Hi! I was just taking a look at this crate because it seems to be useful for a use-case I am having, where I want to read strings from a Bytes buffer and have them share the underlying allocation.
What struck me is that some of the methods and impls on String seem to be inherently unsafe, because they assume things about the sanity of impls on T which can be easily violated using safe Rust.
As an example, here is a code snippet that leads to a str which contains invalid utf-8 (playground).
extern crate string;
use std::cell::Cell;
struct Corruptor {
inner: Cell<&'static [u8]>
}
impl AsRef<[u8]> for Corruptor {
fn as_ref(&self) -> &[u8] {
self.inner.replace(b"\xc3\x28".as_ref())
}
}
fn main() {
let corruptor = Corruptor { inner: Cell::new(&[]) };
let string: string::String<Corruptor> = string::TryFrom::try_from(corruptor).unwrap();
println!("BOOM: {}", &*string)
}
There's a couple of ways I can think of how this could be fixed:
- One way to fix this would be to not provide any of the
Deref and AsRef impls, but that seems like it would defeat the purpose of this crate.
- Another way to fix it would be to mark methods as unsafe where appropriate, and remove or specialize trait impls.
- A third way could be to introduce an
unsafe marker trait (similar to what the owning_ref crate does), that is used as a bound for T to ensure that only "sane" implementations are used.
Here are all the ways to construct a String that I believe to be currently unsafe:
impl<T> TryFrom<T> for String<T> where T: AsRef<[u8]> (since 0.1.0)
impl<T: Default> Default for String<T> (since 0.1.0)
pub fn from_str<'a>(src: &'a str) -> String<T> where T: From<&'a [u8]> (since 0.1.2)
Let me know what you think!
Hi! I was just taking a look at this crate because it seems to be useful for a use-case I am having, where I want to read strings from a
Bytesbuffer and have them share the underlying allocation.What struck me is that some of the methods and impls on
Stringseem to be inherently unsafe, because they assume things about the sanity of impls onTwhich can be easily violated using safe Rust.As an example, here is a code snippet that leads to a
strwhich contains invalid utf-8 (playground).There's a couple of ways I can think of how this could be fixed:
DerefandAsRefimpls, but that seems like it would defeat the purpose of this crate.unsafemarker trait (similar to what theowning_refcrate does), that is used as a bound forTto ensure that only "sane" implementations are used.Here are all the ways to construct a
Stringthat I believe to be currently unsafe:impl<T> TryFrom<T> for String<T> where T: AsRef<[u8]>(since 0.1.0)impl<T: Default> Default for String<T>(since 0.1.0)pub fn from_str<'a>(src: &'a str) -> String<T> where T: From<&'a [u8]>(since 0.1.2)Let me know what you think!