Skip to content

vestauth/vestauth

Repository files navigation

vestauth

auth for agents–from the creator of dotenv and dotenvx.

1 minute demo 📺

Vestauth gives agents a cryptographic identity and a simple way to authenticate HTTP requests. Most agent systems rely on API keys, bearer tokens, or username/passwords. These approaches are difficult to rotate, easy to leak, and hard to attribute to a specific agent. Vestauth replaces shared secrets with public/private key cryptography. Agents sign requests using a private key, and tools verify those requests using the agent's public key. It's elegant and the future. [1]

Scott Motte–creator of dotenv and dotenvx

 

Quickstart npm version downloads RFC 9421 Compatible Web-Bot-Auth Draft Compatible

npm i -g vestauth
vestauth agent init

vestauth agent curl https://api.vestauth.com/whoami --pp
vestauth agent curl -X POST https://ping.vestauth.com/ping --pp
with curl 🌐
curl -sfS https://vestauth.sh | sh
vestauth agent init

curl installs

 

with github releases 🐙
curl -L -o vestauth.tar.gz "https://github.com/vestauth/vestauth/releases/latest/download/vestauth-$(uname -s)-$(uname -m).tar.gz"
tar -xzf vestauth.tar.gz
./vestauth agent init

github releases

 

or windows 🪟

Download the windows executable directly from the releases page.

(unzip to extract vestauth.exe)

 

Agent: Identity & Authentication

Give agents cryptographic identities…

$ mkdir your-agent
$ cd your-agent

$ vestauth agent init
✔ agent created (.env/AGENT_UID=agent-4b94ccd425e939fac5016b6b)

…and sign their curl requests with cryptographic authentication.

> SIGNED - 200
$ vestauth agent curl https://api.vestauth.com/whoami
{"uid":"agent-4b94ccd425e939fac5016b6b",...}

> UNSIGNED - 400
$ curl https://api.vestauth.com/whoami
{"error":{"status":400,"code":null,"message":"bad_request","help":null,"meta":null}}
learn more

First vestauth agent init populates a .env file with an AGENT_PUBLIC_JWK, AGENT_PRIVATE_JWK, and AGENT_UID.

# .env
AGENT_PUBLIC_JWK="{"crv":"Ed25519","x":"py2xNaAfjKZiau-jtmJls6h_3n8xJ1Ur0ie-n9b8zWg","kty":"OKP","kid":"B0u80Gw28W9U2Jl5t_EBiWeBajO2104kOYZ9Ikucl5I"}"
AGENT_PRIVATE_JWK="{"crv":"Ed25519","d":"Z9vbwN-3eiFMVv_TPWXOxqSMJAT21kZvejWi72yiAaQ","x":"py2xNaAfjKZiau-jtmJls6h_3n8xJ1Ur0ie-n9b8zWg","kty":"OKP","kid":"B0u80Gw28W9U2Jl5t_EBiWeBajO2104kOYZ9Ikucl5I"}"
AGENT_UID="agent-4b94ccd425e939fac5016b6b"
Variable Role Usage
AGENT_PUBLIC_JWK Verification Published for tool signature validation
AGENT_PRIVATE_JWK Signing Used locally to sign HTTP requests
AGENT_UID Identity Builds discovery FQDN and identifies the agent

Then vestauth agent curl autosigns curl requests – injecting valid signed headers according to the web-bot-auth draft. You can peek these with the built-in headers primitive.

$ vestauth primitives headers GET https://api.vestauth.com/whoami --pp
{
  "Signature": "sig1=:d4Id5SXhUExsf1XyruD8eBmlDtWzt/vezoCS+SKf0M8CxSkhKBtdHH7KkYyMN6E0hmxmNHsYus11u32nhvpWBQ==:",
  "Signature-Input": "sig1=(\"@authority\");created=1770247189;keyid=\"B0u80Gw28W9U2Jl5t_EBiWeBajO2104kOYZ9Ikucl5I\";alg=\"ed25519\";expires=1770247489;nonce=\"NURxn28X7zyKJ9k5bHxuOyO5qdvF9L5s2qHmhTrGUzbwGSIoUCHmwSlwiiCRgTDGuum83yyWMHJU4jmrVI_XPg\";tag=\"web-bot-auth\"",
  "Signature-Agent": "sig1=agent-4b94ccd425e939fac5016b6b.api.vestauth.com"
}

Vestauth turns curl into a powerful primitive for tool-side agent identity, verification, and authentication. See the next section.

 

Tool: Verification

Verify requests and safely trust agent identity using cryptographic proof.

