
The introduction of the Nordmøre grid in shrimp trawls has reduced the bycatch of non-target spec... more The introduction of the Nordmøre grid in shrimp trawls has reduced the bycatch of non-target species. In the Norwegian Northern shrimp (Pandalus borealis) fishery, the mandatory selective gear consists of a Nordmøre grid with 19 mm bar spacing combined with a 35 mm mesh size diamond mesh codend. However, fish bycatch in shrimp trawls remains a challenge and further modifications of the gear that can improve selectivity are still sought. Therefore, this study estimated and compared the size selectivity of Nordmøre grids with bar spacings of 17 and 21 mm. Further, the effect of applying these two grids on trawl size selectivity was predicted and compared to the legislated gear configuration. Experimental fishing trials were conducted in the Barents Sea where the bottom trawl fleet targets Northern shrimp. Results were obtained for the target species and two by-catch species: cod (Gadus morhua) and American plaice (Hippoglossoides platessoides). This study demonstrated that reducing ba...
Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences
Diamond-mesh codends are the most commonly used in demersal trawls. However, mesh geometry tends ... more Diamond-mesh codends are the most commonly used in demersal trawls. However, mesh geometry tends to vary in these codends during fishing, which leads to a less well-defined size selection process. This leaves one questioning the rationality of regulating exploitation patterns based on mesh size when size selection and (or) variation between hauls is highly variable. While it has been speculated and theoretically investigated how much the variability in mesh geometry may contribute to the variability in size selection, it remained to be quantified experimentally. Therefore, we conducted field test comparing the size selectivity of a simple diamond-mesh codend, where meshes are subjected to variation in geometry, with a rigid diamond-mesh codend, where the geometry of the meshes were kept constant. For Atlantic cod ( Gadus morhua), the simple diamond-mesh codend was found to have 45% more variation in size selection than the codend with fixed mesh geometry. This confirms theoretical p...
Gear modifications in fisheries are usually implemented to obtain catch patterns that meet manage... more Gear modifications in fisheries are usually implemented to obtain catch patterns that meet management objectives. In the Basque bottom trawl fishery, gear regulations include the use of a square mesh panel (SMP) placed at the top panel of the extension piece of the trawl to supplement diamond mesh codend selectivity. However, the catch patterns obtained with this combination have raised concern among scientists and authorities. This study combines new data on different SMP and codend designs with existing data from the literature to produce new results that are applied to predict the size selectivity and catch patterns of different gear combinations for a variety of fishing scenarios. A systematic approach based on the concept of treatment trees was outlined and applied to depict the effect of individual and combined gear design changes on size selectivity and catch patterns for hake (Merluccius merluccius) and blue whiting (Micromesistius poutassou). This approach led to identifica...
Commercial bycatch species and their exploitation pattern in the Mediterranean trawl fishery are ... more Commercial bycatch species and their exploitation pattern in the Mediterranean trawl fishery are little studied. The present work examines the overall size-selection pattern, both regarding the trawl in the sea and the fisher onboard the vessel, for seven commercial bycatch species using different codends. The applied selection model predicted the escape, discard, and landing probability for each species simultaneously, a useful method for providing information important for fisheries management under the ecosystem approach. Among the studied codends, the 40-mm diamond mesh codend, still in use in non-EU Mediterranean fleets, was found unsuitable for the stocks in all cases. The 40-mm square mesh codend (40S) was found appropriate for blue whiting (Micromesistius poutassou), comber (Serranus cabrilla), and bogue (Boops boops) sustainability. The 50-mm diamond mesh codend (50D) was more suitable than the square mesh codend only for the spotted flounder (Citharus linguatula). Both the...
Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 2021
In most trawl fisheries, drag forces tend to close the meshes in large areas of diamond mesh code... more In most trawl fisheries, drag forces tend to close the meshes in large areas of diamond mesh codends, negatively affecting their selective potential. In the Barents Sea deep-water shrimp (Pandalus borealis) trawl fishery, selectivity is based on a sorting grid followed by a diamond mesh codend. However, the retention of juvenile fish as well as undersized shrimp is still a problem. In this study, we estimated the effect of applying different codend modifications, each aimed at affecting codend mesh openness and thereby selectivity. Changing from a 4-panel to a 2-panel construction of the codend did not affect size selectivity. Shortening the lastridge ropes of a 4-panel codend by 20% resulted in minor reductions for juvenile fish bycatch, but a 45% reduction of undersized shrimp was observed. Target-size catches of shrimp were nearly unaffected. When the codend mesh circumference was reduced while simultaneously shortening the lastridge ropes, the effect on catch efficiency for shri...
This study investigated the size selectivity and catch efficiency in the Northeast Atlantic demer... more This study investigated the size selectivity and catch efficiency in the Northeast Atlantic demersal trawl fishery targeting cod (Gadus morhua) and haddock (Melanogrammus aeglefinus). The use of a sorting grid followed by a size selective codend is compulsory in this fishery. Experimental fishing was conducted with a commercially rigged trawl, flexigrid section, and diamond-mesh codend. The flexigrid section is a dual sorting system and all fish that escaped from the two grids in the flexigrid system and the codend were retained in separate covers. This allowed us to estimate the combined size selectivity of the system, as well as the separate contributions from the first grid, second grid, and codend. The catch efficiencies for cod and haddock below and above the minimum reference length (MRL) were quantified by estimating the values for a set of exploitation pattern indicators. The results showed that most fish escaped from the flexigrid section. Only a few fish below the MRL entered the codend and nearly all of them subsequently escaped through the codend meshes. The probability of retaining undersized cod and haddock was low with the combined system. Furthermore, the results showed that the probability of escape was high through the second grid in the system for fish above the MRL, and this finding was supported by the exploitation pattern indicators. In particular, the estimated exploitation pattern indicators showed that using the current MRL and the fish size distributions encountered during the trials, no haddock and only 2.3 % of cod below the MRL were retained by the gear. However, 77.4 % of the haddock and 16.0 % of the cod above the MRL were found to escape, thereby indicating poor catch efficiency, especially for haddock. These results demonstrate the importance of supplementing size selectivity research with estimates of the actual catch efficiency using the gear employed, which were quantified using exploitation pattern indicators in this study.
The effect of shifting from a diamond mesh codend (T0) to a 90° turned mesh codend (T90) on the s... more The effect of shifting from a diamond mesh codend (T0) to a 90° turned mesh codend (T90) on the size selectivity of seven commercially important species in the Mediterranean bottom trawl fishery was evaluated. During sea trials conducted in the north-western Adriatic, two experimental codends made of 54 mm nominal mesh size netting that differed only in mesh configuration were alternately mounted on the same trawl. Overall, the size selectivity was significantly improved for all the species analysed, shifting from T0 to T90. The difference in the average expected L50values between T90 and T0 was particularly marked in European hake (Merluccius merluccius, 21.26 vs 11.26 cm total length), common squid (Loligo vulgaris, 12.06 vs 7.88 cm mantle length) and mantis shrimp (Squilla mantis, 20.78 vs 13.35 mm carapace length). Both codends had an excessive size selectivity especially for red mullet (Mullus barbatus), Mediterranean horse mackerel (Trachurus mediterraneus) and whiting (Merlan...
Damage incurred during the catch process is an indicator of the overall quality of fish and fish ... more Damage incurred during the catch process is an indicator of the overall quality of fish and fish welfare. Because catch quality is difficult to improve once it has deteriorated, it is important to preserve quality during the catch process. Atlantic cod (Gadus morhua) is the most important species in the Barents Sea bottom trawl fishery. Bottom trawling is a non-benign fishing method, and it is therefore considered important to reduce damage imparted to fish during capture, and subsequently improve catch quality and fish welfare. In the present study, the levels of damage on cod captured with a new gear design were assessed in the Barents Sea bottom trawl fishery. Furthermore, this study investigated to what extent the compulsory sorting grid and diamond mesh codend configuration employed in the fishery is responsible for the damage incurred by cod during the capture process. In total, 750 cod captured over 25 hauls were evaluated for catch damage (marks, ecchymosis, exsanguination, and scale loss). The results showed that substituting the grid and codend configuration with a four-panel selective knotless section followed by a gentle codend increased the probability of cod having no catch damage by 6.00% (CI: 0.6%-11.41%). Moreover, the gentle codend led to a significant reduction in the severity of all catch damage categories.
Journal of Northwest Atlantic Fishery Science, 2017
selection of Greenland halibut (Reinhardtius hippoglossoides) in the Norwegian bottom trawl fishe... more selection of Greenland halibut (Reinhardtius hippoglossoides) in the Norwegian bottom trawl fishery with a newly developed double grid system.
Shrimp trawlers in the Barents Sea use a Nordmøre sorting grid ahead of a small-mesh codend to av... more Shrimp trawlers in the Barents Sea use a Nordmøre sorting grid ahead of a small-mesh codend to avoid bycatch while catching shrimps efficiently. However, small fish can still pass through the grid to enter the codend, which increases their risk of being retained. In this study, we quantified the selectivity of a standard Nordmøre grid used together with one of two different codend designs, namely a diamond mesh codend with square mesh panels and a codend with a square mesh sorting cone section, for deep-water shrimp (Pandalus borealis), redfish (Sebastes spp.), and American plaice (Hippoglossoides platessoides). For the first time, the selective properties of these two alternative designs were estimated and compared to those of a Nordmøre grid used together with a 35-mm diamond mesh codend, which is the compulsory gear used in the fishery today. With this traditional codend, the size selectivity of both bycatch species showed the expected characteristic bell-shaped size selection pattern, with low retention probability of very small fish and bigger fish but with high retention probability of certain sizes of juveniles. Using the square mesh sorting cone significantly reduced the maximum retention risk of redfish. The maximum retention with the diamond mesh codend with square mesh panels was estimated to be 14% lower than that of the traditional codend, but the difference was not statistically significant. The two alternative codend designs did not result in any significant reduction in bycatch of American plaice.
