Skip to content

Scrub owner quotations from the new-WSL records: paraphrase the canonical inputs, regenerate, and carry a dated paraphrase in the relay contract - #1161

Open
seathatflowsinourveins wants to merge 10 commits into
mainfrom
claude/cc-native-practice-relay-contract-scrub-20261015
Open

seathatflowsinourveins wants to merge 10 commits into
mainfrom
claude/cc-native-practice-relay-contract-scrub-20261015

Conversation

@seathatflowsinourveins

@seathatflowsinourveins seathatflowsinourveins commented Oct 15, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

Scope

Commit 1 (a3d53be4, formerly #1159): the canonical inputs and the generated files

What changes:

  • Canonical input: consensus.json had six owner quotation spans in five fields. Each becomes a dated, attributed paraphrase ("the owner, (paraphrased): …", they/them), dated from the record's own context. The agent-messaging amendment's decision, text, arms and experiment contract are unchanged.
  • Regenerated, never hand-edited:
    • assemble_manifest.py wrote the manifest (5 spans; --check exit 0), and render_tables.py --check exits 0.
    • build_new_wsl_handbook.py --write, then --check, regenerated the handbook (5 spans). That covers the read's four at base :851, :933 and :934, plus one more at the context-supply record.
    • The handbook receipt has new current outputs, a regenerations entry and a previous_outputs entry.
  • Regression: OwnerQuotationTests, in tests/test_new_wsl_handbook.py, uses invented prose only. It rejects any field that holds the owner's words, and any sentence that attributes a quoted span to the owner, in the canonical inputs and the generated handbook. Dated paraphrases and protocol or contract text pass. The existing owner-quote check in tests/test_new_wsl_definitive_defaults.py now uses the same rule.

Its temporary exemption (removed by the second commit): three owner-verbatim fields stay in consensus.json: the wave3, wave4 and wave5 authority.verbatim.

  • They are the relay contract, not copies. assemble_manifest.py requires them (OWNER_AUTHORITY_FIELDS), and check_owner_batch refuses a batch whose hash-bound relaying decision record lacks them.
  • They never reach the manifest or the handbook.
  • The regression exempts exactly those three paths, and only while the assembler requires the field. The exemption's text names the follow-up branch claude/cc-native-practice-relay-contract-scrub-20261015.
  • The command center ruled at 2026-10-15T12:19Z that this exemption is temporary. The follow-up comes immediately, at P1, as its own PR. It changes the relay contract to a dated paraphrase plus a hash binding to a private record, scrubs the three fields and the relaying decision records, and removes the exemption.

Commit 2 (c95453a1): the relay contract

The contract:

  • Fields: OWNER_AUTHORITY_FIELDS swaps verbatim for two fields:
    • paraphrase: dated, they/them, beginning "the owner, <date_utc> (paraphrased): ";
    • relay_record: the command center's private record that holds the exact words, by name and location only.
  • check_owner_batch keeps its sha256 binding to the committed relaying decision record and checks that the record states the paraphrase. Anything digest-like in relay_record is refused. A hash of the private record's bytes would break digest custody, and a short owner sentence is open to guess-and-check (the command center accepted this correction to its first wording). The exact words stay only in the private record; a local check outside CI can compare them.
  • Scrubbed:
    • the wave3, wave4 and wave5 authority fields;
    • the three decision records' block quotes;
    • a second owner quotation in the round-2 record (a 2026-10-03 answer).
  • Re-bound and regenerated: the three batches re-bind to the records' new sha256 values. The manifest and the handbook are regenerated through their builders, and the handbook receipt gains a regeneration entry.

Commit 3 (9371e2ad): repo-wide, from the command center's FULL read at c95453a

The CC ruled the split at 2026-10-15T13:25Z: this commit now, and burn-down PRs by area after it. Owner text is cited here by location only.

  • P1: the named records. Each change is a dated, they/them paraphrase with a supersession note beside it:
    • wave2-records.json owner_decisions[1], where verbatim becomes paraphrase;
    • claude-request.md (the opening paragraph and item 3);
    • docs/decisions/2026-10-04-repository-quality-rule.md;
    • repository-quality-promptfoo.json:7 and verdicts.json:7, where owner_words becomes owner_paraphrase;
    • verdicts.json's Q11 correction, its 1067 reason and its 2541 claim;
    • docs/decisions/2026-10-04-upstream-surface-watch.md:19-20;
    • the consensus record's claim that the rule record quotes the rule verbatim (C:1662), regenerated into definitive-manifest.json and the handbook.
  • Re-bound:
    • the consensus record's hashed records, copy-notes.json and integration-resolutions.json's measured_record;
    • the manifest and the handbook through their builders;
    • the handbook receipt, with a regeneration entry and a reason on every previous_outputs entry (P3, receipt.json:1308).
  • Left at their own dates: these historical captures keep the hashes of their dates:
    • starred-protected-20261011 and starred-convergence-20261010;
    • the 2026-10-08 g6c-b record;
    • the 2026-10-06 fix-wave receipts;
    • the 2026-10-07 gateway relabel.
  • P2: DIGEST_LIKE also refuses SRI and named-algorithm forms (sha512-…) and base64 runs of 20+ characters with a digit and both letter cases. A session name such as native-agent-stack-99 still passes.
  • P3:
    • the relay paraphrases are in they/them;
    • an interim owner decision and a relayed owner_decisions entry refuse an owner-words key at runtime;
    • a paraphrase that is only its prefix is refused.
  • Tree-wide scanner (tests/test_owner_quote_publication.py): it reads every tracked UTF-8 text file up to 8,000,000 bytes (MAX_BYTES). Two larger published JSON files are skipped; the GPT read at e21a7b6 checked both directly and found no hits.
    • What it flags: the owner, or the user (as these records call the owner), next to a speech word and a quote mark; a verbatim claim; an owner-words key; or a verbatim key in a file of owner decisions.
    • JSON: string values are read one at a time, so their delimiting quote marks do not count as quotation.
    • Ratchet: tests/fixtures/owner-quote-baseline.json holds per-file counts only: 290 hits in 169 files, the burn-down's input. An unlisted file must be clean, and a count changes only together with the baseline.
    • Fail-first (corrected by commit 4): with commit 3's detector, the run at c95453a flagged only the named records it could see. That detector missed the attribution without a speech word at claude-proposals.md:88 and the single-quoted owner words at verdicts.json:1070. Commit 4's detector catches both; its fail-first is below.
  • Detector scope: the approved split said owner-only. The detector also reads "the user" as a speaker, because three of the named records call the owner that. An owner-only detector missed them at base.

Commit 4 (e21a7b61): final, from the command center's adjudication at 9371e2a

This is the third round, scope-locked. Findings are cited by path:line only.

  • P1: evidence/artifacts/new-wsl-layer-consensus-20261002/claude-proposals.md:88 held an attributed owner sentence with no speech word.

    • It is now a dated they/them paraphrase.
    • The consensus record (consensus.json:30-32) and copy-notes.json re-bind to it.
    • The manifest and the handbook regenerate, and the handbook receipt gains its regeneration entry.
  • P2-1: a relay_record case isolates DIGEST_LIKE's base64 branch. It fails at c95453a (unexpectedly None) and passes now.

    • The local review's P2 at c95453a is fixed in the same place: a dated record name was refused as a digest. A hex run now counts as a digest only when it mixes digits and letters a-f, and a hex-prefix case covers that.
  • P2-2: the scanner also flags two more forms:

    • an attribution without a speech word (the owner, a colon, then a quote mark);
    • single-quoted owner words, opened by a typographic quote or by a straight single quote at the start of a word.

    Synthetic cases include plain apostrophes, which pass. verdicts.json:1070 no longer keeps single-quoted owner words. The ratchet baseline is regenerated: 477 hits in 242 files.

