Skip to content

Conversation

@ychin
Copy link
Contributor

@ychin ychin commented Oct 8, 2023

Cmdline expansion for option values that take a comma-separated list of file names is currently not handling file names with commas as the commas are not escaped. For such options, the commas in file names need to be escaped (to differentiate from a comma that delimit the list items). The escaped comma is unescaped in copy_option_part() during option parsing.

Fix as follows:

  • Cmdline completion for option values with comma-separated file/folder names will not start a new match when seeing \\, and will instead consider it as one value.
  • File/folder regex matching will strip the \\ when seeing \\, to make sure it can match the correct files/folders.
  • The expanded value will escape , with \\,, similar to how spaces are escaped to make sure the option value is correct on the cmdline.

This fix also takes into account the fact that Win32 Vim handles file name escaping differently. Typing \, for a file name results in it being handled literally but in other platforms \, is interpreted as a simple ',' and commas need to be escaped using \\, instead.

Also, make sure this new logic only applies to comma-separated options like 'path'. Non-list options like 'set makeprg=' and regular ex commands like :edit <Tab> do not require escaping and will continue to work.

Also fix up documentation to be clearer. The original docs are slightly misleading in how it discusses triple slashes for 'tags'.

@ychin ychin mentioned this pull request Oct 8, 2023
Cmdline expansion for option values that take a comma-separated list
of file names is currently not handling file names with commas as the
commas are not escaped. For such options, the commas in file names need
to be escaped (to differentiate from a comma that delimit the list
items). The escaped comma is unescaped in `copy_option_part()` during
option parsing.

Fix as follows:
- Cmdline completion for option values with comma-separated file/folder
  names will not start a new match when seeing `\\,` and will instead
  consider it as one value.
- File/folder regex matching will strip the `\\` when seeing `\\,` to
  make sure it can match the correct files/folders.
- The expanded value will escape `,` with `\\,`, similar to how spaces
  are escaped to make sure the option value is correct on the cmdline.

This fix also takes into account the fact that Win32 Vim handles file
name escaping differently. Typing '\,' for a file name results in it
being handled literally but in other platforms '\,' is interpreted as a
simple ',' and commas need to be escaped using '\\,' instead.

Also, make sure this new logic only applies to comma-separated options
like 'path'. Non-list options like 'set makeprg=<Tab>' and regular ex
commands like `:edit <Tab>` do not require escaping and will continue to
work.

Also fix up documentation to be clearer. The original docs are slightly
misleading in how it discusses triple slashes for 'tags'.
@ychin ychin force-pushed the fix-cmdline-option-completion-comma-handling branch from 0d74d0b to cbd4a33 Compare October 8, 2023 19:03
@chrisbra
Copy link
Member

chrisbra commented Oct 9, 2023

thanks!

@chrisbra chrisbra closed this in 5484485 Oct 9, 2023
@ychin ychin deleted the fix-cmdline-option-completion-comma-handling branch October 9, 2023 20:13
zeertzjq added a commit to zeertzjq/neovim that referenced this pull request Oct 9, 2023
Problem:  cmdline-completion for comma-separated options wrong
Solution: Fix command-line expansions for options with filenames with
          commas

Fix command-line expansions for options with filenames with commas

Cmdline expansion for option values that take a comma-separated list
of file names is currently not handling file names with commas as the
commas are not escaped. For such options, the commas in file names need
to be escaped (to differentiate from a comma that delimit the list
items). The escaped comma is unescaped in `copy_option_part()` during
option parsing.

Fix as follows:
- Cmdline completion for option values with comma-separated file/folder
  names will not start a new match when seeing `\\,` and will instead
  consider it as one value.
- File/folder regex matching will strip the `\\` when seeing `\\,` to
  make sure it can match the correct files/folders.
- The expanded value will escape `,` with `\\,`, similar to how spaces
  are escaped to make sure the option value is correct on the cmdline.

This fix also takes into account the fact that Win32 Vim handles file
name escaping differently. Typing '\,' for a file name results in it
being handled literally but in other platforms '\,' is interpreted as a
simple ',' and commas need to be escaped using '\\,' instead.

Also, make sure this new logic only applies to comma-separated options
like 'path'. Non-list options like 'set makeprg=<Tab>' and regular ex
commands like `:edit <Tab>` do not require escaping and will continue to
work.

Also fix up documentation to be clearer. The original docs are slightly
misleading in how it discusses triple slashes for 'tags'.

closes: vim/vim#13303
related: vim/vim#13301

vim/vim@5484485

Co-authored-by: Yee Cheng Chin <[email protected]>
zeertzjq added a commit to zeertzjq/neovim that referenced this pull request Oct 10, 2023
Problem:  cmdline-completion for comma-separated options wrong
Solution: Fix command-line expansions for options with filenames with
          commas

Fix command-line expansions for options with filenames with commas

Cmdline expansion for option values that take a comma-separated list
of file names is currently not handling file names with commas as the
commas are not escaped. For such options, the commas in file names need
to be escaped (to differentiate from a comma that delimit the list
items). The escaped comma is unescaped in `copy_option_part()` during
option parsing.

