Skip to content

Retain stopped 2026-10-04 skills landscape sweep - #692

Closed
seathatflowsinourveins wants to merge 2 commits into
mainfrom
c5/skills-sweep-20261004
Closed

Retain stopped 2026-10-04 skills landscape sweep#692
seathatflowsinourveins wants to merge 2 commits into
mainfrom
c5/skills-sweep-20261004

Conversation

@seathatflowsinourveins

@seathatflowsinourveins seathatflowsinourveins commented Oct 4, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

Retain the post-run evidence from the 2026-10-04 skills landscape sweep. The Workflow reports completion, but native child usage is incomplete and the completed-result assembler refuses it. The sweep is appended as stopped with lower-bound usage and votes: not_returned in all 13 lifecycle tasks. Its retained votes, failure entries, source-review refusals and critic findings remain available for the next sweep and paired trials.

Scope

  • Changes: publish the dated manifest's skills lane_groupings, retain native usage and source reviews, append the stopped saturation record, and document the lifecycle-task results.
  • Base commit: 8c32a84b246da66e43a6188c973741b09329e223.
  • Branch: c5/skills-sweep-20261004.
  • Lane: lane:foundation (use this single PR label).
  • Owned paths: catalogs/saturation/ledger.json, catalogs/sota-convergence/README.md, catalogs/sota-convergence/manifest-20261004.json, docs/decisions/2026-10-04-skills-landscape-sweep.md, evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/, its -attempts/ directory, and manifests/evidence.json.
  • North-star action: preserve evidence needed to select and trial skills for complex-system engineering and US-equities research and historical simulation.

SOTA sources

  • native-agent-stack landscape-sweep README, commit 8c32a84b246da66e43a6188c973741b09329e223, Run it steps 8–12 and Skills modality; executed its existing conversion, manifest, source-review, result and ledger tools.
  • Stopped-run recipe, the same commit, section 4; incomplete usage requires a stopped record with lower-bound usage, explanatory layer notes and lost workers.
  • vercel-labs/skills, v1.7.0, commit 7407f3893ad4dceab546ac002c3ef806e4000c73, skill discovery and parseSkillMd; the native source reviewer used the verified [email protected] reader described in skills-yaml.pin.json.

The 33 source-reviewed skills are pinned below. The other 13 distinct skill-and-pin entries stopped qualification; their exact reasons are retained in evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/source-review-results.json.

