Skip to content

Commit 261f670

Browse files
Bomerclaude
andcommitted
Name the accessibility error as upstream
Windows only, and not ours: ListView asks for two-pane semantics, a Tooltip's overlay child is grafted back onto the tooltip's child from inside the Overlay, and the bridge cannot reconcile the two. flutter/flutter#182444. It fires as the mouse crosses list rows, which is why James sees it during use and why it says nothing about an app burning CPU with nobody at the keyboard. Excluding the collapsed player took the pending count from 42 to 26, so that change was worth making on its own; the remainder is whatever is genuinely on screen. Removing tooltips from list rows would quieten it and cost the labels a screen reader needs, which is not a trade worth making blind. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <[email protected]>
1 parent cd213b0 commit 261f670

1 file changed

Lines changed: 16 additions & 0 deletions

File tree

‎.agent/PROJECT.md‎

Lines changed: 16 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -449,6 +449,22 @@ positive report of mobile-and-nothing-else skips: an unrecognised or empty repor
449449
LAN, because losing the fastest connection is a worse error than spending a wave. A VPN over
450450
mobile counts as a way in.
451451

452+
**"Failed to update ui::AXTree, error: Nodes left pending" is upstream, and it is a
453+
tooltip inside a scrollable.** Windows only. `ListView` asks for two-pane semantics, which
454+
inserts a synthetic inner node; a `Tooltip`'s overlay child is physically in the `Overlay` but
455+
semantically grafted back onto the tooltip's child; the Windows bridge cannot reconcile the
456+
two and drops the update. It fires while the mouse moves across list rows, which is why the
457+
console fills during ordinary use and not while the app is idle. See
458+
[flutter/flutter#182444](https://github.com/flutter/flutter/issues/182444).
459+
460+
This app is full of the shape — every `IconButton` with a tooltip inside a list — so the only
461+
thing we can do about it is stop *adding* to what the bridge is handed. The collapsed player
462+
is excluded from semantics for that reason (and for its tickers), which took the pending count
463+
from 42 to 26 on James's machine. The rest comes from whatever is genuinely on screen, and the
464+
remedy for that would be dropping tooltips from list rows, which costs the labels a screen
465+
reader needs. **Not worth trading until somebody is actually using a screen reader with it**,
466+
and worth re-checking on each Flutter upgrade rather than fixing here.
467+
452468
**A hang on Windows leaves nothing to read.** `AppHangB1` in the event log names the process
453469
and the version and stops there: no stack, no dump, no exception. `FrameWatch` exists for the
454470
next one — it counts frame times all session and splits build (our Dart on the UI thread) from

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)