Fix as follows:
- Cmdline completion for option values with comma-separated file/folder
  names will not start a new match when seeing `\\,` and will instead
  consider it as one value.
- File/folder regex matching will strip the `\\` when seeing `\\,` to
  make sure it can match the correct files/folders.
- The expanded value will escape `,` with `\\,`, similar to how spaces
  are escaped to make sure the option value is correct on the cmdline.

This fix also takes into account the fact that Win32 Vim handles file
name escaping differently. Typing '\,' for a file name results in it
being handled literally but in other platforms '\,' is interpreted as a
simple ',' and commas need to be escaped using '\\,' instead.

Also, make sure this new logic only applies to comma-separated options
like 'path'. Non-list options like 'set makeprg=<Tab>' and regular ex
commands like `:edit <Tab>` do not require escaping and will continue to
work.

Also fix up documentation to be clearer. The original docs are slightly
misleading in how it discusses triple slashes for 'tags'.

closes: vim/vim#13303
related: vim/vim#13301

vim/vim@5484485

Co-authored-by: Yee Cheng Chin <[email protected]>
zeertzjq added a commit to zeertzjq/neovim that referenced this pull request Oct 10, 2023
Problem:  cmdline-completion for comma-separated options wrong
Solution: Fix command-line expansions for options with filenames with
          commas

Fix command-line expansions for options with filenames with commas

Cmdline expansion for option values that take a comma-separated list
of file names is currently not handling file names with commas as the
commas are not escaped. For such options, the commas in file names need
to be escaped (to differentiate from a comma that delimit the list
items). The escaped comma is unescaped in `copy_option_part()` during
option parsing.

Fix as follows:
- Cmdline completion for option values with comma-separated file/folder
  names will not start a new match when seeing `\\,` and will instead
  consider it as one value.
- File/folder regex matching will strip the `\\` when seeing `\\,` to
  make sure it can match the correct files/folders.
- The expanded value will escape `,` with `\\,`, similar to how spaces
  are escaped to make sure the option value is correct on the cmdline.

This fix also takes into account the fact that Win32 Vim handles file
name escaping differently. Typing '\,' for a file name results in it
being handled literally but in other platforms '\,' is interpreted as a
simple ',' and commas need to be escaped using '\\,' instead.

Also, make sure this new logic only applies to comma-separated options
like 'path'. Non-list options like 'set makeprg=<Tab>' and regular ex
commands like `:edit <Tab>` do not require escaping and will continue to
work.

Also fix up documentation to be clearer. The original docs are slightly
misleading in how it discusses triple slashes for 'tags'.

closes: vim/vim#13303
related: vim/vim#13301

vim/vim@5484485

Co-authored-by: Yee Cheng Chin <[email protected]>
zeertzjq added a commit to neovim/neovim that referenced this pull request Oct 10, 2023
…ong (#25569)

Problem:  cmdline-completion for comma-separated options wrong
Solution: Fix command-line expansions for options with filenames with
          commas

Fix command-line expansions for options with filenames with commas

Cmdline expansion for option values that take a comma-separated list
of file names is currently not handling file names with commas as the
commas are not escaped. For such options, the commas in file names need
to be escaped (to differentiate from a comma that delimit the list
items). The escaped comma is unescaped in `copy_option_part()` during
option parsing.

Fix as follows:
- Cmdline completion for option values with comma-separated file/folder
  names will not start a new match when seeing `\\,` and will instead
  consider it as one value.
- File/folder regex matching will strip the `\\` when seeing `\\,` to
  make sure it can match the correct files/folders.
- The expanded value will escape `,` with `\\,`, similar to how spaces
  are escaped to make sure the option value is correct on the cmdline.

This fix also takes into account the fact that Win32 Vim handles file
name escaping differently. Typing '\,' for a file name results in it
being handled literally but in other platforms '\,' is interpreted as a
simple ',' and commas need to be escaped using '\\,' instead.

Also, make sure this new logic only applies to comma-separated options
like 'path'. Non-list options like 'set makeprg=<Tab>' and regular ex
commands like `:edit <Tab>` do not require escaping and will continue to
work.

Also fix up documentation to be clearer. The original docs are slightly
misleading in how it discusses triple slashes for 'tags'.

closes: vim/vim#13303
related: vim/vim#13301

vim/vim@5484485

Co-authored-by: Yee Cheng Chin <[email protected]>
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants