Repository navigation
Closed as not planned
Description
Why
Founder lock 2026-08-19: role-first.
Org chart (#198) and channel roles (#116) both answer “who does this work?” and overlap. Oscar has not used the Org chart. Channel roles match how work actually happens (per room). Call-by-name CoS (sibling) needs channel roles for what a named person may do — not a company poster.
This is a discussion / decision issue, not a delete-and-ship work order. No production deletion until a decision entry supersedes D-060’s product surface (or explicitly keeps the protocol and hides UI only).
Locked
- Role-first (A): Channel role = “what work is allowed in this room” + tool walls (D-043 / D-044).
- Call by name, not by role (sibling call/wake issue).
- CoS may prototype small; feature work must go to a named specialist (e.g. Dev).
- Factory-as-code stays discussion.
- Do not implement founder Inbox Wake as the recovery product.
Two layers today (overlap)
| Question | Channel role (#116) | Org roster (#198) |
|---|---|---|
| In this room, who may code / write? | Yes | No |
| Who may CoS call? | Names of holders (product) | Manager-chain for crew-handoff auto-create |
| Budget brake | No | Yes |
| Chart UI | No | Yes (unused) |
Proposed direction (not yet a DECISIONS.md entry)
- Invest in channel roles (intake CoS, code Dev, hard capabilities).
- Hide or demote Org chart UI (Settings / advanced). Hiding ≠ deleting 30680.
- Keep
KIND_ORG_ROSTER+ budget +crew-handoffdormant until we know whether the money brake is still needed. - Do not make manager-chain the thing Oscar must draw before the company works. Calling
@Devby name is enough for day-one.
Officer loop in docs/crew/HERMES.md (ORG-CHECK, crew-office) is tied to the tree — must be rewritten to “CoS of this channel” or dropped if the chart goes away. Surface that conflict; do not silently pick.
Questions to answer before implementation
- Hide Org UI only, or also stop requiring 30680 for any happy path?
- Does
crew-handoffstay (named call + optional handoff tag) or does plain mention replace kickoff? - Where do budgets live if the tree is dormant?
Explicit non-goals
- Paperclip-style ticket org
- Rewriting mobile to React Native
- Board-as-home (D-037)
Related
- Agent roles: owner-assigned role per agent, channel routing presets, role-scoped capability #116, Org hierarchy: founder-signed roster with relay-validated tree — top-down kickoff gate, budget cascade, flat peer flow, org chart as projection #198, D-043, D-044, D-060
- Sibling: agent-to-agent call by name
- PR docs(crew): role-first CoS; remove unused Org (planning) #228
Metadata
Metadata
Assignees
Labels
No labels
Activity
docs(crew): lock Org product removal in feature 0002
oscarlehuu commentedon Aug 19, 2026
Superseded by #233 (remove unused Org product).
feat(workflows): add workflow editor (block#6248)