Conversation
|
@claude review this PR. |
|
Claude finished @kovtcharov's task —— View job PR Review in Progress
|
Implemented Option 2 (enhanced error messages) with TDD approach and fixed documentation issues in MCP client guide and CLI reference. Features: - Enhanced MCP validation error messages (TDD approach) * Detects JSON-RPC validation errors (code -32602) * Shows complete tool schema in error output * Shows arguments that were provided * Helps LLM self-correct input validation issues * No new dependencies required - Documentation improvements * Updated Quick Start to use 'time' server (cross-platform) * Added explanation of 'gaia mcp add' command * Clarified command format with quotes * Added --config flag documentation throughout * Added MCP Client commands section to CLI reference * Verified all documentation links work Changes: - src/gaia/mcp/client/mcp_client.py: Enhanced error formatting - tests/unit/mcp/client/test_mcp_client.py: 5 new tests - docs/guides/mcp-client.mdx: Updated examples and CLI commands - docs/reference/cli.mdx: Added MCP Client commands section Testing: - All 49 unit tests pass - All 8 integration tests pass - Both examples verified working - No regressions Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.5 <[email protected]>
Update docs package.json to use mintlify dev server for local development. The start script now runs `mintlify dev` instead of the Node.js proxy server. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.5 <[email protected]>
- Update title from "MCP Client Guide" to "MCP Client" for consistency - Add example links at top of guide for quick reference - Fix footer format to match other guides (standard copyright) - Add database-mixin to SDK navigation (Mixins & Utilities) - Document gaia mcp test-client CLI command in reference - Clean up spec file formatting and footer Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.5 <[email protected]>
- Provide single-file, copy-pasteable example matching working patterns - Include proper initialization (skip_lemonade, explicit __init__ calls) - Add system prompt rebuilding for MCP tool registration - Show expected output for better user experience - Use process_query instead of run for consistency with examples - Add tip pointing to production config-based pattern Fixes incomplete Quick Start that caused NameError when users tried to follow the guide. Now provides a fully working example users can run immediately without modifications. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.5 <[email protected]>
The previous Quick Start was broken because it lacked the JSON response format instructions that the Agent base class requires for tool calling. Without these instructions, the LLM outputs tool calls as text instead of executing them. Changes: - Add complete response format instructions to _rebuild_system_prompt - Include tool calling JSON schema and rules - Update expected output to show actual tool execution - Make it clear this is a complete, working example This matches the pattern used in working examples like mcp_multi_server_agent.py and mcp_config_based_agent.py. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.5 <[email protected]>
- Simplified mcp_config_based_agent.py from 195 to 64 lines - Reduced docstring from 43 to 3 lines - Removed verbose print statements and status output - Added silent_mode=True for clean console output - Changed MCP client logging from INFO to DEBUG - mcp_client_manager.py: 8 log level changes - mcp_client.py: 4 log level changes - mcp_client_mixin.py: 5 log level changes - Now only shows essential output by default - Updated MCP client guide documentation - Replaced verbose examples with actual clean output - Fixed prerequisites to require [mcp] extra - Added [mcp,dev] option for development - Fixed setup.py missing packages - Added gaia.mcp.client - Added gaia.mcp.client.transports Example now produces clean output: Connected: memory, thinking, time Agent: The current time in Tokyo is 11:59 PM...
- Added Step 2 to setup.mdx for Node.js installation via NVM - Windows: winget or manual download from GitHub - Linux: curl script from nvm-sh/nvm - Version: 20.20.0 (latest LTS with January 2026 security fixes) - Updated system requirements table with Node.js as optional - Added .nvmrc file with v20.20.0 - Updated MCP client guide prerequisites - Added example of npm-based MCP server command - Links to setup guide for NVM installation - Added prerequisites table to MCP client spec - Documents GAIA [mcp] and Node.js dependencies
Phase 0: File Reorganization - Move mcp_client_mixin.py to src/gaia/mcp/mixin.py (follows database mixin pattern) - Update imports across codebase (examples, tests, docs) - Reorganize docs.json navigation: - SDK Reference: Move mcp-client to SDKs group - Specifications: Move mcp-agent to Core Framework - Specifications: Move mcp-server to SDKs group - Specifications: Move mcp-client to Tool Mixins, rename to "MCP Tool Mixin" Phase 1: Automatic System Prompt Rebuild - Add rebuild_system_prompt() method to Agent base class - Automatically called in Agent.__init__ after tool registration - MCPClientMixin auto-calls rebuild after connecting MCP servers - ChatAgent simplified to use base class method - Remove manual _rebuild_system_prompt() from examples and tests This eliminates the need for users to manually rebuild system prompts when dynamically adding MCP tools or indexing documents. Changes: 20 files, -406/+160 lines Tests: 49/49 unit, 9/9 integration pass Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.5 <[email protected]>
High priority fixes: - Clarify only stdio transport is currently supported (HTTP exists but not integrated) - Add missing load_mcp_servers_from_config() method documentation - Document call_tool() error response format Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.5 <[email protected]>
Following patterns from chat.mdx and llm.mdx: - Add quick reference header with navigation links - Add source code info box (updated to src/gaia/mcp/mixin.py) - Add import statement note - Add development badge - Add comprehensive code examples: - Connect multiple servers - Load servers from config - Direct client usage (without agent) - Using MCPClientManager - Enhanced error handling - Enhanced debug mode - Add copyright footer Expanded from 160 to 332 lines. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.5 <[email protected]>
Navigation fixes (docs.json): - Add MCP Client SDK to SDK Reference → Mixins & Utilities - Move spec/mcp-agent from Core Framework to Agents & Apps - Move spec/routing-agent from Infrastructure to Agents & Apps Spec fixes (spec/mcp-client.mdx): - Remove icon: "plug" (no other tool mixins have icons) Guide fixes (guides/mcp-client.mdx): - Rename "For Team Projects" → "Example 1: Project-Level Config" - Rename "For Personal Use" → "Example 2: User-Level Config" - Remove team/personal labels from benefits section - Remove manual _rebuild_system_prompt() calls (automated in Phase 1) - Add comments about automatic system prompt updates Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.5 <[email protected]>
Removed sections (moved to SDK reference): - Python SDK Examples (~100 lines) - Multiple code patterns - Configuration (~58 lines) - Agent-level and global config Kept sections: - Complete Examples - Tutorial-style setup guide (recently cleaned up) Result: 711 → 553 lines (trimmed 158 lines) The guide now focuses on getting started, concepts, and step-by-step tutorials. Detailed SDK patterns belong in docs/sdk/infrastructure/mcp-client.mdx. Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.5 <[email protected]>
…reamline setup instructions
|
Please revert |
|
@claude review the comments and code but avoid reviewing anything related to docs/package-lock.json. |
|
Claude finished @kovtcharov-amd's task —— View job PR Review Complete
SummaryThis is a well-structured PR that adds MCP client support to GAIA. The implementation follows GAIA patterns well and has good test coverage. Most of the previous review comments from @kovtcharov have been addressed. Code Quality: 🟢 GoodStrengths
Minor Issues🟡 HTTP Transport Not Exposed (
🟡 Hardcoded Version ( "version": "0.15.2"
🟢 Console Print Fallback (
Outstanding Review CommentsBased on the review thread, these items from @kovtcharov may still need attention:
Test Coverage: 🟢 Good
Documentation: 🟢 Well-Documented
The ASCII diagram in the spec ( RecommendationApprove with minor suggestions:
|
…aia-agents-to-any-mcp-server' into 203-mcp-client-support-connect-gaia-agents-to-any-mcp-server
…t-connect-gaia-agents-to-any-mcp-server
## Summary - Add release notes for v0.15.4 documenting MCP client support and other enhancements - Bump version from 0.15.3.2 to 0.15.4 ## Context The release notes commit was made after PR #277 (MCP Client Support) was merged and needs to be brought into main separately. ## Changes - `docs/releases/v0.15.4.mdx` — new release notes page - `docs/docs.json` — add v0.15.4 to navigation - `src/gaia/version.py` — bump version to 0.15.4 --------- Co-authored-by: Kalin Ovtcharov <[email protected]>

Summary
Adds MCP (Model Context Protocol) client support to GAIA, enabling agents to connect to and consume tools from external MCP servers.
Key Features
gaia mcp client add/remove/list/testfor managing MCP server connectionsChanges
src/gaia/mcp/client/module with MCPClient, MCPClientManager, and transport implementationssrc/gaia/agents/base/mcp_client_mixin.pyfor agent integrationsrc/gaia/cli.pyfor MCP client managementexamples/mcp_config_based_agent.pyandexamples/mcp_multi_server_agent.pytests/unit/mcp/client/andtests/mcp/docs/guides/mcp-client.mdx,docs/sdk/infrastructure/mcp-client.mdx, anddocs/spec/mcp-client.mdxTest Plan
🤖 Generated with Claude Code