Skip to content

Use typed Apple screenshot recovery reasons #4442

Open

Description

@thymikee

Current execution status — 2026-11-13

Open; unpublished at d722fb6129a1c014de4d355c63bc487ed8d3542c. All 33 focused cases, typecheck, formatting and diff-check pass after three authored-test type errors were corrected. Regression, exact affected validation and native simulator recovery evidence remain.

Latest detailed Current state.

Parent: #4368. Audit: APPLE-10. Authorized next-ten scope. Source baseline: 5781ba4aa63462d7fa55b5987e5841a01c691dfc.

Problem and owner

packages/platform-apple/src/core/screenshot.ts drives retry/recovery with combined message, stdout/stderr and argv text. The simulator timeout branch can be influenced by an argument containing screenshot. The existing host-kit isCommandTimeoutError helper already exposes structured timeout evidence.

Required behavior and prevention design

Stamp screenshot/tool failure reasons at the existing Apple execution/adapter boundary and consume those reasons in retry and boot-recovery decisions. Human diagnostic wording and argv spelling must not select behavior. Reuse host-kit's typed timeout evidence. Parse unavoidable external-tool protocol evidence once at its producer, separate from the human message; do not add another global classifier or match normalized error text downstream.

Preserve the currently supported recovery conditions, deadlines, cancellation, capture facts and native backend ownership. Do not broaden retries, add fallback or rewrite unrelated performance classifiers. Remove superseded combined-text control branches rather than retaining parallel typed/text behavior.

Completion evidence

A typed timeout survives changed wording. Identical message/argv text without the relevant typed reason does not trigger recovery. Test malformed/unrelated tool output and each retained terminal/retry outcome through the screenshot execution boundary. Keep error cause/hint/dispatch/cleanup evidence. Demonstrate a base failure or credible mutation, use existing integration seams, run full format and exact-head affected validation, and obtain independent review/CI. Native recovery changes require one owned simulator run; deterministic predicate tests alone are insufficient for a native-path claim. Preserve #4050 and justified test retention.

Dependencies

Open #4111 edits the same screenshot module but its current patch does not change the recovery predicate. Coordinate and recheck drift before implementation; do not take over density or burst work (#4291). No real release, upload, merge or tags are authorized.

Activity

  1. apex-sentinel-staging commented on Nov 11, 2026

    @apex-sentinel-staging

    Apex Sentinel · Issue review

    Suggested label: feature

    The issue proposes replacing screenshot failure text/argv matching with typed recovery reasons and reuse of structured timeout evidence, which is an internal enhancement/refactor request. It includes concrete files, required behavior, tests, and dependencies, so a maintainer could act on it.

  2. thymikee commented on Nov 13, 2026

    @thymikee
    MemberAuthor

    Decision: typed simulator screenshot timeout and observed-state boot recovery:

    Adopt the following finite policy for #4442 at baseline 80075b6. Reuse the preserved producer-boundary correction, not the rejected downstream prose classifier. Only the local simctl screenshot adapter may parse the tool's top-level stderr protocol header for domain=NSPOSIXErrorDomain and exact numeric code=60. Stamp reason simulator-screenshot-timeout; do not synthesize host-kit timeoutMs for an external-tool timeout. Host-kit isCommandTimeoutError remains authority for its own process timeout. Unclassified supplied callback errors remain unknown; message/argv spelling cannot cause retry/fallback. Malformed, stdout-only, unrelated-domain/code and nested-only headers remain negative controls.

    Preserve the released skipped-boot-check recovery path with the existing scoped simctl JSON state reader. After an eligible failed simulator capture, while skipIosSimulatorBootCheck is true, obtain one fresh same-operation state observation and recover only for exactly Shutdown. Use a screenshot-owned 5000ms probe ceiling, with earlier request cancellation/deadline authoritative. Do not use the 60000ms inventory timeout. Booted, Booting, Creating, Shutting Down, missing/unreadable state or failed probe cannot authorize boot recovery. Cancellation remains terminal and must not be swallowed by the probe. An unknown probe preserves the original capture failure and diagnostics. Keep the existing single boot recovery/re-capture and retry/runner/mask policies; do not broaden retries or add fallback.