  • addyosmani/agent-skills@spec-driven-development, commit 1401c8b8030e023baeebb31781a6653fe8e93026, skills/spec-driven-development/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/addyosmani-agent-skills-spec-driven-development.json.
  • addyosmani/agent-skills@test-driven-development, commit 1401c8b8030e023baeebb31781a6653fe8e93026, skills/test-driven-development/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/addyosmani-agent-skills-test-driven-development.json.
  • affaan-m/ECC@intent-driven-development, commit ef648e01899ba3e8dc6371642deaaf64b4477775, skills/intent-driven-development/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/affaan-m-ecc-intent-driven-development.json.
  • affaan-m/ECC@tdd-workflow, commit ef648e01899ba3e8dc6371642deaaf64b4477775, skills/tdd-workflow/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/affaan-m-ecc-tdd-workflow.json.
  • anthropics/claude-plugins-official@build-mcp-server, commit d182ca456ca09d31d139f7d3818d1d333b103cce, plugins/mcp-server-dev/skills/build-mcp-server/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/anthropics-claude-plugins-official-build-mcp-server.json.
  • anthropics/claude-plugins-official@claude-md-improver, commit d182ca456ca09d31d139f7d3818d1d333b103cce, plugins/claude-md-management/skills/claude-md-improver/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/anthropics-claude-plugins-official-claude-md-improver.json.
  • anthropics/knowledge-work-plugins@debug, commit 8444efcd48f7012f09797778a36a33e73d0861f4, engineering/skills/debug/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/anthropics-knowledge-work-plugins-debug.json.
  • bgauryy/octocode@octocode-research, commit c265e3f9413161c900cbf4aa70d451b8e6b3920a, skills/octocode-research/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/bgauryy-octocode-octocode-research.json.
  • cathrynlavery/diagram-design@diagram-design, commit f903933a534ba92cde1c85a28186267b3a317bb2, skills/diagram-design/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/cathrynlavery-diagram-design-diagram-design.json.
  • codybrom/clairvoyance@red-flags, commit b11ca9349436fb7afd891a999d07d6d1a15b348b, skills/red-flags/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/codybrom-clairvoyance-red-flags.json.
  • Fission-AI/OpenSpec@openspec-explore, commit 2500d6da971336167548b53731a35b2127df35ac, skills/openspec-explore/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/fission-ai-openspec-openspec-explore.json.
  • getsentry/skills@skill-writer, commit d18b7aa8ba878354e5c348310230e652f7690f9c, skills/skill-writer/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/getsentry-skills-skill-writer.json.
  • github/awesome-copilot@build-evidence-map, commit 143a3d976b3c1603cc8932984d5e1f28501cb5fc, skills/build-evidence-map/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/github-awesome-copilot-build-evidence-map.json.
  • github/awesome-copilot@threat-model-analyst, commit 143a3d976b3c1603cc8932984d5e1f28501cb5fc, skills/threat-model-analyst/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/github-awesome-copilot-threat-model-analyst.json.
  • haacked/dotfiles@resolve-conflicts, commit ed1f1ce07d5063c92ded3213155d2cb658615d04, ai/skills/resolve-conflicts/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/haacked-dotfiles-resolve-conflicts.json.
  • hegeldev/hegel-skill@hegel-review, commit a60b28243199b24aeebb2c90aece34082ee4997c, skills/hegel-review/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/hegeldev-hegel-skill-hegel-review.json.
  • laurigates/claude-plugins@property-based-testing, commit 9caa2be8e7b4b35823e4154c610e3846af05635c, testing-plugin/skills/property-based-testing/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/laurigates-claude-plugins-property-based-testing.json.
  • Neeeophytee/finding-unknowns-skills@assumption-test, commit ca5696a0f08d2de6b2997fff1d6cc05c3ed587cc, skills/assumption-test/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/neeeophytee-finding-unknowns-skills-assumption-test.json.
  • Neeeophytee/finding-unknowns-skills@interview-me, commit ca5696a0f08d2de6b2997fff1d6cc05c3ed587cc, skills/interview-me/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/neeeophytee-finding-unknowns-skills-interview-me.json.
  • NVIDIA/SkillSpector@skill-inspector, commit 35270064e42230dbc566e4134c55b5d581355db3, skills/skill-inspector/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/nvidia-skillspector-skill-inspector.json.
  • obra/superpowers@systematic-debugging, commit 8ca22dba9a94f28898bbce59f2537ff4d87c747d, skills/systematic-debugging/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/obra-superpowers-systematic-debugging.json.
  • shihyuho/skills@writing-agents-md, commit c8951dd5c8447ccb4963ae24dde82c2b580d5910, skills/writing-agents-md/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/shihyuho-skills-writing-agents-md.json.
  • softaworks/agent-toolkit@agent-md-refactor, commit 3027f20f3181758385a1bb8c022d4041dfb4de84, skills/agent-md-refactor/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/softaworks-agent-toolkit-agent-md-refactor.json.
  • tech-leads-club/agent-skills@gh-fix-ci, commit 120b67676388241b314699fa8fa9af25ada6d1d4, packages/skills-catalog/skills/(tooling)/gh-fix-ci/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/tech-leads-club-agent-skills-gh-fix-ci.json.
  • tech-leads-club/agent-skills@security-threat-model, commit 120b67676388241b314699fa8fa9af25ada6d1d4, packages/skills-catalog/skills/(security)/security-threat-model/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/tech-leads-club-agent-skills-security-threat-model.json.
  • trailofbits/skills@ask-questions-if-underspecified, commit daa4ad03eb6ae7c451665ff30b5daaa6cfbe613c, plugins/ask-questions-if-underspecified/skills/ask-questions-if-underspecified/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/trailofbits-skills-ask-questions-if-underspecified.json.
  • trailofbits/skills@atheris, commit 82fe8226252622fa807643bdca1710901198553a, plugins/testing-handbook-skills/skills/atheris/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/trailofbits-skills-atheris.json.
  • trailofbits/skills@semgrep-rule-creator, commit 82fe8226252622fa807643bdca1710901198553a, plugins/semgrep-rule-creator/skills/semgrep-rule-creator/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/trailofbits-skills-semgrep-rule-creator.json.
  • tt-a1i/archify@archify, commit bb6f126f1748a4079df1d263302466eb4333e3b0, archify/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/tt-a1i-archify-archify.json.
  • tw93/Waza@hunt, commit c3b74dd5845b39a80a79c36bb82b028947674a05, skills/hunt/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/tw93-waza-hunt.json.
  • upstash/context7@find-docs, commit bfa02ea67b5707fe0e0a673faa49d0f50b28c80b, skills/find-docs/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/upstash-context7-find-docs.json.
  • wshobson/agents@python-testing-patterns, commit 156b7a5e7a8b93642628a339ee4039c925b34c7f, plugins/python-development/skills/python-testing-patterns/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/wshobson-agents-python-testing-patterns.json.
  • wshobson/agents@uv-package-manager, commit 83e95a4893fab062a539c49fde5a4c2db26da577, plugins/python-development/skills/uv-package-manager/SKILL.md; review: evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/wshobson-agents-uv-package-manager.json.

Evidence-class table

Claim Evidence class Command / receipt
137 proposals, 47 vote-survivor occurrences across 13 tasks, and seven retained-failure reopen entries local_integration evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/convert-summary.json and returns.json; native convert.py
33 source reviews bind reviewed SKILL.md bytes to the adjudicated commit and folder tree source_review evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/*.json; native source_reviews.py
13 distinct source-review stops affect 14 survivor occurrences source_review evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/source-review-results.json; source_reviews.py exited 1
Workflow metadata reports 101 agents; native usage retains one incomplete critic child and one superseded critic attempt local_integration evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526-attempts/child-usage-wf_47005bb5-412.json, measurement exit 1; usage is a lower bound
Stopped sweep accepted without changing prior records local_integration catalogs/saturation/ledger.json; append and check against origin/main
Publication hashes and scope pass local_integration scripts/validate.py: exit 0, 69 components, 4 profiles, 195 receipts, 9,924 hashed files
Harness and ledger regression suite passes synthetic python3 -m unittest tests.test_saturation_ledger tests.test_landscape_sweep_harness: Ran 323 tests; OK (skipped=4)

Adoption requires the separate paired benchmarks and trial decisions named in the decision record.

Local commands run

Commands ran from the repository worktree. W below is the private sweep work directory, H=tools/sota-convergence/landscape-sweep, RUN=wf_47005bb5-412, LANE=landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526, and A=evidence/artifacts/$LANE.

rtk python3 $H/convert.py --workflow-output "$W/run-$RUN.json" --work-dir "$W" --usage "$W/child-usage-$RUN.json" --out "$W/out" --limit 'Workflow wf_47005bb5-412 finished with 101 agents. child-usage exited 1 with status incomplete: one child was lost when an earlier account reached its weekly limit, and one superseded attempt returned nothing. Failures and all measured usage are retained; usage is a lower bound, and missing usage is unknown.'
# exit 3: 14 string fields required publication redaction; redaction-receipt.json records the pointers and confirms no remaining findings.
# Copy summary found seven file_only GPT-6 returns; their failures remain reopened.
rtk python3 tools/sota-convergence/extract_layers.py --repo-root . --out "$W/work"
rtk python3 tools/sota-convergence/github_freshness.py --work-dir "$W/work" --workers 6
# exit 0 each: reconstructed missing manifest working inputs through README step 2.
rtk python3 tools/sota-convergence/build_manifest.py --work-dir "$W/work" --lanes "$W/out/lanes.json" --out "$W/manifest-20261004.json" --checked-at 2026-10-04 --id sota-convergence-20261004
# exit 0 after working inputs were restored; first attempt exited 1 for missing foundation-layers.json.
rtk python3 $H/source_reviews.py --survivors "$W/out/survivors.json" --out "$A" --lane "$LANE"
# exit 1: 33 reviews, 13 distinct stopped entries (14 occurrences); printed results retained.
rtk python3 $H/make_result.py --layers "$W/out/layers.json" --reviews "$W/out/reviews.json" --sweep-id "$LANE" --returns-ref "$A/returns.json" --usage-ref "$A-attempts/child-usage-$RUN.json" --manifest-ref catalogs/sota-convergence/manifest-20261004.json --work-dir "$W"
# exit 2: child_usage.status incomplete; wrote stopped RESULT.json by recipe section 4.
rtk python3 scripts/saturation_ledger.py --append "$W/RESULT.json"
# exit 0: appended landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526.
rtk python3 scripts/saturation_ledger.py --check --base origin/main
# exit 0: 6 sweep records, chain intact, bindings verified.
rtk python3 $H/make_result.py --decision-record "$W/RESULT.json"
# exit 0: initial decision record generated; its same native renderer expanded retained outcomes and source-review stops for review.
TMPDIR="$W/tmp" rtk python3 scripts/validate.py
# exit 0 after registering changed content.
TMPDIR="$W/tmp" rtk python3 -m unittest tests.test_saturation_ledger tests.test_landscape_sweep_harness
# exit 0: Ran 323 tests in 64.919s; OK (skipped=4).
rtk git diff --check
# exit 0.

