Affected version: [email protected]

Summary

/compact via Discord native slash command completes the compaction successfully but shows "⚠️ Command produced no visible reply." instead of the expected confirmation (e.g. ⚙️ Compacted (50k → 10k) • 10k/200k).

By contrast, /new via native slash command produces a visible ephemeral reply as expected.

Expected behavior

The Discord interaction should reply with the compaction result text, e.g. ⚙️ Compacted (50k → 10k) • context usage.

Actual behavior

Discord shows the DISCORD_EMPTY_VISIBLE_REPLY_WARNING ephemeral fallback: "⚠️ Command produced no visible reply."

The compaction itself succeeds — session context is compacted and the system event is enqueued — but the reply.text from handleCompactCommand never reaches the Discord interaction delivery pipeline.

Root cause analysis

In commands-handlers.runtime-lGFD5UPQ.js, handleCompactCommand returns { shouldContinue: false, reply: { text: "⚙️ ..." } } after compaction completes. However, in the Discord native command path (provider-CiI2mFp8.js), dispatchDiscordNativeAgentReply → nativeCommandRuntime.dispatchReplyWithDispatcher does not surface this command handler reply through the deliver callback.

At line 956 of provider-CiI2mFp8.js:

if (params.suppressReplies || didReply || dispatchResult.queuedFinal || 
    dispatchResult.counts.final !== 0 || dispatchResult.counts.block !== 0 || 
    dispatchResult.counts.tool !== 0) return;

All counts are 0 and didReply is false, so it falls through to the empty reply warning.

Likely contributing factor: compaction involves an LLM summarization call (10-30+ seconds), which may cause timing issues with the interaction response pipeline, though the interaction is deferred so the 15-minute follow-up window should be sufficient.

Workaround

Type /compact as a plain text message (not from the slash command menu). Text commands go through the normal chat flow and deliver the confirmation as a regular message.

Steps to reproduce

1. Open a Discord channel with an active OpenClaw bot session that has conversation history
2. Use the native slash command menu to run /compact
3. Observe: "⚠️ Command produced no visible reply." (ephemeral)
4. Run /status — compaction count has incremented, confirming it worked

Environment

• Discord native commands with commands.native: "auto"
• Multiple bot accounts tested (same behavior across all)
• OpenClaw v2026.5.27