  • Fail-first (this commit's scanner and baseline, in scratch exports):

    • at 9371e2a, claude-proposals.md is unlisted and verdicts.json is above its count;
    • at c95453a, claude-request.md, claude-proposals.md, repository-quality-promptfoo.json and upstream-surface-watch.md are unlisted, and verdicts.json, wave2-records.json and the rule record are above their counts.
  • Results: 530 tests OK across the readers of these files; the generators' --check exit 0; validate rc 0.

Commit 5 (fd51f88d): final, from the command center's adjudication at e21a7b6

The command center ruled at 2026-10-15T15:49Z and completed the ruling at 16:20Z, with both families' reads at e21a7b6. Its scope is the 23 files this PR changes. Findings are cited by path:line only.

  • The command center's items:
    • evidence/artifacts/new-wsl-layer-consensus-20261002/wave2-records.json:147 and :274, and evidence/artifacts/final-architecture-round2-20261004/verdicts.json:220 and :1160, are dated paraphrases.
    • A possessive attribution class: the owner's or the user's, then a quoted phrase of two or more words. A string literal's closing delimiter and a quoted dated-paraphrase prefix are not quotations.
    • A positive case for a dated relay-record name (assemble_manifest.py:395-397; also the GPT read's follow-up 1).
  • A FULL read of the changed files:
    • wave2-records.json:103 held quoted owner wording and is now a dated paraphrase.
    • docs/decisions/2026-10-04-repository-quality-rule.md:7 and docs/decisions/2026-10-04-2604-e2e-fix-wave.md:51 now state the 2026-10-01 rule without quoting it.
    • Every other candidate line is a slot owner, code, the relay contract's own text, or an existing paraphrase.
  • The GPT read's P2s and the local review's P2s (tests/test_owner_quote_publication.py):
    • Each attribution is matched within one sentence. Markdown paragraphs, list items and block quotes are read as wrapped prose, and a hit is located at the line where its attribution starts (GPT blocker 2; local review :73-75).
    • A typographic apostrophe inside a word is not a quote mark (GPT blocker 3; local review :32).
    • A single closing quote before the speaker is an attribution (local review :35).
  • Re-bound:
    • consensus.json and integration-resolutions.json;
    • the manifest and the handbook, through their builders;
    • the handbook receipt, which gains this regeneration with its previous outputs and reason.
  • Ratchet baseline: regenerated at 469 hits in 229 files.
  • Fail-first:
    • The seven new detector cases all fail against e21a7b6's detector, and all hold now.
    • This commit's scanner and baseline over the e21a7b6 tree report verdicts.json and wave2-records.json above their counts.
    • The GPT reviewer's probe returns 3 of 3 OK. It failed 3 of 3 at e21a7b6.
  • Results: 616 tests OK (3 skipped) across the readers of these files; the three generators' --check exit 0; validate rc 0.

Supersession: the no-owner-quote rule of 2026-10-14 supersedes, for every published file, the round-2 resolution to quote the owner exactly (evidence/artifacts/final-architecture-round2-20261004/integration-resolutions.json:543, :630, :801). #1159 applied it to the generated files; this PR applies it to the relay contract and its decision records.

No history rewrite: earlier commits keep the old text, and this diff necessarily shows the removed lines.

Commit 6 (9bcb8133): blocker, from the GPT fix3r read at fd51f88

The GPT fix3r read at fd51f88 (2026-10-15, CHANGES_REQUESTED, one P1; the command center released this commit at 2026-10-15T20:45Z). Findings are cited by locator only.

  • evidence/artifacts/new-wsl-layer-consensus-20261002/wave2-records.json:274 (layers.custody.ruling.changes["12"]) kept earlier wording under a paraphrase label. It now states the owner's 2026-09-26 decision in other words, dated and attributed. Against the field at the PR's base, the attributed clause shares no run of two or more non-numeric words. The line count is unchanged.
  • Re-bound: consensus.json (4) and integration-resolutions.json (1); the manifest and the handbook through their builders; the handbook receipt gains this regeneration with its previous outputs and reason; manifests/evidence.json.
  • Fail-first: tests/test_new_wsl_handbook.py OwnerQuotationTests gains a check of the custody change's public text. It failed at fd51f88 (1 of 5) and holds now.
  • Results: 741 tests OK (3 skipped) across the readers of these files; the three generators' --check exit 0; validate rc 0; tests.test_pre_push_gate OK on the committed tree; the reviewer's fix3r detector probe returns 7 of 7 on fd51f88 and on this head.

Commit 7 (e0ff2abb): the adjudicated fold at 9bcb813

The command center's adjudication of #1161 at 9bcb813 (2026-10-15T21:59Z) followed its delta read (PASS) and the local Codex
re-review after the bounded rounds (three P2s, no P0/P1). The GPT fix4 delta read of fd51f88..9bcb813 is an ACK. Findings are
cited by locator only.

  • Fixed (claims false at the head): the detector's docstring (tests/test_owner_quote_publication.py:1, :7-8) now states its
    three bounds, each naming its Follow-up below. manifests/evidence.json is rewritten by scripts/evidence_manifest.py --write
    (:67), which restores 13 rows' \u escapes that the previous round's registration had written as raw UTF-8.
  • Results: 228 tests OK across the detector's and the handbook's readers; validate rc 0; tests.test_pre_push_gate 29 OK on the committed tree.

Commit 8 (768d9cc0): the adjudicated fold at e0ff2ab

The local Codex re-review at e0ff2ab (two P2s, no P0/P1) and the command center's adjudication of it (2026-10-15, addendum 01 to
its adjudication at 9bcb813). The GPT fix5 delta read of 9bcb813..e0ff2ab (coordination/cc-reads-20261005/fix5-pr1161/GPT-VERDICT-e0ff2abb3.md)
is an ACK. Findings are cited by locator only.

  • Fixed: commit 3 (9371e2a) had attached the relay-contract supersession reason to the historical ROW70 entry of the handbook
    receipt (previous_outputs[7]) as well as to its own entry ([20]). [7] is back to its bytes at the base, and the 19 entries
    the base holds are equal to it. test_each_supersession_reason_binds_only_the_entry_it_supersedes failed at e0ff2ab (entries 7
    and 20 shared a reason) and holds now.
  • Results: 229 tests OK across the detector's and the handbook's readers; validate rc 0; tests.test_pre_push_gate 29 OK on the committed tree.

Commit 9 (1fb477b5): the P1 fold at 768d9cc

The command center's ruling of 2026-10-16: the co-op's GPT count read at 768d9cc found four real instances of the shape
that escaped the block-quote introduction check (tests/test_owner_quote_publication.py:66), a P1; the other shape (:61)
has none on real content and stays a Follow-up. The positions came from the GPT locator read (coordination/cc-reads-20261005/loc1-pr1161/).
Findings are cited by locator only.

  • Two records carried directive wording under an owner introduction (docs/decisions/2026-09-25-top-rule-sota-sources.md:22,
    docs/decisions/2026-10-05-official-upstream-never-rebuild.md:17): each is now a dated paraphrase in other words.
  • Two named a role or a lane as an owner (docs/decisions/2026-10-03-currency-wave-w1.md:227, a retained repair report, and
    evidence/artifacts/delegated-decisions-20260928/coordination.md:13): each now names it as a lane, with the change dated.
  • Bindings: the starred-convergence captures record these files' sha256 at their own dates and stay unchanged;
    evidence/artifacts/engine-currency-20261013/context.json binds its file at a commit.
  • Detector: a block quote is attributed by the paragraph or list item above it, read whole, when that names the owner and
    ends with a colon, with or without a speech word, and blank quote lines are skipped. This also closes C3. Four synthetic cases
    failed at 768d9cc and hold now.
  • Baseline: one burn-down file goes from 2 to 3 (a block quote in a file already listed), and the detector's own fixtures
    from 30 to 35.
  • Results: the detector's module OK; the binding readers (tests.test_ecosystem_manifest, tests.test_starred_convergence)
    124 OK; validate rc 0; tests.test_pre_push_gate 29 OK on the committed tree.