The Nordmøre grid is the principle bycatch mitigation device in many shrimp trawl fisheries. Howe... more The Nordmøre grid is the principle bycatch mitigation device in many shrimp trawl fisheries. However, in several of these fisheries, bycatch is a problem because small sized fish can pass through the grid and enter the codend together with the targeted shrimp. One such fishery is the Northeast Atlantic deep-water shrimp (Pandalus borealis) fishery, where the use of a Nordmøre grid is mandatory. In this fishery, redfish (Sebastes spp.) and polar cod (Boreogadus saida) are two common bycatch species. Redfish is a commercially important species that at times is captured in great numbers, whereas polar cod is a threatened species that can also be caught in high numbers. Sieve panels are bycatch reduction devices commonly used in shrimp fisheries and their potential to replace or supplement the Nordmøre grid in the Northeast Atlantic deep-water shrimp fishery is of interest. We investigated the size selectivity of redfish, polar cod and deep-water shrimp for the Nordmøre grid and four sieve panel configurations differing in mesh size (182 and 286 mm) and inclination angle (10 and 20°). The sieve panels were unable to replace the Nordmøre grid as a stand-alone device due to greater catches of the bycatch species. However, combining the two devices provided promising results. Specifically, when a large-mesh sieve panel was placed in front of the Nordmøre grid, 20-40% fewer small redfish and polar cod in a specific size range entered the codend, while the loss of targeted shrimp was less than 5%.
The Nordmøre grid and the sieve panel are two of the main devices used to reduce fish bycatch in ... more The Nordmøre grid and the sieve panel are two of the main devices used to reduce fish bycatch in trawl fisheries targeting shrimp species. However, even when using such devices, some small-sized fish enter the codend of the trawl together with the targeted shrimp. Therefore, bycatch reduction remains a problem in some shrimp fisheries. One such fishery is the Northeast Atlantic deep-water shrimp (Pandalus borealis) fishery where it is mandatory to use a Nordmøre grid. In this study, the bycatch reduction efficiencies and patterns for several fish species using the standard Nordmøre grid and an experimental sieve panel were investigated and compared. The effect of combining these devices was also explored. The bycatch reduction patterns differed significantly between the two devices and a more efficient bycatch reduction was obtained by combining them. However, while the loss of commercial-sized shrimp was only between 0 and 2% for the Nordmøre grid, it was between 37 and 56% for the tested sieve panel, making this completely unacceptable for commercial fishing. Therefore, before a sieve panel can be considered as an option for the fishery, other sieve panel designs that have a significantly lower loss of shrimp catches need to be identified.
Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 2019
Size selectivity of a new sorting section combining a sorting grid and a square mesh panel was te... more Size selectivity of a new sorting section combining a sorting grid and a square mesh panel was tested for haddock (Melanogrammus aeglefinus) in the Barents Sea demersal trawl fishery. Sampling data for a wide size range enabled investigating the selection process for this species in detail, both for the grid and the square mesh panel. Contrary to earlier studies modelling size selectivity for grids and square mesh panels, which assume that the escape behaviour of all sizes of fish is equal, we applied a model that accounted for haddock of different sizes showing different escape behaviours. Our results demonstrated that this model could describe the experimental data collected better than existing models. Specifically, our results showed that the likelihood for smaller haddock to seek escape through the grid and the square mesh panel was higher than that for bigger haddock that still would manage to escape through the devices if they attempted. The new modelling approach presented i...
In recent years, Norwegian fishermen have reported problems with fish accumulation in front of th... more In recent years, Norwegian fishermen have reported problems with fish accumulation in front of the mandatory sorting grids (Sort-X, Sort-V, and Flexigrid). These problems are associated with high fish entry rates and low water flow through the grid sections. In this study, we replaced the lifting panel in the original design of a sorting grid section (Sort-V) by another steel grid ("lower grid") in order to improve water flow and increase sorting area. Two different inclination angles of this new additional "lower grid" were tested. The results demonstrated that both the lower grid and the main grid contributed to the release of cod and haddock. However, the release efficiency of the lower grid was low compared to that of the main grid. A larger proportion of fish contacted at least one of the grids with the lower grid set at 40 o compared to at 35 o. The new double grid was found to release significantly more haddock between 38 and 50 cm long than the mandatory Flexigrid. For cod, the sorting system was at least as good as the Flexigrid at releasing undersized fish. Thus, the new double grid system represents a potential alternative to the Flexigrid. Although the Sort-V single grid releases significantly more undersized cod and haddock than the new double grid system, it also releases a significantly higher proportion of the targeted commercial sizes.
Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 2019
The Nordmøre grid is regarded as an efficient bycatch-reducing device and is used in various shri... more The Nordmøre grid is regarded as an efficient bycatch-reducing device and is used in various shrimp trawl fisheries globally. However, in some shrimp fisheries, bycatch remains a problem that seriously impacts commercial trawl activities. This study tested and compared the performance of two versions of the Nordmøre grid in the northeast Arctic deepwater (northern) shrimp (Pandalus borealis) fishery, a standard version with an operating angle of approximately 45° and a longer version of the grid (40% longer) with an operating angle of approximately 30°. The grid passage probability for the bycatch of juvenile cod (Gadus morhua), haddock (Melanogrammus aeglefinus), American plaice (Hippoglossoides platessoides), and redfish (Sebastes spp.) increased significantly for certain size ranges of fish when using the longer grid. The longer grid also resulted in a significant increase in grid passage probability for large shrimp. Previous studies have reported that a reduced operating angle ...
Light-emitting diodes (LEDs) have been tested in trawl fisheries to reduce the bycatch of unwante... more Light-emitting diodes (LEDs) have been tested in trawl fisheries to reduce the bycatch of unwanted species through behavioural stimulation. Previous studies used LED lights to either highlight escaping routes or increase the contact rate with square-mesh panels. However, phototactic responses (moving towards or away from light sources) to LED lights could also be exploited to separate species during the catching process. We investigated if either positive or negative phototaxis can be used to improve fish vertical separation from Nephrops (Nephrops norvegicus) in the aft section of a horizontally separated trawl codend. The aim was to increase the proportion of fish entering the upper compartment. We conducted two different experiments in front of the separation into compartments, inserting green LED lights in the upper and lower netting panel, respectively. Species vertical separation was analysed and compared in two identical trawls towed in parallel, one equipped with lights and ...
Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 2017
We tested the ability of stimulators to improve the release efficiency of cod (Gadus morhua) and ... more We tested the ability of stimulators to improve the release efficiency of cod (Gadus morhua) and haddock (Melanogrammus aeglefinus) through the meshes of a square mesh section installed in a trawl. The section was tested in three different configurations: without any stimulation device, with a mechanical stimulation device, and with LED light stimulation devices. We analysed and compared the behaviour of cod and haddock in all three configurations based on release results and underwater recordings. Parallel to the fishing trials, we carried out fall-through tests to determine the upper physical size limits for cod and haddock to be able to escape through the square meshes in the section. This enabled us to infer whether lack of release efficiency was due to fish behaviour or release potential of the square meshes in the section. The results showed that the escape behaviour of haddock can be triggered by mechanical stimulation. In contrast, cod did not react significantly to the pres...
The aim of this study was to provide practitioners working with trawl selectivity with general an... more The aim of this study was to provide practitioners working with trawl selectivity with general and easily understandable guidelines regarding the fish sampling effort necessary during sea trials. In particular, we focused on how many fish would need to be caught and length measured in a trawl haul in order to assess the selectivity parameters of the trawl at a designated uncertainty level. We also investigated the dependency of this uncertainty level on the experimental method used to collect data and on the potential effects of factors such as the size structure in the catch relative to the size selection of the gear. We based this study on simulated data created from two different fisheries: the Barents Sea cod (Gadus morhua) trawl fishery and the Mediterranean Sea multispecies trawl fishery represented by red mullet (Mullus barbatus). We used these two completely different fisheries to obtain results that can be used as general guidelines for other fisheries. We found that the uncertainty in the selection parameters decreased with increasing number of fish measured and that this relationship could be described by a power model. The sampling effort needed to achieve a specific uncertainty level for the selection parameters was always lower for the covered codend method compared to the paired-gear method. In many cases, the number of fish that would need to be measured to maintain a specific uncertainty level was around 10 times higher for the paired-gear method than for the covered codend method. The trends observed for the effect of sampling effort in the two fishery cases investigated were similar; therefore the guidelines presented herein should be applicable to other fisheries.
Fisheries and Aquaculture in the Modern World, 2016
This chapter provides a general overview of the Barents Sea demersal trawl fishery. First, it rev... more This chapter provides a general overview of the Barents Sea demersal trawl fishery. First, it reviews historical catch levels and current biomass status of four commercially important demersal species (cod, haddock, Greenland halibut, and redfish) and includes an overview of their management plan that has been carried out by the Joint Norwegian-Russian commission. Then, it presents the evolution of the technical regulations for improving size selectivity in this fishery and describes current challenges in gear selectivity. Later, this chapter describes the concept of size selectivity, introduces the selective parameters that define a selection curve, and progressively introduces different parametric models that describe the selection process. The most common experimental methods and gear used to collect selectivity data are described, and their advantages and disadvantages are discussed. Finally, this chapter describes an alternative, or a complementary method, to the conventional estimation of trawl selectivity-the FISHSELECT method. This method is based on morphology measurements and fish penetration models to estimate the selective properties of different mesh shapes and sizes at different mesh openings, which are later used to provide simulation-based prediction of size selectivity. FISHSELECT has already been applied to four important species of the Barents Sea Demersal Fishery, and the results have in all cases showed to be coherent with the results obtained from sea trial results.
The catch composition of bottom trawls is commonly refined and improved through changes in codend... more The catch composition of bottom trawls is commonly refined and improved through changes in codend design. Measures like reducing the number of meshes in codend circumference or turning diamond netting by 90 degrees are well known to improve the size selectivity of fish species with rounded cross-sectional shape. Based on this we speculated whether the same measures, if applied in other parts of a bottom trawl, would provide similar benefits as in the codend. Therefore, experiments were carried out by deploying these changes to the trawl extension piece in a Mediterranean bottom trawl fishery. However, for European hake and monkfish, results showed no indication of improved selectivity or catch pattern compared to the standard extension piece in the trawl. Contrary, for red mullet, one of the most important species in this fishery, reducing the number of meshes in the circumference of the extension piece jeopardized the size selection obtained in the trawl with a standard extension p...
The introduction of the Nordmøre grid in shrimp trawls has reduced the bycatch of non-target spec... more The introduction of the Nordmøre grid in shrimp trawls has reduced the bycatch of non-target species. In the Norwegian Northern shrimp (Pandalus borealis) fishery, the mandatory selective gear consists of a Nordmøre grid with 19 mm bar spacing combined with a 35 mm mesh size diamond mesh codend. However, fish bycatch in shrimp trawls remains a challenge and further modifications of the gear that can improve selectivity are still sought. Therefore, this study estimated and compared the size selectivity of Nordmøre grids with bar spacings of 17 and 21 mm. Further, the effect of applying these two grids on trawl size selectivity was predicted and compared to the legislated gear configuration. Experimental fishing trials were conducted in the Barents Sea where the bottom trawl fleet targets Northern shrimp. Results were obtained for the target species and two by-catch species: cod (Gadus morhua) and American plaice (Hippoglossoides platessoides). This study demonstrated that reducing ba...
Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences
Diamond-mesh codends are the most commonly used in demersal trawls. However, mesh geometry tends ... more Diamond-mesh codends are the most commonly used in demersal trawls. However, mesh geometry tends to vary in these codends during fishing, which leads to a less well-defined size selection process. This leaves one questioning the rationality of regulating exploitation patterns based on mesh size when size selection and (or) variation between hauls is highly variable. While it has been speculated and theoretically investigated how much the variability in mesh geometry may contribute to the variability in size selection, it remained to be quantified experimentally. Therefore, we conducted field test comparing the size selectivity of a simple diamond-mesh codend, where meshes are subjected to variation in geometry, with a rigid diamond-mesh codend, where the geometry of the meshes were kept constant. For Atlantic cod ( Gadus morhua), the simple diamond-mesh codend was found to have 45% more variation in size selection than the codend with fixed mesh geometry. This confirms theoretical p...
Gear modifications in fisheries are usually implemented to obtain catch patterns that meet manage... more Gear modifications in fisheries are usually implemented to obtain catch patterns that meet management objectives. In the Basque bottom trawl fishery, gear regulations include the use of a square mesh panel (SMP) placed at the top panel of the extension piece of the trawl to supplement diamond mesh codend selectivity. However, the catch patterns obtained with this combination have raised concern among scientists and authorities. This study combines new data on different SMP and codend designs with existing data from the literature to produce new results that are applied to predict the size selectivity and catch patterns of different gear combinations for a variety of fishing scenarios. A systematic approach based on the concept of treatment trees was outlined and applied to depict the effect of individual and combined gear design changes on size selectivity and catch patterns for hake (Merluccius merluccius) and blue whiting (Micromesistius poutassou). This approach led to identifica...
Commercial bycatch species and their exploitation pattern in the Mediterranean trawl fishery are ... more Commercial bycatch species and their exploitation pattern in the Mediterranean trawl fishery are little studied. The present work examines the overall size-selection pattern, both regarding the trawl in the sea and the fisher onboard the vessel, for seven commercial bycatch species using different codends. The applied selection model predicted the escape, discard, and landing probability for each species simultaneously, a useful method for providing information important for fisheries management under the ecosystem approach. Among the studied codends, the 40-mm diamond mesh codend, still in use in non-EU Mediterranean fleets, was found unsuitable for the stocks in all cases. The 40-mm square mesh codend (40S) was found appropriate for blue whiting (Micromesistius poutassou), comber (Serranus cabrilla), and bogue (Boops boops) sustainability. The 50-mm diamond mesh codend (50D) was more suitable than the square mesh codend only for the spotted flounder (Citharus linguatula). Both the...
Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 2021
In most trawl fisheries, drag forces tend to close the meshes in large areas of diamond mesh code... more In most trawl fisheries, drag forces tend to close the meshes in large areas of diamond mesh codends, negatively affecting their selective potential. In the Barents Sea deep-water shrimp (Pandalus borealis) trawl fishery, selectivity is based on a sorting grid followed by a diamond mesh codend. However, the retention of juvenile fish as well as undersized shrimp is still a problem. In this study, we estimated the effect of applying different codend modifications, each aimed at affecting codend mesh openness and thereby selectivity. Changing from a 4-panel to a 2-panel construction of the codend did not affect size selectivity. Shortening the lastridge ropes of a 4-panel codend by 20% resulted in minor reductions for juvenile fish bycatch, but a 45% reduction of undersized shrimp was observed. Target-size catches of shrimp were nearly unaffected. When the codend mesh circumference was reduced while simultaneously shortening the lastridge ropes, the effect on catch efficiency for shri...
