-
-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 811
Closed
Labels
Description
Ideas about potential goals for Borg
Borg is a fork of Attic and it was done to allow some different approaches to development, goals and policy (for details about how and why the fork happened, see jborg/attic#217 and the attic mailing list):
Openness
- Borg is intended to be an effort by "The Borg Collective"
(see AUTHORS) and you can be assimilated into it, if you like. - Welcome feature requests, discuss their general usefulness.
- Accept pull requests of good quality and coding style,
give feedback on PRs that can't be accepted "as is". - Openly discuss about stuff, don't work in the dark.
As simple as possible, but not simpler
- Nobody likes tools that are too complicated, ...
- ... but nobody likes everything to be fixed and inflexible either.
- Do the usually right thing by default, but offer other options.
- Accept the fact that the usually right defaults might be totally unfit
for some users / use cases.
Compatibility - boon and bane of backup software
- Don't break it accidentally / without good reason / without warning.
- Break it if above does not apply. needs more thoughts/discussion
- As the fork is "new software" from the perspective of a Borg user or
a Borg packaging distribution, there is no past we need to stay compatible
with - we have the chance to break compatibility and change everything
that we think needs changing. - Over time, we'll have more users and incompatible changes get harder.
- Avoid getting into the "compatible forever" trap - we should maybe not
assure compatibility of development versions nor spanning major releases. - When used for long-term archiving, special considerations and care are required.
E.g. a development snapshot of Borg might be not the right thing for this.
Also, Borg exists to be able to change things. So if you don't like or can't
live with a changing software, don't use it.
matkoniecz