    Delete the orphan simulator-not-booted reason predicate and superseded simulator text branches. Preserve cause, hint, capture facts, status-bar cleanup and typed cancellation. Keep the existing boot memo policy unchanged in this issue; its pre-existing possibility of a recent memo short-circuit after an observed shutdown remains a recorded limitation, not a claim of guaranteed recovery. Do not invent a screenshot-specific CoreSimulator code405 contract.

    Implementation must prove the real local adapter seam, identical-text/different-reason and changed-text/same-reason cases, malformed protocol and every retained terminal/retry/state outcome. Native screenshot/recovery evidence is still required through owned T3 devices and the owning harness; source inspection and binary strings alone do not establish native completion. #4111's current screenshot density hunks are an external textual conflict risk, not permission to maintain it. Preserve deadlines, #4050, independent review and exact-head validation; no merge/release/tags.

  3. thymikee commented on Nov 13, 2026

    @thymikee
    MemberAuthor

    Current state: The typed-recovery candidate is local and unpublished at d722fb6129a1c014de4d355c63bc487ed8d3542c, on base 80075b6412dfa94fd765a36407270e21adce8981.

    The bounded pinned run at predecessor b483fc2bb40d78fc6fa25f004bc26091a392b864 passed installation, build and all 33 tests in the three authored protocol/retry/observed-state suites, with no skipped tests or real simulator calls. Typecheck then found three errors in the authored test files. Those diagnostics are historical failures, unrelated to #4512.

    The coordinator corrected the test types in d722fb6: an explicit retry-attempt parameter and error-outcome narrowing that also asserts the scripted commands failed. No production source or existing assertion was removed. Full repository formatting, the same 33 focused tests, typecheck and diff-check passed on the committed content. The checkout is clean. This is focused evidence, not an exact affected-gate receipt or regression proof.

    The adopted producer-stamped timeout and fresh JSON Shutdown policy is unchanged. Remaining: isolated old-production/mutation detection, exact affected validation, required independent review of subsequent deltas, and owned simulator evidence for the actual capture/recovery path. The recent-boot-memo limitation remains separately tracked; no code-405 assumption or prose-driven fallback is adopted. No PR or merge-readiness claim.

  4. thymikee commented on Nov 14, 2026

    @thymikee
    MemberAuthor

    Current state: Refreshed #4442 source at54812974 passed33focused tests and typecheck, but its exact gate FAILED at candidate test lint (1passed,1failed,7not-run,4skipped). The old failed receipt is retained. The coordinator fixed catch-variable names and replaceAll, and moved four predicate tests byte-identically to an adjacent discovered file, preserving every assertion. Production source is unchanged.

    New unpublished head b80056b passes full pinned format/lint,67focused tests across5files,and repo typecheck. A new Claude worker owns one exact-head affected gate. #4050 remains unchanged. Regression/mutation discrimination, native simulator evidence,current-head independent review and CI/publication are still pending. External#4111 remains open with screenshot overlap; it is not maintained by this work. No merge,release,tags or readiness claim.

  5. thymikee commented on Nov 14, 2026

    @thymikee
    MemberAuthor

    Current state: #4442 exact local validation passed at b80056b:8checks passed,1provider integration deduplicated,4skipped,none failed/not-run;19825unit tests passed with10skipped and377related passed. #4050 remains unchanged. Earlier54812974 lint failure stays historically failed. Native evidence, independent current-head review, regression/mutation detection and GitHub/publication obligations remain open.

    A new bounded Claude wave is running: #4442 isolated mutation/control proof has the sole execution slot, #4442 current-head independent source review is read-only, and #4441 source-only phase-owner work follows adopted Decision #4441 (comment). The transfer worker reuses existing remote commits with explicit local dependency layers; it cannot execute checks, implement the proxy adapter or claim independent publication yet.

    #4426 review corrections are committed at0e98de50e462c1c6975637e23998eabe8aaa1966, authored-unrun and queued behind the proof slot; its historical gate/native/#4512 limitations remain. Seven implementation scopes remain overall: #4442,#4426,#4441,#4448,#4519,#4520,#4518. The last remains reproduce-first/blocked on external4511. No duplicate implementation,merge,release,tags,delegate polling or timer-launched work is authorized. The one published-only backstop remains enabled.

  6. thymikee commented on Nov 14, 2026

    @thymikee
    MemberAuthor

    Current state: Apple4442 b80056b passed its exact gate and all four production mutants were caught with67/67restored controls. Evidence remains attributed to b800. Independent source review found no correctness defect but two Low hygiene issues, now root-fixed at600d51dc49c06b44c3e66e098cff3629fee72b71: remove test-only probe injection, answer the real listing in tests, and correct redundant/fixture assertions. Pinned format/lint/typecheck and77tests across6files pass. A new Claude worker owns the sole execution slot for600d mutation controls and one exact gate. Native,CI and publication remain open; prior review input omissions are disclosed.

    Transfer4441 source review found a real completed-hop timer leak that could replace a resumed hop's retryable failure with the old timeout. The coordinator fixed lower watchdog retirement at6089d90d905071810c1b4ab4e5c89d7aabc7258c, restacked, and retired the upper observer at43abdfa8020b19290dd1dd5174c00274868b29f9. Misleading budget prose is corrected. The finite low-level wrapper stays until its fixture proof migrates to the outer lifecycle owner. Phase expiry remains intentionally terminal under adopted policy; ordinary transport resets retain their retry. These transfer changes are unformatted/unvalidated and still need real-loopback detection,wire/closure checks and exact receipts. Nothing is published.

    Android4426 at0e98de50 remains authored-unrun and queued. Seven implementation scopes remain:#4442,#4426,#4441,#4448,#4519,#4520,#4518; the last remains reproduce-first/blocked on external4511. Historical failed receipts,#4512 and API36causes stay as recorded. No merge,release,tags,delegate polling or new timer.

  7. thymikee commented on Nov 14, 2026

    @thymikee
    MemberAuthor

    Current state: #4442 at600d51dc49c06b44c3e66e098cff3629fee72b71 has passing focused controls77/77 and all four production mutants fail intended assertions(6,1,4,1failures),with source restored. Its exact affected gate FAILEDunit; exactCommit=true,checkoutChanged=false,failOpen=false. Seven checks passed including377related tests;unit had19821passed,3failed,10skipped. Provider integration did not run;four checks were skipped. #4050 remains intact.

    The three failures are5000ms timeouts in scripts/tests/release-publish.test.ts at89,104,113. Cause is UNPROVEN. No unchanged-base comparison was run by that worker,and no contention/base-fault diagnosis is made. A new bounded Claude task now owns one identical check:unit run on unchanged based78be6c8 and one on candidate600d,strictly sequentially,with no gate retry. A separate source-only recheck addresses the current-head review corrections and missing normative inputs.

    The old b800 exact pass remains atb800;it is not a passing600d receipt. Native owned-simulator evidence,review,GitHub and publication remain open. The recent-boot memo,provider narrowing and capture-signal gaps remain disclosed. #4512/API36historical causes are not conflated with this new release-test cluster. Transfer4441 and Android4426 wait for execution capacity. No blind retry,source weakening,merge,release,tags,device allocation or worker polling.

  8. thymikee commented on Nov 14, 2026

    @thymikee
    MemberAuthor

    Current state: #4442 source recheck at600d found no production correctness defect and confirmed the test-only probe injection is gone. It found one Low coverage gap:R1. The retained real-probe test compares its timeout to the producer constant itself,so a30000ms probe could pass. The coordinator's earlier claim that it pinned5000ms was incorrect and is retracted.

    A small patch now asserts the observed timeout is literal5000ms and below the capture budget. It is PREPARED,NOT APPLIED,because the running unchanged-base/candidate unit comparison must retain its frozen600d head. No additional worker or execution was started. After the comparison completion event,the coordinator will apply/format/test/commit the correction and prove a30000ms mutant is caught;the next head still requires its own exact receipt.

