Repository navigation
fix: Break event timestamp ties by created timestamp in the Dask offline store - #6952
Merged
shuchu merged 2 commits intoNov 10, 2026
Merged
Conversation
…ine store The Dask offline store sorted by created_timestamp_column and then by timestamp_field in a second pass, relying on that second sort to keep the created timestamp order for rows sharing an event timestamp. sort_values is not stable, so with enough rows the older row could end up last and win the keep="last" deduplication, both in historical retrieval and in pull_latest_from_table_or_query. Sort once by [timestamp_field, created_timestamp_column] instead. Signed-off-by: LuisFigueroaG <[email protected]>
|
Codecov Report❌ Patch coverage is
Additional details and impacted files@@ Coverage Diff @@
## master #6952 +/- ##
=======================================
Coverage 49.04% 49.05%
=======================================
Files 433 433
Lines 54308 54304 -4
Branches 7910 7908 -2
=======================================
+ Hits 26637 26640 +3
+ Misses 25790 25785 -5
+ Partials 1881 1879 -2
... and 1 file with indirect coverage changes Continue to review full report in Codecov by Harness.
🚀 New features to boost your workflow:
|
franciscojavierarceo
pushed a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Nov 10, 2026
# [0.68.0](v0.67.0...v0.68.0) (2026-11-10) ### Bug Fixes * add watch verb on clusterroles and clusterrolebindings for feast-operator ([#7062](#7062)) ([b6bdda4](b6bdda4)) * Apply on demand feature views in SparkRetrievalJob.to_spark_df() ([#6993](#6993)) ([f416309](f416309)) * Break event timestamp ties by created timestamp in Milvus write batches ([#7084](#7084)) ([bbaca76](bbaca76)) * Break event timestamp ties by created timestamp in the Dask offline store ([#6952](#6952)) ([eb93b08](eb93b08)) * Build the Go feature server image in two stages ([1e5e90c](1e5e90c)), closes [#7060](#7060) * Fall back to the serialized body when UDF source misses globals ([#6816](#6816)) ([f61079f](f61079f)) * Install patched libbrotli1 to address DSA-6582-1 ([#7096](#7096)) ([d458393](d458393)) * Keep description, tags and nested types of ODFV schema fields ([8ef6e75](8ef6e75)) * Keep entity columns out of StreamFeatureView proto features ([#7033](#7033)) ([d520584](d520584)) * Keep the metrics server running when a Gunicorn worker exits ([#7012](#7012)) ([68c5d54](68c5d54)), closes [#7011](#7011) * Key registry proto caches on the proto, not its id() ([#7085](#7085)) ([147adad](147adad)) * Log ODFV materialization skips instead of printing them ([#7117](#7117)) ([8fdcee7](8fdcee7)) * Pin build dependencies of source builds to the CI lock ([#7104](#7104)) ([dec2f24](dec2f24)) * Populate spec.project in registry REST feature view responses (#… ([#7037](#7037)) ([e304a84](e304a84)) * Preserve colliding source timestamps in Dask retrieval ([#7071](#7071)) ([1396c88](1396c88)) * Preserve Dask historical requests without eligible features ([#7000](#7000)) ([fff09f7](fff09f7)) * Read None elements of UUID and Decimal lists as None ([#7039](#7039)) ([03f30fe](03f30fe)) * Retire the support of Python3.10 ([#7101](#7101)) ([a56766e](a56766e)), closes [#7104](#7104) [#7089](#7089) [#7106](#7106) [#7105](#7105) * Serialize UUID and TimeUuid entity keys ([#7032](#7032)) ([0c845a1](0c845a1)) * Stop the Ray engine from hiding materialization errors ([#7026](#7026)) ([7903e2e](7903e2e)), closes [#7024](#7024) * **ui:** stop treating the monitoring baseline as the latest window ([#7056](#7056)) ([0f01802](0f01802)), closes [#7054](#7054) * Use date-only bounds for partition filters built from string timestamps ([#7116](#7116)) ([b1f2168](b1f2168)) * Validate entity column types in feast dbt import ([#7067](#7067)) ([abca80c](abca80c)), closes [#5876](#5876) * Warm up the whole DynamoDB connection pool ([#6985](#6985)) ([8ce548c](8ce548c)) ### Features * Add --gc-freeze option to feast serve ([#7089](#7089)) ([aad0c15](aad0c15)) * Add native complex types and scalar index tags to the Milvus online store ([#7120](#7120)) ([f7068d6](f7068d6)) * Add num_partitions and partition_key_isolation to the Milvus online store ([#7083](#7083)) ([68de84e](68de84e)), closes [#6940](#6940) * Add Pinecone online store integration ([#6585](#6585)) ([7a84f2a](7a84f2a)) * Add PolarisSource and PolarisProvider for Apache Polaris ([#7006](#7006)) ([386759c](386759c)) * Add row deletion to the Milvus online store ([#7082](#7082)) ([d3e2041](d3e2041)) * Add upstream FeatureView lineage support for PushSource ([#6853](#6853)) ([c9b9d72](c9b9d72)) * Optional nameless pre-computed vectors with a schema fingerprint ([#7077](#7077)) ([9420fac](9420fac)) ### Performance Improvements * Scan Lance sources lazily in the DuckDB offline store ([1299e4e](1299e4e))
shuchu
added a commit
to shuchu/feast
that referenced
this pull request
Nov 11, 2026
…ine store (feast-dev#6952) The Dask offline store sorted by created_timestamp_column and then by timestamp_field in a second pass, relying on that second sort to keep the created timestamp order for rows sharing an event timestamp. sort_values is not stable, so with enough rows the older row could end up last and win the keep="last" deduplication, both in historical retrieval and in pull_latest_from_table_or_query. Sort once by [timestamp_field, created_timestamp_column] instead. Signed-off-by: LuisFigueroaG <[email protected]> Co-authored-by: Shuchu Han <[email protected]> Signed-off-by: Shuchu Han <[email protected]>
shuchu
pushed a commit
to shuchu/feast
that referenced
this pull request
Nov 11, 2026
# [0.68.0](feast-dev/feast@v0.67.0...v0.68.0) (2026-11-10) ### Bug Fixes * add watch verb on clusterroles and clusterrolebindings for feast-operator ([feast-dev#7062](feast-dev#7062)) ([b6bdda4](feast-dev@b6bdda4)) * Apply on demand feature views in SparkRetrievalJob.to_spark_df() ([feast-dev#6993](feast-dev#6993)) ([f416309](feast-dev@f416309)) * Break event timestamp ties by created timestamp in Milvus write batches ([feast-dev#7084](feast-dev#7084)) ([bbaca76](feast-dev@bbaca76)) * Break event timestamp ties by created timestamp in the Dask offline store ([feast-dev#6952](feast-dev#6952)) ([eb93b08](feast-dev@eb93b08)) * Build the Go feature server image in two stages ([1e5e90c](feast-dev@1e5e90c)), closes [feast-dev#7060](feast-dev#7060) * Fall back to the serialized body when UDF source misses globals ([feast-dev#6816](feast-dev#6816)) ([f61079f](feast-dev@f61079f)) * Install patched libbrotli1 to address DSA-6582-1 ([feast-dev#7096](feast-dev#7096)) ([d458393](feast-dev@d458393)) * Keep description, tags and nested types of ODFV schema fields ([8ef6e75](feast-dev@8ef6e75)) * Keep entity columns out of StreamFeatureView proto features ([feast-dev#7033](feast-dev#7033)) ([d520584](feast-dev@d520584)) * Keep the metrics server running when a Gunicorn worker exits ([feast-dev#7012](feast-dev#7012)) ([68c5d54](feast-dev@68c5d54)), closes [feast-dev#7011](feast-dev#7011) * Key registry proto caches on the proto, not its id() ([feast-dev#7085](feast-dev#7085)) ([147adad](feast-dev@147adad)) * Log ODFV materialization skips instead of printing them ([feast-dev#7117](feast-dev#7117)) ([8fdcee7](feast-dev@8fdcee7)) * Pin build dependencies of source builds to the CI lock ([feast-dev#7104](feast-dev#7104)) ([dec2f24](feast-dev@dec2f24)) * Populate spec.project in registry REST feature view responses (#… ([feast-dev#7037](feast-dev#7037)) ([e304a84](feast-dev@e304a84)) * Preserve colliding source timestamps in Dask retrieval ([feast-dev#7071](feast-dev#7071)) ([1396c88](feast-dev@1396c88)) * Preserve Dask historical requests without eligible features ([feast-dev#7000](feast-dev#7000)) ([fff09f7](feast-dev@fff09f7)) * Read None elements of UUID and Decimal lists as None ([feast-dev#7039](feast-dev#7039)) ([03f30fe](feast-dev@03f30fe)) * Retire the support of Python3.10 ([feast-dev#7101](feast-dev#7101)) ([a56766e](feast-dev@a56766e)), closes [feast-dev#7104](feast-dev#7104) [feast-dev#7089](feast-dev#7089) [feast-dev#7106](feast-dev#7106) [feast-dev#7105](feast-dev#7105) * Serialize UUID and TimeUuid entity keys ([feast-dev#7032](feast-dev#7032)) ([0c845a1](feast-dev@0c845a1)) * Stop the Ray engine from hiding materialization errors ([feast-dev#7026](feast-dev#7026)) ([7903e2e](feast-dev@7903e2e)), closes [feast-dev#7024](feast-dev#7024) * **ui:** stop treating the monitoring baseline as the latest window ([feast-dev#7056](feast-dev#7056)) ([0f01802](feast-dev@0f01802)), closes [feast-dev#7054](feast-dev#7054) * Use date-only bounds for partition filters built from string timestamps ([feast-dev#7116](feast-dev#7116)) ([b1f2168](feast-dev@b1f2168)) * Validate entity column types in feast dbt import ([feast-dev#7067](feast-dev#7067)) ([abca80c](feast-dev@abca80c)), closes [feast-dev#5876](feast-dev#5876) * Warm up the whole DynamoDB connection pool ([feast-dev#6985](feast-dev#6985)) ([8ce548c](feast-dev@8ce548c)) ### Features * Add --gc-freeze option to feast serve ([feast-dev#7089](feast-dev#7089)) ([aad0c15](feast-dev@aad0c15)) * Add native complex types and scalar index tags to the Milvus online store ([feast-dev#7120](feast-dev#7120)) ([f7068d6](feast-dev@f7068d6)) * Add num_partitions and partition_key_isolation to the Milvus online store ([feast-dev#7083](feast-dev#7083)) ([68de84e](feast-dev@68de84e)), closes [feast-dev#6940](feast-dev#6940) * Add Pinecone online store integration ([feast-dev#6585](feast-dev#6585)) ([7a84f2a](feast-dev@7a84f2a)) * Add PolarisSource and PolarisProvider for Apache Polaris ([feast-dev#7006](feast-dev#7006)) ([386759c](feast-dev@386759c)) * Add row deletion to the Milvus online store ([feast-dev#7082](feast-dev#7082)) ([d3e2041](feast-dev@d3e2041)) * Add upstream FeatureView lineage support for PushSource ([feast-dev#6853](feast-dev#6853)) ([c9b9d72](feast-dev@c9b9d72)) * Optional nameless pre-computed vectors with a schema fingerprint ([feast-dev#7077](feast-dev#7077)) ([9420fac](feast-dev@9420fac)) ### Performance Improvements * Scan Lance sources lazily in the DuckDB offline store ([1299e4e](feast-dev@1299e4e)) Signed-off-by: Shuchu Han <[email protected]>
This file contains hidden or bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
What this PR does / why we need it:
When two rows share an event timestamp, Feast is supposed to keep the one with the latest
created_timestamp_column. The Dask offline store did this with two consecutive sorts, first by the created timestamp and then by the event timestamp, and relied on the second sort preserving the order of the first:Dask's
sort_values(and pandas' default quicksort) is not stable, so for tied event timestamps the older row can end up last and windrop_duplicates(keep="last"). With 300 entities, each having two rows with the same event timestamp, 291 came back with the older row. A single partition with 20 entities already returned 12 wrong rows. This affectsget_historical_features(_drop_duplicates) andpull_latest_from_table_or_query(evaluate_offline_job).This sorts once by
[timestamp_field, created_timestamp_column]in both places, including theZeroDivisionErrorfallbacks. Multi-columnsort_valuesis supported by dask since well before thedask>=2024.2.1minimum.Which issue(s) this PR fixes:
No existing issue.
Checks
git commit -s)Testing Strategy
Added
test_dask_created_timestamp_tiebreak.py, coveringget_historical_featuresandpull_latest_from_table_or_querywith 100 entities across 4 partitions. Both tests failed in 5 out of 5 runs on master and pass with this change.ruff format --check,ruff checkandmypypass on the changed files, andsdk/python/tests/unit/infra/offline_stores/passes (291 passed).