Skip to content

Instantly share code, notes, and snippets.

@Lenormju
Last active March 22, 2023 13:26
Show Gist options
  • Select an option

  • Save Lenormju/2957dfa81e0d245a4a5822ef8ed6c234 to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.

Select an option

Save Lenormju/2957dfa81e0d245a4a5822ef8ed6c234 to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
Why BitBucket sucks (mainly compared to GitLab)

Repositories :

  • no stats on repositories and their contributors
  • there is no list of tags for a repository, you can only browse the branches graph and squint your eyes (and if the commit title is too long the tag isn't even displayed !)
  • you can't restrict write access to a repo without losing read access
  • the authorization to force-push is per-repo, not per-branch

Security :

  • the UI does not display that a commit is signed or not

Merge requests and code reviews :

  • they are called "pull requests" despite being inside the same repo
  • a pull request can be merged without its discussions adressed
    • because discussions don't have a in-progress/closed state
  • you can't know which PRs you are assigned to and have already approved, but are not yet merged
  • in a code review comment, code suggestions can only be one line long
  • you can't write a review comment farther than 10 lines from a code change
  • you can't permalink a comment on a commit, it has to be part of a review
  • image diff is only allowed for same-size image
  • you are not notified ("todo") when someone answers to you in a comment without tagging you
  • you can't submit your PR' comments in a single wave, so each PR reviewers receive a bunch of very short emails, instead of a consolidated one
  • on a PR page, the threads are listed by most recent activity, which makes it difficult to answer them all because they jump.
  • on a PR, you can't mark a file as "read", if you click on it it is automatically considered as done

UX :

  • the pages never auto-refresh. While this may look like a feature sometimes, it means that if you don't F5 regularly you won't be notified that something changed. But to be honest, I was sometimes bit by a GitLab auto-refresh bug.
  • can't simply create a branch, edit a file, commit and open a PR online.
  • if you search in a file (which is UX-horrible by the way), it ceases to display the whole file, the last few lines of the file can not be scrolled to, how ironic if they contain your search term ! Like if there was not a Ctrl+F in a browser ...

Notifications :

  • there is no recent activities page
  • you can't tune your notifications per-repo, you just have to suffer the flood if you want any notification at all

Goodies :

  • Markdown rendering does not include Latex (math) nor Mermaid
  • you can't ask to not run the pipelines (-o ci.skip), because there is none, so you can't tell simply your Kenkins not to
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment