Skip to content

Conversation

@dcousens
Copy link

@dcousens dcousens commented Sep 5, 2016

Call sites:

src/main.cpp:3508:    if (block.nBits != GetNextWorkRequired(pindexPrev, &block, consensusParams))
src/miner.cpp:71:        pblock->nBits = GetNextWorkRequired(pindexPrev, pblock, consensusParams);
src/miner.cpp:188:    pblock->nBits          = GetNextWorkRequired(pindexPrev, pblock, chainparams.GetConsensus());

Assumptions of not NULL in same code blocks:

src/miner.cpp:64: int64_t nNewTime = std::max(pindexPrev->GetMedianTimePast()+1, GetAdjustedTime());
src/miner.cpp:186: pblock->hashPrevBlock  = pindexPrev->GetBlockHash();

That, including what you've already done, eliminates the need for this.
AFAIK.

@NicolasDorier NicolasDorier merged this pull request into NicolasDorier:fixup Sep 5, 2016
@dcousens dcousens deleted the patch-1 branch September 5, 2016 12:48
NicolasDorier pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Aug 3, 2017
c521b3ac6 Merge bitcoin#11: fixup define checks. Cleans up some oopses from bitcoin#5.
8b1cd3753 fixup define checks. Cleans up some oopses from bitcoin#5.
6b1508d6d Merge bitcoin#6: Fixes typo
fceb80542 Merge bitcoin#10: Clean up compile-time warnings (gcc 7.1)
0ec2a343f Clean up compile-time warnings (gcc 7.1)
d4c268a35 Merge bitcoin#5: Move helper functions out of sse4.2 object
8d4eb0847 Add HasAcceleratedCRC32C to port_win.h
77cfbfd25 crc32: move helper functions out of port_posix_sse.cc
4c1e9e016 silence compiler warnings about uninitialized variables
495316485 Merge bitcoin#2: Prefer std::atomic over MemoryBarrier
2953978ef Fixes typo
f134284a1 Merge #1: Merge upstream LevelDB 1.20
ba8a445fd Prefer std::atomic over MemoryBarrier

git-subtree-dir: src/leveldb
git-subtree-split: c521b3ac654cfbe009c575eacf7e5a6e189bb5bb
NicolasDorier pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Mar 5, 2018
…tion

d31e5c1 Fix shutdown in case of errors during initialization (Wladimir J. van der Laan)

Pull request description:

  PR bitcoin#10286 introduced a few steps which are not robust to early shutdown in initialization.

  Stumbled upon this with bitcoin#11781, not sure if there are other scenarios that can trigger it, but it's good to harden against this in any case.

  E.g.
  ```
  $ src/bitcoind  -debuglogfile=/dfdf
  Error: Could not open debug log file /dfdf
  Program received signal SIGSEGV, Segmentation fault.
  UnregisterValidationInterface (pwalletIn=0x0) at /.../bitcoin/src/validationinterface.cpp:82
  82          g_signals.m_internals->BlockChecked.disconnect(boost::bind(&CValidationInterface::BlockChecked, pwalletIn, _1, _2));
  (gdb) bt
  #0  UnregisterValidationInterface (pwalletIn=0x0) at /.../bitcoin/src/validationinterface.cpp:82
  #1  0x00005555555a11fc in Shutdown () at /.../bitcoin/src/init.cpp:196
  bitcoin#2  0x00005555555961cc in AppInit (argc=<optimized out>, argv=<optimized out>) at /.../bitcoin/src/bitcoind.cpp:183
  bitcoin#3  0x0000555555596249 in main (argc=0, argv=0x555555ecf200) at /.../bitcoin/src/bitcoind.cpp:19
  ```

Tree-SHA512: 7dd9570a9803514a17781bfadf1edde47e96df4e852cce2f423cab422e005fb94d44e777af1a6ea5167b04a4d889e848ae7a61a7e0e94232247ddea32ee70fc8
NicolasDorier pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Jun 20, 2019
…sync as non-deterministic

c061be1 tests: Mark unit test blockfilter_index_initial_sync as non-deterministic (practicalswift)

Pull request description:

  Mark unit test `blockfilter_index_tests/blockfilter_index_initial_sync` as non-deterministic.

  Before this PR:

  ```
  $ contrib/devtools/test_deterministic_coverage.sh 500
  [2019-06-04 09:58:57] Measuring coverage, run #1 of 500
  [2019-06-04 10:00:33] Measuring coverage, run bitcoin#2 of 500
  [2019-06-04 10:02:19] Measuring coverage, run bitcoin#3 of 500

  The line coverage is non-deterministic between runs. Exiting.

  The test suite must be deterministic in the sense that the set of lines executed at least
  once must be identical between runs. This is a necessary condition for meaningful
  coverage measuring.

  --- gcovr.run-1.txt     2019-06-04 10:00:33.389059973 +0000
  +++ gcovr.run-3.txt     2019-06-04 10:03:45.619491207 +0000
  @@ -72,7 +72,7 @@
   hash.h                                        54      33    61%   71,74-77,82,85-89,111,113,128,147-148,175,178-181
   httprpc.cpp                                  120       3     2%   31,34-35,38-40,46,49,52,54,56,58,70,73-74,76,78-79,81,83-84,89,91,94-95,97,99-101,103,106-107,111-112,117-119,121-122,125,128,130,132,134-136,138-139,142,145,148,151-153,156-160,163-166,171,173-175,180-182,185,187,189-190,192,195,198-199,201,203-204,212,215,217,219-222,224,227-228,230,232,237,239-240,243-245,247-251,254,256,259,261-264,266-267 [* 205-206,208-209]
   httpserver.cpp                               312       6     1%   46,49-50,53,55,80-81,90,92-93,96-98,101,104,106-109,111-112,114,118,120-122,126,128-129,153,155,157-158,164,166-178,180,182,184-188,192,194-196,198-199,201-202,204-205,207-208,213,216-221,225,228-232,236-239,243-244,247-254,256-258,264-267,270-271,274,279,281-282,286,288-290,292-293,297,299-300,303-307,309-310,312-317,322-328,330,332,335,339,341-342,346,352-353,355,358,360,364,368-369,375,378,381-384,388-391,393-394,398-400,402,404-406,409,411-412,414,416,426,428-431,433-434,438,440-441,443,445-446,449,451-455,457-459,463-464,466-469,471-473,475-477,479,482,484,487,490-493,496-497,499-500,502,504,506,508-509,511,513-514,517,519,521-522,527,529-533,535,538,540-543,550-555,558,560-562,570,572-574,577-582,585-590,594-597,600,602-604,606-609,611,614,616,619,621,625-626,628-629,631-632,634-635,640,642-643,646,648-651,653,655-656
  -index/base.cpp                               149      94    63%   20,22-25,28,66,98,102-103,117-118,140-141,145-146,155,163,175,177-178,181-182,184-185,200-201,203,212,214-215,219-221,228-229,234,236,240,243-244,247-249,258-260,262,270,292-294,308-309 [* 263]
  +index/base.cpp                               149      97    65%   20,22-25,28,66,98,102-103,117-118,140-141,145-146,155,163,175,177-178,181-182,184-185,200-201,203,212,214-215,219-221,228-229,234,236,240,243-244,247-249,258-260,262,270,308-309 [* 263]
   index/base.h                                   3       2    66%   77
   index/blockfilterindex.cpp                   199     134    67%   70,79,81,84-88,91,122,139,142,179-181,184-185,188-189,193-194,201-202,207,233,258,262-263,265-266,268,271-272,274,277,279,284,286,288-289,294,301-302,304,322,329,332-333,350,371,373,438,440-441,444,446,449,455-456,459,461,464,466 [* 162-163]
   index/blockfilterindex.h                       4       4   100%
  @@ -358,7 +358,7 @@
   util/validation.cpp                            5       1    20%   12,15-17
   validation.cpp                              2167     808    37%   291,293,297-300,302,330,332,340,348,355-357,359,362,364-365,368,371,380,382-383,385-386,388-389,396,398-402,406-413,415,417,419,422-425,439-440,442-443,446,449,455-458,461-464,467,469-470,472,474,476,492,494-495,502-503,505-507,511-513,515,517,523,526,528,533,535,540,542-544,550,552-556,558-560,564,574,578-583,586,590-591,594-596,601-602,607-608,611-612,616-617,619-621,635-636,638,640,647-648,651,657-658,660-662,665-667,673,675,677-678,682-683,690,693,700-701,703-705,709-710,713-714,716,719-720,724-727,733-735,737-739,741-743,747-748,751-752,754,757-764,771,773-774,776-779,785-788,793-794,796-800,815-816,818-822,825,827,830,835,838-839,841-843,846-848,850,853,859,864-867,875,877-879,884-885,887-891,895,899-900,904-906,908-909,911,930-931,933,936,942,944-950,952,959,962,965-968,972,978,982-984,990-991,994-996,999,1003-1004,1011,1013,1015-1019,1022-1023,1026-1032,1056,1065,1079,1091,1108,1112,1114-1118,1125,1127-1130,1133-1135,1138-1139,1147,1149,1151-1152,1155,1197,1199-1201,1206-1209,1211-1212,1226,1230,1232-1234,1236,1238-1241,1245-1246,1256,1258,1260-1262,1264-1266,1268,1278-1280,1282-1283,1286,1289,1291-1292,1294-1302,1305-1311,1319-1323,1330,1332-1333,1336-1339,1379,1383-1384,1395,1401,1405-1407,1411-1414,1423-1428,1438-1440,1451,1455,1458,1471,1480,1497,1503,1519,1525,1527-1530,1532-1533,1536,1538-1539,1549,1551,1553,1555,1559-1562,1571,1573,1578,1580,1582-1584,1588-1589,1594-1597,1601-1606,1613-1616,1619-1623,1630,1632,1635,1637,1639-1640,1642-1646,1658,1660,1675,1688,1711,1713-1715,1742,1755,1760,1765,1769,1811,1815,1817,1841-1845,1855,1942,1946-1947,1956,1984-1986,1991-1992,1994,1996-1999,2005-2007,2010-2012,2022-2023,2028-2031,2038-2039,2042,2044,2049,2058-2061,2064,2114-2115,2117-2118,2120-2124,2152-2153,2156,2159-2163,2165-2169,2171-2172,2176-2178,2187-2188,2191-2194,2199,2207-2211,2215-2220,2224,2227-2230,2235,2237-2238,2261-2263,2265,2274,2278,2286,2301,2303-2304,2306-2309,2311,2313-2318,2320,2322,2325,2327-2328,2330,2332-2334,2338,2340,2343-2344,2407-2410,2430,2445-2447,2507-2509,2511-2514,2518,2520-2521,2523-2524,2561,2564,2590,2592-2593,2595-2598,2603,2620,2626,2658,2719,2724,2773,2776-2777,2779,2781,2783,2785-2788,2791,2793-2795,2799,2801-2802,2805,2807-2809,2813,2816,2818-2821,2825-2826,2832-2834,2841-2845,2848,2854,2858-2859,2861,2865-2868,2872-2875,2880,2884-2885,2890-2891,2894-2895,2897,2900-2906,2908,2910,2912,2918-2922,2924,2928-2929,2940,3002-3005,3009-3010,3026-3028,3036-3037,3039-3040,3045,3053,3056,3077,3080,3090,3112,3118,3129,3133,3135-3136,3141-3142,3150,3190-3193,3259,3268,3273,3277,3282-3285,3303,3314,3321-3324,3338-3341,3345-3346,3348-3350,3360,3372,3392,3397,3403,3406,3408,3435-3441,3443,3468-3469,3485,3487-3488,3492-3493,3534-3536,3542,3547-3549,3552,3565-3566,3601-3602,3610,3628,3630,3632,3645,3647,3649-3651,3653,3657,3659,3661-3669,3675-3680,3686-3687,3691,3693-3697,3702,3704,3706-3708,3711-3718,3720,3724,3726-3729,3748,3750-3752,3754,3758-3759,3763,3765,3767,3772,3774,3777-3778,3780-3781,3783,3787-3788,3790,3792-3794,3798-3800,3823,3825,3828,3830,3832,3836-3838,3841-3843,3845,3848,3850,3854-3856,3858-3859,3861-3862,3864-3867,3870-3873,3875-3876,3879,3882-3883,3886-3893,3899,3901,3905-3909,3911-3915,3922-3924,3926-3928,3931,3933-3934,3940-3942,3945-3947,3952,3954-3955,3957,3960-3961,3964,3966,3968-3972,3975,3977,3980,3982,3985,3987-3988,3992-3996,3998-4006,4008-4009,4011-4012,4014,4016,4019,4021-4022,4024-4026,4028-4032,4037-4041,4043-4045,4047,4050,4053-4054,4057,4060-4064,4066-4067,4069-4075,4079-4080,4086,4089-4091,4094-4097,4101,4106,4108,4110,4112-4114,4116-4117,4119,4121,4123-4124,4126,4128-4130,4132-4134,4138-4142,4144-4147,4154,4158-4163,4166-4169,4172-4173,4177,4179-4180,4183,4185,4187-4189,4191-4193,4195,4197-4201,4207-4208,4212,4220-4223,4230,4232-4233,4237,4240,4243,4247,4249,4251,4253-4255,4265-4266,4277,4279,4282,4285-4287,4292-4293,4296,4298,4302,4305-4306,4310-4311,4315-4318,4360,4363-4367,4370,4377,4397,4412,4415-4416,4418,4421-4422,4424,4426-4429,4433-4437,4439-4441,4448-4452,4454-4456,4458,4460,4462-4467,4471-4475,4477,4480-4481,4486-4488,4493,4496-4503,4505,4507-4511,4513-4514,4517-4519,4529-4531,4546,4600,4638-4639,4647,4653,4662-4664,4696,4703-4704,4718,4720,4723,4725,4727,4730,4732-4733,4736,4738-4739,4742,4744-4745,4750,4752-4757,4761-4765,4769-4770,4774-4776,4779-4781,4783-4785,4787-4790,4793-4794,4800-4801,4803,4807,4809-4810,4812-4813,4815-4816,4823,4827,4829,4831-4832,4834-4835,4838-4840,4842,4845,4848-4849,4853,4855-4856,4858-4863,4866-4872,4877,4891,4907 [* 1085-1086,1140-1141,1513-1514,2201-2202,2428,3569-3570,4400-4401,4442,4453,4504,4522-4523,4526-4527,4818-4819,4873-4874]
   validation.h                                  19       5    26%   338,350-352,356-363,366,484
  -validationinterface.cpp                       81      50    61%   78-82,85-86,112-113,116,119-120,123-124,126-128,130,133-136,151-153,163-165,169-171
  +validationinterface.cpp                       83      60    72%   78-82,85-86,112-113,116,133-136,151-153,163-165,169-171
   validationinterface.h                          9       4    44%   94,105,112,118,135
   versionbits.cpp                               92      27    29%   33,35-36,38-39,48-50,52-54,56-57,61-62,67-71,73,75-76,80,82-83,91,98,100,102-103,105,109-110,113-118,121-122,124,127,129-130,134,137,141,149,151,153-155,159,177,179,184,194,196,199,201,204,206 [* 26]
   versionbits.h                                  1       1   100%
  @@ -400,5 +400,5 @@
   zmq/zmqpublishnotifier.h                       5       0     0%   12,31,37,43,49
   zmq/zmqrpc.cpp                                23       3    13%   16,18,20,23,33-35,37,40-47,51,62,64-65
   ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  -TOTAL                                      52472    7784    14%
  +TOTAL                                      52474    7797    14%
   ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  $
  ```