// index.js
const express = require('express')
const vestauth = require('vestauth')
const app = express()

// vestauth agent curl http://localhost:3000/whoami
app.get('/whoami', async (req, res) => {
  try {
    const url = `${req.protocol}://${req.get('host')}${req.originalUrl}`

    // --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    // 🪪 Reveal the agent's cryptographic identity.                                 //
    // The `tool.verify` method turns your endpoint into a cryptographically     //
    // authenticated tool — verifying signatures, keys, and returning the agent. //
    // --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    const agent = await vestauth.tool.verify(req.method, url, req.headers)

    res.json(agent)
  } catch (err) {
    res.status(401).json({ code: 401, error: { message: err.message }})
  }
})

app.listen(3000, () => { console.log('listening on http://localhost:3000') })
$ npm install express vestauth --save
$ node index.js
listening on http://localhost:3000
$ vestauth agent curl http://localhost:3000/whoami
{"uid":"agent-4b94ccd425e939fac5016b6b",...}
learn more
Agent → Signs Request → Tool → Discovers Keys → Verifies Signature → Trusted Agent

Vestauth verifies requests using public key discovery and HTTP Message Signature validation.

When a signed request is received, Vestauth:

  1. Extracts the agent identity from the Signature-Agent header.
  2. Resolves the agent's discovery endpoint.
  3. Fetches the agent's public keys from its .well-known/http-message-signatures-directory.
  4. Verifies the request signature using RFC 9421.
  5. Validates timestamps and nonce protections to prevent replay attacks.

If verification succeeds, the tool can safely trust the agent's cryptographic identity.

Vestauth intentionally separates identity discovery from verification to support key rotation and distributed agent infrastructure.

 

Advanced

Become a vestauth power user.

CLI 📟

Advanced CLI commands.

`agent init`

Create agent.

$ vestauth agent init
✔ agent created (.env/AGENT_UID=agent-609a4fd2ebf4e6347108c517)
⮕ next run: [vestauth agent curl https://api.vestauth.com/whoami]
`agent init --hostname`

Use --hostname to override the agent API hostname (defaults to AGENT_HOSTNAME, then api.vestauth.com): When no scheme is provided, https:// is assumed. For local non-TLS endpoints, pass http://... explicitly.

$ vestauth agent init --hostname https://vestauth.yoursite.com
✔ agent created (.env/AGENT_UID=agent-609a4fd2ebf4e6347108c517)
⮕ next run: [vestauth agent curl https://api.vestauth.com/whoami]
`agent curl`

Run curl as agent.

$ vestauth agent curl https://api.vestauth.com/whoami
{"uid":"agent-609a4fd2ebf4e6347108c517", ...}
`agent curl --pretty-print`

Pretty print curl json output.

$ vestauth agent curl https://api.vestauth.com/whoami --pp
{
  "uid": "agent-609a4fd2ebf4e6347108c517",
  "kid": "FGzgs758DBGnI1S0BejChDsK0IKZm3qPpOOXdRnnBkM",
  "public_jwk": {
    ...
  },
  "well_known_url": "https://agent-609a4fd2ebf4e6347108c517.api.vestauth.com/.well-known/http-message-signatures-directory"
}
`agent headers`

Generate signed headers as agent.

$ vestauth agent headers GET https://api.vestauth.com/whoami --pp
{
  "Signature": "sig1=:UW6A7j8jo+gQxd+EeVgDddY51ZOc9plrSaupW/N53hQnQFvP9BuwQHgL7SVPLQIu4cnRzLgvwm7Yu9YMO+HUDQ==:",
  "Signature-Input": "sig1=(\"@authority\");created=1770396357;keyid=\"FGzgs758DBGnI1S0BejChDsK0IKZm3qPpOOXdRnnBkM\";alg=\"ed25519\";expires=1770396657;nonce=\"PrE7A6I_5fWnxBsBigNvxjp3-YangXl71V1uM3hPZavh918JqzjMSRcjHv_n5XIb3N8WivZEeigCBH6QGDSqgA\";tag=\"web-bot-auth\"",
  "Signature-Agent": "sig1=agent-609a4fd2ebf4e6347108c517.api.vestauth.com"
}
`agent headers --uid`

Change the AGENT_UID.

