@@ -250,8 +250,22 @@ const gestureTargetAuthoredDragUse = defineUse({
250250 */
251251export const gestureViewportRuntimeUse = defineUse ( { required : [ 'gestureViewport' ] } ) ;
252252
253- /** `scroll <direction>` executes one pass and needs nothing else. */
254- const scrollDirectionUse = defineUse ( { required : [ 'scrollDirection' ] } ) ;
253+ /**
254+ * `scroll <direction>` executes one pass, and the capture that lets it answer with the movement it
255+ * observed (#2714) is CONDITIONAL — not `preferred`, not `required` (ADR 0019 §2). Not preferred:
256+ * the observation is what makes the direction tier's answer honest, which is correctness rather
257+ * than a faster path, and §2 reserves `preferred` for optimizations that never carry correctness.
258+ * Not required: a runtime that cannot read a screen still scrolls, and `movement: 'unobserved'` —
259+ * or no movement field at all — is the answer it owes.
260+ *
261+ * Both sides are complete. An owner that can capture answers with the movement it saw; an owner that
262+ * cannot answers exactly the response it answered before, distance and all. `scroll-runtime.test.ts`
263+ * pins one case per side of that parity.
264+ */
265+ const scrollDirectionUse = defineUse ( {
266+ required : [ 'scrollDirection' ] ,
267+ conditional : [ 'captureSnapshot' ] ,
268+ } ) ;
255269/**
256270 * Every scroll that verifies between passes: `scroll top`/`scroll bottom` read hidden content at
257271 * the edge, and `scroll --until <selector>` re-reads the tree to decide whether the target came
0 commit comments