  After this PR:

  ```
  $ contrib/devtools/test_deterministic_coverage.sh 500
  [2019-06-03 14:45:25] Measuring coverage, run #1 of 500
  [2019-06-03 14:48:15] Measuring coverage, run bitcoin#2 of 500
  [2019-06-03 14:50:49] Measuring coverage, run bitcoin#3 of 500
  [2019-06-03 14:52:20] Measuring coverage, run bitcoin#4 of 500
  [2019-06-03 14:53:49] Measuring coverage, run bitcoin#5 of 500
  …
  [2019-06-04 09:04:58] Measuring coverage, run bitcoin#496 of 500
  [2019-06-04 09:07:42] Measuring coverage, run bitcoin#497 of 500
  [2019-06-04 09:10:32] Measuring coverage, run bitcoin#498 of 500
  [2019-06-04 09:13:26] Measuring coverage, run bitcoin#499 of 500
  [2019-06-04 09:16:32] Measuring coverage, run bitcoin#500 of 500

  Coverage test passed: Deterministic coverage across 500 runs.
  $
  ```

ACKs for commit c061be:

Tree-SHA512: 00cd55b4371290d8587ab667c64249bc31d26cc9dc3dd519677eb91ddb9dbc5333dfbdef5e90c7a0d74eecd24757113e7ec3eda836859ddc033b1de715df81b6
NicolasDorier pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Jun 20, 2019
…est deterministic

f899580 tests: Make coins_tests/updatecoins_simulation_test deterministic (practicalswift)

Pull request description:

  Make `coins_tests/updatecoins_simulation_test` deterministic.

  Before:

  ```
  $ contrib/devtools/test_deterministic_coverage.sh 1000
  [2019-06-15 05:36:20] Measuring coverage, run #1 of 1000
  [2019-06-15 05:38:05] Measuring coverage, run bitcoin#2 of 1000
  [2019-06-15 05:39:49] Measuring coverage, run bitcoin#3 of 1000
  [2019-06-15 05:41:38] Measuring coverage, run bitcoin#4 of 1000
  [2019-06-15 05:43:16] Measuring coverage, run bitcoin#5 of 1000
  ...
  [2019-06-16 18:25:23] Measuring coverage, run bitcoin#880 of 1000
  [2019-06-16 18:27:12] Measuring coverage, run bitcoin#881 of 1000
  [2019-06-16 18:29:33] Measuring coverage, run bitcoin#882 of 1000
  [2019-06-16 18:33:00] Measuring coverage, run bitcoin#883 of 1000
  [2019-06-16 18:35:32] Measuring coverage, run bitcoin#884 of 1000

  The line coverage is non-deterministic between runs. Exiting.

  The test suite must be deterministic in the sense that the set of lines executed at least
  once must be identical between runs. This is a necessary condition for meaningful
  coverage measuring.

  --- gcovr.run-1.txt     2019-06-15 05:38:05.282359029 +0200
  +++ gcovr.run-884.txt   2019-06-16 18:37:23.518298374 +0200
  @@ -269,7 +269,7 @@
   test/bloom_tests.cpp                         320     320   100%
   test/bswap_tests.cpp                          13      13   100%
   test/checkqueue_tests.cpp                    223     222    99%   169
  -test/coins_tests.cpp                         478     472    98%   52,68,344-345,511,524
  +test/coins_tests.cpp                         478     474    99%   52,68,511,524
   test/compilerbug_tests.cpp                    18      18   100%
   test/compress_tests.cpp                       27      27   100%
   test/crypto_tests.cpp                        268     268   100%
  @@ -401,5 +401,5 @@
   zmq/zmqpublishnotifier.h                       5       0     0%   12,31,37,43,49
   zmq/zmqrpc.cpp                                23       3    13%   16,18,20,23,33-35,37,40-47,51,62,64-65
   ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  -TOTAL                                      53323   28305    53%
  +TOTAL                                      53323   28307    53%
   ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
  ```

  After:

  ```
  $ contrib/devtools/test_deterministic_coverage.sh 1000
  [2019-06-15 05:36:20] Measuring coverage, run #1 of 1000
  [2019-06-15 05:38:05] Measuring coverage, run bitcoin#2 of 1000
  [2019-06-15 05:39:49] Measuring coverage, run bitcoin#3 of 1000
  [2019-06-15 05:41:38] Measuring coverage, run bitcoin#4 of 1000
  [2019-06-15 05:43:16] Measuring coverage, run bitcoin#5 of 1000
  ...
  $
  ```

ACKs for commit f89958:
  MarcoFalke:
    ACK f899580 (checked that the randomness state of g_insecure_rand_ctx is the same after three test runs)

Tree-SHA512: 796d362b050c5750e351de1126b62f0f2c8e2d712cf01b6e1a3e2cc6ef92fa68439a32fc24c76d34bce4d553aee4ae4ea88a036c56eb9e25979649a19c59c3e5
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants