Quality Gatekeeper Review

Verdict: PASS
Risk: Medium
Lane: quality
Checks:

• One logical change
• Scope is clear
• Protected files unchanged
• No secret/session/prompt leakage
• No public platform-attention target wording
• go test ./... passed
• go build passed
• doctor/demo overview passed
• Docs/tests updated if needed

Notes:

• GitHub mergeStateStatus observed as UNKNOWN after merge; PR state is MERGED with merge commit f354b39967120e8410c9de8f0826c2c6e750d07c.
• GitHub CI Test and build: SUCCESS.
• Changed files: report/engine/TUI/i18n internals, docs/ci-integration.md, and CI report scripts. No protected release/package files changed.
• Risk is Medium because this introduces conservative tool authority classification and JSON report fields, but remains local-only and deterministic.

Validated commands:

• go test ./...
• go build -o /tmp/agenttrace-review-pr-205 ./cmd/agenttrace
• /tmp/agenttrace-review-pr-205 --doctor || true
• /tmp/agenttrace-review-pr-205 --demo --overview -f json
• AGENTTRACE_BIN=/tmp/agenttrace-review-pr-205 AGENTTRACE_CI_OUT=/tmp/agenttrace-review-pr-205-ci scripts/ci/check-output-contract.sh
• AGENTTRACE_BIN=/tmp/agenttrace-review-pr-205 AGENTTRACE_CI_OUT=/tmp/agenttrace-review-pr-205-ci scripts/ci/check-deterministic-output.sh
• AGENTTRACE_BIN=/tmp/agenttrace-review-pr-205 AGENTTRACE_CI_OUT=/tmp/agenttrace-review-pr-205-ci scripts/ci/check-report-semantics.sh
• AGENTTRACE_BIN=/tmp/agenttrace-review-pr-205 AGENTTRACE_CI_OUT=/tmp/agenttrace-review-pr-205-ci scripts/ci/check-docs-commands.sh
• AGENTTRACE_BIN=/tmp/agenttrace-review-pr-205 AGENTTRACE_CI_OUT=/tmp/agenttrace-review-pr-205-ci scripts/ci/check-release-surfaces.sh
• AGENTTRACE_BIN=/tmp/agenttrace-review-pr-205 AGENTTRACE_CI_OUT=/tmp/agenttrace-review-pr-205-ci scripts/ci/check-pages-artifact.sh site
• /tmp/agenttrace-review-pr-205 --demo --overview -f json --baseline /tmp/agenttrace-review-pr-205-ci/agenttrace-demo.json

Decision: PASS. The implementation satisfies #201: reports expose authority category counts and highest category, unknown authority remains explicit/conservative, fixture behavior is deterministic, and CI report checks can compare new authority categories. Final label action: status/auto-merged.

Event: Validation
Actor: Product
Scope: PR #205 post-merge
State change: status/ready-for-review -> status/auto-merged
Evidence: Revalidated master at merge commit f354b39 after #205 landed. Passed go test ./..., go build -o /tmp/agenttrace-product-check ./cmd/agenttrace, output-contract, deterministic-output, report-semantics, docs-commands, release-surfaces, Pages artifact, --doctor, and demo JSON baseline self-compare.
Next owner: Product / Growth

Decision: Post-merge validation PASS. #201 is closed with status/auto-merged. The next release-train review in #179 should include #205 as the authority-classification companion to #203 baseline comparison.

Event: Validation correction
Actor: Product
Scope: PR #205 post-merge
State change: no label change; keep status/auto-merged
Evidence: The previous Product validation comment used an outdated local assertion name while checking the JSON manually. The actual merged JSON contract exposes authority data as summary.tool_authority and surfaces.authority_categories, not authority_summary.
Next owner: Product / Growth

Corrected check: reran demo JSON baseline self-compare on master at f354b39 and verified summary.tool_authority, surfaces.authority_categories, baseline_comparison, and incident_timelines are present. The corrected output showed authority categories [read_only_files, test_or_build], highest authority test_or_build, baseline_comparison.new_high_authority_tool_use=[], and 3 incident timelines.

Decision: Post-merge validation remains PASS with the corrected field names. The earlier comment's command list is valid for build/tests/CI scripts, but this comment supersedes the field-name detail.