؉ Tlymphocyte (CTL) responses, which are in turn determined by host and viral genetic factors, su... more ؉ Tlymphocyte (CTL) responses, which are in turn determined by host and viral genetic factors, such as restricting major histocompatibility complex molecules and the available viral epitope sequences. However, CTL are derived stochastically through the random gene rearrangements to produce T-cell receptors (TCR), and the relative impact of genetic versus stochastic processes on CTL targeting of HIV and immune-driven viral evolution is unclear. Here we evaluate identical twins infected with HIV-1 as neonates from a common blood transfusion, with subsequently similar environmental exposures, thereby allowing controlled comparisons of CTL targeting and viral evolution. Seventeen years after infection, their CTL targeting of HIV-1 was remarkably similar. In contrast, their overall TCR profiles were highly dissimilar, and a dominant epitope was recognized by distinctly different TCR in each twin. Furthermore, their viral epitopes had diverged, and there was ongoing viral phylogenetic divergence between the twins between 12 and 17 years after infection. These results indicate that while CTL targeting is predominately genetically determined, stochastic influences render the interaction of HIV-1 and host immunity, and therefore viral escape and CTL efficacy, unpredictable.
The determinants of CD8 ؉ cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) antiviral activity against human immunodef... more The determinants of CD8 ؉ cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) antiviral activity against human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) remain poorly defined. Although recent technological advances have markedly enhanced the ability to detect HIV-1-specific T cells, commonly used assays do not reveal their direct interaction with virus. We investigated two determinants of CTL antiviral efficiency by manipulating HIV-1 and measuring the effects on CTL suppression of viral replication in acutely infected cells. Translocation of a Gag epitope into the early protein Nef markedly increased the activity of CTL recognizing that epitope, in comparison to HIV-1 expressing the epitope normally in the late protein Gag. Because this epitope translocation resulted not only in earlier expression but also in loss of major histocompatibility complex class I downregulation by Nef, the activities of CTL against a panel of viral constructs differing in kinetics of epitope expression and class I downmodulation were compared. The results indicated that both the timing of epitope expression and the reduction of class I have profound effects on the ability of CTL to suppress HIV-1 replication in acutely infected cells. The epitope targeting of CTL and viral control of class I therefore likely play important roles in the ability of CTL to exert pressure on HIV-1.
The HIV-1 Nef protein plays a key role in pathogenesis, as demonstrated by strong selective press... more The HIV-1 Nef protein plays a key role in pathogenesis, as demonstrated by strong selective pressure to maintain its open reading frame, and disease attenuation when it is deleted. Among myriad cellular effects attributed to Nef, downregulation of cell surface CD4 and major histocompatibility complex class I (MHC-I) proteins are the best documented. However, few data regarding primary isolate Nef functions are available, and most studies have been performed using transient transfections to express Nef driven by a non-physiologic promoter. A novel assay system to measure simultaneously the downregulation of CD4 and MHC-I by primary HIV-1 nef in a more physiologic viral genomic context is presented. Examination of plasma nef mixtures allowed comprehensive profiling of these Nef functions within the quasispecies in vivo. Subsets within the circulating nef population were observed that are either fully functional or non-functional. These data demonstrated that this assay system allows rapid characterization of bulk and clonal Nef functional profiles that can be used in pathogenesis studies to define further its important role in pathogenesis.
Most currently available HIV-1 reporter gene constructs are large and disrupt the nef reading fra... more Most currently available HIV-1 reporter gene constructs are large and disrupt the nef reading frame. This report describes a novel reporter gene based on the small murine heat stable antigen (HSA) protein, which is expressed on the surface of infected cells. This HSA reporter can be inserted in the vpr reading frame, leaving nef intact. Nine amino acids from the extracellular domain of HSA are replaced with an influenza hemagglutinin (HA) antibody epitope (HSA-HA). Like the parental reporter protein, this novel reporter is expressed on the surface of infected cells. Antibodies for HSA and HA specifically detect reporter viruses with each construct, indicating disruption of the original HSA antibody epitope. Finally, a strategy is developed to detect each reporter virus by real-time PCR quantitation. The growth of viruses tagged with each reporter allows precise assessment of the relative growth of viruses differing in mutations of interest. Moreover, the availability of these reporters in either of two half-genome plasmids allows convenient production of reporter and non-reporter HIV-1 by co-transfection of appropriately paired plasmids. These paired reporter viruses offer a potentially useful standardized method for measurement of HIV-1 fitness in competition assays.
CD8 ϩ class I-restricted cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) usually incompletely suppress HIV-1 in vi... more CD8 ϩ class I-restricted cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) usually incompletely suppress HIV-1 in vivo, and while analogous partial suppression induces antiretroviral drug-resistance mutations, epitope escape mutations are inconsistently observed. However, escape mutation depends on the net balance of selective pressure and mutational fitness costs, which are poorly understood and difficult to study in vivo. Here we used a controlled in vitro system to evaluate the ability of HIV-1 to escape from CTL clones, finding that virus replicating under selective pressure rapidly can develop phenotypic resistance associated with genotypic changes. Escape varied between clones recognizing the same Gag epitope or different Gag and RT epitopes, indicating the influence of the T cell receptor on pressure and fitness costs. Gag and RT escape mutations were monoclonal intra-epitope substitutions, indicating limitation by fitness constraints in structural proteins. In contrast, escape from Nef-specific CTL was more rapid and consistent, marked by a polyclonal mixture of epitope point mutations and upstream frameshifts. We conclude that incomplete viral suppression by CTL can result in rapid emergence of immune escape, but the likelihood is strongly determined by factors influencing the fitness costs of the particular epitope targeted and the ability of responding CTL to recognize specific epitope variants.
The use of reporter constructs of HIV-1 molecular clones has been useful in studying the effects ... more The use of reporter constructs of HIV-1 molecular clones has been useful in studying the effects of infection on individual cells. A strategy of producing viral half-genome constructs containing reporter genes that can be used to produce recombinant complete infectious virions is described. This approach allows rapid generation of reporter and non-reporter virions from the same genetic construct, obviating the need to produce a new reporter genetic construct for each viral change to be studied. We provide an example of the utility of this system for studying the effects of Nef on infected cells.
The variability of HIV-1 sequences within and between persons in vivo complicates immunologic scr... more The variability of HIV-1 sequences within and between persons in vivo complicates immunologic screening with a fixed sequence, and using peptides based on consensus sequences therefore has become a common practice for pathogenesis and vaccine studies. Here, we screen a cohort of HIV-1-infected persons in the United States for CD8 + T lymphocyte (CTL) responses using Gag peptides based on the Clade C primary isolate DU422 and the consensus sequence for Clade B. Surprisingly, the DU422 and Clade B consensus peptides are similar in sensitivity, but many responses are detected only by one set or the other. About equal numbers of discordantly detected responses are specific to consensus Clade B peptides as DU422 peptides. A minority of discordant detection is due to the varying frames of the peptide sets and therefore a technical artifact; the majority is due to sequence differences. This lack of superiority of the Clade B consensus peptides to detect CD8 + T lymphocyte responses is an unexpected finding that suggests that detection of HIV-1-specific cellular immunity with these peptides may be significantly insensitive and raises questions as to whether screening with a single sequence adequately reflects responses to the viral swarm in vivo. D
Vaccination for human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) remains an elusive goal. Whether an u... more Vaccination for human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) remains an elusive goal. Whether an unsuccessful vaccine might not only fail to provoke detectable immune responses but also could actually interfere with subsequent natural immunity upon HIV-1 infection is unknown. We performed detailed assessment of an HIV-1 gag DNA vaccine recipient (subject 00015) who was previously uninfected but sustained HIV-1 infection before completing a vaccination trial and another contemporaneously acutely infected individual (subject 00016) with the same strain of HIV-1. Subject 00015 received the vaccine at weeks 0, 4, and 8 and was found to have been acutely HIV-1 infected around the time of the third vaccination. Subject 00016 was a previously
More recently, Shacklett et al [2] and Hoxie and et al [3] have examined attenuated SIV infection... more More recently, Shacklett et al [2] and Hoxie and et al [3] have examined attenuated SIV infection via mutations in the transmembrane domain of gp41, which also subsequently protects from challenge by wild-type SIV. Shacklett et al found that SIV containing multiple (stop and ...
Cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) are crucial for immune control of viral infections. "Functional av... more Cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) are crucial for immune control of viral infections. "Functional avidity," defined by the sensitizing dose of exogenously added epitope yielding half-maximal CTL triggering against uninfected target cells (SD 50 ), has been utilized extensively as a measure of antiviral efficiency. However, CTLs recognize infected cells via endogenously produced epitopes, and the relationship of SD 50 to antiviral activity has never been directly revealed. We elucidate this relationship by comparing CTL killing of cells infected with panels of epitope-variant viruses to the corresponding SD 50 for the variant epitopes. This reveals a steeply sigmoid relationship between avidity and infected cell killing, with avidity thresholds (defined as the SD 50 required for CTL to achieve 50% efficiency of infected cell killing [KE 50 ]), below which infected cell killing rapidly drops to none and above which killing efficiency rapidly plateaus. Three CTL clones recognizing the same viral epitope show the same KE 50 despite differential recognition of individual epitope variants, while CTLs recognizing another epitope show a 10-fold-higher KE 50 , demonstrating epitope dependence of KE 50 . Finally, the ability of CTLs to suppress viral replication depends on the same threshold KE 50 . Thus, defining KE 50 values is required to interpret the significance of functional avidity measurements and predict CTL efficacy against virus-infected cells in pathogenesis and vaccine studies.
؉ Tlymphocyte (CTL) responses, which are in turn determined by host and viral genetic factors, su... more ؉ Tlymphocyte (CTL) responses, which are in turn determined by host and viral genetic factors, such as restricting major histocompatibility complex molecules and the available viral epitope sequences. However, CTL are derived stochastically through the random gene rearrangements to produce T-cell receptors (TCR), and the relative impact of genetic versus stochastic processes on CTL targeting of HIV and immune-driven viral evolution is unclear. Here we evaluate identical twins infected with HIV-1 as neonates from a common blood transfusion, with subsequently similar environmental exposures, thereby allowing controlled comparisons of CTL targeting and viral evolution. Seventeen years after infection, their CTL targeting of HIV-1 was remarkably similar. In contrast, their overall TCR profiles were highly dissimilar, and a dominant epitope was recognized by distinctly different TCR in each twin. Furthermore, their viral epitopes had diverged, and there was ongoing viral phylogenetic divergence between the twins between 12 and 17 years after infection. These results indicate that while CTL targeting is predominately genetically determined, stochastic influences render the interaction of HIV-1 and host immunity, and therefore viral escape and CTL efficacy, unpredictable.
The determinants of CD8 ؉ cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) antiviral activity against human immunodef... more The determinants of CD8 ؉ cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) antiviral activity against human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) remain poorly defined. Although recent technological advances have markedly enhanced the ability to detect HIV-1-specific T cells, commonly used assays do not reveal their direct interaction with virus. We investigated two determinants of CTL antiviral efficiency by manipulating HIV-1 and measuring the effects on CTL suppression of viral replication in acutely infected cells. Translocation of a Gag epitope into the early protein Nef markedly increased the activity of CTL recognizing that epitope, in comparison to HIV-1 expressing the epitope normally in the late protein Gag. Because this epitope translocation resulted not only in earlier expression but also in loss of major histocompatibility complex class I downregulation by Nef, the activities of CTL against a panel of viral constructs differing in kinetics of epitope expression and class I downmodulation were compared. The results indicated that both the timing of epitope expression and the reduction of class I have profound effects on the ability of CTL to suppress HIV-1 replication in acutely infected cells. The epitope targeting of CTL and viral control of class I therefore likely play important roles in the ability of CTL to exert pressure on HIV-1.
The HIV-1 Nef protein plays a key role in pathogenesis, as demonstrated by strong selective press... more The HIV-1 Nef protein plays a key role in pathogenesis, as demonstrated by strong selective pressure to maintain its open reading frame, and disease attenuation when it is deleted. Among myriad cellular effects attributed to Nef, downregulation of cell surface CD4 and major histocompatibility complex class I (MHC-I) proteins are the best documented. However, few data regarding primary isolate Nef functions are available, and most studies have been performed using transient transfections to express Nef driven by a non-physiologic promoter. A novel assay system to measure simultaneously the downregulation of CD4 and MHC-I by primary HIV-1 nef in a more physiologic viral genomic context is presented. Examination of plasma nef mixtures allowed comprehensive profiling of these Nef functions within the quasispecies in vivo. Subsets within the circulating nef population were observed that are either fully functional or non-functional. These data demonstrated that this assay system allows rapid characterization of bulk and clonal Nef functional profiles that can be used in pathogenesis studies to define further its important role in pathogenesis.
Most currently available HIV-1 reporter gene constructs are large and disrupt the nef reading fra... more Most currently available HIV-1 reporter gene constructs are large and disrupt the nef reading frame. This report describes a novel reporter gene based on the small murine heat stable antigen (HSA) protein, which is expressed on the surface of infected cells. This HSA reporter can be inserted in the vpr reading frame, leaving nef intact. Nine amino acids from the extracellular domain of HSA are replaced with an influenza hemagglutinin (HA) antibody epitope (HSA-HA). Like the parental reporter protein, this novel reporter is expressed on the surface of infected cells. Antibodies for HSA and HA specifically detect reporter viruses with each construct, indicating disruption of the original HSA antibody epitope. Finally, a strategy is developed to detect each reporter virus by real-time PCR quantitation. The growth of viruses tagged with each reporter allows precise assessment of the relative growth of viruses differing in mutations of interest. Moreover, the availability of these reporters in either of two half-genome plasmids allows convenient production of reporter and non-reporter HIV-1 by co-transfection of appropriately paired plasmids. These paired reporter viruses offer a potentially useful standardized method for measurement of HIV-1 fitness in competition assays.
CD8 ϩ class I-restricted cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) usually incompletely suppress HIV-1 in vi... more CD8 ϩ class I-restricted cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) usually incompletely suppress HIV-1 in vivo, and while analogous partial suppression induces antiretroviral drug-resistance mutations, epitope escape mutations are inconsistently observed. However, escape mutation depends on the net balance of selective pressure and mutational fitness costs, which are poorly understood and difficult to study in vivo. Here we used a controlled in vitro system to evaluate the ability of HIV-1 to escape from CTL clones, finding that virus replicating under selective pressure rapidly can develop phenotypic resistance associated with genotypic changes. Escape varied between clones recognizing the same Gag epitope or different Gag and RT epitopes, indicating the influence of the T cell receptor on pressure and fitness costs. Gag and RT escape mutations were monoclonal intra-epitope substitutions, indicating limitation by fitness constraints in structural proteins. In contrast, escape from Nef-specific CTL was more rapid and consistent, marked by a polyclonal mixture of epitope point mutations and upstream frameshifts. We conclude that incomplete viral suppression by CTL can result in rapid emergence of immune escape, but the likelihood is strongly determined by factors influencing the fitness costs of the particular epitope targeted and the ability of responding CTL to recognize specific epitope variants.
؉ Tlymphocyte (CTL) responses, which are in turn determined by host and viral genetic factors, su... more ؉ Tlymphocyte (CTL) responses, which are in turn determined by host and viral genetic factors, such as restricting major histocompatibility complex molecules and the available viral epitope sequences. However, CTL are derived stochastically through the random gene rearrangements to produce T-cell receptors (TCR), and the relative impact of genetic versus stochastic processes on CTL targeting of HIV and immune-driven viral evolution is unclear. Here we evaluate identical twins infected with HIV-1 as neonates from a common blood transfusion, with subsequently similar environmental exposures, thereby allowing controlled comparisons of CTL targeting and viral evolution. Seventeen years after infection, their CTL targeting of HIV-1 was remarkably similar. In contrast, their overall TCR profiles were highly dissimilar, and a dominant epitope was recognized by distinctly different TCR in each twin. Furthermore, their viral epitopes had diverged, and there was ongoing viral phylogenetic divergence between the twins between 12 and 17 years after infection. These results indicate that while CTL targeting is predominately genetically determined, stochastic influences render the interaction of HIV-1 and host immunity, and therefore viral escape and CTL efficacy, unpredictable.
The determinants of CD8 ؉ cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) antiviral activity against human immunodef... more The determinants of CD8 ؉ cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) antiviral activity against human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) remain poorly defined. Although recent technological advances have markedly enhanced the ability to detect HIV-1-specific T cells, commonly used assays do not reveal their direct interaction with virus. We investigated two determinants of CTL antiviral efficiency by manipulating HIV-1 and measuring the effects on CTL suppression of viral replication in acutely infected cells. Translocation of a Gag epitope into the early protein Nef markedly increased the activity of CTL recognizing that epitope, in comparison to HIV-1 expressing the epitope normally in the late protein Gag. Because this epitope translocation resulted not only in earlier expression but also in loss of major histocompatibility complex class I downregulation by Nef, the activities of CTL against a panel of viral constructs differing in kinetics of epitope expression and class I downmodulation were compared. The results indicated that both the timing of epitope expression and the reduction of class I have profound effects on the ability of CTL to suppress HIV-1 replication in acutely infected cells. The epitope targeting of CTL and viral control of class I therefore likely play important roles in the ability of CTL to exert pressure on HIV-1.
The HIV-1 Nef protein plays a key role in pathogenesis, as demonstrated by strong selective press... more The HIV-1 Nef protein plays a key role in pathogenesis, as demonstrated by strong selective pressure to maintain its open reading frame, and disease attenuation when it is deleted. Among myriad cellular effects attributed to Nef, downregulation of cell surface CD4 and major histocompatibility complex class I (MHC-I) proteins are the best documented. However, few data regarding primary isolate Nef functions are available, and most studies have been performed using transient transfections to express Nef driven by a non-physiologic promoter. A novel assay system to measure simultaneously the downregulation of CD4 and MHC-I by primary HIV-1 nef in a more physiologic viral genomic context is presented. Examination of plasma nef mixtures allowed comprehensive profiling of these Nef functions within the quasispecies in vivo. Subsets within the circulating nef population were observed that are either fully functional or non-functional. These data demonstrated that this assay system allows rapid characterization of bulk and clonal Nef functional profiles that can be used in pathogenesis studies to define further its important role in pathogenesis.
