Skip to content

[Question] HumanInTheLoop 没法扩展么? #4091

Open

Description

@1135092871

Question

// Add hook nodes for afterModel hooks for (Hook hook : afterModelHooks) { if (hook instanceof ModelHook modelHook) { if (hook instanceof HumanInTheLoopHook humanInTheLoopHook) { graph.addNode(Hook.getFullHookName(hook) + ".afterModel", humanInTheLoopHook); } else { graph.addNode(Hook.getFullHookName(hook) + ".afterModel", modelHook::afterModel); } } else if (hook instanceof MessagesModelHook messagesModelHook) { graph.addNode(Hook.getFullHookName(hook) + ".afterModel", MessagesModelHook.afterModelAction(messagesModelHook)); } }
ReactAgent的人机协作这里,完全写死了啊,我都没法自定义一个其他能中断的hook,人机协作又不是只有工具同意拒绝这种

Activity

  1. changed the title [-][Question][/-] [+][Question] HumanInTheLoop 没法扩展么?[/+] on Jan 19, 2026
  2. 1135092871 commented on Jan 19, 2026

    @1135092871
    Author

    这里ReactAgent构建图时,普通的 ModelHook 处理,只注册了 afterModel 方法,HumanInTheLoopHook又是私有构造方法,压根没法继承。毫无扩展可言

  3. yuluo-yx commented on Jan 19, 2026

    @yuluo-yx
    Collaborator

    可以把你的需求详细描述下,社区同学会跟进

  4. 1135092871 commented on Jan 20, 2026

    @1135092871
    Author

    我想在Agent里实现一个询问用户的人机协作hook,但是发现ReactAgent构建图时,这个hook,要么instanceof HumanInTheLoopHook,要么就只能注册AfterModel方法,没法在ReactAgent自定义一个可中断的hook。所以我现在想要实现询问用户的人机协作,就只能提供一个askUser的工具,将HumanInTheLoopHook,approveOn,塞这个工具名,实现中断,重传的时候将用户回答放在RunableConfig里,在工具的ToolContext里拿到,通过工具响应返回用户回答。这样实现就很麻烦

  5. n4oworld commented on Jan 21, 2026

    @n4oworld

    如果不是工具,可以参考官网的 https://java2ai.com/docs/frameworks/graph-core/examples/human-in-the-loop 。

    InterruptionMetadata 模式:可以在任意节点随时中断,通过实现 InterruptableAction 接口来控制中断时机

  6. 1135092871 commented on Jan 21, 2026

    @1135092871
    Author

    问题是我现在想在ReactAgent构造的图里面实现中断,现在除了HumanInTheLoopHook,其他的只是注册了afterModel方法,就算实现了InterruptableAction,我也没法注入进ReactAgent里诶

  7. n4oworld commented on Jan 22, 2026

    @n4oworld

    不太懂你的意思,我是用graph编排我的流程,然后我某个节点实现了InterruptableAction 。这个流程里面有N个LLM节点,agent.asNode就可以把reactAgent转成节点,官网有示例。 如果是单个agent里面的,让agent构造图不太懂这个,但我理解的如果让agent自行编排的话,这时候应该就是调用工具了,所以就可以用上工具的中断。

  8. 1135092871 commented on Jan 22, 2026

    @1135092871
    Author

    我想的是能够在ReactAgent这个单agent里自定义我想要的中断的hook,但是目前这里只允许HumanInTheLoopHook,其他只是注册aftermodel方法。

    for (Hook hook : afterModelHooks) {
     			if (hook instanceof ModelHook modelHook) {
    			if (hook instanceof HumanInTheLoopHook humanInTheLoopHook) {
    				graph.addNode(Hook.getFullHookName(hook) + ".afterModel", humanInTheLoopHook);
    				} else {
    					graph.addNode(Hook.getFullHookName(hook) + ".afterModel", modelHook::afterModel);
    				}
    			} else if (hook instanceof MessagesModelHook messagesModelHook) {
    				graph.addNode(Hook.getFullHookName(hook) + ".afterModel", MessagesModelHook.afterModelAction(messagesModelHook));
    			}
    		}
    

    我期望的是这样,有一个中断抽象类,在ReactAgent构建图时,判断这个中断抽象类,然后HumanInTheLoopHook和我自定义的Hook都继承这个抽象类,这样我就能在ReactAgent里自定义中断hook了。
    代码如下

    public abstract class InterruptableHook extends ModelHook implements AsyncNodeActionWithConfig, InterruptableAction {
    
