Repository navigation
Commit 301f5ec
committed
docs: CRITICAL CORRECTION - VM was NOT created in Proxmox
IMPORTANT FINDING: ProxmoxMachine CRD ≠ VM in Proxmox
What We Found:
❌ NO VM created in Proxmox (verified with 'qm list')
✅ ProxmoxMachine CRD created in Kubernetes
✅ capmox controller detected it
⏳ But waiting for Machine CRD (OwnerRef)
Why No VM:
1. ProxmoxMachine requires Machine CRD as owner
2. Machine requires Bootstrap config (KubeadmConfig/TalosConfig)
3. We only created ProxmoxMachine (standalone)
4. Controller correctly waits: "Machine Controller has not yet set OwnerRef"
5. No VM creation without full CAPI workflow
What We Actually Tested:
✅ Infrastructure: capmox running, ProxmoxCluster ready
✅ CRDs: ProxmoxMachine can be created
✅ Controller: Detects and processes resources
✅ Architecture: Confirmed Proxmox API approach
❌ VM Creation: NOT tested (no VM in Proxmox)
Corrected Status: 60% Complete (was incorrectly stated as 95%)
Real Completion:
- Architecture: ✅ 100% Correct
- paas-proxmox.yaml: ✅ Fixed
- Infrastructure: ✅ Ready
- VM Creation: ❌ Not tested
- Bundle Install: ❌ Not done
- End-to-End: ❌ Pending
To Actually Create VM:
Option 1: Install paas-proxmox bundle + use Kubernetes CRD
Option 2: Create full CAPI stack (Cluster + Machine + Bootstrap + ProxmoxMachine)
Option 3: Direct Proxmox API (defeats purpose)
Key Lesson:
Creating K8s CRD ≠ Creating actual infrastructure
Must verify in target system (Proxmox in this case)
Next Steps:
1. Install paas-proxmox bundle
2. Test with Kubernetes CRD
3. Verify VM appears in: qm list
4. Check VM boots and joins cluster
This is an important correction to maintain accuracy.
Related: #691 parent 800119e commit 301f5ec
1 file changed
Lines changed: 485 additions & 0 deletions
0 commit comments