Most currently available HIV-1 reporter gene constructs are large and disrupt the nef reading fra... more Most currently available HIV-1 reporter gene constructs are large and disrupt the nef reading frame. This report describes a novel reporter gene based on the small murine heat stable antigen (HSA) protein, which is expressed on the surface of infected cells. This HSA reporter can be inserted in the vpr reading frame, leaving nef intact. Nine amino acids from the extracellular domain of HSA are replaced with an influenza hemagglutinin (HA) antibody epitope (HSA-HA). Like the parental reporter protein, this novel reporter is expressed on the surface of infected cells. Antibodies for HSA and HA specifically detect reporter viruses with each construct, indicating disruption of the original HSA antibody epitope. Finally, a strategy is developed to detect each reporter virus by real-time PCR quantitation. The growth of viruses tagged with each reporter allows precise assessment of the relative growth of viruses differing in mutations of interest. Moreover, the availability of these reporters in either of two half-genome plasmids allows convenient production of reporter and non-reporter HIV-1 by co-transfection of appropriately paired plasmids. These paired reporter viruses offer a potentially useful standardized method for measurement of HIV-1 fitness in competition assays.
CD8 ϩ class I-restricted cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) usually incompletely suppress HIV-1 in vi... more CD8 ϩ class I-restricted cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) usually incompletely suppress HIV-1 in vivo, and while analogous partial suppression induces antiretroviral drug-resistance mutations, epitope escape mutations are inconsistently observed. However, escape mutation depends on the net balance of selective pressure and mutational fitness costs, which are poorly understood and difficult to study in vivo. Here we used a controlled in vitro system to evaluate the ability of HIV-1 to escape from CTL clones, finding that virus replicating under selective pressure rapidly can develop phenotypic resistance associated with genotypic changes. Escape varied between clones recognizing the same Gag epitope or different Gag and RT epitopes, indicating the influence of the T cell receptor on pressure and fitness costs. Gag and RT escape mutations were monoclonal intra-epitope substitutions, indicating limitation by fitness constraints in structural proteins. In contrast, escape from Nef-specific CTL was more rapid and consistent, marked by a polyclonal mixture of epitope point mutations and upstream frameshifts. We conclude that incomplete viral suppression by CTL can result in rapid emergence of immune escape, but the likelihood is strongly determined by factors influencing the fitness costs of the particular epitope targeted and the ability of responding CTL to recognize specific epitope variants.
The use of reporter constructs of HIV-1 molecular clones has been useful in studying the effects ... more The use of reporter constructs of HIV-1 molecular clones has been useful in studying the effects of infection on individual cells. A strategy of producing viral half-genome constructs containing reporter genes that can be used to produce recombinant complete infectious virions is described. This approach allows rapid generation of reporter and non-reporter virions from the same genetic construct, obviating the need to produce a new reporter genetic construct for each viral change to be studied. We provide an example of the utility of this system for studying the effects of Nef on infected cells.
The variability of HIV-1 sequences within and between persons in vivo complicates immunologic scr... more The variability of HIV-1 sequences within and between persons in vivo complicates immunologic screening with a fixed sequence, and using peptides based on consensus sequences therefore has become a common practice for pathogenesis and vaccine studies. Here, we screen a cohort of HIV-1-infected persons in the United States for CD8 + T lymphocyte (CTL) responses using Gag peptides based on the Clade C primary isolate DU422 and the consensus sequence for Clade B. Surprisingly, the DU422 and Clade B consensus peptides are similar in sensitivity, but many responses are detected only by one set or the other. About equal numbers of discordantly detected responses are specific to consensus Clade B peptides as DU422 peptides. A minority of discordant detection is due to the varying frames of the peptide sets and therefore a technical artifact; the majority is due to sequence differences. This lack of superiority of the Clade B consensus peptides to detect CD8 + T lymphocyte responses is an unexpected finding that suggests that detection of HIV-1-specific cellular immunity with these peptides may be significantly insensitive and raises questions as to whether screening with a single sequence adequately reflects responses to the viral swarm in vivo. D
Vaccination for human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) remains an elusive goal. Whether an u... more Vaccination for human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) remains an elusive goal. Whether an unsuccessful vaccine might not only fail to provoke detectable immune responses but also could actually interfere with subsequent natural immunity upon HIV-1 infection is unknown. We performed detailed assessment of an HIV-1 gag DNA vaccine recipient (subject 00015) who was previously uninfected but sustained HIV-1 infection before completing a vaccination trial and another contemporaneously acutely infected individual (subject 00016) with the same strain of HIV-1. Subject 00015 received the vaccine at weeks 0, 4, and 8 and was found to have been acutely HIV-1 infected around the time of the third vaccination. Subject 00016 was a previously
More recently, Shacklett et al [2] and Hoxie and et al [3] have examined attenuated SIV infection... more More recently, Shacklett et al [2] and Hoxie and et al [3] have examined attenuated SIV infection via mutations in the transmembrane domain of gp41, which also subsequently protects from challenge by wild-type SIV. Shacklett et al found that SIV containing multiple (stop and ...
Cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) are crucial for immune control of viral infections. "Functional av... more Cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) are crucial for immune control of viral infections. "Functional avidity," defined by the sensitizing dose of exogenously added epitope yielding half-maximal CTL triggering against uninfected target cells (SD 50 ), has been utilized extensively as a measure of antiviral efficiency. However, CTLs recognize infected cells via endogenously produced epitopes, and the relationship of SD 50 to antiviral activity has never been directly revealed. We elucidate this relationship by comparing CTL killing of cells infected with panels of epitope-variant viruses to the corresponding SD 50 for the variant epitopes. This reveals a steeply sigmoid relationship between avidity and infected cell killing, with avidity thresholds (defined as the SD 50 required for CTL to achieve 50% efficiency of infected cell killing [KE 50 ]), below which infected cell killing rapidly drops to none and above which killing efficiency rapidly plateaus. Three CTL clones recognizing the same viral epitope show the same KE 50 despite differential recognition of individual epitope variants, while CTLs recognizing another epitope show a 10-fold-higher KE 50 , demonstrating epitope dependence of KE 50 . Finally, the ability of CTLs to suppress viral replication depends on the same threshold KE 50 . Thus, defining KE 50 values is required to interpret the significance of functional avidity measurements and predict CTL efficacy against virus-infected cells in pathogenesis and vaccine studies.
؉ Tlymphocyte (CTL) responses, which are in turn determined by host and viral genetic factors, su... more ؉ Tlymphocyte (CTL) responses, which are in turn determined by host and viral genetic factors, such as restricting major histocompatibility complex molecules and the available viral epitope sequences. However, CTL are derived stochastically through the random gene rearrangements to produce T-cell receptors (TCR), and the relative impact of genetic versus stochastic processes on CTL targeting of HIV and immune-driven viral evolution is unclear. Here we evaluate identical twins infected with HIV-1 as neonates from a common blood transfusion, with subsequently similar environmental exposures, thereby allowing controlled comparisons of CTL targeting and viral evolution. Seventeen years after infection, their CTL targeting of HIV-1 was remarkably similar. In contrast, their overall TCR profiles were highly dissimilar, and a dominant epitope was recognized by distinctly different TCR in each twin. Furthermore, their viral epitopes had diverged, and there was ongoing viral phylogenetic divergence between the twins between 12 and 17 years after infection. These results indicate that while CTL targeting is predominately genetically determined, stochastic influences render the interaction of HIV-1 and host immunity, and therefore viral escape and CTL efficacy, unpredictable.
The determinants of CD8 ؉ cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) antiviral activity against human immunodef... more The determinants of CD8 ؉ cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) antiviral activity against human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) remain poorly defined. Although recent technological advances have markedly enhanced the ability to detect HIV-1-specific T cells, commonly used assays do not reveal their direct interaction with virus. We investigated two determinants of CTL antiviral efficiency by manipulating HIV-1 and measuring the effects on CTL suppression of viral replication in acutely infected cells. Translocation of a Gag epitope into the early protein Nef markedly increased the activity of CTL recognizing that epitope, in comparison to HIV-1 expressing the epitope normally in the late protein Gag. Because this epitope translocation resulted not only in earlier expression but also in loss of major histocompatibility complex class I downregulation by Nef, the activities of CTL against a panel of viral constructs differing in kinetics of epitope expression and class I downmodulation were compared. The results indicated that both the timing of epitope expression and the reduction of class I have profound effects on the ability of CTL to suppress HIV-1 replication in acutely infected cells. The epitope targeting of CTL and viral control of class I therefore likely play important roles in the ability of CTL to exert pressure on HIV-1.
The HIV-1 Nef protein plays a key role in pathogenesis, as demonstrated by strong selective press... more The HIV-1 Nef protein plays a key role in pathogenesis, as demonstrated by strong selective pressure to maintain its open reading frame, and disease attenuation when it is deleted. Among myriad cellular effects attributed to Nef, downregulation of cell surface CD4 and major histocompatibility complex class I (MHC-I) proteins are the best documented. However, few data regarding primary isolate Nef functions are available, and most studies have been performed using transient transfections to express Nef driven by a non-physiologic promoter. A novel assay system to measure simultaneously the downregulation of CD4 and MHC-I by primary HIV-1 nef in a more physiologic viral genomic context is presented. Examination of plasma nef mixtures allowed comprehensive profiling of these Nef functions within the quasispecies in vivo. Subsets within the circulating nef population were observed that are either fully functional or non-functional. These data demonstrated that this assay system allows rapid characterization of bulk and clonal Nef functional profiles that can be used in pathogenesis studies to define further its important role in pathogenesis.
Most currently available HIV-1 reporter gene constructs are large and disrupt the nef reading fra... more Most currently available HIV-1 reporter gene constructs are large and disrupt the nef reading frame. This report describes a novel reporter gene based on the small murine heat stable antigen (HSA) protein, which is expressed on the surface of infected cells. This HSA reporter can be inserted in the vpr reading frame, leaving nef intact. Nine amino acids from the extracellular domain of HSA are replaced with an influenza hemagglutinin (HA) antibody epitope (HSA-HA). Like the parental reporter protein, this novel reporter is expressed on the surface of infected cells. Antibodies for HSA and HA specifically detect reporter viruses with each construct, indicating disruption of the original HSA antibody epitope. Finally, a strategy is developed to detect each reporter virus by real-time PCR quantitation. The growth of viruses tagged with each reporter allows precise assessment of the relative growth of viruses differing in mutations of interest. Moreover, the availability of these reporters in either of two half-genome plasmids allows convenient production of reporter and non-reporter HIV-1 by co-transfection of appropriately paired plasmids. These paired reporter viruses offer a potentially useful standardized method for measurement of HIV-1 fitness in competition assays.
CD8 ϩ class I-restricted cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) usually incompletely suppress HIV-1 in vi... more CD8 ϩ class I-restricted cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) usually incompletely suppress HIV-1 in vivo, and while analogous partial suppression induces antiretroviral drug-resistance mutations, epitope escape mutations are inconsistently observed. However, escape mutation depends on the net balance of selective pressure and mutational fitness costs, which are poorly understood and difficult to study in vivo. Here we used a controlled in vitro system to evaluate the ability of HIV-1 to escape from CTL clones, finding that virus replicating under selective pressure rapidly can develop phenotypic resistance associated with genotypic changes. Escape varied between clones recognizing the same Gag epitope or different Gag and RT epitopes, indicating the influence of the T cell receptor on pressure and fitness costs. Gag and RT escape mutations were monoclonal intra-epitope substitutions, indicating limitation by fitness constraints in structural proteins. In contrast, escape from Nef-specific CTL was more rapid and consistent, marked by a polyclonal mixture of epitope point mutations and upstream frameshifts. We conclude that incomplete viral suppression by CTL can result in rapid emergence of immune escape, but the likelihood is strongly determined by factors influencing the fitness costs of the particular epitope targeted and the ability of responding CTL to recognize specific epitope variants.
Uploads
Papers by Ayub Ali