@@ -85,31 +85,40 @@ Each pin cites the rule by id in a comment and the scenario where one exists
8585
8686Baseline must be zero on E4/E5/E9 after §2 lands.
8787
88- ## 4. The carve, with four changes to the design
89-
90- The model (§2 of the design) and the table (§2.5) stand. These change:
91-
92- 1 . ** Step 1 runs against the generator before step 2.** The shadow seat under
93- ` __TEST__ ` computes the table's predicted slot beside every decider and
94- asserts agreement — on the suite _ and_ on 50k generator cases per seed.
95- Every mismatch is a table error or a bug on ` next ` . The table is correct
96- before any behaviour moves. The two invariants — a leaf never raises its
97- world; posture is never inherited — are pinned as ` INV-* ` here, not at
98- step 9.
99- 2 . ** Step 4 is stated honestly.** ` t._verdict ` (today ` newLane(t) ` ) stays as
100- the record; ` _ahead ` is a rename and the design says so. What goes is
101- seating verdict passes through ` passLane ` and the ` _parent._verdict === l `
102- arms (` core.ts:361 ` , ` lanes.ts:645 ` , ` :672 ` , ` :934 ` , ` verdict.ts:442 ` ,
103- ` route ` ). Verdicts need no node set: ` latest() ` is read-level (D-27), so
104- the posture is the whole mechanism. The isPending-page byte figure is
105- re-derived from what actually becomes unreachable in ` lanes.ts ` , or
106- dropped. R7 is the semantic reason verdict work must not use the lane
107- read path: that path's visibility rule is the optimistic one.
108- 3 . ** Bytes are a tracked budget, not a per-step gate.** Steps 2–4 may be
109- transiently positive. The hard check is after P0 and at step 9: the floor
110- and compiled hello world do not grow. CodSpeed on every step as before.
111- 4 . ** Serial merges, isolated worktrees.** One PR lands at a time; each
112- rebases; no two agents share a git store (the #4366 /#4373 incident).
88+ ## 4. The carve: rebuild beside, then swap
89+
90+ The model and the table stand; the plan is no longer the nine-step fold.
91+ The design is ` reader-seat-rebuild.md ` : the seat and the slot table are
92+ built _ beside_ the existing deciders as ` core/seat.ts ` (+ the display-ahead
93+ rows in ` verdict.ts ` and a ` lanes.ts ` core/layer split), reachable only
94+ under ` __TEST__ ` , and asserted against every decider on every read and
95+ every pass; then one PR makes the seat live and deletes the deciders. Three
96+ to five PRs (` reader-seat-rebuild.md ` §5):
97+
98+ - ** S0** — shadow under ` __TEST__ ` , ` INV-seat ` pinned (a leaf never raises
99+ its world; posture is never inherited; the shadow agrees), differential
100+ on the suites, the oracle and 50k generator cases per seed (3289, 91501,
101+ 7; owned and unowned; every pair). Every mismatch is a table error (fix
102+ the row, say so) or a bug on ` next ` (file it with rule id and row; do not
103+ fix in S0). Dist byte-identical.
104+ - ** S1** — the seat is live; ` frameRead ` , ` bornInto ` , ` joinPass ` ,
105+ ` readerSeesCommitted ` , ` stagedScreen ` , ` stagedRead ` , ` route ` ,
106+ ` verdictValue ` 's arms, ` laneRead ` 's arms and the duplicated hold arms of
107+ ` read ` /` serve ` go. ` t._verdict ` (today ` newLane(t) ` ) stays as the record;
108+ verdict passes are seated by posture, not ` passLane ` ; verdicts have no
109+ node set (` latest() ` is read-level, D-27). R7 is the semantic reason
110+ verdict work must not use the lane read path.
111+ - ** S2** — ` lanes.ts ` split into a sub-hold core and the optimistic layer;
112+ the isPending-only byte saving is ** measured** (` scripts/size ` ), not
113+ estimated.
114+ - ** S3** — bits and hooks freed (` JOINED ` , ` STAGED_READ ` , ` LANE_READ ` ,
115+ ` PROBED ` ; ` FRAME_READ ` +` SCREEN_READ ` → one STALE bit).
116+ - ** S4** (deferred) — store shims replaced with the store twins (§6).
117+
118+ Gates: S0 differential zero; S1 and S3 floor scenario and compiled hello
119+ world not above ` next ` post-P0; CodSpeed on every PR. Serial merges,
120+ isolated worktrees — one PR lands at a time, each rebases, no two agents
121+ share a git store (the #4366 /#4373 incident).
113122
114123The byte case is not the justification. The justification is the drift in
115124§1 and the bug concentration the audit measured. Say that in the PR bodies.
0 commit comments