What happened?
Description
Since 4.11.2 and 5.3.3 the installation of Craft CMS checks the \craft\base\Plugin::$schemaVersion of all plugins against the schema version defined in project config. If not the same, the install stops.
I encountered this with the plugins:
solspace/craft-calendarcooltronicpl/document-helpers
I have not checked the other plugins in this project yet.
The direct cause is the recent change in combination with these plugins not defining the \craft\base\Plugin::$schemaVersion. From the documentation I would assume this is actually required for a plugin. Perhaps the default value in \craft\base\PluginTrait could be null? Or some other way to make it required?
Background
- Affects Craft CMS 4 (since 4.11.2) and Craft CMS 5 (since 5.3.2)
Steps to reproduce
- Given an existing Craft CMS project
- Given project config lists plugin
calendar (https://github.com/solspace/craft-calendar) with key "schemaVersion" is "5.0.0"
- Install Craft CMS with
./craft install/craft
Expected behavior
See message: Success installed
Actual behavior
See error
*** installing Craft
Project config validation failed: Calendar is installed with schema version 1.0.0, but project.yaml expects 5.0.0.
Run `composer install` or remove your `config/project/` folder and try again.
Aborting install.
Craft CMS version
4.11.3
PHP version
8.2.6
Operating system and version
Alpine Linux (Docker container)
Database type and version
MySQL 8.0.29
Image driver and version
GD 8.2.6
Installed plugins and versions
Name Handle Package Name Version Installed Enabled
------------------------- ------------------------- ------------------------------------ -------------- --------- -------
Amazon S3 aws-s3 craftcms/aws-s3 2.2.1 Yes Yes
Blitz blitz putyourlightson/craft-blitz 4.22.0 Yes Yes
Breadcrumb breadcrumb youandmedigital/breadcrumb 2.0.0 Yes Yes
Calendar calendar solspace/craft-calendar 5.0.7 Yes Yes
Compress compress venveo/craft-compress 4.0.1 Yes Yes
Craftagram craftagram jsmrtn/craftagram 3.0.0 Yes Yes
Doxter doxter verbb/doxter 5.0.6 Yes Yes
Element API element-api craftcms/element-api 4.1.0 Yes Yes
Elements Panel elements-panel putyourlightson/craft-elements-panel 2.0.0 Yes Yes
Embedded Assets embeddedassets spicyweb/craft-embedded-assets 4.1.1 Yes Yes
Facebook Conversion facebook-conversion dwy/facebook-conversion v1.3.3 Yes Yes
Feed Me feed-me craftcms/feed-me 5.7.0 Yes Yes
Formie formie verbb/formie 2.1.26 Yes Yes
Hide Admin hide-admin jalendport/craft-hideadmin 2.0.0-beta.1 Yes Yes
HTTP Basic Authentication basicauth codemonauts/craft-basicauth 2.0.0 Yes Yes
Image Base64 craft-twig-imagebase64 kisonay/craft-twig-imagebase64 1.1.1 Yes Yes
Imager imager aelvan/imager dev-dev-craft4 Yes Yes
Linkit linkit presseddigital/linkit 4.0.4.1 Yes Yes
Maps simplemap ether/simplemap 4.0.8 Yes Yes
Mix mix misterbk/mix v1.7.1 Yes Yes
Navigation navigation verbb/navigation 2.1.0 Yes Yes
Neo neo spicyweb/craft-neo 4.2.10 Yes Yes
Password Policy password-policy craftpulse/craft-password-policy 4.1.0 Yes Yes
PDF Generator document-helpers cooltronicpl/document-helpers 2.3.2 Yes Yes
Redactor redactor craftcms/redactor 3.1.0 Yes Yes
Redactor Custom Styles redactor-custom-styles carlcs/craft-redactorcustomstyles 4.0.3 Yes Yes
Retour retour nystudio107/craft-retour 4.1.18 Yes Yes
Scout scout studioespresso/craft-scout 4.1.1 Yes Yes
SEOmatic seomatic nystudio107/craft-seomatic 4.1.2 Yes Yes
Shortcodes shortcodes verbb/shortcodes 3.0.0 Yes Yes
Simple Logger simple-logger leowebguy/simple-logger 1.0.2 Yes Yes
Spoon spoon doublesecretagency/craft-spoon 4.0.4 Yes Yes
Two-Factor Authentication two-factor-authentication born05/craft-twofactorauthentication 3.4.0 Yes Yes
Vite vite nystudio107/craft-vite 4.0.10 Yes Yes
What happened?
Description
Since 4.11.2 and 5.3.3 the installation of Craft CMS checks the
\craft\base\Plugin::$schemaVersionof all plugins against the schema version defined in project config. If not the same, the install stops.I encountered this with the plugins:
solspace/craft-calendarcooltronicpl/document-helpersI have not checked the other plugins in this project yet.
The direct cause is the recent change in combination with these plugins not defining the
\craft\base\Plugin::$schemaVersion. From the documentation I would assume this is actually required for a plugin. Perhaps the default value in\craft\base\PluginTraitcould benull? Or some other way to make it required?Background
Steps to reproduce
calendar(https://github.com/solspace/craft-calendar) with key "schemaVersion" is "5.0.0"./craft install/craftExpected behavior
See message:
Success installedActual behavior
See error
Craft CMS version
4.11.3
PHP version
8.2.6
Operating system and version
Alpine Linux (Docker container)
Database type and version
MySQL 8.0.29
Image driver and version
GD 8.2.6
Installed plugins and versions