Notices are Errors, not Messages

(related to #1735)

I think parseN/parseE are broken

Lines 635 to 640 in e4578d2

    
           // same thing, different name 
        
           Connection.prototype.parseN = function (buffer, length) { 
        
             var msg = this.parseE(buffer, length) 
        
             msg.name = 'notice' 
        
             return msg 
        
           }

node-postgres/lib/connection.js

Lines 592 to 604 in e4578d2

    
           // parses error 
        
           Connection.prototype.parseE = function (buffer, length) { 
        
             var fields = {} 
        
             var msg, item 
        
             var input = new Message('error', length) 
        
             var fieldType = this.readString(buffer, 1) 
        
             while (fieldType !== '\0') { 
        
               fields[fieldType] = this.parseCString(buffer) 
        
               fieldType = this.readString(buffer, 1) 
        
             } 
        
             if (input.name === 'error') { 
        
               // the msg is an Error instance 
        
               msg = new Error(fields.M)

It looks like the one should create a Message and the other should create an Error, depending on the .name. However, parseE does always construct the input message with .name === 'error', so the else path is never hit.

Rediscovered this for #2020. I don’t think the change was intentional, but it’s existed since 2.4.0 so it’ll have to stay that way in 7.x at least. It doesn’t really make sense to expose Message-compatible objects either – length is meaningless to library users, and name almost so.

@brianc

Interested in changing this as part of 8.0, @brianc? (Adding it to the milestone so it’s not forgotten, but it doesn’t have to stay there.)

Good idea!

Make notice messages not an instance of Error

Make notice messages not an instance of Error (#2090)

8.0 Release (brianc#2117)

Navigation Menu

Repository navigation

Notices are Errors, not Messages #1982

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

	// same thing, different name
	Connection.prototype.parseN = function (buffer, length) {
	var msg = this.parseE(buffer, length)
	msg.name = 'notice'
	return msg
	}

	// parses error
	Connection.prototype.parseE = function (buffer, length) {
	var fields = {}
	var msg, item
	var input = new Message('error', length)
	var fieldType = this.readString(buffer, 1)
	while (fieldType !== '\0') {
	fields[fieldType] = this.parseCString(buffer)
	fieldType = this.readString(buffer, 1)
	}
	if (input.name === 'error') {
	// the msg is an Error instance
	msg = new Error(fields.M)

Notices are Errors, not Messages #1982

Description

Activity

charmander commented on Dec 5, 2019

charmander commented on Jan 30, 2020

brianc commented on Jan 30, 2020

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

Issue actions