This study investigated the size selectivity and catch efficiency in the Northeast Atlantic demer... more This study investigated the size selectivity and catch efficiency in the Northeast Atlantic demersal trawl fishery targeting cod (Gadus morhua) and haddock (Melanogrammus aeglefinus). The use of a sorting grid followed by a size selective codend is compulsory in this fishery. Experimental fishing was conducted with a commercially rigged trawl, flexigrid section, and diamond-mesh codend. The flexigrid section is a dual sorting system and all fish that escaped from the two grids in the flexigrid system and the codend were retained in separate covers. This allowed us to estimate the combined size selectivity of the system, as well as the separate contributions from the first grid, second grid, and codend. The catch efficiencies for cod and haddock below and above the minimum reference length (MRL) were quantified by estimating the values for a set of exploitation pattern indicators. The results showed that most fish escaped from the flexigrid section. Only a few fish below the MRL entered the codend and nearly all of them subsequently escaped through the codend meshes. The probability of retaining undersized cod and haddock was low with the combined system. Furthermore, the results showed that the probability of escape was high through the second grid in the system for fish above the MRL, and this finding was supported by the exploitation pattern indicators. In particular, the estimated exploitation pattern indicators showed that using the current MRL and the fish size distributions encountered during the trials, no haddock and only 2.3 % of cod below the MRL were retained by the gear. However, 77.4 % of the haddock and 16.0 % of the cod above the MRL were found to escape, thereby indicating poor catch efficiency, especially for haddock. These results demonstrate the importance of supplementing size selectivity research with estimates of the actual catch efficiency using the gear employed, which were quantified using exploitation pattern indicators in this study.
The effect of shifting from a diamond mesh codend (T0) to a 90° turned mesh codend (T90) on the s... more The effect of shifting from a diamond mesh codend (T0) to a 90° turned mesh codend (T90) on the size selectivity of seven commercially important species in the Mediterranean bottom trawl fishery was evaluated. During sea trials conducted in the north-western Adriatic, two experimental codends made of 54 mm nominal mesh size netting that differed only in mesh configuration were alternately mounted on the same trawl. Overall, the size selectivity was significantly improved for all the species analysed, shifting from T0 to T90. The difference in the average expected L50values between T90 and T0 was particularly marked in European hake (Merluccius merluccius, 21.26 vs 11.26 cm total length), common squid (Loligo vulgaris, 12.06 vs 7.88 cm mantle length) and mantis shrimp (Squilla mantis, 20.78 vs 13.35 mm carapace length). Both codends had an excessive size selectivity especially for red mullet (Mullus barbatus), Mediterranean horse mackerel (Trachurus mediterraneus) and whiting (Merlan...
Damage incurred during the catch process is an indicator of the overall quality of fish and fish ... more Damage incurred during the catch process is an indicator of the overall quality of fish and fish welfare. Because catch quality is difficult to improve once it has deteriorated, it is important to preserve quality during the catch process. Atlantic cod (Gadus morhua) is the most important species in the Barents Sea bottom trawl fishery. Bottom trawling is a non-benign fishing method, and it is therefore considered important to reduce damage imparted to fish during capture, and subsequently improve catch quality and fish welfare. In the present study, the levels of damage on cod captured with a new gear design were assessed in the Barents Sea bottom trawl fishery. Furthermore, this study investigated to what extent the compulsory sorting grid and diamond mesh codend configuration employed in the fishery is responsible for the damage incurred by cod during the capture process. In total, 750 cod captured over 25 hauls were evaluated for catch damage (marks, ecchymosis, exsanguination, and scale loss). The results showed that substituting the grid and codend configuration with a four-panel selective knotless section followed by a gentle codend increased the probability of cod having no catch damage by 6.00% (CI: 0.6%-11.41%). Moreover, the gentle codend led to a significant reduction in the severity of all catch damage categories.
Journal of Northwest Atlantic Fishery Science, 2017
selection of Greenland halibut (Reinhardtius hippoglossoides) in the Norwegian bottom trawl fishe... more selection of Greenland halibut (Reinhardtius hippoglossoides) in the Norwegian bottom trawl fishery with a newly developed double grid system.
Shrimp trawlers in the Barents Sea use a Nordmøre sorting grid ahead of a small-mesh codend to av... more Shrimp trawlers in the Barents Sea use a Nordmøre sorting grid ahead of a small-mesh codend to avoid bycatch while catching shrimps efficiently. However, small fish can still pass through the grid to enter the codend, which increases their risk of being retained. In this study, we quantified the selectivity of a standard Nordmøre grid used together with one of two different codend designs, namely a diamond mesh codend with square mesh panels and a codend with a square mesh sorting cone section, for deep-water shrimp (Pandalus borealis), redfish (Sebastes spp.), and American plaice (Hippoglossoides platessoides). For the first time, the selective properties of these two alternative designs were estimated and compared to those of a Nordmøre grid used together with a 35-mm diamond mesh codend, which is the compulsory gear used in the fishery today. With this traditional codend, the size selectivity of both bycatch species showed the expected characteristic bell-shaped size selection pattern, with low retention probability of very small fish and bigger fish but with high retention probability of certain sizes of juveniles. Using the square mesh sorting cone significantly reduced the maximum retention risk of redfish. The maximum retention with the diamond mesh codend with square mesh panels was estimated to be 14% lower than that of the traditional codend, but the difference was not statistically significant. The two alternative codend designs did not result in any significant reduction in bycatch of American plaice.
The Nordmøre grid is the principle bycatch mitigation device in many shrimp trawl fisheries. Howe... more The Nordmøre grid is the principle bycatch mitigation device in many shrimp trawl fisheries. However, in several of these fisheries, bycatch is a problem because small sized fish can pass through the grid and enter the codend together with the targeted shrimp. One such fishery is the Northeast Atlantic deep-water shrimp (Pandalus borealis) fishery, where the use of a Nordmøre grid is mandatory. In this fishery, redfish (Sebastes spp.) and polar cod (Boreogadus saida) are two common bycatch species. Redfish is a commercially important species that at times is captured in great numbers, whereas polar cod is a threatened species that can also be caught in high numbers. Sieve panels are bycatch reduction devices commonly used in shrimp fisheries and their potential to replace or supplement the Nordmøre grid in the Northeast Atlantic deep-water shrimp fishery is of interest. We investigated the size selectivity of redfish, polar cod and deep-water shrimp for the Nordmøre grid and four sieve panel configurations differing in mesh size (182 and 286 mm) and inclination angle (10 and 20°). The sieve panels were unable to replace the Nordmøre grid as a stand-alone device due to greater catches of the bycatch species. However, combining the two devices provided promising results. Specifically, when a large-mesh sieve panel was placed in front of the Nordmøre grid, 20-40% fewer small redfish and polar cod in a specific size range entered the codend, while the loss of targeted shrimp was less than 5%.
The Nordmøre grid and the sieve panel are two of the main devices used to reduce fish bycatch in ... more The Nordmøre grid and the sieve panel are two of the main devices used to reduce fish bycatch in trawl fisheries targeting shrimp species. However, even when using such devices, some small-sized fish enter the codend of the trawl together with the targeted shrimp. Therefore, bycatch reduction remains a problem in some shrimp fisheries. One such fishery is the Northeast Atlantic deep-water shrimp (Pandalus borealis) fishery where it is mandatory to use a Nordmøre grid. In this study, the bycatch reduction efficiencies and patterns for several fish species using the standard Nordmøre grid and an experimental sieve panel were investigated and compared. The effect of combining these devices was also explored. The bycatch reduction patterns differed significantly between the two devices and a more efficient bycatch reduction was obtained by combining them. However, while the loss of commercial-sized shrimp was only between 0 and 2% for the Nordmøre grid, it was between 37 and 56% for the tested sieve panel, making this completely unacceptable for commercial fishing. Therefore, before a sieve panel can be considered as an option for the fishery, other sieve panel designs that have a significantly lower loss of shrimp catches need to be identified.
Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 2019
Size selectivity of a new sorting section combining a sorting grid and a square mesh panel was te... more Size selectivity of a new sorting section combining a sorting grid and a square mesh panel was tested for haddock (Melanogrammus aeglefinus) in the Barents Sea demersal trawl fishery. Sampling data for a wide size range enabled investigating the selection process for this species in detail, both for the grid and the square mesh panel. Contrary to earlier studies modelling size selectivity for grids and square mesh panels, which assume that the escape behaviour of all sizes of fish is equal, we applied a model that accounted for haddock of different sizes showing different escape behaviours. Our results demonstrated that this model could describe the experimental data collected better than existing models. Specifically, our results showed that the likelihood for smaller haddock to seek escape through the grid and the square mesh panel was higher than that for bigger haddock that still would manage to escape through the devices if they attempted. The new modelling approach presented i...
In recent years, Norwegian fishermen have reported problems with fish accumulation in front of th... more In recent years, Norwegian fishermen have reported problems with fish accumulation in front of the mandatory sorting grids (Sort-X, Sort-V, and Flexigrid). These problems are associated with high fish entry rates and low water flow through the grid sections. In this study, we replaced the lifting panel in the original design of a sorting grid section (Sort-V) by another steel grid ("lower grid") in order to improve water flow and increase sorting area. Two different inclination angles of this new additional "lower grid" were tested. The results demonstrated that both the lower grid and the main grid contributed to the release of cod and haddock. However, the release efficiency of the lower grid was low compared to that of the main grid. A larger proportion of fish contacted at least one of the grids with the lower grid set at 40 o compared to at 35 o. The new double grid was found to release significantly more haddock between 38 and 50 cm long than the mandatory Flexigrid. For cod, the sorting system was at least as good as the Flexigrid at releasing undersized fish. Thus, the new double grid system represents a potential alternative to the Flexigrid. Although the Sort-V single grid releases significantly more undersized cod and haddock than the new double grid system, it also releases a significantly higher proportion of the targeted commercial sizes.
Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 2019
The Nordmøre grid is regarded as an efficient bycatch-reducing device and is used in various shri... more The Nordmøre grid is regarded as an efficient bycatch-reducing device and is used in various shrimp trawl fisheries globally. However, in some shrimp fisheries, bycatch remains a problem that seriously impacts commercial trawl activities. This study tested and compared the performance of two versions of the Nordmøre grid in the northeast Arctic deepwater (northern) shrimp (Pandalus borealis) fishery, a standard version with an operating angle of approximately 45° and a longer version of the grid (40% longer) with an operating angle of approximately 30°. The grid passage probability for the bycatch of juvenile cod (Gadus morhua), haddock (Melanogrammus aeglefinus), American plaice (Hippoglossoides platessoides), and redfish (Sebastes spp.) increased significantly for certain size ranges of fish when using the longer grid. The longer grid also resulted in a significant increase in grid passage probability for large shrimp. Previous studies have reported that a reduced operating angle ...
Light-emitting diodes (LEDs) have been tested in trawl fisheries to reduce the bycatch of unwante... more Light-emitting diodes (LEDs) have been tested in trawl fisheries to reduce the bycatch of unwanted species through behavioural stimulation. Previous studies used LED lights to either highlight escaping routes or increase the contact rate with square-mesh panels. However, phototactic responses (moving towards or away from light sources) to LED lights could also be exploited to separate species during the catching process. We investigated if either positive or negative phototaxis can be used to improve fish vertical separation from Nephrops (Nephrops norvegicus) in the aft section of a horizontally separated trawl codend. The aim was to increase the proportion of fish entering the upper compartment. We conducted two different experiments in front of the separation into compartments, inserting green LED lights in the upper and lower netting panel, respectively. Species vertical separation was analysed and compared in two identical trawls towed in parallel, one equipped with lights and ...
Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences, 2017
We tested the ability of stimulators to improve the release efficiency of cod (Gadus morhua) and ... more We tested the ability of stimulators to improve the release efficiency of cod (Gadus morhua) and haddock (Melanogrammus aeglefinus) through the meshes of a square mesh section installed in a trawl. The section was tested in three different configurations: without any stimulation device, with a mechanical stimulation device, and with LED light stimulation devices. We analysed and compared the behaviour of cod and haddock in all three configurations based on release results and underwater recordings. Parallel to the fishing trials, we carried out fall-through tests to determine the upper physical size limits for cod and haddock to be able to escape through the square meshes in the section. This enabled us to infer whether lack of release efficiency was due to fish behaviour or release potential of the square meshes in the section. The results showed that the escape behaviour of haddock can be triggered by mechanical stimulation. In contrast, cod did not react significantly to the pres...
The aim of this study was to provide practitioners working with trawl selectivity with general an... more The aim of this study was to provide practitioners working with trawl selectivity with general and easily understandable guidelines regarding the fish sampling effort necessary during sea trials. In particular, we focused on how many fish would need to be caught and length measured in a trawl haul in order to assess the selectivity parameters of the trawl at a designated uncertainty level. We also investigated the dependency of this uncertainty level on the experimental method used to collect data and on the potential effects of factors such as the size structure in the catch relative to the size selection of the gear. We based this study on simulated data created from two different fisheries: the Barents Sea cod (Gadus morhua) trawl fishery and the Mediterranean Sea multispecies trawl fishery represented by red mullet (Mullus barbatus). We used these two completely different fisheries to obtain results that can be used as general guidelines for other fisheries. We found that the uncertainty in the selection parameters decreased with increasing number of fish measured and that this relationship could be described by a power model. The sampling effort needed to achieve a specific uncertainty level for the selection parameters was always lower for the covered codend method compared to the paired-gear method. In many cases, the number of fish that would need to be measured to maintain a specific uncertainty level was around 10 times higher for the paired-gear method than for the covered codend method. The trends observed for the effect of sampling effort in the two fishery cases investigated were similar; therefore the guidelines presented herein should be applicable to other fisheries.
Fisheries and Aquaculture in the Modern World, 2016
This chapter provides a general overview of the Barents Sea demersal trawl fishery. First, it rev... more This chapter provides a general overview of the Barents Sea demersal trawl fishery. First, it reviews historical catch levels and current biomass status of four commercially important demersal species (cod, haddock, Greenland halibut, and redfish) and includes an overview of their management plan that has been carried out by the Joint Norwegian-Russian commission. Then, it presents the evolution of the technical regulations for improving size selectivity in this fishery and describes current challenges in gear selectivity. Later, this chapter describes the concept of size selectivity, introduces the selective parameters that define a selection curve, and progressively introduces different parametric models that describe the selection process. The most common experimental methods and gear used to collect selectivity data are described, and their advantages and disadvantages are discussed. Finally, this chapter describes an alternative, or a complementary method, to the conventional estimation of trawl selectivity-the FISHSELECT method. This method is based on morphology measurements and fish penetration models to estimate the selective properties of different mesh shapes and sizes at different mesh openings, which are later used to provide simulation-based prediction of size selectivity. FISHSELECT has already been applied to four important species of the Barents Sea Demersal Fishery, and the results have in all cases showed to be coherent with the results obtained from sea trial results.
Uploads
Papers by Bent Herrmann