Skip to content

PostgreSQL Domain Expert Review #4

@NikolayS

Description

@NikolayS

Expert: Senior PostgreSQL DBA / Internals Consultant

Scope

Validate SPEC.md's PostgreSQL-specific claims, diagnostic queries (FR-9), backslash command behavior (FR-3), and psql output fidelity.

Deliverables

  • Audit all 12+ \dba diagnostic queries for correctness across PG 12-18
  • Validate backslash command output format matches real psql (character-by-character)
  • Identify pg_catalog views that changed between PG 12-18 (breaking compatibility)
  • Review pg_ash investigation chain methodology — does it follow real DBA workflow?
  • Validate autonomy protocols: would a senior DBA trust these actions?
  • Identify missing diagnostics that experienced DBAs rely on
  • Review connection pooler compatibility claims (pgBouncer, PgCat, Supavisor)
  • Validate vacuum/bloat detection methodology and thresholds
  • Review index health assessment criteria (unused, redundant, invalid, bloated)

Context

This review ensures Samo earns DBA trust. Every diagnostic query must be production-correct, every psql behavior must match expectations.

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    phase-0Phase 0: psql replacementphase-1Phase 1: beyond psqlspec-reviewSPEC review and analysis

    Projects

    No projects

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions