Skip to content

Commit fa8dfef

Browse files
committed
Phase 3 closure summary: 6 batches, +257L foundation, §5 disposed
Documents Phase 3 completion per supervisor 01:02:46Z + theologian 01:01:50Z Tier 8 spec adoption. All 6 batches landed + pushed: B1 c905827 +140L PhxHirBuilderState foundation B2 1343895 +80L exception_table_ Class B-kept closure B3 b92d85e -13L pending_b2_blocks_ DEAD-STATE delete B4 b44a514 +27L block_map_ Class B-kept closure B5 782d56d +9L static_method_stack_ rename B6 7971941 +14L temps_ rename + §5 forcing-decision COMPLETE NET cumulative: +257L (foundation cost; transitional per pythia python#103 + Tier 8 spec). §5 forcing-decision endpoint: 4 Class B-kept + 1 dead-deleted. Honest framing: keep-bias is DESIGN CHOICE (architectural decision, not deferral); Tier 8 pilot validates migrate-arm by porting one Class B field to pure C. Document covers: batch ledger + §5 endpoint + 9-bridge foundation surface + falsifier infrastructure landed in-flight (W44 + W45 §1-2 + W45 §3.5) + per-bench floor 4-criterion + Tier 8 pilot scheduling + cross-links to specs + pythia checkpoints + MEMORY.md ZERO-C++ terminal goal. Authorization: supervisor 01:02:46Z post-Batch-6 closure summary directive. Theologian §5 spec amendment ("keep-bias as design choice + Tier 8 migrate-arm pilot scheduled") pending in parallel.
1 parent 7971941 commit fa8dfef

1 file changed

Lines changed: 130 additions & 0 deletions

File tree

Lines changed: 130 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,130 @@
1+
# Tier 7 Phase 3 — Closure Summary
2+
3+
**Status:** PHASE 3 COMPLETE 2026-04-24. All 6 batches landed + pushed
4+
to SonicField/cpython phoenix-asm-integration. Per-batch dual-arch +
5+
per-bench floor + W45 §3.5 BUILD MODE all green.
6+
7+
**Phase 3 design choice (per pythia #103 + theologian 00:59:37Z +
8+
supervisor 00:59:39Z):** Class B-kept is a TRANSITIONAL disposition,
9+
not the final shape. Bridge surface paid as Phase 3 foundation cost;
10+
Tier 8 pilot validates the migrate-arm by porting one Class B field
11+
to pure C (per docs/tier8-class-b-cport-migrate-arm-spec.md).
12+
13+
---
14+
15+
## Batch ledger
16+
17+
| Batch | Commit | NET | Description |
18+
|-------|--------|-----|-------------|
19+
| 1 | c905827742 | +140L | PhxHirBuilderState foundation + parseExceptionTable port + 3 bridges |
20+
| 2 | 1343895045 | +80L | findExceptionHandler port + exception_table_ Class B-kept closure (read+write bridges) |
21+
| 3 | b92d85e751 | -13L | pending_b2_blocks_ DEAD-STATE delete (no writers post-W26 refactor) |
22+
| 4 | b44a5143cc | +27L | block_map_ Class B-kept closure (blocks_lookup_cpp + hir_c_api rewire) |
23+
| 5 | 782d56d0c6 | +9L | static_method_stack_ rename _pop_c → _pop_cpp (consistency) |
24+
| 6 | 7971941afe | +14L | temps_ alloc_stack rename (75-site sed) — all 5 Class B disposed |
25+
26+
**Cumulative NET: +257L** (foundation cost).
27+
28+
**Push count:** 18 → 24 today; full session 4 + 24 = 28 push events
29+
across the multi-day workstream (inclusive of pre-Phase 3 Phase 1
30+
burndown + W44/W45/§3.5 falsifier infra).
31+
32+
## §5 forcing-decision endpoint
33+
34+
All 5 Class B HirBuilder members disposed:
35+
36+
| Member | Disposition | Closure mechanism |
37+
|--------|-------------|--------------------|
38+
| `exception_table_` (std::vector) | CLOSED via Batch 2 | 4 bridges: push_cpp + size_cpp + entry_cpp + find_c (read+write) |
39+
| `block_map_` (std::unordered_map ×2) | CLOSED via Batch 4 | 1 bridge: blocks_lookup_cpp + hir_c_api rewire |
40+
| `pending_b2_blocks_` (std::vector) | DELETED via Batch 3 | dead-state, zero writers post-W26 refactor |
41+
| `static_method_stack_` (jit::Stack) | CLOSED via Batch 5 | rename to _cpp convention |
42+
| `temps_` (TempAllocator) | CLOSED via Batch 6 | rename + 73-site mechanical sed |
43+
44+
§5 keep-bias is a DESIGN CHOICE (architectural decision, not deferral).
45+
PhxArray-equivalent C-port for std::vector / unordered_map / Stack /
46+
TempAllocator is multi-session-per-container scope; bridging at the
47+
opaque-pointer surface is the tractable Phase 3 endpoint.
48+
49+
## Foundation surface (carried to Tier 8)
50+
51+
7 _cpp bridges shipped across B1–B6:
52+
53+
1. `hir_builder_state_init` (B1 ctor)
54+
2. `hir_builder_state_parse_exception_table_c` (B1 algorithm)
55+
3. `hir_builder_state_exception_table_push_cpp` (B1 write)
56+
4. `hir_builder_state_exception_table_size_cpp` (B2 read)
57+
5. `hir_builder_state_exception_table_entry_cpp` (B2 read)
58+
6. `hir_builder_state_find_exception_handler_c` (B2 algorithm)
59+
7. `hir_builder_state_block_map_blocks_lookup_cpp` (B4 read)
60+
8. `hir_builder_state_static_method_stack_pop_cpp` (B5 read)
61+
9. `hir_builder_state_temps_alloc_stack_cpp` (B6 alloc)
62+
63+
PhxHirBuilderState struct: 5 Class A members (code, preloader,
64+
current_func, func, kwnames). Class B members not in struct (kept C++
65+
behind opaque-access via the 7 _cpp bridges).
66+
67+
## Falsifier infrastructure landed in-flight
68+
69+
- **W44 caller-gate** (pre-Phase 3): DO-NOT-USE marker enforcement.
70+
- **W45 §1–§2 bridge-sig falsifier** (pre-Phase 3): signature mutation +
71+
build-fail verifier. 15/15 fixtures cover Phase 1 #2#7 + Phase 3
72+
Batches 1, 2, 4, 5, 6 bridges.
73+
- **W45 §3.5 derivation-drift falsifier** (mid-Phase 3, bfc6321b77):
74+
4 fixtures (BEFORE_ASYNC_WITH + _Py_ID + ExceptionTableEntry.depth +
75+
block_map_blocks_lookup_cpp return-type). Integrated as
76+
gate_phoenix.sh Step 1g (eb3cdf3f54), BUILD MODE per push for
77+
builder*.{cpp,h,c} touch.
78+
- **§3.5 5/5 backstop:** triggered post-Batch 4 land per
79+
supervisor 23:49:22Z; impl shipped same workstream.
80+
81+
## Per-bench floor (spec §6 #9 amendment)
82+
83+
4-criterion floor enforced per commit:
84+
85+
1. geo-mean ≥ 1.0x
86+
2. geo-mean drop ≤ 5% same-session
87+
3. no single bench drops > 20% same-session
88+
4. no single bench < 0.5x absolute
89+
90+
Phase 3 series: 1.27x → 1.29x → 1.28x → 1.26x → 1.29x → 1.26x. Net
91+
geo-mean change ≈ -1% across 6 batches; well within noise floor;
92+
zero floor violations.
93+
94+
## Tier 8 pilot scheduled
95+
96+
Per `docs/tier8-class-b-cport-migrate-arm-spec.md` (theologian
97+
01:01:50Z, supervisor 01:02:46Z ADOPTED):
98+
99+
- Pilot field: `exception_table_` (POD-equivalent per Phase 3 §2.2;
100+
4 bridges → 0 on full port to PhxArray).
101+
- Acceptance criterion #10: pilot must net-subtract ≥ +257L of Phase 3
102+
foundation cost (validates "transitional cost paid back" framing
103+
vs "permanent scaffold").
104+
- Estimated pilot subtraction: ~-150L (4 bridge impls + 4 decls +
105+
C++ struct/field/shims). Brings Phase 3 + Tier 8 cumulative from
106+
+257L to ~+107L.
107+
- Full Tier 8 across all 4 Class B containers projects net-negative
108+
vs Phase 3 foundation.
109+
110+
## Cross-link
111+
112+
- Phase 3 spec: `docs/tier7-phase3-hirbuilder-state-extraction-spec.md`
113+
(theologian 22:59:11Z, supervisor 22:59:54Z + 23:00:15Z amendments)
114+
- §5 amendment: pending theologian post-this-summary edit ("keep-bias
115+
as design choice + Tier 8 migrate-arm pilot scheduled" — replaces
116+
withdrawn "FINAL" framing per pythia #103)
117+
- Tier 8 spec: `docs/tier8-class-b-cport-migrate-arm-spec.md`
118+
(theologian 01:01:50Z, supervisor 01:02:46Z ADOPTED)
119+
- W44: `scripts/check_do_not_use_callers.sh`,
120+
`docs/w44-do-not-use-callers-gate.md`
121+
- W45: `scripts/w45_bridge_drift_falsifier.sh`,
122+
`scripts/w45_section_3_5_derivation_drift.sh`,
123+
`docs/w45-bridge-signature-drift-falsifier.md` (§§1–2 + §2.5/§2.7)
124+
- Pythia checkpoints: #89 (Phase 3 spec gate), #90/#91 (W45 trigger),
125+
#92 (cross-post storm), #93 (block_map writer-grep + per-bench
126+
floor + §3.5 trigger amendments), #94 (per-bench mechanized untested
127+
+ §5 keep-bias risk), #103 (cathedral-scaffold six-month-regret +
128+
Tier 8 migrate-arm pilot demand)
129+
- MEMORY.md terminal goal: ZERO C++ — Phase 3 is foundation toward,
130+
not satisfaction of

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)