Commit 10 (d4e3b6ac): the fold at 1fb477b, the ratchet on the merge with main

This answers GPT's fix7 micro and the count2 re-check at 1fb477b. Both give the same P2 blocker
(coordination/cc-reads-20261005/fix7-pr1161/ and count2-pr1161/, cited by name and locator only): the ratchet failed on
the merged tree (tests/test_owner_quote_publication.py:217 at 1fb477b; a file that main added since, returns.json:902).
The command center ruled ONE fold at 2026-10-16T05:13Z.

  • Rebase: once, onto main 30542e705. The range-diff shows nine = pairs, and git merge-tree rc 0. Commits 1 to 9
    are now 4cd31e8f, bbeb43a7, 81afff68, aa6e33a5, 7dde9061, ec766080, e556062c, ba0a7af8 and fd112c41.
    The headings above keep their earlier names. The earlier head is kept as a local backup ref.
  • Measured baseline: measured_counts() and write_baseline() rebuild tests/fixtures/owner-quote-baseline.json from
    scan() of the tree that lands, with no hand-set number
    (python3 tests/test_owner_quote_publication.py --write-baseline).
    • On the rebased tree it measures 230 files and 478 hits.
    • The one change is the file main added, at 3.
  • Merge test: test_the_ratchet_holds_on_the_merge_with_main runs the ratchet on git merge-tree --write-tree of the
    default branch and HEAD, extracted outside the checkout. It is skipped only where no default branch is fetched. With the
    earlier baseline it fails on this merge: the added file, 3 hits, unlisted.
  • Results:
    • the detector module, 5 tests OK;
    • the reviewer probe, 7/7 (counts only);
    • tests.test_new_wsl_handbook, 94 OK;
    • test_new_wsl_definitive_defaults, test_validate, test_evidence_manifest and test_registry_rows together,
      248 OK;
    • validate rc 0, and build_new_wsl_handbook --check rc 0;
    • tests.test_pre_push_gate 29 OK on the committed tree.

SOTA sources

Evidence-class table

Claim Evidence class Command / receipt
No owner verbatim field or relayed quotation remains in the canonical inputs, the relaying records or the generated files synthetic OwnerQuotationTests (fail-before at a3d53be)
The relay contract refuses the words coming back, an undated paraphrase, a digest in relay_record, and a record that does not state the paraphrase synthetic the assembler's negative controls
The outputs are the generators' own local_integration assemble_manifest.py --check, render_tables.py --check, build_new_wsl_handbook.py --check: exit 0

Local commands run

$ python3 -m unittest tests.test_new_wsl_handbook.OwnerQuotationTests tests.test_new_wsl_definitive_defaults.Manifest   # #1159 head a3d53be4 with these tests
FAIL: ...carry_no_owner_quotation (the three verbatim fields); FAIL x3: ...relaying_decision_records_carry_the_paraphrase_not_the_words; ERROR: ...refuses_an_owner_batch_outside_amendment_4
$ systemd-run --user --scope -p CPUWeight=idle --quiet -- python3 -m unittest tests.test_architecture_pin_source tests.test_harbor_currency_contracts tests.test_new_wsl_client_config tests.test_new_wsl_definitive_defaults tests.test_new_wsl_handbook tests.test_new_wsl_profile tests.test_starred_convergence tests.test_ecosystem_manifest
Ran 615 tests; OK (skipped=3)
$ python3 scripts/validate.py
rc 0; status passed
$ systemd-run --user --scope -p CPUWeight=idle --quiet -- python3 -m unittest tests.test_architecture_pin_source tests.test_codex_lane tests.test_harbor_currency_contracts tests.test_new_wsl_handbook tests.test_new_wsl_gateway_composition tests.test_research_entry tests.test_owner_quote_publication tests.test_new_wsl_definitive_defaults tests.test_new_wsl_client_config tests.test_new_wsl_profile   # fd51f88d
Ran 616 tests; OK (skipped=3)
$ python3 scripts/build_new_wsl_handbook.py --check; python3 .../assemble_manifest.py --check; python3 .../render_tables.py --check docs/decisions/2026-10-01-new-wsl-definitive-defaults.md
rc 0; rc 0; rc 0

