Incorporating horses into speech-language pathology services is a valid treatment strategy that c... more Incorporating horses into speech-language pathology services is a valid treatment strategy that can be used to help the client achieve their communication and/or swallowing goals. The purpose of this article is to discuss the history and terminology of incorporating horses into rehabilitation, explain theories for why incorporating horses works, and provide clinical applications to the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association's nine areas of practice with clinical reports.
Journal of rehabilitation research and development
This study explored the effects and effectiveness of animal-assisted therapy (AAT) for persons wi... more This study explored the effects and effectiveness of animal-assisted therapy (AAT) for persons with aphasia. Three men with aphasia from left-hemisphere strokes participated in this study. The men received one semester of traditional therapy followed by one semester of AAT. While both therapies were effective, in that each participant met his goals, no significant differences existed between test results following traditional speech-language therapy versus AAT. Results of a client-satisfaction questionnaire, however, indicated that each of the participants was more motivated, enjoyed the therapy sessions more, and felt that the atmosphere of the sessions was lighter and less stressed during AAT compared with traditional therapy.
Abstract—This study explored the effects and effectiveness of animal-assisted therapy (AAT) for p... more Abstract—This study explored the effects and effectiveness of animal-assisted therapy (AAT) for persons with aphasia. Three men with aphasia from left-hemisphere strokes participated in this study. The men received one semester of traditional ther-apy followed by one semester of AAT. While both therapies were effective, in that each participant met his goals, no significant differences existed between test results following traditional speech-language therapy versus AAT. Results of a client-satisfaction questionnaire, however, indicated that each of the participants was more motivated, enjoyed the therapy sessions more, and felt that the atmosphere of the sessions was lighter and less stressed during AAT compared with traditional therapy. Key words: animal-assisted therapy, aphasia, brain injury, communication, increased motivation, rehabilitation, speech-language pathology, speech-language therapy, stroke, therapy animals, therapy efficacy.
Contemporary Issues in Communication Science and Disorders
This study examined the effects of aphasia and ideomotor apraxia on conversational gesture. Parti... more This study examined the effects of aphasia and ideomotor apraxia on conversational gesture. Participants included 8 neurologically normal control participants and 12 participants having aphasia from a single left-hemisphere stroke. Testing included the Western Aphasia Battery (Kertesz, 1982), the Florida Apraxia Battery (Rothi et al., 1992), and scoring of conversational gesture. Statistical findings using a between-group analysis of variance revealed a statistically significant difference in quantity and type of gestures used between experimental and control participants. Within the experimental participants, there was a clear relationship between severity of aphasia and conversational gesture, but not between severity of ideomotor apraxia and conversational gesture. Therefore, severity of aphasia appears to be a better predictor than severity of ideomotor apraxia for the production of spontaneous gesture.
Neuropsychiatry, neuropsychology, and behavioral neurology, 1999
Ideomotor apraxia was studied in patients with Alzheimer disease (AD) and unilateral left hemisph... more Ideomotor apraxia was studied in patients with Alzheimer disease (AD) and unilateral left hemispheric damaged (LHD) stroke to determine whether these groups differed. Given that the neuropathology of AD is bilateral and more diffuse than the localized involvement in patients after an LHD stroke, and given that the cognitive deficits in AD are more widespread than in LHD stroke, the authors predicted that patients with these disorders would differ in response to an auditory command task administered to evaluate ideomotor apraxia, and that the two patient groups would be significantly more impaired than healthy matched control subjects. Twenty-one persons were studied, including equal numbers of patients with AD, patients with unilateral LHD stroke, and control subjects. An auditory command test of limb apraxia was administered and videotaped to score performance and to code spatial-temporal or content errors. The patients with AD and LHD stroke were significantly more impaired than h...
Liepmann posited that, in right handers, the left parietal lobe contains movement formulas or rep... more Liepmann posited that, in right handers, the left parietal lobe contains movement formulas or representations. Therefore, performance failures may be induced by degraded representations, a failure of these representations to influence motor systems or a failure of stimuli to fully access these representations. Imitation may help the performance of subjects with degraded representations. However, patients who have impaired visual access to movement representations may perform more poorly with imitation than to verbal command. Trajectories of repetitive 'slicing' gestures made by a previously reported subject (Raymer et al.) with an infarction in the left visual association cortex (left occipital and inferior temporal lobe) that spared the parietal lobe were contrasted with those of three apraxic subjects with lesions that included the left parietal lobe and four non-brain-damaged control subjects. All subjects were asked to produce the gesture to verbal command and to imitation. Movements of the left hand, wrist, elbow and shoulder were digitized from neighboring views, reconstructed in three dimensions, and analysed graphically and numerically. The apraxic subjects with left parietal damage were unable to maintain the proper linearity and spatiotemporal attributes of their wrist motions and showed interjoint coordination deficits. Their deficits were most pronounced to verbal command, with their movements improving though remaining poorly performed when they imitated. The subject with the left occipital and inferior temporal lesion that spared parietal cortex, however, showed an opposite pattern. This subject exhibited close to normal performance when producing the movement to verbal command, but significant deficits when imitating.
Three-dimensional motion analyses were performed on trajectories of repetitive "... more Three-dimensional motion analyses were performed on trajectories of repetitive "slicing" gestures by 4 participants with left-hemisphere lesions and limb apraxia, 6 participants with right-hemisphere lesions, and 7 neurologically intact participants. Left hemispheric lesioned participants with apraxia, but not right hemispheric lesioned participants showed impaired coupling of spatial and temporal aspects of wrist trajectories and deficits in interjoint coordination. Both groups of brain-lesioned participants differed from control participants in the 3-D plane of the wrist motion. The deficits of some right hemispheric lesioned participants in controlling the plane of wrist motion may be a consequence of left hemispatial neglect with rightward deviations. In contrast, the deficits of apraxic participants in controlling wrist trajectories and coordinating joint motions seem to reflect a deficit in these participants for the movement plan.
Journal of the International Neuropsychological Society, 1995
Humans learn skilled acts in order to effectively interact with their environment. A loss of the ... more Humans learn skilled acts in order to effectively interact with their environment. A loss of the ability to perform skilled acts is termed apraxia. Apraxia has been thought to be of theoretical interest, but the ecological implications of apraxia are controversial and have not been fully studied. We examined ten patients with unilateral left hemisphere cerebral infarctions (eight of whom were apraxic) and compared their mealtime eating behavior to a group of neurologically normal, age-matched controls. The stroke patients were less efficient in completing the meal. They made more action errors and were less organized in the sequencing of mealtime activities. Because the patients made more errors while using tools than when performing nontool actions, their deficit could not be accounted for by an elemental motor deficit. A positive relationship was found between mealtime action errors and the severity of apraxia. These findings suggest that limb apraxia may adversely influence activ...
The Journal of Rehabilitation Research and Development, 2006
This study explored the effects and effectiveness of animal-assisted therapy (AAT) for persons wi... more This study explored the effects and effectiveness of animal-assisted therapy (AAT) for persons with aphasia. Three men with aphasia from left-hemisphere strokes participated in this study. The men received one semester of traditional therapy followed by one semester of AAT. While both therapies were effective, in that each participant met his goals, no significant differences existed between test results following traditional speech-language therapy versus AAT. Results of a client-satisfaction questionnaire, however, indicated that each of the participants was more motivated, enjoyed the therapy sessions more, and felt that the atmosphere of the sessions was lighter and less stressed during AAT compared with traditional therapy.
Competing models of the basis of limb apraxia were tested through analysis of joint coordination ... more Competing models of the basis of limb apraxia were tested through analysis of joint coordination deficits in three apraxic subjects with lesions that included the left parietal lobe. Three-dimensional shoulder, elbow, wrist and hand trajectories were recorded for repetitive 'slicing' gestures made in a series of conditions in which contextual cues were introduced in a graded fashion. The apraxic subjects showed marked deficits in joint coordination across context conditions. Even when actually manipulating a tool and object, the apraxic subjects failed to show proper joint synchronization, failed to apportion their relative joint amplitudes properly, and failed to produce the correct phase relationships among pairs of arm angles. Thus, apraxic subjects not only have deficits in the spatial plan for the movement, but they also have deficits in translating those plans into the details of the angular motions at the joints, even when actually manipulating a tool and object. These data support a model of apraxia in which apraxia can result from either the destruction of visuo-kinaesthetic motor representations of learned movement, stored in posterior association cortex, or from a separation of these representations from premotor or motor areas.
