Elsa Costa

Fulbright University Vietnam, History, Faculty Member

Followers

Following

Public Views

Elsa Costa, Assistant Professor of History, Fulbright University Vietnam. PhD in History, Duke University. Focus on, among other subjects, Spain in the Renaissance and Enlightenment, economic change, racialization, reformist literature, raison d'état, utopianism, Christian humanism and Platonism, biblical and legal philology, medieval and modern theories of kingship, absolute and imperial sovereignty.
Supervisors: John French, Malachi Hacohen, Elvira Vilches, and Jehangir Malegam

less

Catherine Jaffe

Texas State University

Mónica Bolufer Peruga

European University Institute

Laura Guinot Ferri

Universitat de València

Ana Sánchez-Rojo

Tulane University

Nuria Valverde Pérez

Universidad Autonoma Metropolitana

Esther Schomacher

Humboldt Universität zu Berlin

Nicolas Duriau

University of Oxford

Maria Valderez De Colletes Negreiros

Universidade Estadual Paulista "Júlio de Mesquita Filho"

Victor Garcia Gonzalez

Universidad de Málaga

Sara Muniain Ederra

InterestsView All (26)

Uploads

Book Reviews by Elsa Costa

Against Abstraction: Notes from an Ex-Latin Americanist by Alberto Moreiras (review)

The Latin Americanist, 2023

Download

Idolatry and the Construction of the Spanish Empire by Mina García Soormally (review)

The Latin Americanist, 2021

Download

Jerónimo Antonio Gil and the Idea of the Spanish Enlightenment by Kelly Donahue-Wallace (review)

The Latin Americanist, 2019

Download

Papers by Elsa Costa

Against Reason: Juan Pablo Forner and the Enlightenment of Sentiment and Sensibility

Journal for Eighteenth-Century Studies, 2024

This article explores Spain's positioning in the shifting currents of the later Enlightenment thr... more This article explores Spain's positioning in the shifting currents of the later Enlightenment through the polemic works of lawyer and satirist Juan Pablo Forner. Forner's attempts to prove the existence of an autochthonous tradition of Spanish pragmatism and empiricism form an index of the penetration of intra-Enlightenment debates into Spanish thought in the late eighteenth century. Forner, profoundly aware of tensions between Cartesian rationalism and Lockean sentimental empiricism across Europe, intervenes on the side of empiricism, insisting that Cartesianism is nothing but a guise of Scholastic hyperrationalism. The article disputes scholarly perceptions of Forner as a Christian reactionary.

Download

When the angels played: monadology and divine absconsion in Walter Benjamin

Le interpretazioni di Walter Benjamin si estendono dall'estremo di considerarlo l'ultimo ... more Le interpretazioni di Walter Benjamin si estendono dall'estremo di considerarlo l'ultimo significativo uomo di lettere del periodo precedente alla seconda guerra mondiale fino all'estremo opposto di ritenerlo un rabbino hassidico. C'è accordo sul fatto che circa dal 1916-1920 Benjamin fu interessato alla teologia e alla metafisica ebraica e cristiana e che dal 1925 circa fino alla sua morte nel 1940 fu apertamente marxista e giunse fino alla quasi esclusione della metafisica. L'articolo individua le ambiguità della cosmologia teistica del primo Benjamin, sostenendo che l'instabilità intrinseca delle sue considerazioni, specialmente su linguaggio, giudizio e allegoria, lo ha costretto ad abbandonare il platonismo giovanile e ad abbracciare una cosmologia in cui Dio è nascosto. Proprio come i primi atei si ispirarono alla speculazione di Duns Scoto secondo il quale un triangolo avrebbe avuto ancora tre angoli in un universo in cui Dio non esistesse, la visione ...

Download

“But I Want the Truth!” The Legacy of Martial Gueroult in São Paulo Philosophy, 1935-2018

A Contracorriente, 2021

Not long after the founding of the University of São Paulo (USP) philosophy department in 1935, B... more Not long after the founding of the University of São Paulo (USP) philosophy department in 1935, Brazilian philosophy students found themselves entranced by “the Method,” a system of logical formalism pioneered by French philosophers Martial Gueroult and Victor Goldschmidt. Its rise was seemingly unstoppable, and by the late 1950s the Method was seen as the only way to write about philosophy at USP. This article examines the rise, fall, and resurgence of the Method at USP through its influence on the lives and oeuvres of three renowned USP philosophers: José Arthur Giannotti, Marilena Chauí, and Paulo Arantes. A dozen other Brazilian and French philosophers are consulted as necessary. Although the initial reception of Gueroultian teaching was euphoric, its problematic aspects soon became apparent. The pessimism of the Method with respect to the possibility of creating philosophy, rather than writing about it, dismayed many. Its insistence upon an arbitrary but unassailable canon disappointed others, while its dismissal of external reality weighed heavy on still other consciences. It also became apparent that Gueroult and Goldschmidt did not enjoy the same unchallenged reputation in France as they did at USP. With the inauguration of the interdisciplinary Marx Seminar of 1958-1964, national concerns and the possibility of Brazilian particularity enjoyed a brief dominance over Gueroultian universalism. During the military dictatorship of 1964-1985, which purged most faculty members in 1968, the USP faculty reoriented itself to admit historical context into its scope. This did not address many of the major problems with the Method, including canonical selection and Gueroult’s declaration of the end of philosophy. Only after the end of the Cold War did some faculty members begin to challenge the Method’s precepts, although the canonical provisions of the Method remain hegemonic at USP today.

Download

When the Angels Played: Monadology and Divine Absconsion in Walter Benjamin

Doctor Virtualis, 2020

Interpretations of Walter Benjamin have ranged from the last pre-war man of letters to a Hasidic ... more Interpretations of Walter Benjamin have ranged from the last pre-war man of letters to a Hasidic rabbi. There is consensus that from roughly 1916-1920 Benjamin was interested in Jewish and Christian theology and metaphysics and that from about 1925 to his death in 1940 he was vocally Marxist to the near exclusion of metaphysics. This article identifies ambiguities in Benjamin’s early, theistic cosmology, arguing that the inherent instability of Benjamin’s accounts especially of language, judgment and allegory compelled him to discard his early Platonism and embrace a cosmology in which God is abscondite. Just as early atheists took inspiration from Duns Scotus’s speculation that a triangle would still have three angles in a universe in which God does not exist, Benjamin’s vision of a world abandoned by God led him, over the course of the 1920s, into atheistic materialism. When the materialist Benjamin continued, despite himself, to encounter divine traces and teleology in his literary excursions, he concluded that he had to chase God even further from his creation in order for humanity to perceive the latter as it really was. This state of affairs continued until the last year of Benjamin’s life, during which he chose to embrace theology as the hidden spirit lurking within the letter of historical materialism.

Download

Against Abstraction: Notes from an Ex-Latin Americanist by Alberto Moreiras (review)

The Latin Americanist, 2023

Download

Idolatry and the Construction of the Spanish Empire by Mina García Soormally (review)

The Latin Americanist, 2021

Download

Jerónimo Antonio Gil and the Idea of the Spanish Enlightenment by Kelly Donahue-Wallace (review)

The Latin Americanist, 2019

Download

Against Reason: Juan Pablo Forner and the Enlightenment of Sentiment and Sensibility

Journal for Eighteenth-Century Studies, 2024