Document ID: COMP-001 Version: 1.3 Date: 2026-02-21 Classification: Public Status: Approved
← Back to Documentation Hub | Next: ISO 9001 Matrix →
This document provides an honest, auditable assessment of the Agile V Skills Library's compliance posture. It states clearly what the skills cover, what they do not cover, and what users must do themselves to achieve full certification against each claimed standard.
Non-certification statement: This Agile V profile supports structured qualification and validation evidence. It does not determine legal applicability, replace controlled procedures, provide technical Part 11 controls, or establish regulatory compliance.
Coverage labels: Where this posture describes coverage, a Markdown skill or JSON schema is at most a NORMATIVE CONTRACT or SCHEMA-BACKED artifact — not OPERATIONALLY EVIDENCED, RUNTIME-ENFORCED, or EXTERNALLY ASSESSED. See COMP-006 for the full label legend.
Two qualification scopes: Distinguish target-system qualification (the regulated product built with Agile V) from assurance-toolchain qualification (the Agile V skills + runtime + model configuration). These are separate scopes; qualify each independently.
The Agile V Skills Library v1.3 claims:
compliance: "ISO 9001 / ISO 27001 Aligned (Design Phase); GxP-Aware"
This means:
- ISO 9001 / ISO 27001 Aligned: The skills structurally implement the intent of these standards for the design and development phase. They are not a certification -- they are a framework that, when used within an organization's QMS, supports compliance.
- Design Phase: The skills cover requirements, design, synthesis, verification, and acceptance. They do NOT cover production, manufacturing, distribution, or post-market surveillance.
- GxP-Aware: The skills include controls relevant to GxP (decision logging, traceability, human gates, CAPA, revalidation). Intended-use validation is provided by
validation-agent(planning, protocol, report, deviation behavior) and is distinct fromred-team-verifierverification — the two are not conflated. Theagile-v-gxp-qualificationprofile (draft) adds schema-backed qualification-evidence contracts and treats DQ/IQ/OQ/PQ as evidence stages to which agents contribute (not agent names). The skills do NOT implement 21 CFR Part 11 electronic signatures or closed-system controls; these require organizational infrastructure.
| Capability | Standard Clauses Addressed | Skill(s) |
|---|---|---|
| Requirements decomposition and traceability | ISO 9001 8.2, 8.5; ISO 13485 7.3.2, 7.5.3; AS9100D 8.5.2 | requirement-architect, build-agent, compliance-auditor |
| Independent verification (Red Team Protocol) | ISO 9001 8.3; ISO 13485 7.3.5; AS9100D 8.3.4 | test-designer, red-team-verifier |
| Intended-use validation (distinct from verification) | ISO 13485 7.3.6; GxP / GAMP 5 | validation-agent |
| Qualification evidence stages (DQ/IQ/OQ/PQ; schema-backed, draft) | GxP / GAMP 5; ISO 13485 4.1.6 | agile-v-gxp-qualification |
| Human-in-the-loop approval gates | ISO 9001 5.1; ISO 13485 7.3.4; 21 CFR Part 11 (partial) | agile-v-core (Human Gates) |
| Decision logging with rationale | ISO 9001 7.5; Principle #9; GxP ALCOA+ | compliance-auditor |
| Automated Traceability Matrix | ISO 9001 8.5; ISO 13485 7.5.3; GxP | compliance-auditor |
| Change Request protocol | ISO 9001 8.3.5; ISO 13485 7.3.7; ISO 27001 A.8.32 | agile-v-core, requirement-architect, logic-gatekeeper |
| Risk register and assessment | ISO 9001 6.1; AS9100D 8.1.1 | agile-v-core |
| CAPA protocol | ISO 13485 8.5; ISO 9001 10.1-10.2 | agile-v-core, compliance-auditor |
| Document versioning and archival | ISO 9001 7.5; ISO 13485 4.2.4-4.2.5 | agile-v-core (Iteration Lifecycle) |
| Nonconformity disposition | ISO 9001 8.7; ISO 13485 8.3 | red-team-verifier |
| Quality metrics and KPIs | ISO 9001 9.1; AS9100D 9.1.1 | compliance-auditor |
| Secure coding practices | ISO 27001 A.8.28 | build-agent |
| LLM provider security controls | ISO 27001 A.5.23 | agile-v-core |
| Periodic review and revalidation | GxP / GAMP 5 | agile-v-core |
| Configuration management | ISO 27001 A.8.9; AS9100D 8.1.2 | agile-v-core (State Persistence) |
| Secure development lifecycle | ISO 27001 A.8.25-A.8.27 | agile-v-core (Pipeline), red-team-verifier |
"Independent verification" in this table means role-separated (
I2) verification per the Red Team Protocol. It is not automatically the authority-separated (I3) or organizationally independent (I4) assurance some clauses/regulated profiles require for higher risk levels; seedocs/agile-v-runtime/08_INDEPENDENCE_CLASSES.md.
These are organizational responsibilities that the skills cannot fulfill. Users must implement these independently.
| Gap | Why It's Out of Scope | Standards Affected |
|---|---|---|
| Production and manufacturing controls | Skills are a design-phase toolchain, not a production system | ISO 13485 7.5.1 |
| Electronic signatures (21 CFR Part 11) | External control — requires organizational PKI and secure audit-trail infrastructure; skills cannot provide authenticated identity or non-repudiable e-signatures | 21 CFR Part 11, Annex 11 |
| Supplier/LLM provider audits | Skills document requirements (suitability now a draft contract); auditing is an organizational activity | AS9100D 8.4 |
| IQ/configuration execution evidence for the AQMS platform | Contracts exist (SCHEMA-BACKED, draft: SYSTEM_BASELINE + IQ protocol); executing and retaining installation/configuration evidence is an organizational responsibility |
ISO 13485 4.1.6, GxP |
| Customer feedback and satisfaction | Skills have no external customer interface | ISO 9001 5.1.2, ISO 13485 7.2 |
| Employee competency and training | Skills assume a competent operator | ISO 9001 7.1.2 |
| Physical infrastructure and environment | Skills run on user-provided infrastructure | ISO 9001 7.1.3 |
| Unique Device Identification (UDI) | Design artifacts are not manufactured devices | ISO 13485 7.5.8 |
| Design transfer to manufacturing | Skills end at acceptance, not production handoff | ISO 13485 7.3.8 |
| Management review of QMS effectiveness | Requires organizational management structures | ISO 9001 9.3 |
| Agent access control enforcement | Protocol-based separation (honor system); runtime enforcement is environment-specific | ISO 27001 A.8.3 |
| Standard | Skills Posture | Compliance Level | Details |
|---|---|---|---|
| ISO 9001:2015 | Aligned (Design Phase) | 3 Compliant, 9 Partial, 2 Non-Compliant | COMP-002 |
| ISO 13485:2016 | Partial (Design Controls) | 2 Compliant, 6 Partial, 6 Non-Compliant | COMP-003 |
| AS9100D | Partial (Design + CM) | 2 Compliant, 4 Partial, 2 Non-Compliant | COMP-004 |
| ISO 27001:2022 | Aligned (Dev Controls) | 5 Compliant, 10 Partial, 2 Non-Compliant | COMP-005 |
| GxP / GAMP 5 | Aware + qualification/validation evidence (draft) | Reported by coverage label, not binary counts; V&V separated; Part 11 e-signature remains an external-control gap | COMP-006 |
For a consolidated gap-closing action plan, see COMP-007: Gap Roadmap.
| Version | Date | Author | Changes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.3 | 2026-02-21 | agile-v.org | Initial release with v1.3 audit findings |