Geschwind (1975) proposed a disconnection model in which an apraxic subject is unable to carry ou... more Geschwind (1975) proposed a disconnection model in which an apraxic subject is unable to carry out movements to command because the left hemisphere that comprehended the verbal command is disconnected from the right premotor and motor areas which controls the left hand. An alternate model, however, proposes that apraxia results from destruction of spatiotemporal representations of learned movement stored in the left hemisphere (Heilman, 1979). The disconnection hypothesis would predict that apraxic subjects should be able to correctly imitate gestures and correctly use actual tools since these tasks do not require language. The movement representation model predicts that imitation and actual tool use would also be impaired. Motion analyses were performed on the trajectories of repetitive 'slicing' gestures made in a series of conditions in which contextual cues were introduced in a graded fashion. Four cue conditions were presented: no cues (verbal command), object present, tool present and both object and tool present. Positions of the hand, wrist, elbow, and shoulder were digitized from neighbouring views, reconstructed in three dimensions and analysed with respect to specific spatiotemporal features of the trajectories. Three subjects with limb apraxia, who had lesions that included left parietal cortex, and four neurologically intact subjects participated. The apraxic subjects showed disturbances in planning the movement of the hand in space across the cue conditions. For example, they showed deficits in the plane of motion, the shape of the trajectory and in the coupling of hand speed and trajectory shape even when given full contextual cues. These data support the hypothesis that apraxia can result from the destruction of spatiotemporal representations of learned movement, rather than from a disconnection between the receptive language areas in the left hemisphere and the contralateral motor cortices.
Corticobasal degeneration (CBD) is a degenerative disease that often presents with an asymmetric ... more Corticobasal degeneration (CBD) is a degenerative disease that often presents with an asymmetric progressive ideomotor limb apraxia. Some apraxic subjects may fail to perform skilled purposive movements on command because they have lost the memories or representations that specify how these movements should be performed (representational deficit). In contrast, other apraxic subjects may have the movement representations but are unable to utilize the information contained in them to execute skilled purposive movements (production-execution deficit). To learn if the apraxic deficit in CBD is induced by a representational or a production-execution deficit, we tested three nondemented subjects with CBD on tasks requiring production of meaningful or meaningless gestures to command, gesture imitation, gesture discrimination, and novel gesture learning. A fourth subject with incomplete data also is presented. The results suggest that the apraxia associated with CBD is initially induced by a production-execution defect with relative sparing of the movement representations.
Incorporating horses into speech-language pathology services is a valid treatment strategy that c... more Incorporating horses into speech-language pathology services is a valid treatment strategy that can be used to help the client achieve their communication and/or swallowing goals. The purpose of this article is to discuss the history and terminology of incorporating horses into rehabilitation, explain theories for why incorporating horses works, and provide clinical applications to the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association's nine areas of practice with clinical reports.
Journal of rehabilitation research and development
This study explored the effects and effectiveness of animal-assisted therapy (AAT) for persons wi... more This study explored the effects and effectiveness of animal-assisted therapy (AAT) for persons with aphasia. Three men with aphasia from left-hemisphere strokes participated in this study. The men received one semester of traditional therapy followed by one semester of AAT. While both therapies were effective, in that each participant met his goals, no significant differences existed between test results following traditional speech-language therapy versus AAT. Results of a client-satisfaction questionnaire, however, indicated that each of the participants was more motivated, enjoyed the therapy sessions more, and felt that the atmosphere of the sessions was lighter and less stressed during AAT compared with traditional therapy.
Abstract—This study explored the effects and effectiveness of animal-assisted therapy (AAT) for p... more Abstract—This study explored the effects and effectiveness of animal-assisted therapy (AAT) for persons with aphasia. Three men with aphasia from left-hemisphere strokes participated in this study. The men received one semester of traditional ther-apy followed by one semester of AAT. While both therapies were effective, in that each participant met his goals, no significant differences existed between test results following traditional speech-language therapy versus AAT. Results of a client-satisfaction questionnaire, however, indicated that each of the participants was more motivated, enjoyed the therapy sessions more, and felt that the atmosphere of the sessions was lighter and less stressed during AAT compared with traditional therapy. Key words: animal-assisted therapy, aphasia, brain injury, communication, increased motivation, rehabilitation, speech-language pathology, speech-language therapy, stroke, therapy animals, therapy efficacy.
Contemporary Issues in Communication Science and Disorders
This study examined the effects of aphasia and ideomotor apraxia on conversational gesture. Parti... more This study examined the effects of aphasia and ideomotor apraxia on conversational gesture. Participants included 8 neurologically normal control participants and 12 participants having aphasia from a single left-hemisphere stroke. Testing included the Western Aphasia Battery (Kertesz, 1982), the Florida Apraxia Battery (Rothi et al., 1992), and scoring of conversational gesture. Statistical findings using a between-group analysis of variance revealed a statistically significant difference in quantity and type of gestures used between experimental and control participants. Within the experimental participants, there was a clear relationship between severity of aphasia and conversational gesture, but not between severity of ideomotor apraxia and conversational gesture. Therefore, severity of aphasia appears to be a better predictor than severity of ideomotor apraxia for the production of spontaneous gesture.
Neuropsychiatry, neuropsychology, and behavioral neurology, 1999
Ideomotor apraxia was studied in patients with Alzheimer disease (AD) and unilateral left hemisph... more Ideomotor apraxia was studied in patients with Alzheimer disease (AD) and unilateral left hemispheric damaged (LHD) stroke to determine whether these groups differed. Given that the neuropathology of AD is bilateral and more diffuse than the localized involvement in patients after an LHD stroke, and given that the cognitive deficits in AD are more widespread than in LHD stroke, the authors predicted that patients with these disorders would differ in response to an auditory command task administered to evaluate ideomotor apraxia, and that the two patient groups would be significantly more impaired than healthy matched control subjects. Twenty-one persons were studied, including equal numbers of patients with AD, patients with unilateral LHD stroke, and control subjects. An auditory command test of limb apraxia was administered and videotaped to score performance and to code spatial-temporal or content errors. The patients with AD and LHD stroke were significantly more impaired than h...
Liepmann posited that, in right handers, the left parietal lobe contains movement formulas or rep... more Liepmann posited that, in right handers, the left parietal lobe contains movement formulas or representations. Therefore, performance failures may be induced by degraded representations, a failure of these representations to influence motor systems or a failure of stimuli to fully access these representations. Imitation may help the performance of subjects with degraded representations. However, patients who have impaired visual access to movement representations may perform more poorly with imitation than to verbal command. Trajectories of repetitive 'slicing' gestures made by a previously reported subject (Raymer et al.) with an infarction in the left visual association cortex (left occipital and inferior temporal lobe) that spared the parietal lobe were contrasted with those of three apraxic subjects with lesions that included the left parietal lobe and four non-brain-damaged control subjects. All subjects were asked to produce the gesture to verbal command and to imitation. Movements of the left hand, wrist, elbow and shoulder were digitized from neighboring views, reconstructed in three dimensions, and analysed graphically and numerically. The apraxic subjects with left parietal damage were unable to maintain the proper linearity and spatiotemporal attributes of their wrist motions and showed interjoint coordination deficits. Their deficits were most pronounced to verbal command, with their movements improving though remaining poorly performed when they imitated. The subject with the left occipital and inferior temporal lesion that spared parietal cortex, however, showed an opposite pattern. This subject exhibited close to normal performance when producing the movement to verbal command, but significant deficits when imitating.
Three-dimensional motion analyses were performed on trajectories of repetitive "... more Three-dimensional motion analyses were performed on trajectories of repetitive "slicing" gestures by 4 participants with left-hemisphere lesions and limb apraxia, 6 participants with right-hemisphere lesions, and 7 neurologically intact participants. Left hemispheric lesioned participants with apraxia, but not right hemispheric lesioned participants showed impaired coupling of spatial and temporal aspects of wrist trajectories and deficits in interjoint coordination. Both groups of brain-lesioned participants differed from control participants in the 3-D plane of the wrist motion. The deficits of some right hemispheric lesioned participants in controlling the plane of wrist motion may be a consequence of left hemispatial neglect with rightward deviations. In contrast, the deficits of apraxic participants in controlling wrist trajectories and coordinating joint motions seem to reflect a deficit in these participants for the movement plan.
Journal of the International Neuropsychological Society, 1995
Humans learn skilled acts in order to effectively interact with their environment. A loss of the ... more Humans learn skilled acts in order to effectively interact with their environment. A loss of the ability to perform skilled acts is termed apraxia. Apraxia has been thought to be of theoretical interest, but the ecological implications of apraxia are controversial and have not been fully studied. We examined ten patients with unilateral left hemisphere cerebral infarctions (eight of whom were apraxic) and compared their mealtime eating behavior to a group of neurologically normal, age-matched controls. The stroke patients were less efficient in completing the meal. They made more action errors and were less organized in the sequencing of mealtime activities. Because the patients made more errors while using tools than when performing nontool actions, their deficit could not be accounted for by an elemental motor deficit. A positive relationship was found between mealtime action errors and the severity of apraxia. These findings suggest that limb apraxia may adversely influence activ...