Retention and registration used host_receipts.register_file as prescribed in README step 11, including the complete smoke usage record as its own artifact. The unchanged full-run usage record retains the superseded attempt. Original Workflow and Codex job files remain in the private work directory.

Decision record

docs/decisions/2026-10-04-skills-landscape-sweep.md preserves all 47 vote-survivor occurrences and 90 refuted proposals, per-task overturn conditions, source-review stops, incomplete workers and critic findings. A stopped sweep neither counts nor resets saturation. The comparison that would overturn this retention decision requires complete native usage, delivered GPT-6 outputs, source reviews at every adjudicated pin and hash, and a completed record accepted by unchanged checks.

Host evidence

This PR adds research artifacts under evidence/artifacts/; it adds no files under evidence/hosts/ and makes no host platform-status claim.

Checklist

  • GitHub Actions changes: none.
  • Publication redactions use existing validator patterns; no credential value is included.
  • No paid hosting, subscription or billing surface added.
  • Original run files, peer files and worktrees preserved.
  • Commit split prepared: content first; manifests/evidence.json alone in the final registry commit.

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

Scout and others added 2 commits October 4, 2026 12:35
Scout @claude
docs(skills): retain stopped 2026-10-04 landscape sweep
452673d 
Retain 137 proposals and 47 vote-survivor occurrences across 13 lifecycle
tasks, with 33 source reviews and all source-review stops and lane failures.

Record incomplete native usage as a lower bound and append the stopped
sweep under the existing saturation recipe. Preserve the critic findings
and paired-trial overturn conditions in the dated decision record.

Validation: scripts/validate.py passed; 323 ledger and harness tests ran
successfully with four skips; append-only ledger check passed.

Co-Authored-By: GPT-6.1 Sol (OpenAI Codex) via the packaged SDK worker
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
Scout @claude
chore(evidence): register skills landscape sweep artifacts
a0a21a2 
Update manifests/evidence.json alone, after the content commit, with
retained research artifacts and refreshed hashes for the saturation ledger,
catalog README and dated skills decision record.

Co-Authored-By: GPT-6.1 Sol (OpenAI Codex) via the packaged SDK worker
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
@seathatflowsinourveins seathatflowsinourveins added the lane:foundation Foundation lane: Claude/Codex setup, hosts, memory, RAG, research, workers label Oct 4, 2026
@seathatflowsinourveins
seathatflowsinourveins marked this pull request as draft October 4, 2026 16:37
@seathatflowsinourveins

seathatflowsinourveins commented Oct 4, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Held as draft: the usage record will be re-derived after the harness fix that links usage-limit-killed attempts to their completed re-runs (superseded_by), so this run can be recorded as complete rather than stopped. Coordinated with session 5f, whose 2026-10-04 landscape sweep has the same gap.

@seathatflowsinourveins seathatflowsinourveins mentioned this pull request Oct 4, 2026
Merged
1 task
seathatflowsinourveins added a commit that referenced this pull request Oct 5, 2026
@seathatflowsinourveins
Private-content scan: catch encoded home paths; redact 11 committed l…
1de2a7f 
…ocations and re-pin their hashes (#697)

### Scope
- **Pattern:** `scripts/validate.py` PRIVATE_CONTENT gains an **encoded home path** pattern. It catches the dash-encoded paths that Claude Code uses for project and scratchpad directories: `-home-<name>-`, `-Users-<name>-` and the Windows `<drive>--Users-<name>-`. The existing `/home/<name>/` pattern missed them, so an evidence redaction could report zero remaining hits.
- **Redactions:** the new pattern found 11 committed locations, now redacted to `-home-<user>-` (the 2026-09-26 precedent):
  - six socraticode token-comparison run outputs;
  - five lines of the blind-catalog-convergence coverage review.

  These held another host's user name inside encoded paths.
- **Pins:** every hash that pinned a redacted file is updated: the gap-wave2 receipt raw-artifact hashes, the closure provenance and the convergence record frozen inputs.
- **Test literal:** a planted literal in `tests/test_token_e2e_grader.py` is now built at run time, so the source no longer matches. The tested input is unchanged.
- **Base:** origin/main. **Lane:** `lane:foundation`.

## SOTA sources
- Repository redaction precedent: `evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-20260926/returns.json` (`-home-<user>-`).
- Claude Code stores sessions under `~/.claude/projects/<encoded cwd>/`: https://code.claude.com/docs/en/settings
- Found by the Claude read of #692. The paired converter fix, which redacts this form at write time, is #696.

### Local commands, run at the head with TMPDIR outside /tmp
- `python3 scripts/validate.py`: passed. It includes the full tracked-tree scan, now 0 hits.
- `python3 scripts/validate_convergence.py --all-recorded --root . --json`: 0.
- 18 test modules, including test_validate, test_token_e2e_grader, test_sota_convergence and test_host_receipts: 1,320 tests OK, 5 skipped.
- Merge-tree landing check: LANDABLE.

### Review
- Built on the GPT lane (Sol, max), over two rounds.
- [ ] Claude cross-family read: requested.

🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code)
@seathatflowsinourveins seathatflowsinourveins mentioned this pull request Oct 6, 2026
Draft
3 of 6 tasks
@seathatflowsinourveins

seathatflowsinourveins commented Oct 7, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Closed with a record by the PR triage of 2026-10-07 (the command center's ruling, item review-ns2604-coop-20261007T023012Z (the command center's PR-triage ruling of 2026-10-07; proposal by github-ci-finalize, triage-20261007.json)). Not merged; the branch c5/skills-sweep-20261004 stays on origin at a0a21a2.

What it holds: docs/decisions/2026-10-04-skills-landscape-sweep.md; evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-skills-20261004-0526/ (37 files) and -attempts/ (3 files); catalogs/sota-convergence/manifest-20261004.json; catalogs/sota-convergence/README.md and catalogs/saturation/ledger.json (modified)

Superseded by: not superseded; unprioritized under the 2026-10-07 PR triage (confidence: high that nothing supersedes it: no skills sweep has landed on main since 2026-10-04; 4af7417 (#696) is sweep tooling; open #804 covers the roles, runtimes and vendor sweeps; open #817 lists only next sweep inputs (2a017e5:docs/decisions/2026-10-06-skills-hygiene-and-discovery.md:118))

Reopen trigger: The next skills landscape sweep (keyed by lifecycle task) needs prior survivors as its seed (this run's 137 proposals and 46 distinct survivor entries), or the 13 stopped source reviews are resumed. Reopen with gh pr reopen 692.

@seathatflowsinourveins
seathatflowsinourveins deleted the c5/skills-sweep-20261004 branch October 8, 2026 17:05
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Reviewers

No reviews

Assignees

No one assigned

Labels

lane:foundation Foundation lane: Claude/Codex setup, hosts, memory, RAG, research, workers

Projects

None yet

Milestone

No milestone

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant

@seathatflowsinourveins