Follow-ups

  • From GPT's fix7 micro and count2 at 1fb477b, by locator. These are scanner-class: the locators were relayed by
    script, and their intent is not restated here. Lines are as at 1fb477b; the scanner file's lines move at d4e3b6ac
    (:62 to :66, :139 to :143, :171 to :175).
    • fix7 P3s:
      • tests/test_owner_quote_publication.py:62 with this body's :233;
      • tests/test_owner_quote_publication.py:139 with this body's :184;
      • docs/harness-defaults.md:123, which is already in the burn-down front's follow-up 2 (live locators into
        line-moving files).
    • count2 P2, rated as a follow-up: tests/test_new_wsl_handbook.py:96 with tests/test_owner_quote_publication.py:171.
      Both pass on the merged tree (the handbook module, 94 OK). Its interaction with WSL install: add no-start mode and host port allocation #1180's generator change (still open)
      is checked when WSL install: add no-start mode and host port allocation #1180 lands.
    • count2 P3s:
      • docs/harness-defaults.md:123 with tests/test_new_wsl_handbook.py:1397;
      • tests/test_owner_quote_publication.py:139 with this body's :239.
  • First burn-down PR, at the front of the queue (the command center's ruling of 2026-10-15T16:20Z): these are the GPT read's items at e21a7b6 that fall outside the 23 files:
    • its P1 locators: evidence/artifacts/new-wsl-local-models-20261002/PREREGISTRATION-local-models.md:134-136, evidence/artifacts/prompt-audit-20260927/x9-round3/prereg-r3.draft.json:7 and prereg-r3.json:7. They are baselined at one hit each. They are preregistrations, so the burn-down states how a paraphrase keeps their hash bindings;
    • its follow-up 2, live locator references into line-moving files (for example docs/harness-defaults.md:123), and follow-up 3, the scanner's size bound;
    • the earlier queue: returns.json:5904, credential-inventory.json:213 and openhands-resolver-isolation.md:919.
    • From the command center's MICRO read at fd51f88:
      • P2: evidence/artifacts/new-wsl-layer-consensus-20261002/wave2-records.json:274: fixed in 9bcb813 (the GPT fix3r read made it its P1).
      • P3: the detector boundary at tests/test_owner_quote_publication.py:79 (below).
    • From the command center's adjudication at 9bcb813 (2026-10-15T21:59Z):
      • C1, the restructure: several attributions in one line or paragraph count once in the ratchet (rule 4: a recurring class is
        restructured, not given another pattern round);
      • C3: a block-quote introduction wrapped across lines: closed in 1fb477b; a CommonMark parser stays a PROPOSAL for
        introductions further from the quote;
      • the C2 bound: files over 8 MB are not scanned (the P2 was rejected: no failure on real content);
      • wave2-records.json:274 narrows the 2026-09-26 decision to paid search; set it against
        evidence/artifacts/final-architecture-round2-20261004/verdicts.json:1173 and :1186,
        catalogs/sota-convergence/manifest-20260929.json:4720 and evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-20260929/returns.json:17191
        and :17329.
    • From the local Codex re-review at e0ff2ab, P2-A (the command center's adjudication, addendum 01): the detector's JSON path
      keys on owner_decision tokens, so an attribution object without one is not counted. It is the detector-gap class sent to the
      restructure (rule 4); a scan of the tracked JSON finds no such object on real content (rule 5).
    • From the local Codex re-review at 768d9cc (pr1161-768d9cc0/review_output.json, cited by name): two more instances of the
      same detector-gap class, at tests/test_owner_quote_publication.py:61 and :66. They go to the detector's restructure with
      C1, C3 and P2-A (rule 4); no commit. The count-only check of real content for these two instances is run by the GPT family,
      which reads this class's review files.
    • From the GPT fix3r read at fd51f88 (coordination/cc-reads-20261005/fix3r-pr1161/GPT-VERDICT-fd51f88d2.md), three P3s:
      • the detector's disclosed sentence-boundary limitation;
      • an existing live locator, and the scanner's bounded coverage;
      • the pinned primary reference for the scanner corrections.
    • The final commit's wider detector reports 50 structural locators in 36 files outside the 23 that e21a7b6's detector did not. They are counted in the baseline and are not confirmed quotations; the classification pass decides each. The blueprints/us-equities/ one goes to the trading lane:
      • adoption/new-wsl/client-config-map.json:298,345,488
      • blueprints/convergence-practice/local-inference-latest-20260926/results/results.md:188
      • blueprints/us-equities/sim-paper-compare/README.md:522
      • catalogs/sota-convergence/manifest-20260926.json:16879,19225
      • docs/decisions/2026-09-22-github-automation-closure.md:385
      • docs/decisions/2026-09-23-max-effort-default.md:77
      • docs/decisions/2026-09-25-skills-trial-and-usage.md:3
      • docs/decisions/2026-09-25-workstation-sota-refresh.md:336
      • docs/decisions/2026-09-26-codex-worker-lane.md:89
      • docs/decisions/2026-09-28-community-sweep.md:219
      • docs/decisions/2026-09-28-delegated-decisions.md:107
      • docs/decisions/2026-09-28-openhands-resolver-isolation.md:157
      • docs/decisions/2026-10-01-definitive-sota-wsl-program.md:346
      • docs/decisions/2026-10-01-new-wsl-architecture-edition.md:175,182
      • docs/decisions/2026-10-01-new-wsl-definitive-defaults.md:344
      • docs/decisions/2026-10-03-compaction-window-ab-retirement.md:426
      • docs/decisions/2026-10-04-new-wsl-changelog-parity.md:44,57
      • docs/decisions/2026-10-05-macos-ci-advisory.md:13
      • docs/decisions/2026-10-10-landscape-scratch-ownership.md:115
      • evidence/artifacts/currency-wave-w1-20261003/judgments/move-hold-judges.json:33
      • evidence/artifacts/delegated-decisions-20260928/m3/packet.redacted.md:3
      • evidence/artifacts/final-architecture-round2-20261004/landscape-verdicts.json:24
      • evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-20260926/lanes.json:5774,6352,7129,10786,12120
      • evidence/artifacts/landscape-sweep-20260926/returns.json:3299,13223,16965,29959,30787
      • evidence/artifacts/mac-stage1-client-layer-20260927/README.md:254,557
      • evidence/artifacts/new-wsl-definitive-defaults-20261001/foundation-definitive.compact.json:387
      • evidence/artifacts/new-wsl-definitive-defaults-20261001/trading/trading-ownership.json:9
      • evidence/artifacts/new-wsl-install-plan-20261002/SOURCES.md:345
      • evidence/artifacts/omniroute-rebuild-20260930/PLAN.md:68
      • evidence/artifacts/omniroute-rebuild-20260930/receipt.json:112
      • evidence/artifacts/sdk-runtime-coverage-20260922/dispatch-frameworks.json:1678
      • evidence/artifacts/skills-trials-20261009/corpus/C10/case-optional-fields/SKILL.md:3
      • evidence/artifacts/sota-finalization-20260930/plan.json:57
      • manifests/stack.json:1940
      • tests/test_native_practice_retired_routes.py:389
      • tools/landing/README.md:124
  • A known detector boundary (tests/test_owner_quote_publication.py:79, burn-down FRONT): a sentence ends only before a capital letter, so a paraphrase followed by a sentence that opens with a quote mark is read as one sentence. It errs toward a hit, never a miss.
  • The baseline counts structural hits, not confirmed quotations. The burn-down starts with a classification pass, and trading files go to the trading lane.
  • The starred-convergence captures (catalogs/convergence-practice/sources/starred-protected-20261011.json, starred-convergence-20261010.json) and docs/decisions/2026-10-08-source-based-records-g6c-b.md record the three decision records' sha256 at their own dates. They are dated historical captures that their tests do not recompute, so they are left unchanged.

Checklist

  • No GitHub Actions changed.
  • No workflows changed.
  • No secrets are printed, logged or committed.
  • No new paid hosting, subscription or billing surface.
  • Peer-owned untracked files and worktrees were preserved.

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

@seathatflowsinourveins seathatflowsinourveins added the lane:foundation Foundation lane: Claude/Codex setup, hosts, memory, RAG, research, workers label Oct 15, 2026
@seathatflowsinourveins
seathatflowsinourveins changed the base branch from claude/cc-native-practice-owner-quote-scrub-20261015 to main October 15, 2026 13:01
@seathatflowsinourveins seathatflowsinourveins changed the title Relay contract: owner batches carry a dated paraphrase, never the owner's words (removes #1159's exemption) Scrub owner quotations from the new-WSL records: paraphrase the canonical inputs, regenerate, and carry a dated paraphrase in the relay contract Oct 15, 2026
seathatflowsinourveins added a commit that referenced this pull request Oct 15, 2026
…ecome dated paraphrases; a tree-wide scanner with a ratchet baseline

The command center's FULL read of #1161 at c95453a (CHANGES_REQUESTED) and its split ruling of 2026-10-15T13:25Z.

P1, the named records (each paraphrased with its date and they/them, with a supersession note beside the change):
- wave2-records.json owner_decisions[1]: verbatim -> paraphrase, plus publication_note;
- claude-request.md: the opening quotation and the quotation in item 3;
- docs/decisions/2026-10-04-repository-quality-rule.md: the block quote;
- new-wsl-fix-wave-20261004/repository-quality-promptfoo.json and final-architecture-round2-20261004/verdicts.json:
  owner_words -> owner_paraphrase plus publication_note; verdicts.json's correction (Q11), its 1067 reason and its
  2541 claim lose their quotations;
- docs/decisions/2026-10-04-upstream-surface-watch.md: the requirement's quotation;
- the consensus record's claim that the rule record quotes the rule verbatim, regenerated into the manifest and the
  handbook.
Re-bound: the consensus record's hashed records, copy-notes.json (sha256 and a replacement entry) and
integration-resolutions.json's measured_record; the manifest and the handbook through their builders; the handbook
receipt gains a regeneration entry, and every previous_outputs entry now has its reason (P3, receipt.json:1308). Dated
historical captures (starred-protected-20261011, starred-convergence-20261010, the 2026-10-08 g6c-b record, the
2026-10-06 fix-wave receipts, the 2026-10-07 gateway relabel) keep the hashes of their own dates.

P2: DIGEST_LIKE also refuses a named algorithm in any case (sha256, or sha512- as in SRI integrity) and a base64 run
(20+ characters with a digit and both letter cases), so a session name such as native-agent-stack-99 still passes.
P3: the relay paraphrases are in they/them; an interim owner decision and a relayed owner_decisions entry refuse an
owner-words key at runtime; a paraphrase that is only its prefix is refused.

Tree-wide scanner (tests/test_owner_quote_publication.py): every tracked text file, owner-attribution markers (the owner,
or the user as these records call the owner, near a speech word and a quote mark; a verbatim claim; an owner-words key; a
verbatim key in a file of owner decisions; a block quote introduced as owner speech), JSON string values read one by one
so their delimiters are not quotation, and dated-paraphrase block quotes skipped. tests/fixtures/owner-quote-baseline.json
holds per-file counts (names and counts only) for the burn-down PRs: an unlisted file must be clean and a count changes
only with the baseline.

Fail-before: the scanner at c95453a with this baseline lists the named records as unlisted files with hits, and the
assembler's new negative controls fail there. After: tests.test_owner_quote_publication, test_new_wsl_definitive_defaults,
test_new_wsl_handbook, test_research_entry and the other readers of these files OK; assemble_manifest --check,
render_tables --check and build_new_wsl_handbook --check exit 0; validate rc 0. No history rewrite.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
seathatflowsinourveins added a commit that referenced this pull request Oct 15, 2026
…oted owner words, a wider detector, dated record names

The command center's adjudication of #1161 at 9371e2a (third round, scope-locked). Findings cited by path:line.

- P1: evidence/artifacts/new-wsl-layer-consensus-20261002/claude-proposals.md:88 held an attributed owner sentence
  with no speech word. It is a dated they/them paraphrase; the consensus record (consensus.json:30-32) and copy-notes.json
  re-bind; the manifest and the handbook regenerate; the handbook receipt gains its regeneration entry.
- P2-1: tests/test_new_wsl_definitive_defaults.py gains a relay_record case that isolates DIGEST_LIKE's base64 branch;
  it fails at c95453a (unexpectedly None) and passes now. The local review's P2 at c95453a (a dated record name
  refused as a digest) is fixed in the same place: a hex run counts as a digest only when it mixes digits and letters
  a-f, with a hex-prefix case.
- P2-2: tests/test_owner_quote_publication.py also flags an attribution without a speech word (the owner, a colon,
  then a quote mark) and single-quoted owner words (a typographic or a word-opening straight single quote), with
  synthetic cases including plain apostrophes, which pass. evidence/artifacts/final-architecture-round2-20261004/
  verdicts.json:1070 keeps no single-quoted owner words. The ratchet baseline is regenerated: 477 hits in 242 files
  (names and counts only).

Fail-first with this commit's scanner and baseline: at 9371e2a, claude-proposals.md is unlisted and verdicts.json is
above its count; at c95453a, the named records of the earlier rounds are unlisted or above their counts. After: 530
tests OK across the readers of these files; the generators' --check exit 0; validate rc 0. No history rewrite.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
seathatflowsinourveins added a commit that referenced this pull request Oct 15, 2026
… sentence-bounded and wrapped detection

The command center's adjudication of #1161 at e21a7b6 (2026-10-15T15:49Z, completed 16:20Z with both families'
reads). Findings are cited by path:line only.

Records (dated they/them paraphrases; hashed bindings, the manifest, the handbook and its receipt follow):
- The command center's items: evidence/artifacts/new-wsl-layer-consensus-20261002/wave2-records.json:147 and :274,
  evidence/artifacts/final-architecture-round2-20261004/verdicts.json:220 and :1160.
- The FULL read of the changed files: wave2-records.json:103 held quoted owner wording and is now a dated paraphrase;
  docs/decisions/2026-10-04-repository-quality-rule.md:7 and docs/decisions/2026-10-04-2604-e2e-fix-wave.md:51 state the
  2026-10-01 rule without quoting it. consensus.json and integration-resolutions.json re-bind; the handbook receipt
  records this regeneration with its previous outputs and reason.

Detector (tests/test_owner_quote_publication.py):
- A possessive attribution class: the owner's or the user's, then a quoted phrase of two or more words. A string
  literal's closing delimiter and a quoted dated-paraphrase prefix are not quotations.
- GPT fix2 P2 (verdict blocker 2) and the local review's P2 at :73-75: each attribution is matched within one sentence,
  and Markdown paragraphs, list items and block quotes are read as wrapped prose; a hit is located at the line where the
  attribution starts.
- GPT fix2 P2 (blocker 3) and the local review's P2 at :32: a typographic apostrophe inside a word is not a quote mark.
- The local review's P2 at :35: a single closing quote before the speaker is an attribution.
- The ratchet baseline is regenerated: 469 hits in 229 files (names and counts only).

tests/test_new_wsl_definitive_defaults.py: a dated relay-record name assembles (assemble_manifest.py:395-397; GPT
fix2 follow-up 1).

Fail-first: the seven new detector cases all fail against e21a7b6's detector and hold now. This commit's scanner and
baseline over the e21a7b6 tree report verdicts.json and wave2-records.json above their counts. The GPT reviewer's
probe now returns 3 of 3 OK. After: 616 tests OK (3 skipped) across the readers of these files; the three generators'
--check exit 0; validate rc 0.

Outside the changed files, for the first burn-down PR: GPT fix2's P1 locators (three baselined preregistration
records) and its P3 follow-ups 2 and 3. No history rewrite.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
seathatflowsinourveins added a commit that referenced this pull request Oct 15, 2026
… of the custody ruling restated in other words

The GPT fix3r read of #1161 at fd51f88 (2026-10-15, CHANGES_REQUESTED, one P1) found that
evidence/artifacts/new-wsl-layer-consensus-20261002/wave2-records.json:274 (layers.custody.ruling.changes["12"])
kept the earlier wording under a paraphrase label; the command center's MICRO read at fd51f88 had listed the
same locator as a follow-up. Findings are cited by locator only.

- The field now states the owner's 2026-09-26 decision in other words, dated and attributed (they/them). Measured
  against the field at the PR's base, the attributed clause shares no run of two or more non-numeric words; the
  only shared run is the date. The line count is unchanged, so locators into the file hold.
- Bindings follow: consensus.json (4) and integration-resolutions.json (1) re-bind the record's sha256;
  assemble_manifest.py rewrites definitive-manifest.json; build_new_wsl_handbook.py --write regenerates the
  handbook, and its receipt records the regeneration with the previous outputs and the reason; manifests/evidence.json
  re-registers the changed files.
- tests/test_new_wsl_handbook.py OwnerQuotationTests: the custody change carries the new public paraphrase and no
  paraphrase label over earlier wording. It failed before the change (1 failure of 5) and holds now.

After: 741 tests OK (3 skipped) across the readers of these files; build_new_wsl_handbook.py --check,
assemble_manifest.py --check and render_tables.py --check exit 0; validate rc 0; the reviewer's fix3r detector
probe returns 7 of 7 on fd51f88 and on this tree. The read's three P3s go to the body's Follow-ups. No history
rewrite.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
seathatflowsinourveins added a commit that referenced this pull request Oct 15, 2026
… bounds, and evidence.json in the repository writer's form

The command center's adjudication of #1161 at 9bcb813 (2026-10-15T21:59Z, bound to the local Codex review's
review_output.json and to its Claude-family delta read, PASS) ruled two fix-now items under the scope-lock rule (claims
false at the head). The GPT fix4 delta read of fd51f88..9bcb813 is an ACK with no new finding. Findings are cited by
locator only.

- tests/test_owner_quote_publication.py:1 and :7-8 claimed every tracked text file is checked and every new quotation
  fails. The docstring now states the three bounds, each naming its Follow-up: a file over MAX_BYTES (8 MB) is not
  scanned; several attributions in one line or paragraph count once (C1, the detector's restructure); a block-quote
  introduction wrapped across lines is not detected (C3, a CommonMark parser as a PROPOSAL routed to the
  layer-resolution protocol).
- manifests/evidence.json: 13 rows outside W:274 had gone from \u escapes to raw UTF-8, because the registration helper
  wrote raw UTF-8 and that round ran only --check. The file is rewritten by scripts/evidence_manifest.py --write (:67),
  so the tree matches what the next write produces; the edited test file is re-registered.

No behaviour changes. C1, C3 and the C2 bound are Follow-ups in the body, with W:274's narrowing of the decision to
paid search against verdicts.json:1173 and :1186, catalogs/sota-convergence/manifest-20260929.json:4720 and
returns.json:17191 and :17329. After: 228 tests OK across the detector's and the handbook's readers; validate rc 0.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
seathatflowsinourveins added a commit that referenced this pull request Oct 16, 2026
…on per handbook-receipt history entry

The local Codex re-review of #1161 at e0ff2ab (two P2s) and the command center's adjudication of it (2026-10-15,
addendum 01 to its adjudication at 9bcb813); the GPT fix5 delta read of 9bcb813..e0ff2ab is an ACK. Findings are
cited by locator only.