The Journal of Rehabilitation Research and Development, 2006
This study explored the effects and effectiveness of animal-assisted therapy (AAT) for persons wi... more This study explored the effects and effectiveness of animal-assisted therapy (AAT) for persons with aphasia. Three men with aphasia from left-hemisphere strokes participated in this study. The men received one semester of traditional therapy followed by one semester of AAT. While both therapies were effective, in that each participant met his goals, no significant differences existed between test results following traditional speech-language therapy versus AAT. Results of a client-satisfaction questionnaire, however, indicated that each of the participants was more motivated, enjoyed the therapy sessions more, and felt that the atmosphere of the sessions was lighter and less stressed during AAT compared with traditional therapy.
Competing models of the basis of limb apraxia were tested through analysis of joint coordination ... more Competing models of the basis of limb apraxia were tested through analysis of joint coordination deficits in three apraxic subjects with lesions that included the left parietal lobe. Three-dimensional shoulder, elbow, wrist and hand trajectories were recorded for repetitive 'slicing' gestures made in a series of conditions in which contextual cues were introduced in a graded fashion. The apraxic subjects showed marked deficits in joint coordination across context conditions. Even when actually manipulating a tool and object, the apraxic subjects failed to show proper joint synchronization, failed to apportion their relative joint amplitudes properly, and failed to produce the correct phase relationships among pairs of arm angles. Thus, apraxic subjects not only have deficits in the spatial plan for the movement, but they also have deficits in translating those plans into the details of the angular motions at the joints, even when actually manipulating a tool and object. These data support a model of apraxia in which apraxia can result from either the destruction of visuo-kinaesthetic motor representations of learned movement, stored in posterior association cortex, or from a separation of these representations from premotor or motor areas.
Geschwind (1975) proposed a disconnection model in which an apraxic subject is unable to carry ou... more Geschwind (1975) proposed a disconnection model in which an apraxic subject is unable to carry out movements to command because the left hemisphere that comprehended the verbal command is disconnected from the right premotor and motor areas which controls the left hand. An alternate model, however, proposes that apraxia results from destruction of spatiotemporal representations of learned movement stored in the left hemisphere (Heilman, 1979). The disconnection hypothesis would predict that apraxic subjects should be able to correctly imitate gestures and correctly use actual tools since these tasks do not require language. The movement representation model predicts that imitation and actual tool use would also be impaired. Motion analyses were performed on the trajectories of repetitive 'slicing' gestures made in a series of conditions in which contextual cues were introduced in a graded fashion. Four cue conditions were presented: no cues (verbal command), object present, tool present and both object and tool present. Positions of the hand, wrist, elbow, and shoulder were digitized from neighbouring views, reconstructed in three dimensions and analysed with respect to specific spatiotemporal features of the trajectories. Three subjects with limb apraxia, who had lesions that included left parietal cortex, and four neurologically intact subjects participated. The apraxic subjects showed disturbances in planning the movement of the hand in space across the cue conditions. For example, they showed deficits in the plane of motion, the shape of the trajectory and in the coupling of hand speed and trajectory shape even when given full contextual cues. These data support the hypothesis that apraxia can result from the destruction of spatiotemporal representations of learned movement, rather than from a disconnection between the receptive language areas in the left hemisphere and the contralateral motor cortices.
Corticobasal degeneration (CBD) is a degenerative disease that often presents with an asymmetric ... more Corticobasal degeneration (CBD) is a degenerative disease that often presents with an asymmetric progressive ideomotor limb apraxia. Some apraxic subjects may fail to perform skilled purposive movements on command because they have lost the memories or representations that specify how these movements should be performed (representational deficit). In contrast, other apraxic subjects may have the movement representations but are unable to utilize the information contained in them to execute skilled purposive movements (production-execution deficit). To learn if the apraxic deficit in CBD is induced by a representational or a production-execution deficit, we tested three nondemented subjects with CBD on tasks requiring production of meaningful or meaningless gestures to command, gesture imitation, gesture discrimination, and novel gesture learning. A fourth subject with incomplete data also is presented. The results suggest that the apraxia associated with CBD is initially induced by a production-execution defect with relative sparing of the movement representations.
Uploads
Papers by Beth Macauley