-
-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 4.4k
Enhancement: Allow Systemd-boot to deal with multiple ESPs #3252
Description
This is a request for enhancement to what is now the current 229 version of Systemd found in the Archlinux repositories.
I recognize that "proper" protocol is to only have a single EFI system partition on a single system, however there are multiple reasons that this is not ideal for many users. One major issue being that any secondary drive will always be a slave to the drive with the ESP, thus if that drive crashes and/or is removed, no drive can be booted.
Further, for those of us with Windows dual-booted, Windows is often unpredictable with updates and sharing a ESP with Linux can often result in the LinuxOS being treated as a second class citizen. One major issue is with Windows' "fastboot" option, which can leave the ESP unwritable for any other OS. This is a major bummer, and causes serious issue.
That being said, as I don't want my Linux SSD slaved to my Windows SSD, I have an ESP partition on each drive. This setup, which functional (as I can switch between each OS from my bios boot menu) is not ideal, as systemd-boot can only see the boot options within 'its' ESP.
I propose, if it is technically feasible, that systemd-boot be able to recognize and be able to boot from foreign ESPs to the one currently housing the bootloader. This would allow a Windows drive and a Linux drive to stay fully isolated from one another while still retaining a working and unified boot experience.
This would be akin to how the legacy-bios method of booting a system functioned. And, while I am not 100% sure, I believe that the uefi variant of Grub2 has the aforementioned request already integrated.
sorry for any mistakes in my bug report, this is the first one I have posted to the systemd community. Cheers!