- P2-B, fixed: commit 3 of this change (9371e2a) attached the relay-contract supersession reason to the historical ROW70
  entry of evidence/artifacts/new-wsl-handbook-20261001/receipt.json (previous_outputs[7]) as well as to its own entry
  ([20]), so two output pairs claimed one supersession. [7] is restored to its bytes at the base; the 19 entries the base
  holds are now equal to it. tests/test_new_wsl_handbook.py gains
  test_each_supersession_reason_binds_only_the_entry_it_supersedes: one reason per entry, and a reason that cites a date
  sits on an entry superseded no earlier. It failed at e0ff2ab (entries 7 and 20 share a reason) and holds now.
- P2-A, a Follow-up in the body: the detector's JSON path keys on owner_decision tokens, the class the adjudication sent
  to the restructure; a scan of the tracked JSON finds no such object on real content.

manifests/evidence.json re-registers the two edited files through scripts/evidence_manifest.py --write. After: 229
tests OK across the detector's and the handbook's readers; validate rc 0.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
seathatflowsinourveins added a commit that referenced this pull request Oct 16, 2026
…'s introduction check missed, and that check widened

The command center's ruling of 2026-10-16 on #1161 at 768d9cc: the co-op's GPT count read found four real instances of
shape 1, all escaping the block-quote introduction check (tests/test_owner_quote_publication.py:66), a P1; shape 2 (:61)
has none on real content and stays a Follow-up. The locators came from the GPT locator read loc1-pr1161 by position only.
Findings are cited by locator only.

- docs/decisions/2026-09-25-top-rule-sota-sources.md:22 and docs/decisions/2026-10-05-official-upstream-never-rebuild.md:17
  carried directive wording under an owner introduction. Both are now dated paraphrases in other words, the first
  citing the rule's own text by commit (AGENTS.md at 7bbb021, the commit that added the record).
- docs/decisions/2026-10-03-currency-wave-w1.md:227 (a retained repair report) and
  evidence/artifacts/delegated-decisions-20260928/coordination.md:13 named a role or a lane as an owner. They now name it
  as a lane; the report's header records the change and its date.
- Bindings: the starred-convergence captures record these files' sha256 at their own dates and stay unchanged (this
  change's convention); evidence/artifacts/engine-currency-20261013/context.json binds its file at commit 993cc89.
- Detector: a block quote is attributed by the paragraph or list item just above it, read whole, when that names the owner
  and ends with a colon, with or without a speech word, and a blank quote line is neither checked nor read as an
  introduction. This also closes C3 (an introduction wrapped across lines). test_a_block_quote_introduced_by_a_wrapped_
  sentence_is_found holds synthetic cases and controls only: four cases failed at 768d9cc and hold now.
- Baseline: docs/decisions/2026-10-03-compaction-window-ab-retirement.md goes from 2 to 3 (a block quote in a file already
  listed for the burn-down) and the detector's own synthetic fixtures from 30 to 35.

After: tests.test_owner_quote_publication OK; tests.test_ecosystem_manifest and tests.test_starred_convergence 124 OK;
validate rc 0.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
seathatflowsinourveins and others added 10 commits October 16, 2026 01:14
The GPT read of #1128 at bd3eecf (blocker 1, P1) found owner quotation
spans in the generated handbook's agent-messaging record. They came from
the layer-consensus record: assemble_manifest.py copies its rows and
amendments into the definitive manifest, and build_new_wsl_handbook.py
copies each manifest slot whole into the handbook, so the fix is in the
canonical input and the outputs are regenerated from it.

Layer-consensus record (consensus.json): six owner quotation spans in
five fields become dated, attributed paraphrases of the form: the owner,
<date> (paraphrased): ..., with the date taken from each record's own
context:
- authorization: verbatim -> paraphrase (2026-10-02)
- amend_rows[4] agent-messaging amendment: owner_verbatim ->
  owner_paraphrase (2026-10-02); its decision, text, arms and experiment
  contract are unchanged
- wave2 context-supply interim authority: verbatim -> paraphrase
  (2026-10-03)
- wave5 agent-messaging owner default: two spans in its reason
  (2026-10-02 and 2026-10-03) and one in its posture (2026-10-03); the
  public record of the answer stays linked by URL

Regenerated through the existing generators:
- assemble_manifest.py (write; --check exit 0): definitive-manifest.json
- render_tables.py --check: the 2026-10-01 record's tables stay current
- build_new_wsl_handbook.py --write, then --check exit 0:
  docs/new-wsl-handbook.json and docs/new-wsl-handbook.md
The handbook loses five owner spans: the four the read named (base lines
851, 933, 934) and one in the context-supply record's overturned interim
(base line 2383), which the read did not list.

Bindings: the handbook receipt's current outputs, a regenerations entry
and a previous_outputs entry; manifests/evidence.json re-registers the
eight changed hashed files; scripts/validate.py passes.

Regression: tests/test_new_wsl_handbook.py OwnerQuotationTests checks by
structure, with invented prose only: a field that holds the owner's
words, or a sentence that attributes a double-quoted span to the owner
or the user, fails; a dated paraphrase and separately defined protocol
or contract text pass. Against the base tree it fails with 13 locators
(consensus record 5, manifest 4, handbook 4); after the change all three
tests pass.

tests/test_new_wsl_definitive_defaults.py reads the paraphrase fields,
checks the consensus decision record with the same attribution rule, and
its wave-3 relay check no longer holds any of the owner's words (it
checks the record's block quote instead). assemble_manifest.py: comment
only, the interim authority now carries a dated paraphrase.

Not changed: the owner batches' authority.verbatim fields (wave3, wave4,
wave5) stay in consensus.json. assemble_manifest.py requires them
(OWNER_AUTHORITY_FIELDS, line 389) and refuses a batch whose hashed
relaying decision record does not contain them (check_owner_batch,
lines 542-544); they
never reach the manifest or the handbook. Changing that relay contract
needs its own ruling. The regression keeps exactly those paths, and only
while the assembler requires the field.

This supersedes, for the canonical inputs, the integration resolution
that chose exact quotation (evidence/artifacts/
final-architecture-round2-20261004/integration-resolutions.json:543,
:630, :801). No history rewrite: earlier commits keep the old text.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
…er's words; remove #1159's exemption

Command center ruling 2026-10-15T12:38Z (P1). The no-owner-quote rule of 2026-10-14 supersedes, for every
published file, the round-2 resolution to quote the owner exactly
(evidence/artifacts/final-architecture-round2-20261004/integration-resolutions.json:543, :630, :801).

- assemble_manifest.py: OWNER_AUTHORITY_FIELDS swaps verbatim for paraphrase and relay_record. check_owner_batch
  requires the paraphrase to begin "the owner, <date_utc> (paraphrased): " and the committed, hash-bound relaying
  decision record to state it; relay_record names the command center's private record by name and location only,
  and anything digest-like there is refused (a hash of private bytes would break digest custody, and a short owner
  sentence is open to guess-and-check).
- consensus.json: the wave3, wave4 and wave5 authority.verbatim fields become dated paraphrases plus relay_record;
  the three batches re-bind to their decision records' new sha256.
- The three relaying decision records (2026-10-04 token-full-stack-owner-default, 2604-e2e-fix-wave,
  final-architecture-round2) state the paraphrases; a second owner quotation in the round-2 record (a 2026-10-03
  answer) is paraphrased too.
- The definitive manifest and the handbook are regenerated through their builders; the handbook receipt gains a
  regeneration entry.
- tests: #1159's temporary exemption (relay_contract_paths) is removed; a verbatim field in an owner decision is
  always a finding; test_the_relaying_decision_records_carry_the_paraphrase_not_the_words; the assembler's negative
  controls cover a missing paraphrase, the words coming back as a verbatim key, an undated paraphrase, a digest in
  relay_record and a paraphrase the record does not state.