    The600d exact gate remains FAILED with three release-publish5000ms timeouts,cause unproven. Its77/77focused controls and four detected mutants remain valid at600d,but do not cover this missing budget assertion. Native,CI and publication remain open. No retries,timeout widening,merge,release,tags,device allocation or delegate polling.

  9. thymikee commented on Nov 14, 2026

    @thymikee
    MemberAuthor

    Current state: The paired check:unit runs passed on unchanged base d78be6c and candidate 600d: 19,791 and 19,824 unit tests passed, respectively, with 10 skips each. The tmpdir and smoke checks also passed. None of the three release-publish timeouts reproduced. Their cause remains unproven; the failed exact receipt at 600d is retained. The comparison report records the differing report environment, foreign host activity and the worker's idle wait without assigning a cause.

    After the comparison finished, the coordinator fixed R1 in 855aa4a. The test now checks the observed probe timeout against literal 5,000 ms and below the capture budget. Production code is unchanged. Pinned format, lint, typecheck and 77 focused tests passed. In the isolated experiment, changing the production probe budget to 30,000 ms caused the intended assertion failure: 1 failed, 76 passed. Restoring the source returned all 77 tests to passing, with the experiment clean.

    One new exact-head gate is running at 855a. The worker will not run extra tests, retry a failure or wait for a quiet host. Earlier evidence remains attributed to its original SHA. Native simulator evidence, GitHub checks and publication remain open. Other scopes wait for execution capacity. No merge, release, tags, device allocation, worker polling or timer change.

  10. thymikee commented on Nov 14, 2026

    @thymikee
    MemberAuthor

    Current state: #4442 passed one exact affected gate at 855aa4a. The receipt records exactCommit=true, checkoutChanged=false and failOpen=false: eight checks passed, provider integration was deduplicated, four checks were skipped, and none failed or remained unrun. Unit: 19,824 passed and 10 skipped. Related: 377 passed. #4050 remains unchanged. The earlier 600d failed receipt is retained; its release-test timeouts did not reproduce in the comparison or this gate, and their cause is still unknown.

    The next bounded Claude wave has one native execution owner on the assigned stopped iPhone 17 Pro (iOS 27.0), through T3 tools and the returned CLI. It must prove candidate-backend binding and the real screenshot recovery route, or report the exact native gap, then clean only its owned resources. A separate source-only recheck verifies the final R1 literal-budget correction and the previously unread test-helper path. Native and final review results are not yet claimed; nothing is published.

    Seven implementation scopes remain. Android #4426 and transfer #4441 checks wait for execution capacity; #4448, #4519, #4520 and blocked/reproduce-first #4518 retain their policies and proof requirements. No merge, release, tags, foreign resource changes, worker polling or new timer.

  11. thymikee commented on Nov 14, 2026

    @thymikee
    MemberAuthor

    Current state: The final independent source recheck at 855aa4a found no issues in the R1 correction and its affected probe/helper path. It verified that the test observes the real state-reader timeout, requires literal 5,000 ms and stays below the 20-second capture budget. R1 is fixed. Production and the negative, cancellation and error-preservation cases are unchanged from the previously reviewed 600d source.

    The exact 855a gate and M5 regression proof are already recorded separately. The source review does not prove native behavior. The assigned T3 simulator verification is still the active execution step; no result is inferred and no worker was polled. Native evidence, GitHub checks and publication remain open. The historical 600d timeout failure and its unknown cause remain in the record. No merge, release, tags or new execution was started by this review completion.

  12. thymikee commented on Nov 14, 2026

    @thymikee
    MemberAuthor

    Current state: Native verification at 855aa4a established candidate-daemon binding and a successful ordinary screenshot on the assigned iPhone 17 Pro simulator (iOS 27.0, Xcode 27.1). Settings was discovered, opened and checked by selector and screenshot. This is a control, not recovery evidence.

    The single Shutdown recovery attempt did not dispatch a screenshot to the candidate. T3 device_close(shutdown:true) removed the returned CLI executable; the subsequent command exited 127. Restoring that CLI requires device_open, which boots the simulator and removes the precondition. No fresh recovery probe, boot, re-capture or real NSPOSIXErrorDomain code-60 header was observed. Source inspection suggests readiness admission and its five-second cache also constrain the route; that is not a runtime finding. No shutdown race was repeated and no native error was fabricated.

    The exact 855a affected gate passed: eight checks, 19,824 unit tests passed with 10 skipped, and 377 related tests passed. Provider integration was deduplicated; coverage and replay checks were skipped, not passed. Independent source reviews found no remaining findings. M1–M4 at 600d and M5 at 855a failed at their intended assertions and restored controls passed; mutant runs are dirty-tree evidence with their original SHA attribution. The historical failed 600d receipt remains retained, with its release-test timeout cause unknown.

    Native resources were cleaned: the session closed, the identity-checked private daemon exited after SIGTERM, and private state/config/token files were removed. The coordinator independently observed the assigned simulator stopped and no open devices in this thread. No graceful daemon-stop receipt exists. Foreign resources were untouched; the candidate is clean.

    Publish only as an explicitly blocked draft under the November 14 Decision. Native recovery and protocol-header evidence remain required before readiness; this run does not close #4442. Do not merge, release or push tags.

  13. thymikee commented on Nov 14, 2026

    @thymikee
    MemberAuthor

    Decision: simctl diagnostic preamble and protocol header position:

    The user explicitly requested the #4544 review correction on November 14: a simctl screenshot may print Detected file type from extension: PNG on stderr before its error header. Supersede the first-stderr-line restriction in Decision6853093218. The local adapter must recognize the first unindented An error was encountered processing the command (domain=..., code=...): header line anywhere in stderr. Diagnostic lines may precede it. Keep exact NSPOSIXErrorDomain and numeric60 attribution. Do not skip a preceding unrelated top-level error header to select a later nested or appended timeout. Indented headers, Underlying error lines, stdout-only headers, malformed protocol, other domains/codes, callbacks and successful calls remain negative controls. No prose retry classifier is reintroduced.

    Add the PNG-on-stderr ordering as a protocol positive and prove removing multiline anchoring breaks it. The old M2 proof intentionally rejecting a diagnostic preamble remains historical at its original SHA; it is no longer the current contract. Retain Shutdown-only state recovery, five-second probe, cancellation, unknown-state error preservation, single boot/re-capture and existing memo policy.

    The user also requires an owned simulator recovery run and real raw failure stderr with stamped details.reason or retry diagnostics. The previous ordinary screenshot control does not satisfy that. Inspect supported T3-bound lifecycle/capture paths before a new bounded run; do not claim the seam or code60 from scripted output. Preserve one local execution owner and foreign resources. If the supported route cannot produce the requested evidence, keep the PR blocked and identify the exact missing capability. No merge/release/tags or arbitrary test deletion.

  14. thymikee commented on Nov 14, 2026

    @thymikee
    MemberAuthor

    Current state: PR #4544 at 50034fe has no failed checks: 12 successful, five skipped and one neutral across 18 check entries. Coverage and Integration Tests passed. The native smoke skips remain skips, not native evidence.

    The real Linux Coverage job used Node 24.13 on the merge of 5003 into d78be6c: 20,173 tests passed and 70 skipped, followed by 11 fuzz-worker tests passed. Changed-line coverage passed. This closes the Linux process-fixture CI blocker at 5003 after the isolated regression proof and seven-line fixture correction. The failed 855a job remains historical. Job: https://github.com/callstack/agent-device/actions/runs/43597029890/job/132453624533.

    The PR remains a blocked draft. The user-requested stderr-preamble correction is local at cec1726, with separate proof/exact validation assigned. The required native Shutdown probe, boot/re-capture/PNG and real failure-stderr evidence remain open. No newer-head result or native outcome is inferred from this CI pass, and no worker was polled. The existing watch remains active; no merge or CI retry.

  15. thymikee commented on Nov 14, 2026

    @thymikee
    MemberAuthor

    Decision: screenshot recovery observation for the requested native evidence:

    Adopt the bounded diagnostic option in the #4544 source-grounded native plan under the user's explicit request for an owned recovery run and real failure stderr. Add one internal diagnostic beside the fresh screenshot state probe. When the probe returns, record its observed state, whether it authorizes recovery, and metadata from the original failed capture, including raw stderr through the existing redacted diagnostics owner. Preserve the typed capture details.reason under a separate captureFailureReason key; do not confuse the existing metadata reason/message field with typed evidence. Pass the same typed-reason reader to screenshot retry telemetry through classifyReason. Do not change returned CLI errors, wire schemas, budgets, cancellation, retry/fallback decisions, boot memo, native commands or provider boundaries. Add assertions at the existing diagnostic and tool seams; add no production test-only export or injection.

    The prior report's daemon-readiness explanation is corrected: an open-session screenshot route does not call daemon readiness. The supported candidate route is one already-running bound CLI batch: duration wait, then screenshot. T3 device_close(shutdown:true) runs during the wait; no CLI file is copied/recreated and no raw simctl/ssh screenshot command is used. Once the five-second memo is expired, the surviving session's screenshot can reach the fresh probe and bounded recovery. This is source-grounded, not yet runtime-proven: client/session survival, timing and completion inside the existing batch budget must be established by one owned attempt.

    Do not run that attempt until the diagnostic change is reviewed and validated at a fixed SHA. Use only host local/device BC54AC11-CD86-4C10-8C4E-5101C773FFEB through T3 device_open, its exact returned command and T3 lifecycle tools. Bind one private candidate daemon and retain request/session ownership. Capture control and recovered PNGs, the observed probe event, exact command/boot/capture counts and real stderr. Clean only owned resources, preferring daemon stop and verifying exit.

    A real non-60 error must stay unstamped. A natural code-60 timeout may establish typed reason/retry telemetry, but no supported operation guarantees one. Do not fake stderr, infer a timeout from prose, weaken the header parser or force an unsafe fault. If no code-60 occurs, report that evidence as unobserved and keep the corresponding human request open until it is satisfied or explicitly waived. The PR remains draft and cannot merge on model evidence alone. Preserve one execution owner, historical receipts and prior native-control limitations.

  16. thymikee commented on Nov 14, 2026

    @thymikee
    MemberAuthor

    Current state: The requested preamble correction passed at cec1726. Removing the multiline flag caused both new LF/CRLF PNG-preamble cases to fail at the missing typed reason (2 failed, 17 passed); restoring it returned 19 passes. Its exact gate passed eight checks, including 19,826 unit tests (10 skipped) and 377 related tests. Provider integration was deduplicated; coverage/replay checks skipped. No native proof was supplied by these scripted cases.

    After that frozen run finished, the coordinator implemented Decision6877821474 at local b0cc374. Recovery now records the completed fresh state observation and original failure metadata before that error can be discarded; a separate captureFailureReason preserves the typed reason, and retry telemetry receives it through classifyReason. No recovery policy, budget, cancellation, boot memo, returned error or public schema changed. Full pinned format, lint, whole-repository typecheck and 38 focused tests pass. One independent source reviewer and one serialized mutation/exact owner are assigned at the new SHA; no exact pass is claimed yet.

    New tests exercise a successful second capture and normalization, preserve the first error's diagnostic, keep untyped errors untyped, and run real retry telemetry over the existing tool seam. The first new-test run exposed the existing diagnostics owner's outer-whitespace normalization; the tests now pin that processing. An initial lint issue in a new test constructor was fixed, with failed logs retained. Diagnostic stderr is redacted, bounded and whitespace-normalized by the existing owner, so it must not be labelled byte-for-byte raw stderr.

    Once this head is reviewed and validated, run one owned T3-bound batch attempt using the source-grounded plan. Client/session survival across T3 close remains an unverified runtime assumption. The required Shutdown/probe/boot/re-capture/PNG and real failure evidence remain open, and a natural code60 timeout is not guaranteed. The PR remains a blocked draft at published 50034fe, whose real Linux Coverage is green. No additional push, native run, merge, release, tags, worker polling or timer change.

  17. thymikee commented on Nov 14, 2026

    @thymikee
    MemberAuthor

    Current state: The observation slice passed one exact affected gate at b0cc374, with exactCommit=true, checkoutChanged=false and no fail-open. Eight checks passed, including 19,830 unit tests (10 skipped) and 377 related tests. Provider integration was deduplicated; coverage and three Apple replay checks were skipped, not passed. Independent source review found no issues within its stated bounds.

    Both new mutations were caught: removing the recovery observation event failed two log-existence assertions (2 failed, 36 passed), and removing retry classifyReason failed the typed-reason case (1 failed, 37 passed). Restored controls passed all 38 tests and source hashes matched. Existing policy/state/header proofs retain their original SHA attribution. This is not native evidence.

    The sole execution owner now has one owned native attempt on host local / iPhone 17 Pro BC54AC11-CD86-4C10-8C4E-5101C773FFEB (iOS 27.0), observed stopped before assignment. It must use T3 device_open and the exact returned CLI, prove private candidate-daemon binding, start a wait/screenshot batch, use T3 shutdown during the wait, and capture actual probe/boot/re-capture/PNG and failure diagnostics, then clean only its own resources. Client/session survival is still a runtime assumption. No result is inferred or polled.

    Real non-60 failures must remain unstamped. Diagnostic stderr remains redacted/trimmed/bounded, not byte-exact. A natural code60 or retry attempt greater than one will be reported only if observed. The corresponding human evidence request remains open otherwise. The PR is still a blocked draft at published 50034fe (green CI); b0cc has not been pushed during this review round. No merge, release, tags, blind retries, new timer or concurrent gate.

  18. thymikee commented on Nov 14, 2026

    @thymikee
    MemberAuthor

    Current state: One owned native run at b0cc374 proved the skipped-boot-check recovery on iPhone 17 Pro / iOS 27.0. A candidate-bound batch survived T3 shutdown during its 15-second wait. The first screenshot hung and hit the 20-second host exec deadline; one fresh probe recorded Shutdown/recoveryAuthorized=true, the boot phase succeeded at attempt1, one re-capture succeeded and a valid 402x874 PNG was written. The batch completed 2/2 steps in45,726ms. The coordinator inspected the PNG and independently observed the assigned simulator stopped/open=[] after cleanup.

    This was not a simctl code60 timeout. Diagnostic stderr contains the real PNG-detection and default-display preamble lines, with existing redaction/trimming/bounds. No error header, captureFailureReason, retry reason or retry attempt>1 occurred. The exhausted attempt5 field is a pre-existing maximum-attempt label, not five actual captures. The specific code60/stamp or attempt>1 human request remains unobserved unless explicitly waived.

    The exact b0cc gate and source review passed before the run: eight checks,19,830unitpassed10skipped,377related; providerintegration deduplicated andcoverage/replays skipped. Native assets, hashes, request6e2a67a82db92103 logs and cleanup receipts are retained. Session shutdown, graceful private-daemon stop and removal of private config/token/state all succeeded; no foreign resource was touched. Header/diagnostic review-round changes are ready to push once, with the PR kept draft and its existing watch retained. No merge/release/tags or additional native attempt.

  19. thymikee commented on Nov 14, 2026

    @thymikee
    MemberAuthor

    Current state: PR #4544 at b0cc374 now has green GitHub CI: 12 successful checks, five skipped and one neutral; no failures and no conflict. Coverage and Integration Tests passed at this head. Skipped native lanes remain skips.

    The existing human request for a real simctl code60/stamped reason or actual retry above attempt1 remains open; the owned run proved Shutdown recovery but observed a host-owned deadline instead. The PR stays draft and watched. Queue and the existing PR description are updated. No new code, native attempt, delegate polling, CI retry or merge was started by this backstop.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions