When you sit down to my D&D game, you consent to play my games. Both the RAW B/X game, and the head games that are part and parcel of dealing with a maniac like me.
Like my second ex-wife’s ass cheeks, there a lot of overlap between the two.
You signal your consent by bellying up to the bar and drinking what I’m swilling. You can remove consent at any time by standing up and walking away.
It’s a rough system, but it works great for adults who think like adults.
These days everybody gotta be an autist. We wind up with that D&D Consent form that’s been making the rounds and everybody has offered their smoothbrain takes and identical jokes on it. Even the RPGpundit is taking a few swings at the low hanging Pinata, so you know it’s an easy target ripe for normie-tier edgelord commentary. (Remember to hit the like and subscribe, everybody! Dear God, please hit the YouTube levers for my Pavlovian dopamine hit!) As such, I’d’ve let it slide without comment, but some clever fellow did some clever digging, and it turns out that Monte Cook is just the name behind the worst thing to hit D&D since Monte Cook:
The co-writer and co-owner of Monte Cook Games is a lady named Shanna Germain. Who besides being known for helping to create the interesting Cypher System RPG, is also an author of BDSM literature.
Uh huh. Just as we all expected. I’m not even going to look up a photo of Shanna because we all know what people into BDSM look like. She’s got twenty extra pounds or weird scars or way too many tattoos (read: one). I did find a picture of her father, though:
Yeah. They’re planting this big copper bomb inside the D&D stream that flows beneath the outer wall of the Helm’s Deep that is the wider culture*. They’re going to get everybody used to consent forms for D&D now. Then they’ll move on to clicking consent forms for using social media, then for those few self-flagellants who still have and want to watch something on their Netflix accounts. Then they’ll move on to consent forms signed by children – haha, no they won’t the resistance of the children is half the fun for monsters like the people who use the D&D Consent Form.
It’s basically a Pavlovian training thing for people too dumb to realize how they are being set up to document every decision they make so that it can be used against them if they don’t toe the Line of Poz. Don’t go against the Narrative Family and you’ll be fine…

Justin Trudeau? More like Justin TruDAT, amirite?
The great news is that these consent forms are part of a head game that you don’t have to play. You don’t have to consent to use consent forms. You can withdraw consent from the whole process, but doing what so many have done to my D&D games when they behold my corpulent magnificence – just get up and walk away.
It’s just that simple. Get up. Walk away.
*I love metaphors like a fat kid loves literally anything with too much grease or too much sugar. Or like a Democrat loves pedophilia.
Being the contemplative and intelligent sort of guy who prefers Real D&D to today’s Ersatz D&D, something about that line stuck in my old man turkey gizzard craw, and I think I know what it is.
Which is as it should be. Played right, D&D should be difficult. Characters should die early and often. Coddling them removes the challenge and makes the game as interactive as watching Netflix videos. It occurs to me as I type this that banning meta-knowledge is a cheap and lazy way of trying to inject a little challenge into the game – a way to replace the challenge removed by sanitizing everything. Even those who eschew remove 1HP characters, nerf saving throw difficulties, and install death saves (shudder), recognize that the game has taken on a bland and predictable nature. They can’t go back to the thrill of the capricious dice, though – such would be to admit they are wrong and your well-hung host is right – so they try to find other avenues that allow them the freedom to dance through the statistical raindrops while feeling like they have challenges before them.
Somewhere along the lines somebody stupid got it into their pea-brain that there’s a separation between what a character knows and what a player knows and it’s one of the most pernicious and fun-killing unspoken rules of the modern day table.




It’s great to hear the latest gaming bowel movement is an open community movement. Count me in! After two of my online alts had their YouseTubes vidyas shut down in the Adpocalypse Two Point Oh-No! I’ve been feeling pretty left out. To help, I even made this perfectly suitable new logo for this latest tabletop gaming enema. I even made sure to make it Woke Capitalism Approved for the anti-Capitalists out there.

You must be logged in to post a comment.