Fail-before (#1159 head a3d53be with these tests): the canonical-inputs check lists the three verbatim fields,
the records test fails on all three batches, and the assembler test errors. After: the 8 modules that read these
files, 615 tests OK (3 skips gated on tools); assemble_manifest --check, render_tables --check and
build_new_wsl_handbook --check exit 0; validate rc 0. No history rewrite: earlier commits keep the old text.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
…ecome dated paraphrases; a tree-wide scanner with a ratchet baseline

The command center's FULL read of #1161 at c95453a (CHANGES_REQUESTED) and its split ruling of 2026-10-15T13:25Z.

P1, the named records (each paraphrased with its date and they/them, with a supersession note beside the change):
- wave2-records.json owner_decisions[1]: verbatim -> paraphrase, plus publication_note;
- claude-request.md: the opening quotation and the quotation in item 3;
- docs/decisions/2026-10-04-repository-quality-rule.md: the block quote;
- new-wsl-fix-wave-20261004/repository-quality-promptfoo.json and final-architecture-round2-20261004/verdicts.json:
  owner_words -> owner_paraphrase plus publication_note; verdicts.json's correction (Q11), its 1067 reason and its
  2541 claim lose their quotations;
- docs/decisions/2026-10-04-upstream-surface-watch.md: the requirement's quotation;
- the consensus record's claim that the rule record quotes the rule verbatim, regenerated into the manifest and the
  handbook.
Re-bound: the consensus record's hashed records, copy-notes.json (sha256 and a replacement entry) and
integration-resolutions.json's measured_record; the manifest and the handbook through their builders; the handbook
receipt gains a regeneration entry, and every previous_outputs entry now has its reason (P3, receipt.json:1308). Dated
historical captures (starred-protected-20261011, starred-convergence-20261010, the 2026-10-08 g6c-b record, the
2026-10-06 fix-wave receipts, the 2026-10-07 gateway relabel) keep the hashes of their own dates.

P2: DIGEST_LIKE also refuses a named algorithm in any case (sha256, or sha512- as in SRI integrity) and a base64 run
(20+ characters with a digit and both letter cases), so a session name such as native-agent-stack-99 still passes.
P3: the relay paraphrases are in they/them; an interim owner decision and a relayed owner_decisions entry refuse an
owner-words key at runtime; a paraphrase that is only its prefix is refused.

Tree-wide scanner (tests/test_owner_quote_publication.py): every tracked text file, owner-attribution markers (the owner,
or the user as these records call the owner, near a speech word and a quote mark; a verbatim claim; an owner-words key; a
verbatim key in a file of owner decisions; a block quote introduced as owner speech), JSON string values read one by one
so their delimiters are not quotation, and dated-paraphrase block quotes skipped. tests/fixtures/owner-quote-baseline.json
holds per-file counts (names and counts only) for the burn-down PRs: an unlisted file must be clean and a count changes
only with the baseline.

Fail-before: the scanner at c95453a with this baseline lists the named records as unlisted files with hits, and the
assembler's new negative controls fail there. After: tests.test_owner_quote_publication, test_new_wsl_definitive_defaults,
test_new_wsl_handbook, test_research_entry and the other readers of these files OK; assemble_manifest --check,
render_tables --check and build_new_wsl_handbook --check exit 0; validate rc 0. No history rewrite.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
…oted owner words, a wider detector, dated record names

The command center's adjudication of #1161 at 9371e2a (third round, scope-locked). Findings cited by path:line.

- P1: evidence/artifacts/new-wsl-layer-consensus-20261002/claude-proposals.md:88 held an attributed owner sentence
  with no speech word. It is a dated they/them paraphrase; the consensus record (consensus.json:30-32) and copy-notes.json
  re-bind; the manifest and the handbook regenerate; the handbook receipt gains its regeneration entry.
- P2-1: tests/test_new_wsl_definitive_defaults.py gains a relay_record case that isolates DIGEST_LIKE's base64 branch;
  it fails at c95453a (unexpectedly None) and passes now. The local review's P2 at c95453a (a dated record name
  refused as a digest) is fixed in the same place: a hex run counts as a digest only when it mixes digits and letters
  a-f, with a hex-prefix case.
- P2-2: tests/test_owner_quote_publication.py also flags an attribution without a speech word (the owner, a colon,
  then a quote mark) and single-quoted owner words (a typographic or a word-opening straight single quote), with
  synthetic cases including plain apostrophes, which pass. evidence/artifacts/final-architecture-round2-20261004/
  verdicts.json:1070 keeps no single-quoted owner words. The ratchet baseline is regenerated: 477 hits in 242 files
  (names and counts only).

Fail-first with this commit's scanner and baseline: at 9371e2a, claude-proposals.md is unlisted and verdicts.json is
above its count; at c95453a, the named records of the earlier rounds are unlisted or above their counts. After: 530
tests OK across the readers of these files; the generators' --check exit 0; validate rc 0. No history rewrite.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
… sentence-bounded and wrapped detection

The command center's adjudication of #1161 at e21a7b6 (2026-10-15T15:49Z, completed 16:20Z with both families'
reads). Findings are cited by path:line only.

Records (dated they/them paraphrases; hashed bindings, the manifest, the handbook and its receipt follow):
- The command center's items: evidence/artifacts/new-wsl-layer-consensus-20261002/wave2-records.json:147 and :274,
  evidence/artifacts/final-architecture-round2-20261004/verdicts.json:220 and :1160.
- The FULL read of the changed files: wave2-records.json:103 held quoted owner wording and is now a dated paraphrase;
  docs/decisions/2026-10-04-repository-quality-rule.md:7 and docs/decisions/2026-10-04-2604-e2e-fix-wave.md:51 state the
  2026-10-01 rule without quoting it. consensus.json and integration-resolutions.json re-bind; the handbook receipt
  records this regeneration with its previous outputs and reason.

Detector (tests/test_owner_quote_publication.py):
- A possessive attribution class: the owner's or the user's, then a quoted phrase of two or more words. A string
  literal's closing delimiter and a quoted dated-paraphrase prefix are not quotations.
- GPT fix2 P2 (verdict blocker 2) and the local review's P2 at :73-75: each attribution is matched within one sentence,
  and Markdown paragraphs, list items and block quotes are read as wrapped prose; a hit is located at the line where the
  attribution starts.
- GPT fix2 P2 (blocker 3) and the local review's P2 at :32: a typographic apostrophe inside a word is not a quote mark.
- The local review's P2 at :35: a single closing quote before the speaker is an attribution.
- The ratchet baseline is regenerated: 469 hits in 229 files (names and counts only).

tests/test_new_wsl_definitive_defaults.py: a dated relay-record name assembles (assemble_manifest.py:395-397; GPT
fix2 follow-up 1).

Fail-first: the seven new detector cases all fail against e21a7b6's detector and hold now. This commit's scanner and
baseline over the e21a7b6 tree report verdicts.json and wave2-records.json above their counts. The GPT reviewer's
probe now returns 3 of 3 OK. After: 616 tests OK (3 skipped) across the readers of these files; the three generators'
--check exit 0; validate rc 0.

Outside the changed files, for the first burn-down PR: GPT fix2's P1 locators (three baselined preregistration
records) and its P3 follow-ups 2 and 3. No history rewrite.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
… of the custody ruling restated in other words

The GPT fix3r read of #1161 at fd51f88 (2026-10-15, CHANGES_REQUESTED, one P1) found that
evidence/artifacts/new-wsl-layer-consensus-20261002/wave2-records.json:274 (layers.custody.ruling.changes["12"])
kept the earlier wording under a paraphrase label; the command center's MICRO read at fd51f88 had listed the
same locator as a follow-up. Findings are cited by locator only.

