Repository navigation
Effect Service Conventions: unsafe cause logging
apps/server/src/orchestration-v2/ProviderRuntimeRecoveryService.ts:754 embeds a raw Effect Cause in a log-message object. Pass it as a top-level logError argument so Effect records it as the cause.
Details
Warning
- Invalid effort level "max" in front matter. Fell back to "low". Valid values are: low, medium, high.
Note
Your check run agent prompt is: .macroscope/check-run-agents/effect-service-conventions.md
More information about how Check Run Agents work can be found in our Help Center.
Reviewed all 1 changed files (no prior completed review)
π Agent activity β 18 tool calls
1. browse_code β apps/server/src/orchestration-v2/ProviderRuntimeRecoveryService.ts
2. browse_code β In ProviderRuntimeRecoveryService.ts changed per-thread reconciliation catchCause block, identify whether changed lines violate Effect service conventions regarding error handling/log annotations, and describe cause/error definition and imports. Focus on concrete changed-line violations only.
3. browse_code β Does Effect.logError(message, {trigger, threadId, cause}) place the raw Cause as a log annotation, and is this a concrete violation of the rule 'Keep attributes and log annotations safe and bounded ... arbitrary defect text. Preserve the exact value only as cause'? Compare other service logging conventions if useful.
4. browse_code β docs/internals/effect-services.md
5. browse_code β Does existing codebase widely log Effect Cause in logError as cause property, and does 'Preserve exact value only as cause' permit an actual cause field in logError? Need distinguish unsafe arbitrary text copied into diagnostic fields from actual causal chain.
6. browse_code β Trace actual effect/Effect logError second argument semantics in installed effect version: is object logged as message potentially raw defect text? Just short answer with evidence.
π Considering error logging I'm trying to find a way to fix an issue without losing the root cause of the error. If I remove the cause line, I can keep the safe trigger ID, but it changes the observability of the root causes. I think using Effect.logError is an option, but Iβm uncertain about the API. Maybe I should remove the cause from the log payload while preserving the structured error context. Also, I should comment on the suggestion that a blank cause is a supported replacement.
7. modify_pr β Submitted review with 1 inline comment
8. browse_code β Is removing cause from logError an acceptable fix or does it lose error information for isolated failures? brief.
9. browse_code β Is logError('...', {cause}) conventional and safe? Could logError({cause}) use a structured cause field or must be from logError(message, cause)?
10. browse_code β Does logWithLevel actually recognize cause argument separately and logger's Cause field? brief.
11. browse_code β Is recommendation remove cause entirely instead of logError(message, cause) materially harmful?
π Considering posting comments Iβm thinking about whether to post a comment for correction, but it feels a bit redundant. Maybe it's best to just leave it as is instead of adding more confusion. After all, too much communication can sometimes muddy the waters. I want to keep things clear and straightforward for everyone involved, so Iβll lean towards not saying anything. Less is sometimes more, right? Let's focus on clarity!
12. browse_code β Can logError(message, {trigger,threadId}, cause) preserve bounded metadata and dedicated cause? yes/no
13. browse_code β Is there a single-line replacement on diff line 751 that avoids unsafe cause in message while preserving details using logError(message, cause) and metadata?
14. modify_pr β Correction to my inline suggestion: removing cause entirely would lose the only failure detail for a thread whose recovery is skipped. Instead, pass it as a top-level argument to Effect.logError, alongside the bounded { trigger, threadId } context. Effect then records it in the logger's dedicated causal field rather than embedding it in the message object.
15. browse_code β Is this issue clearly blocking according to stated rules?
16. browse_code β No more investigation needed.
17. browse_code β confirm
18. browse_code β stop
Agent Credits: 54 credits
Token usage: 195 uncached input Β· 1,447,240 cache-read input Β· 57,380 cache-write input Β· 7,465 output
Agent Credits may also include non-token charges from external tools such as web research.