    	@Override
    	public CompletableFuture<Map<String, Object>> apply(OverAllState state, RunnableConfig config) {
    		return afterModel(state, config);
    	}
    
    }
    
    // Add hook nodes for afterModel hooks
    		for (Hook hook : afterModelHooks) {
    			if (hook instanceof ModelHook modelHook) {
    				if (hook instanceof InterruptableHook interruptableHook) {
    					graph.addNode(Hook.getFullHookName(hook) + ".afterModel", interruptableHook);
    				} else {
    					graph.addNode(Hook.getFullHookName(hook) + ".afterModel", modelHook::afterModel);
    				}
    			} else if (hook instanceof MessagesModelHook messagesModelHook) {
    				graph.addNode(Hook.getFullHookName(hook) + ".afterModel", MessagesModelHook.afterModelAction(messagesModelHook));
    			}
    		}
    
    @HookPositions(HookPosition.AFTER_MODEL)
    public class HumanInTheLoopHook extends InterruptableHook {
    	private static final Logger log = LoggerFactory.getLogger(HumanInTheLoopHook.class);
        public static final String HITL_NODE_NAME = "HITL";
    	private Map<String, ToolConfig> approvalOn;
    
    	private HumanInTheLoopHook(Builder builder) {
    		this.approvalOn = new HashMap<>(builder.approvalOn);
    	}
    
    	public static Builder builder() {
    		return new Builder();
    	}
    
  9. wow-blacksheep commented on Mar 22, 2026

    @wow-blacksheep

    我理解你的问题,我在自定义HumanInTheLoopHook时也遇到了这样的问题,即使实现了InterruptableAction也不能进入中断流程自定义方法。请问你现在是怎么解决的呢?

  10. Easy0ne commented on Apr 9, 2026

    @Easy0ne

    不太懂你的意思,我是用graph编排我的流程,然后我某个节点实现了InterruptableAction 。这个流程里面有N个LLM节点,agent.asNode就可以把reactAgent转成节点,官网有示例。 如果是单个agent里面的,让agent构造图不太懂这个,但我理解的如果让agent自行编排的话,这时候应该就是调用工具了,所以就可以用上工具的中断。

    我也是用graph编排+中断对话工具来做对话式的HITL,我使用spring-ai-alibaba-studio来搞的,agent是有resume接口来做中断恢复的,graph只有一个run接口,没有resume接口。请问你是自己定义resume接口的吗?

  11. nfzsh commented on Apr 16, 2026

    @nfzsh

    应该检查AsyncNodeActionWithConfig,而不是instanceof HumanInTheLoopHook,这样永远无法自行扩展,如果觉得没问题我可以提个pr改一下 @yuluo-yx

  12. ItDage commented on May 6, 2026

    @ItDage

    我现在是用相同包名进行重写的

  13. Huberychina commented on May 28, 2026

    @Huberychina

    我理解你的问题,我在自定义HumanInTheLoopHook时也遇到了这样的问题,即使实现了InterruptableAction也不能进入中断流程自定义方法。请问你现在是怎么解决的呢?

    这个问题希望有人跟进一下,无法扩展,传的是个lambda,进不去分支条件

  14. 1135092871 commented on May 28, 2026

    @1135092871
    Author

    我们现在也是重写处理了,他们这块设计的太僵硬了

  15. March-77 commented on Jul 24, 2026

    @March-77
    Contributor

    已提交修复 PR #4848。根因是 ReactAgent 只对内置 InterruptionHook / HumanInTheLoopHook 保留原 hook 对象,其他 ModelHook 会被包装成 modelHook::beforeModel/afterModel 方法引用,导致原对象实现的 InterruptableAction 能力丢失。修复改为基于现有 AsyncNodeActionWithConfig + InterruptableAction 接口能力注册,不新增公共 API;自定义 after-model hook 的真实中断回归测试已覆盖。agent-framework 全量结果:591 tests、0 failures、167 个环境条件跳过,Checkstyle/Spotless 通过。

  16. silent1995 commented on Aug 26, 2026

    @silent1995

    @Easy0ne 好像是得自己写,studio中没有对于graph的resume的处理。可以提个需求

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions