Some regression with union of classes in TS4.2

Bug Report

I apologize for the name of issue, I was not able to correctly formulate the problem.

🔎 Search Terms

4.2, regression, class, extends, union

🕗 Version & Regression Information

This changed between versions 4.1.5 and 4.2.2
(if we take dev then between versions 4.2.0-dev.20210209 and 4.2.0-insiders.20210210)

⏯ Playground Link

Playground link with relevant code

💻 Code

I apologize again, I have shortened the example as much as I can.

/** some declared types */

declare abstract class GlobalController<P, S, SS> {
    isLocal: false;
    abstract getProps(storeState: SS, props: P, state: S): void;
}

declare abstract class LocalController<P, S> {
    isLocal: true;
    abstract getProps(props: P, state: S): void;
}

interface GlobalControllerClass<P, S, SS> {
    new(): GlobalController<P, S, SS>;
}

interface LocalControllerClass<P, S> {
    new(): LocalController<P, S>;
}

type ControllerClass<P, S, SS = {}> = GlobalControllerClass<P, S, SS> | LocalControllerClass<P, S>;

declare const createEnhancer: <P, S, SS = void>(Wrapper: ControllerClass<P, S, SS>) => any;


/** usage */

type ControllerState = {
    bar: any
};

type ControllerProps = {
    baz: any
};


/** fall since TS4.2 (4.1- works fine) */

class FailWithTS42 extends LocalController<ControllerProps, ControllerState> {
    getProps(props: ControllerProps, state: ControllerState) {}
}

createEnhancer(FailWithTS42);

in the sandbox above the same code plus some workarounds that might suggest something

🙁 Actual behavior

createEnhancer(FailWithTS42) in the last line shows the error:

Argument of type 'typeof FailWithTS42' is not assignable to parameter of type 'ControllerClass<ControllerState, ControllerState, ControllerProps>'.
  Type 'typeof FailWithTS42' is not assignable to type 'GlobalControllerClass<ControllerState, ControllerState, ControllerProps>'.
    Construct signature return types 'FailWithTS42' and 'GlobalController<ControllerState, ControllerState, ControllerProps>' are incompatible.
      The types of 'isLocal' are incompatible between these types.
        Type 'true' is not assignable to type 'false'.

🙂 Expected behavior

I can call createEnhancer with class FailWithTS42

Here's a reduced version

declare class LocalController<T, U> {
    isLocal: true;
    getProps(a: T, b: U): void;
}
declare class GlobalController<T, U> {
    isLocal: false;
    // N.B.: Parameter type order is reversed
    getProps(a: U, b: T): void;
}

class FailWithTS42 extends LocalController<{ foo: any }, { bar: any }> { }
const p = new FailWithTS42();

// Fails
declare function createEnhancer1<T, U>(Wrapper: GlobalController<T, U> | LocalController<T, U>): void;
createEnhancer1(p);
// OK; this is the desired inference
createEnhancer1<{ foo: any }, { bar: any }>(p);


// OK
declare function createEnhancer2<T, U>(Wrapper: LocalController<T, U>): void;
createEnhancer2(p);

The TL:DR is that we're getting tripped up here and collecting inferences from GlobalController from the a and b parameters. What should be happening is that we'd detect that LocalController & GlobalController is never so there shouldn't be any inference candidates collected from the latter type.

I don't know why this ever worked.

Anders Hejlsberg (@ahejlsberg)

cc Anders Hejlsberg (@ahejlsberg) for possible interest

Wesley Wigham (@weswigham)

Wesley Wigham (@weswigham) hi! thank you for your work!

i tried version npm:@typescript-deploys/[email protected].

The short version of the code from Ryan Cavanaugh (@RyanCavanaugh) now really works without errors. But the original code still doesn't work. I tried to shorten my code a little more so that the error persists:

declare class GlobalController<P, S> {
    isLocal: false;
    getProps(state: S, props: P): void;
}

declare class LocalController<P, S> {
    isLocal: true;
    getProps(props: P, state: S): void;
}

interface GlobalControllerClass<P, S> {
    new(): GlobalController<P, S>;
}

interface LocalControllerClass<P, S> {
    new(): LocalController<P, S>;
}

declare function createEnhancer<P, S>(Wrapper: GlobalControllerClass<P, S> | LocalControllerClass<P, S>): void;

class FailWithTS42 extends LocalController<{ baz: any }, { bar: any }> {}

createEnhancer(FailWithTS42); // fall since TS4.2 (4.1- works fine)

TS2345: Argument of type 'typeof FailWithTS42' is not assignable to parameter of type 'GlobalControllerClass<{ bar: any; }, { baz: any; }> | LocalControllerClass<{ bar: any; }, { baz: any; }>'.
  Type 'typeof FailWithTS42' is not assignable to type 'GlobalControllerClass<{ bar: any; }, { baz: any; }>'.
    Construct signature return types 'FailWithTS42' and 'GlobalController<{ bar: any; }, { baz: any; }>' are incompatible.
      The types of 'isLocal' are incompatible between these types.
        Type 'true' is not assignable to type 'false'.

Mateusz Burzyński (@Andarist)

Looking at this again, something is just going wrong in a bad way, I don't think this is some "subtle" thing without a direct fix, unless I'm really missing something. Trimming the repro down more and poking at the adjacent cases which do work:

declare function callme<T, U>(Wrapper: NotLocal<T, U> | Local<T, U>): void;

interface Local<T, U> {
    isLocal: true;
    a: T;
    b: U;
}
interface NotLocal<T, U> {
    isLocal: false;
    // N.B.: Order of types is reversed here
    a: U;
    b: T;
}

// No example should error.

// Works
declare const direct_decl: Local<string, number>;
callme(direct_decl);

// Works
type LocalStringNumberAlias = Local<string, number>;
declare const type_alias: LocalStringNumberAlias;
callme(type_alias);

// Fails
interface LocalStringNumberInterface extends Local<string, number> { }
declare const interface_decl: LocalStringNumberInterface;
callme(interface_decl);

That said we haven't seen other reports of this so I think this needs to be deprioritized in terms of scheduled work.

Mateusz Burzyński (@Andarist) this seems very much up your alley in terms of investigations?

Me last night, going to bed right after posting that comment

I take back 90% of it; the problem is obviously that we're doing X<T> | Y <-> X<U> candidate collection via type identity in the first two cases (which works fine), but structural inference in the last case (which doesn't check discriminants and thus fails). This is indeed going to be difficult.

is there a specific reason why structural inference doesn't check discriminates or why this worked pre-4.2? 🤔

I suspect this only worked by accident in 4.1-.

As for why to not check for discriminants - 40% perf hit to material-ui (I remember this one)

#43853 (comment)

Navigation Menu

Repository navigation

Some regression with union of classes in TS4.2 #43753

Bug Report

🔎 Search Terms

🕗 Version & Regression Information

⏯ Playground Link

💻 Code

🙁 Actual behavior

🙂 Expected behavior

9 remaining items

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Type

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

Some regression with union of classes in TS4.2 #43753

Description

Bug Report

🔎 Search Terms

🕗 Version & Regression Information

⏯ Playground Link

💻 Code

🙁 Actual behavior

🙂 Expected behavior

Activity

RyanCavanaugh commented on Apr 21, 2021

RyanCavanaugh commented on Apr 21, 2021

dartess commented on Jul 2, 2021

9 remaining items

RyanCavanaugh commented on Feb 15, 2023

Andarist commented on Feb 15, 2023

RyanCavanaugh commented on Feb 15, 2023

Andarist commented on Feb 15, 2023

RyanCavanaugh commented on Feb 15, 2023

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Type

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

Issue actions