- The field now states the owner's 2026-09-26 decision in other words, dated and attributed (they/them). Measured
  against the field at the PR's base, the attributed clause shares no run of two or more non-numeric words; the
  only shared run is the date. The line count is unchanged, so locators into the file hold.
- Bindings follow: consensus.json (4) and integration-resolutions.json (1) re-bind the record's sha256;
  assemble_manifest.py rewrites definitive-manifest.json; build_new_wsl_handbook.py --write regenerates the
  handbook, and its receipt records the regeneration with the previous outputs and the reason; manifests/evidence.json
  re-registers the changed files.
- tests/test_new_wsl_handbook.py OwnerQuotationTests: the custody change carries the new public paraphrase and no
  paraphrase label over earlier wording. It failed before the change (1 failure of 5) and holds now.

After: 741 tests OK (3 skipped) across the readers of these files; build_new_wsl_handbook.py --check,
assemble_manifest.py --check and render_tables.py --check exit 0; validate rc 0; the reviewer's fix3r detector
probe returns 7 of 7 on fd51f88 and on this tree. The read's three P3s go to the body's Follow-ups. No history
rewrite.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
… bounds, and evidence.json in the repository writer's form

The command center's adjudication of #1161 at 9bcb813 (2026-10-15T21:59Z, bound to the local Codex review's
review_output.json and to its Claude-family delta read, PASS) ruled two fix-now items under the scope-lock rule (claims
false at the head). The GPT fix4 delta read of fd51f88..9bcb813 is an ACK with no new finding. Findings are cited by
locator only.

- tests/test_owner_quote_publication.py:1 and :7-8 claimed every tracked text file is checked and every new quotation
  fails. The docstring now states the three bounds, each naming its Follow-up: a file over MAX_BYTES (8 MB) is not
  scanned; several attributions in one line or paragraph count once (C1, the detector's restructure); a block-quote
  introduction wrapped across lines is not detected (C3, a CommonMark parser as a PROPOSAL routed to the
  layer-resolution protocol).
- manifests/evidence.json: 13 rows outside W:274 had gone from \u escapes to raw UTF-8, because the registration helper
  wrote raw UTF-8 and that round ran only --check. The file is rewritten by scripts/evidence_manifest.py --write (:67),
  so the tree matches what the next write produces; the edited test file is re-registered.

No behaviour changes. C1, C3 and the C2 bound are Follow-ups in the body, with W:274's narrowing of the decision to
paid search against verdicts.json:1173 and :1186, catalogs/sota-convergence/manifest-20260929.json:4720 and
returns.json:17191 and :17329. After: 228 tests OK across the detector's and the handbook's readers; validate rc 0.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
…on per handbook-receipt history entry

The local Codex re-review of #1161 at e0ff2ab (two P2s) and the command center's adjudication of it (2026-10-15,
addendum 01 to its adjudication at 9bcb813); the GPT fix5 delta read of 9bcb813..e0ff2ab is an ACK. Findings are
cited by locator only.

- P2-B, fixed: commit 3 of this change (9371e2a) attached the relay-contract supersession reason to the historical ROW70
  entry of evidence/artifacts/new-wsl-handbook-20261001/receipt.json (previous_outputs[7]) as well as to its own entry
  ([20]), so two output pairs claimed one supersession. [7] is restored to its bytes at the base; the 19 entries the base
  holds are now equal to it. tests/test_new_wsl_handbook.py gains
  test_each_supersession_reason_binds_only_the_entry_it_supersedes: one reason per entry, and a reason that cites a date
  sits on an entry superseded no earlier. It failed at e0ff2ab (entries 7 and 20 share a reason) and holds now.
- P2-A, a Follow-up in the body: the detector's JSON path keys on owner_decision tokens, the class the adjudication sent
  to the restructure; a scan of the tracked JSON finds no such object on real content.

manifests/evidence.json re-registers the two edited files through scripts/evidence_manifest.py --write. After: 229
tests OK across the detector's and the handbook's readers; validate rc 0.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
…'s introduction check missed, and that check widened

The command center's ruling of 2026-10-16 on #1161 at 768d9cc: the co-op's GPT count read found four real instances of
shape 1, all escaping the block-quote introduction check (tests/test_owner_quote_publication.py:66), a P1; shape 2 (:61)
has none on real content and stays a Follow-up. The locators came from the GPT locator read loc1-pr1161 by position only.
Findings are cited by locator only.

- docs/decisions/2026-09-25-top-rule-sota-sources.md:22 and docs/decisions/2026-10-05-official-upstream-never-rebuild.md:17
  carried directive wording under an owner introduction. Both are now dated paraphrases in other words, the first
  citing the rule's own text by commit (AGENTS.md at 7bbb021, the commit that added the record).
- docs/decisions/2026-10-03-currency-wave-w1.md:227 (a retained repair report) and
  evidence/artifacts/delegated-decisions-20260928/coordination.md:13 named a role or a lane as an owner. They now name it
  as a lane; the report's header records the change and its date.
- Bindings: the starred-convergence captures record these files' sha256 at their own dates and stay unchanged (this
  change's convention); evidence/artifacts/engine-currency-20261013/context.json binds its file at commit 993cc89.
- Detector: a block quote is attributed by the paragraph or list item just above it, read whole, when that names the owner
  and ends with a colon, with or without a speech word, and a blank quote line is neither checked nor read as an
  introduction. This also closes C3 (an introduction wrapped across lines). test_a_block_quote_introduced_by_a_wrapped_
  sentence_is_found holds synthetic cases and controls only: four cases failed at 768d9cc and hold now.
- Baseline: docs/decisions/2026-10-03-compaction-window-ab-retirement.md goes from 2 to 3 (a block quote in a file already
  listed for the burn-down) and the detector's own synthetic fixtures from 30 to 35.

After: tests.test_owner_quote_publication OK; tests.test_ecosystem_manifest and tests.test_starred_convergence 124 OK;
validate rc 0.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
…h main, and its baseline is measured

GPT's fix7 micro at 1fb477b (cc-reads-20261005/fix7-pr1161/GPT-VERDICT-1fb477b50.md) and the count2 re-check
(count2-pr1161/GPT-VERDICT-1fb477b50.md) give the same P2 blocker: the ratchet failed on the merged tree
(tests/test_owner_quote_publication.py:217; a file main added since, returns.json:902). The command center ruled ONE
fold at 2026-10-16T05:13Z.

- The branch is rebased once onto main 30542e7. The range-diff shows nine `=` pairs, and git merge-tree rc 0.
- measured_counts() and write_baseline() rebuild tests/fixtures/owner-quote-baseline.json from scan() of the tree that
  lands, with no hand-set number (`python3 tests/test_owner_quote_publication.py --write-baseline`). On the rebased
  tree it measures 230 files and 478 hits. The one change is a file main added, with 3 hits.
- test_the_ratchet_holds_on_the_merge_with_main runs the ratchet on `git merge-tree --write-tree` of the default branch
  and HEAD, extracted outside the checkout. It is skipped only where no default branch is fetched.

Fail-first: the new test fails with the earlier baseline on this merge (the added file, 3 != absent). After the fold,
the module passes 5 tests, the reviewer probe 7/7 (counts only), tests.test_new_wsl_handbook 94, and
test_new_wsl_definitive_defaults, test_validate, test_evidence_manifest and test_registry_rows 248. validate rc 0;
build_new_wsl_handbook --check rc 0.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
@seathatflowsinourveins
seathatflowsinourveins force-pushed the claude/cc-native-practice-relay-contract-scrub-20261015 branch from 1fb477b to d4e3b6a Compare October 16, 2026 05:53

This branch has not been deployed

No deployments
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

lane:foundation Foundation lane: Claude/Codex setup, hosts, memory, RAG, research, workers

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant