Summary
Slack should bypass requireMention in threads where the bot is already participating, matching Discord's existing behavior.
Current Behavior
- In Slack channels with
requireMention: true, the bot requires @mention even in threads where it has already posted
- Users replying to the bot's messages in a thread must still @mention the bot to get a response
Expected Behavior
- If
requireMention: true for a channel, but the message is in a thread where the bot has already posted, auto-respond without requiring mention
- This matches the implicit conversational context — if someone replies to your message in a thread, they're talking to you
Prior Art
Discord already has this behavior via PR #1511:
Discord: limit autoThread mention bypass to bot-owned threads; keep ack reactions mention-gated.
Proposed Solution
Add equivalent logic to the Slack plugin:
if (requireMention && isThread && botAlreadyParticipatingInThread) {
// bypass mention requirement
respond();
}
Environment
- Clawdbot version: 2026.1.24-3
- Channel: Slack (socket mode)
Thanks!
Summary
Slack should bypass
requireMentionin threads where the bot is already participating, matching Discord's existing behavior.Current Behavior
requireMention: true, the bot requires @mention even in threads where it has already postedExpected Behavior
requireMention: truefor a channel, but the message is in a thread where the bot has already posted, auto-respond without requiring mentionPrior Art
Discord already has this behavior via PR #1511:
Proposed Solution
Add equivalent logic to the Slack plugin:
Environment
Thanks!