You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
Commit 2e1c4b9
Browse filesBrowse the repository at this point in the historyBrowse files
Probe: a server that rejects the protocol version the client asks for is up, not down
In modelcontextprotocol/registry#1715 two posts point out that a liveness
result depends on the protocol version the client asks for. A server that
answers "Unsupported protocol version" is up. It must not count as dead.
On the board 15 registry entries did exactly that: they rejected
2025-11-25, the version that the SDK asks for, with HTTP 400 or a JSON-RPC
error (-32022, -32602, -32004). They were "error" or "protocol_error", and
14 of them were down since early October.
- New status unsupported_version. It is gated (reachable, not usable with
this client), so it is never down. Its evidence state is "unknown".
- Each evidence row now keeps the step that failed (method_phase:
initialize or tools/list) and the JSON-RPC error code of the answer. The
file says which client, SDK and requested version ran the checks
(checked_with), and each row already had the version the server
answered.
- The run summary keeps the requested version. The server page uses it.
- A package that answers with a newer version or rejects ours is not
reclassified as crashed.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
Copy file name to clipboardExpand all lines: probe/dataset.ts
+1-1Lines changed: 1 addition & 1 deletion
Original file line number
Diff line number
Diff line change
@@ -88,7 +88,7 @@ const evidence = {
88
88
auth: 'reachable, needs credentials or payment: 401, 403, 402',
89
89
transient: 'no valid answer in this run, and not dead: a timeout, a 429, a 5xx or a refused connection; or a dead cause seen for less than two days',
90
90
dead: 'no DNS, a TLS failure, 404/405/410, or an answer that is not MCP, in every check for two days or more (evidence.failing_since); a package that does not install or has no executable at two checks a week apart',
91
-
unknown: 'a package that needs values, arguments or a network to start, or crashed on start; a URL with placeholders that each user fills in, so it was not called; or an error the probe could not classify'
91
+
unknown: 'a package that needs values, arguments or a network to start, or crashed on start; a URL with placeholders that each user fills in, so it was not called; a server that rejects the protocol version the probe asks for (status unsupported_version: it is up); or an error the probe could not classify'
version: 'the version of the registry entry that was probed (the latest one)',
19
19
host: 'the host of the remote endpoint; npmjs.com or pypi.org for a package server',
20
20
transport: 'streamable-http, sse or stdio',
21
-
status: 'the probe result: ok, auth, payment, newer_protocol, needs_url, not_found, protocol_error, dns, tls, timeout, refused, server_error, rate_limited, error; for a package: crashed, install_failed, no_bin, needs_env, needs_args, needs_network. needs_url: every URL of the entry has a placeholder that each user fills in, so the probe did not call it',
21
+
status: 'the probe result: ok, auth, payment, newer_protocol, unsupported_version (the server rejects the protocol version the probe asks for), needs_url, not_found, protocol_error, dns, tls, timeout, refused, server_error, rate_limited, error; for a package: crashed, install_failed, no_bin, needs_env, needs_args, needs_network. needs_url: every URL of the entry has a placeholder that each user fills in, so the probe did not call it',
22
22
failing_since: 'for a server with no valid answer: the first probe of the current run of failed probes (ISO 8601). The board calls a server down after two days of them; one failed probe is "no answer"',
23
23
http_status: 'the HTTP status of the first response, when there was one',
24
24
auth_scheme: 'the WWW-Authenticate scheme of a server that needs auth',
0 commit comments