$ vestauth agent headers GET https://api.vestauth.com/whoami --uid agent-1234 --pp
{
  "Signature": "sig1=:UW6A7j8jo+gQxd+EeVgDddY51ZOc9plrSaupW/N53hQnQFvP9BuwQHgL7SVPLQIu4cnRzLgvwm7Yu9YMO+HUDQ==:",
  "Signature-Input": "sig1=(\"@authority\");created=1770396357;keyid=\"FGzgs758DBGnI1S0BejChDsK0IKZm3qPpOOXdRnnBkM\";alg=\"ed25519\";expires=1770396657;nonce=\"PrE7A6I_5fWnxBsBigNvxjp3-YangXl71V1uM3hPZavh918JqzjMSRcjHv_n5XIb3N8WivZEeigCBH6QGDSqgA\";tag=\"web-bot-auth\"",
  "Signature-Agent": "sig1=agent-1234.api.vestauth.com"
}
`agent headers --private-jwk`

Change the AGENT_PRIVATE_JWK used to sign the headers.

$ vestauth agent headers GET https://api.vestauth.com/whoami --private-jwk '{"crv":"Ed25519","d":"RyFk7QTOk_bMjFQKjyAR-vJDp7BITn9U0YBFNdpR9wE","x":"hyAxNMbuTcFQq420Dr46ucF0dRZ_FIyxgsujruEoklM","kty":"OKP","kid":"UfHTArlyLsqM8cB8sNfH2z6XOwc0RmJIq2CAPGfvMjk"}' --pp
{
  "Signature": "sig1=:PZUVVjqiECYuk8Hg1GZKKeJmwhLrcRdRA7nm1R595UFK9cx0q9atNFBzKP5wBEmszMIgvpYdMrIQbPEeKz4tCQ==:",
  "Signature-Input": "sig1=(\"@authority\");created=1770396546;keyid=\"UfHTArlyLsqM8cB8sNfH2z6XOwc0RmJIq2CAPGfvMjk\";alg=\"ed25519\";expires=1770396846;nonce=\"BSIugautfZvN3u5QUgl1mMuyxgmeRsRy9XxX7GXxjJxq1mI0kJl4F-C1nITtOfSeEt6xR1YBfyxsffNKy_wKSA\";tag=\"web-bot-auth\"",
  "Signature-Agent": "sig1=agent-609a4fd2ebf4e6347108c517.api.vestauth.com"
}
`agent rotate`

Rotate your AGENT_PRIVATE_JWK and AGENT_PUBLIC_JWK.

$ vestauth agent rotate
✔ agent keys rotated (.env/AGENT_UID=agent-8f1b347e2e58899f3147c05b)
⮕ next run: [vestauth agent curl https://api.vestauth.com/whoami]
`tool verify`

Verify agent.

$ vestauth tool verify GET https://api.vestauth.com/whoami --signature "sig1=:H1kxwSRWFbIzKbHaUy4hQFp/JrmVTX//72JPHcW4W7cPt9q6LytRJgx5pUgWrrr7DCcMWgx/jpTPc8Ht8SZ3CQ==:" --signature-input "sig1=(\"@authority\");created=1770396709;keyid=\"FGzgs758DBGnI1S0BejChDsK0IKZm3qPpOOXdRnnBkM\";alg=\"ed25519\";expires=1770397009;nonce=\"BZSDVktdkjO6XH5jafAdPDttsB6eytXO7u8KXJN1tMtd5bprE3rp08HiaTRo7H6gZGtYb4_qtL7RiGi8P2Gq7w\";tag=\"web-bot-auth\"" --signature-agent "sig1=agent-609a4fd2ebf4e6347108c517.api.vestauth.com"
{"uid":"agent-609a4fd2ebf4e6347108c517",...}
`server start`

Start vestauth server.

$ vestauth server start 
vestauth server listening on http://localhost:3000
`server start --port`

Start vestauth server on specific port.

$ vestauth server start --port 4567
vestauth server listening on http://localhost:4567
`primitives keypair`

Generate public/private keypair.

$ vestauth primitives keypair --pp
{
  "public_jwk": {
    "crv": "Ed25519",
    "x": "QjutZ3_tt2jRD_XSOq4EFCDivnwEzKIrQB2yReddsNo",
    "kty": "OKP",
    "kid": "ZCa5pijSUCw7QKgBs6nkvBBzbEjTMKYSt6iwCDQdIYc"
  },
  "private_jwk": {
    "crv": "Ed25519",
    "d": "RTyREuKAEfIMMs2ejwaKtFefZxt14HmsRR0rFj4U5iM",
    "x": "QjutZ3_tt2jRD_XSOq4EFCDivnwEzKIrQB2yReddsNo",
    "kty": "OKP",
    "kid": "ZCa5pijSUCw7QKgBs6nkvBBzbEjTMKYSt6iwCDQdIYc"
  }
}
`primitives headers`

Generate signed headers.

$ vestauth primitives headers GET http://example.com --pp
{
  "Signature": "sig1=:K7z3Nozcq1z5zfJhrd540DWYbjyQ1kR/S7ZDcMXE5gVhxezvG6Rn9BxEvfteiAnBuQhOkvbpGtF83WpQQerGBw==:",
  "Signature-Input": "sig1=(\"@authority\");created=1770263541;keyid=\"_4GFBGmXKinLBoh3-GJZCiLBt-84GP9Fb0iBzmYncUg\";alg=\"ed25519\";expires=1770263841;nonce=\"0eu7hVMVFm61lQvIryKNmZXIbzkkgpVocoKvN0de5QO8Eu5slTxklJAcVLQs0L_UTVtx4f8qJcqYZ21JTeOQww\";tag=\"web-bot-auth\"",
  "Signature-Agent": "sig1=agent-35e4a794a904d227ee2373b6.api.vestauth.com"
}
`primitives verify`

Verify signed headers.

$ vestauth primitives verify GET https://api.vestauth.com/whoami --signature "sig1=:UHqXQbWZmyYW40JRcdCl+NLccLgPmcoirUKwLtdcpEcIgxG2+i+Q2U3yIYeMquseON3fKm29WSL2ntHeRefHBQ==:" --signature-input "sig1=(\"@authority\");created=1770395703;keyid=\"FGzgs758DBGnI1S0BejChDsK0IKZm3qPpOOXdRnnBkM\";alg=\"ed25519\";expires=1770396003;nonce=\"O8JOC1reBofwbpPcdD-MRRCdrtAf4khvJTuhpRI_RiaH_hpU93okLkmPZVFFcUEdYtYfcduaB8Sca54GTd2GXA\";tag=\"web-bot-auth\"" --signature-agent "sig1=agent-609a4fd2ebf4e6347108c517.api.vestauth.com"
{"uid":"agent-609a4fd2ebf4e6347108c517", ...}

Library 📦

Use vestauth directly in code.

`tool.verify()`

Verify and authenticate an agent's cryptographic identity.

const agent = await vestauth.tool.verify(httpMethod, url, headers)
`primitives.verify()`

Verify and authenticate a signed http request.

await vestauth.primitives.verify(httpMethod, url, headers, publicJwk)

 

Available Tools

List of tools. We're actively building tools and looking for others to help grow the vestauth ecosystem with calls for tools like sending email, sms, uploading files and more. Vestauth agents need more tools. A tool is just a sharp API call. Add your tool here.

 

Compare

Agent + Tool Matrix – Compare Vestauth vs existing auth.

Capability Vestauth API Keys OAuth Cookies
Agent: no browser required ⚠️ (depends on flow)
Agent: easy to automate ⚠️
Agent: no shared secret ⚠️ (bearer tokens)
Agent: per‑request identity proof ⚠️ (token‑based)
Agent: easy key/token rotation ⚠️ ⚠️ ⚠️
Tool: no secret storage ✅ (public keys only)
Tool: strong attribution to agent ⚠️ ⚠️
Tool: stateless verification
Tool: simple to implement ⚠️ (sig verification)
Tool: revocation control ⚠️ ⚠️

Legend: ✅ strong fit, ⚠️ partial/conditional, ❌ poor fit

How It Works

  1. An agent generates a public/private keypair.
  2. The agent signs each HTTP request with its private key.
  3. The tool verifies the signature using the agent’s public key.
  4. Requests are attributable, auditable, and do not require shared secrets or browser sessions.

 

Standards

Vestauth builds on open internet standards for agent authentication.

Specification Purpose
RFC 9421 – HTTP Message Signatures Defines how requests are cryptographically signed and verified
Web-Bot-Auth Draft Defines headers and authentication architecture for autonomous agents

Vestauth follows these specifications to ensure interoperability between agents and tools while avoiding vendor lock-in. Vestauth focuses on developer ergonomics while staying compliant with these emerging standards.

 

Demo

vestauth:ping

https://ping.vestauth.com

 

FAQ

What problem does Vestauth solve?

Vestauth gives agents a cryptographic identity and a simple way to authenticate HTTP requests.

Most agent systems rely on API keys, bearer tokens, or username/passwords. These approaches are difficult to rotate, easy to leak, and hard to attribute to a specific agent.

Vestauth replaces shared secrets with public/private key cryptography. Agents sign requests using a private key, and tools verify those requests using the agent's public key.

 

Why not just use API keys?

API keys are shared secrets. Anyone who obtains the key can impersonate the client, and keys are difficult to rotate safely.

Vestauth uses cryptographic signing instead of shared secrets. This allows tools to verify identity without storing or distributing sensitive credentials.

 

Where are agent keys stored?

Agent keys are generated locally and stored in the agent's environment configuration (.env).

  • AGENT_PRIVATE_JWK is used to sign requests and must never be shared.
  • AGENT_PUBLIC_JWK is safe to publish and is used by tools for verification.

 

Is Vestauth only for AI agents?

No.

Vestauth can authenticate any automated system including:

  • developer tools
  • CLIs
  • automation services
  • bots
  • infrastructure tools

 

Can Vestauth work without curl?

Yes.

Vestauth provides libraries and primitives that can be integrated into any HTTP client or framework. The CLI simply makes it easy to adopt and demonstrate.

 

Do I need to run a Vestauth server?

No.

Vestauth is primarily a client-side and verification library. Agents generate keys locally and sign requests directly. Tools verify requests using public keys exposed via .well-known discovery endpoints.

There is no central authentication server required.

 

Why does Vestauth use Ed25519 keys?

Ed25519 provides:

  • Strong modern cryptographic security
  • Fast signing and verification
  • Small key sizes
  • Wide ecosystem support

 

How does Vestauth authentication work?

Vestauth uses HTTP Message Signatures (RFC 9421). Each request is signed using the agent's private key. The request includes signed headers such as:

  • Signature
  • Signature-Input
  • Signature-Agent

Tools verify the request by retrieving the agent's public key from a discovery endpoint and verifying the signature cryptographically.

If the signature is valid, the tool knows the request was created by the agent that owns that private key.

 

How does Vestauth prevent replay attacks?

Vestauth prevents replay attacks using multiple mechanisms built into HTTP Message Signatures.

Each signed request includes:

  • created timestamp - limits how old a signature can be
  • expires timestamp - defines a short validity window
  • nonce value - ensures each request is unique

Tools verify that:

  1. The signature is still within the allowed time window
  2. The nonce has not been used before
  3. The signature cryptographically matches the request

Because signatures are short-lived and tied to unique nonce values, an intercepted request cannot be reused successfully.

Tools may optionally store nonce values for additional replay protection.

 

Why does Vestauth use public key discovery?

Public key discovery allows tools to verify agent signatures without manual key exchange. Each agent hosts its public keys in a standardized .well-known directory.

This enables dynamic agent onboarding while preserving cryptographic verification.

 

Does Vestauth send secrets over the network?

No.

Vestauth signs requests using private keys locally. Only public keys are shared for verification.

 

How does Vestauth avoid SSRF during public key discovery?

Vestauth prevents Server-Side Request Forgery (SSRF) by restricting public key discovery to trusted domains.

By default, Vestauth only resolves agent discovery endpoints inside the controlled namespace:

*.api.vestauth.com

When a tool verifies a request, Vestauth converts the agent identity into a fixed .well-known endpoint within this trusted domain. Because this domain is controlled by Vestauth, tools never fetch attacker-supplied URLs or internal network addresses.

This removes the most common SSRF attack vector during signature verification.

Custom trusted discovery domains

Tools can optionally configure additional trusted discovery domains using:

TOOL_FQDN_REGEX

This allows organizations to:

  • Host their own agent discovery infrastructure
  • Support private internal agents
  • Implement federated trust models

For example:

TOOL_FQDN_REGEX=".*\.agents\.vestauth\.com|.*\.agents\.example\.internal"

Only discovery endpoints matching this allowlist will be fetched.

Defense in depth

Even with domain scoping, tools may optionally add safeguards such as:

  • HTTPS-only enforcement
  • Request timeouts
  • Response size limits
  • Public key caching

Vestauth removes SSRF by design, while still allowing controlled federation when needed.

 

Why does Vestauth use .well-known discovery instead of embedding public keys directly?

Vestauth uses .well-known discovery to keep requests small, enable key rotation, and support long-term identity management.

Embedding public keys directly in every request would increase header size, reduce caching opportunities, and make key rotation difficult. By publishing keys through a discovery endpoint, Vestauth allows tools to fetch and cache keys independently from individual requests.

This approach provides several benefits:

Efficient requests

Public keys are retrieved once and can be cached by tools. Agents do not need to send large key material with every request.

Key rotation support

Agents can rotate signing keys without changing their identity. Tools simply refresh keys from the discovery endpoint.

Multi-key support

Agents can safely publish multiple active keys (for rotation or staged rollouts) using the standard HTTP Message Signatures directory format.

Standards alignment

Vestauth follows the discovery model used in:

  • HTTP Message Signatures directories
  • OAuth / OpenID Connect key discovery
  • Web identity federation systems

 

Contributing

You can fork this repo and create pull requests or if you have questions or feedback: