Suicide attack
This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page. (Learn how and when to remove these messages)
|
| Part of a series on |
| Suicide |
|---|
A suicide attack (also known by a wide variety of other names, see below) is a deliberate attack in which the perpetrators intentionally end their own lives as part of the attack. These attacks are a form of murder–suicide that is often associated with terrorism or war. When the attackers are labelled as terrorists, the attacks are sometimes referred to as an act of suicide terrorism.[1] Military use of suicide is not directly regulated by international law, but suicide attacks sometimes violate prohibitions against perfidy or targeting civilians.[2] Suicide attacks have occurred in various contexts, ranging from military campaigns—such as the Japanese kamikaze pilots during World War II (1944–1945)—to more contemporary Islamic terrorist campaigns—including the September 11 attacks in 2001. Suicide attacks have been used by a wide range of political ideologies, from far-right (Japan and Germany in WWII) to far-left (such as the PKK and JRA).[3][4]
Definition and terminology
[edit]Kamikaze
[edit]Kamikaze was a term initially used for Japanese suicide pilots in World War II, but is occasionally used in other contexts.
For example, the 1972 Lod Airport massacre in Israel by the Japanese Red Army (JRA) was labelled by some reports at the time a "Kamikaze" attack, but others have criticized the label, including the surviving attacker's interpreter.[5][6] The Kamikaze were a unit of suicide bombers of the Empire of Japan in WWII, which had a very different ideology to the JRA. Researchers from Duke University described the JRA's motives as "rooted in anti-imperialism, anti-colonialism, and anti-capitalism".[7] In more recent reports the 1972 JRA attack on Lod airport is described in modern terms such as "suicide attack" and "suicide mission", even when referring to the attacker who survived.[4] All three militants intended to die, but one survived.[4] He confessed and hoped to be quickly executed, but some attribute this to retrospective "survivor guilt".[8]
Suicide bombing
[edit]The term "suicide bombing" dates back to at least 1940 when a New York Times article mentioned the term in relation to German tactics.[9][non-primary source needed] Less than two years later, the New York Times referred to a Japanese kamikaze attempt on an American carrier as a "suicide bombing".[10] In 1945, The Times of London referred to a kamikaze plane as a "suicide-bomb".[11] Two years later, it referred to a new British pilot-less, radio-controlled rocket missile as originally designed "as a counter-measure to the Japanese 'suicide-bomber'."[12]
Labelling attacks as suicide
[edit]The definition of "suicide" in this context is also a matter of debate.
Suicide terrorism itself has been defined by Ami Pedahzur, a professor at the University of Haifa,[13] as "violent actions perpetrated by people who are aware that the odds they will return alive are close to zero".[14] Other sources exclude from their work "suicidal" or high risk attacks, such as the Lod Airport massacre or a "reckless charge in battle".[15][16] Despite the Lod Airport massacre being explicitly planned as a suicide attack, and modern mainstream Israeli and international media describing the event as a "suicide attack" or "suicide mission".[4] Yoram Schweitzer, from the International Institute for Counter-Terrorism (an Israeli think tank), focuses only on true "suicide attacks", where the odds of survival are not "close to zero" but required to be zero, because "the perpetrator's ensured death is a precondition for the success of his mission".[15]
The narrower definition would also exclude the actions of groups such as those by the Hashishiyeen, by the Moro juramentado, and in Aceh during WWII (see below). Adam Lankford also excludes from the definition are "proxy bombings", which may have political goals and be designed to look like a suicide bombing. The difference is that the "proxy" is forced to carry a bomb under threat, or the proxy isn't fully aware that they are delivering a bomb that will kill them. The definition also generally excludes mass shootings in which the perpetrators commit suicide, as the shooter committing suicide is a separate act from shooting their victims.
Further distinction is how many of such shootings are driven by personal and psychological reasons, rather than political, social or religious motives, such as the Columbine High School massacre, the Virginia Tech shooting or Sandy Hook Elementary School shooting in the United States.[17][better source needed] However, in 1999 the Columbine High School massacre was widely labelled as a suicide attack: both attackers shot themselves, but they planned the attack as a bombing.[18][19] It is also a common trope that Muslim attackers are defined as terrorists while others are defined as mentally ill.
It may not always be clear to investigators which type of killing is which, since suicide attack campaigns sometimes use proxy bombers, as alleged in Iraq,[20] or manipulate the vulnerable to become bombers.[16][21] Adam Lankford, also argues that the motivation to kill and be killed connects some suicide attackers more closely to "suicidal rampage" murderers than is commonly thought.[17]
Religious terminology for attackers and victims
[edit]All Abrahamic religions forbid suicide.[22][23] Suicide and suicide attempts have been decriminalised in most of the western world, but remain criminalised in some countries, such as Afghanistan,[24] Nigeria,[25] Palestine,[26] and others.[27][28][29] Terminology relating to this sin or crime is used by Jews, Christians, and Muslims to condemn suicide attackers (see also above), different terminology is usually used to describe self sacrifice that they believe is justified, including actions their enemies label suicide attacks (see below).
Martyrdom of attackers and victims
[edit]Among Muslims, secular Arabs, and related cultures, the term martyr or shaheed has a broad meaning and can refer to leaders who have been assassinated or executed, civilian casualties of war, and combatants who did not intend to die.[30]
Victims of suicide bombings and the bombers are both commonly referred to as martyrs, by opposing groups, or when referring to different attacks. Some Arabic speaking militant groups and their supporters call suicide attacks "martyrdom operations" (Arabic: للعمليات الاستشهادية, romanized: aleamaliaat alistishhadia).[31] The concept of martyrdom in Islam is broad including people who died in plagues and women who died in childbirth, as well as fallen combatants who did not intend to die.[32] According to Israeli academic Assaf Moghadam, the term "martyrdom operation" has been used by Hamas, Al-Aqsa Martyrs' Brigades, Fatah's Al Aqsa Martyrs Brigades, and other Palestinian factions.[33][verification needed] The term "martyrdom operation" was also used in March 2003 by the Iraqi administration to refer to suicide attacks on invading troops during the 2003 Iraq war, and in particular their promise to retake the Baghdad airport.[citation needed]
Victims of suicide attacks are also referred to as martyrs by a wide variety of cultures. Benazir Bhutto, the leader of the Pakistan People's Party, is the most famous example of a progressive Muslim who is regarded as a martyr after being murdered in a suicide attack. Bhutto was assassinated in 2007 by a teenage Islamic extremist.[34][35] After her death, many things in Pakistan, mostly related to education, were named or renamed in her honour, referring to her by the title "shaheed" (martyr).[b]
When an ISIS-inspired suicide bomber blew himself up at Rafah crossing in 2017, he was described by locals and in Arabic package media as a suicide bomber (Arabic: فجر انتحاري or الانتحاري), not a martyr.[36][37][c] The border guard who was killed attempting to stop him crossing into Egypt, a member of Hamas' Qassam Brigades, was described in official statements and Arabic language media as a martyr (Arabic: الشهيد نضال الجعفري, romanized: al-Shaheed Nidal al-Jaafari) and he became a martyr (Arabic: استشهاد, romanized: Istishhad, Arabic: استشهاد نضال جمعة, lit. 'Martyrdom of Nidal al-Jaafari').[38][39][40], some international media, and the bomber's family. His family condemned him, describing ISIS member's action as completely criminal and anti-Palestine, and announced they would not be holding funeral services for the ISIS suicide-bomber.[41][39] Gaza's clans referred to the bombing as suicide terrorism (Arabic: العمل الإرهابي الانتحاري).[41] The bomber was also posthumously disowned by family, who announced they would be holding no funeral.[42][43]
Biblical references
[edit]
In Israel, Samson's words, in Judges 16:30 (Hebrew: תמות נפשי עם פלשתים, lit. 'let me die with the Philistines', Biblical Hebrew: תָּמוֹת נַפְשִׁי עִם-פְּלִשְׁתִּים).[47][48][49], are quoted as a justification for acts of self sacrifice in battle. The same biblical quote is cited in both praise and criticism of this approach to warfare.[47][50] Prior to the establishment of the State of Israel, this story was cited by two of the anti-British pre-state militant groups in reference to their premeditated plans.[51] One leader claimed that two militants who blew themselves up had not committed suicide, as such, due to allegedly mitigating circumstances.[52][53] Their modern critics claim the situation itself was largely self-inflicted.[54]
Some within Israel view the Samson in a very negative light.[55] People from Christian backgrounds, or people who live within majority-Christian communities, have carried out suicide attacks in Eastern Europe, Lebanon, the United States, New Zealand, and elsewhere (see below). They have usually not used religious language to explain or justify their actions. Most have been members or supporters of secular movements, or they have perpetrated isolated attacks and they did not give lengthy reasons as to why they perpetrated the attacks.[56][57][58][citation needed] However, in 1959 in Houston, Texas, Paul Harold Orgeron reportedly mentioned "the will of God" before detonating a suitcase bomb that killed himself and 5 other people at Poe Elementary School.[59]
Non-Abrahamic religions
[edit]Kuyili – who killed herself in a suicide attack in 1780, see below – is revered as Theepaanchi Amman, meaning "the goddess who jumped into fire", in Muthupatti village near Sivagangai, Tamil Nadu, based on local oral traditions.[60][61]
Opferanschlag (sacrifice bombing)
[edit]In German-speaking areas the term "sacrifice bombing" (German: Opferanschlag) was proposed in 2012 by German scholar Arata Takeda.[62] This is different from the German word used by Nazi Germany to refer to self sacrifice attacks.[citation needed]
Labelling attacks as terrorism
[edit]| Part of a series on |
| Terrorism |
|---|
Suicide attacks include both "suicide terrorism" and attacks targeting combatants. "Terrorism" is often defined as any action "intended to cause death or serious bodily harm to civilians or non-combatants" for the purpose of intimidation.[63] This definition is often not used consistently; even those claiming to define terrorism this way sometimes describe attacks on their own military as "terrorism", while attacks on civilians by allied state actors are almost never called terrorism.[64]
An alternative definition provided by Jason Burke, a journalist who has lived among Islamic militants, suggests that most define terrorism as "the use or threat of serious violence" to advance some kind of "cause", stressing that terrorism is a tactic.[65] This definition is often referred to by the euphemism "political violence".[66][67]
Academic Fred Halliday has written that assigning the descriptor of "terrorist" or "terrorism" to the actions of a group is a tactic used by states to deny "legitimacy" and "rights to protest and rebel".[68] Israeli diplomacy has been very influential in defining terrorism as a concept.[64][69][70] This was largely led by Menachem Begin, who himself has been labelled as a terrorist leader, as commander of the Irgun militant group before Israel was recognized as a nation state by Western powers.[69][70]
Homicide bombing
[edit]Some efforts have been made to replace the term "suicide bombing" with "homicide bombing", based on the assertion that "homicide" is a more apt adjective than "suicide" since the primary purpose of such a bombing is to kill other people. The only major media outlets to use it were the Fox News Channel and the New York Post, both of which are owned by News Corporation and have since mostly abandoned the term.[71][72] Robert Goldney, a professor emeritus at the University of Adelaide, has argued in favor of the term "homicide bomber". Goldney argued that studies show that there is little in common between people who blow themselves up intending to kill as many people as possible in the process and actual suicide victims.[73] Fox News producer Dennis Murray argued that a suicidal act should be reserved for a person who does something to kill only themselves. CNN producer Christa Robinson argued that the term "homicide bomber" was not specific enough, stating that "A homicide bomber could refer to someone planting a bomb in a trash can".[33][74][75]
Background
[edit]Initially, these attacks primarily targeted military, police, and public officials. This approach continued with groups like Al-Qaeda, which combined mass civilian targets with political leadership.[1] While only a few suicide attacks occurred between 1945 and 1980,[76] between 1981 and September 2015 a total of 4,814 suicide attacks were carried out in over 40 countries,[77] resulting in over 45,000 deaths. The global frequency of these attacks increased from an average of three per year in the 1980s to roughly one per month in the 1990s, almost one per week from 2001 to 2003,[78] and roughly one per day from 2003 to 2015.[77] In 2019, there were 149 suicide bombings in 24 countries, carried out by 236 individuals. These attacks resulted in 1,850 deaths and 3,660 injuries.[79]
Related actions
[edit]Suicide protests
[edit]Suicide is sometimes used as an extreme act of protest, without intent to cause tangible damage to the opponent.[80] Romas Kalanta was a 19-year-old Lithuanian student who self-immolated in 1972 to protest against the Soviet regime in Lithuania, sparking the 1972 unrest in Lithuania; another 13 people self-immolated in that same year.[81][additional citation(s) needed] Hunger strikes are another use of self harm, and actual or potential suicide, that is used by some militant groups.[examples needed]
Self-sacrifice to prevent other casualties
[edit]This section may be too long or excessively detailed. (September 2025) |
During the 2006 Lebanon War, IDF Major Roi Klein and his unit took part in the Battle of Bint Jbeil. During a Hezbollah ambush, a hand grenade was thrown over the wall that was between Hezbollah militants and Klein and his unit. Klein jumped on the live grenade and muffled the explosion with his body. The soldiers reported that Klein recited the Jewish prayer, Shema Yisrael, as he jumped on the grenade. He then handed over his encoded radio to another officer, who took command of the force, and died.[82][83][84][85][86] According to The Telegraph he yelled "Long live Israel",[87] although this was probably a misinterpretation of "Shema Yisrael" (שמע ישראל).[88]
Preventing capture
[edit]During the First Jewish–Roman War, the letter of the Sicarii determined that the people in the besieged city of Masada should commit mass suicide, and even murder family members, to avoid capture during the Siege of Masada.[55] The story of Masada is prominent in Israeli culture.[55] The Sicarii Jewish sect are also sometimes described as carrying out "suicidal" attacks against their enemies (see below).[89]
Other than as a way to cause enemy casualties, another situation in which some militaries and related bodies (such as intelligence agencies) encourage their own members to commit suicide is to avoid being captured by the enemy. The concept also often includes the use of intentional friendly fire.[50] Either to avoid disclose of military secrets, avoid the need for a prisoner exchange, or for more intangible ideological motives.[89] Individuals are encouraged by a perception that capture is a fate worse than death, and the likelihood of torture is strongly emphasised in internal propaganda. Sometimes, to the point that even civilians embrace the concept of dying (or killing people on their own side) to avoid capture.[90][91]
In some cases, special forces of Western militaries have been provided with suicide pills to take if they are at risk of capture.[92][93] Some militaries of nation states avoid equipping their troops with any means specifically designed to facilitate suicide, but imply that soldiers are obliged to resort to extreme measures to avoid capture including taking their own lives, or killing their comrades, with whatever means are available.[50][94][95] Hand grenades have been repeatedly used or recommended.[96][50] In 1952, three Chinese soldiers reportedly killed themselves with hand grenades to avoid capture.[96][additional citation(s) needed] Military commanders have reportedly recommended explosives such as hand grenades as a means of suicide, for the advantage of killing as many of the would-be captors as possible, thus converting the situation into an improvised suicide attack.[50]
Attackers killed by their opponents
[edit]Some sources define "suicide terrorism" and "suicide attack" broadly to include attackers who are killed by other people.[97] At the opposite extreme, militant leaders of from Jewish or Islamic militant groups – both religions that forbid suicide – claim that directly causing one's own death sometimes is not suicide (see above: suicide and religious terminology). However, followers of these religiously derived ideologies define their enemies as suicidal, even if their opponent uses the same technique, such as when an ISIS-linked suicide bomber killed al-Qassam border guard Nidal al-Jaafari at Rafah crossing (see above). During the colonial era and up to World War II, Muslims in Aceh and Moro, now part of Indonesia and the Philippines, attacked much more powerful opponents – principally the Dutch, the Japanese, and the Americans – despite near certain death. Some authors have characterised these as predecessors of modern suicide bombings.[98] Other sources say that suicide bombings in places like the Philippines arrose only recently, due to foreign influence from international cultists such as ISIS.[99][100][101]
Sicarii (first century AD)
[edit]The Sicarii Jewish sect are sometimes described as carrying out "suicidal" attacks against their enemies. Riaz Hassan said that the first-century AD Jewish Sicarii sect carried out "suicidal missions to kill" Hellenized Jews they considered immoral collaborators.[89] An article in BBC Arabic originally called the Sicarii the first group to carry out suicide attacks.[additional citation(s) needed] In September 2023, over a year after initial publication, this attracted controversy in English language Israeli media, when a complaint led to a change in the article.[102][103] The Jerusalem Post classified the article under "antisemtitism".[102] The Sicarii sect play a central role in Israeli mythology.[55] The Sicarii killed themselves and their families to avoid capture (see above), but in their attacks they were killed by their opponents.[55] The Sicarii carried out attacks knowing it would lead to their own executions.[102] The revised BBC article claimed the first suicide attacks were by the Order of Assassins, who are also killed by their opponents (see next section).[102][103]
Order of Assassins (1090 to 1275)
[edit]The Order of Assassins (Arabic: حَشّاشِین, romanized: Hashishiyeen; Persian: حشاشين, romanized: Ḥaššāšīn) were from a sect of Ismaili Shi'a Muslims. They assassinated two Caliphs, as well as many viziers, Sultans, and Crusade leaders over 300 years,[when?][104] before being annihilated by Mongol invaders. Hashishiyeen were known for targeting the powerful, using the dagger as a weapon (rather than something safer for the assassin such as a crossbow), and for not attempting to escape after completing their killing.[105]
Moro juramentado
[edit]Juramentado, in Philippine history, refers to a male Moro swordsman (from the Tausug tribe of Sulu) who attacked and killed targeted occupying and invading police and soldiers. Death was expected, and considered martyrdom, undertaken as a form of jihad.[106][107][108][109][110][verification needed]
Moro people who performed suicide attacks were called mag-sabil, and the suicide attacks were known as parang-sabil.[111] The Spanish called them juramentados. The idea of the juramentado was considered part of jihad in the Moros' Islamic religion. During an attack, a juramentado would throw himself at his targets and kill them with bladed weapons such as barongs and kris until he was killed. The Moros performed juramentado suicide attacks against the Spanish in the Spanish–Moro conflict of the 16th to the 19th centuries, against the Americans in the Moro Rebellion from 1899 to 1913), and against the Japanese in World War II.[112]
The Moro (Spanish: juramentados) launched suicide[verification needed] attacks on the Japanese, Spanish, Americans and Filipinos, but did not attack the non-Muslim Chinese as the Chinese were not considered enemies of the Moro people.[113][114][115][116][117] The Japanese responded to these suicide attacks by massacring all known family members and relatives of the attackers.[118]
According to historian Stephan Dale, the Moro were not the only culture who carried out suicide attacks "in their fight against Western hegemony and colonial rule". In the 18th century, suicide tactics were used on the Malabar Coast of southwestern India, and in Aceh in Northern Sumatra as well (see above).[15][119][clarification needed]
Aceh War (1873–1904)
[edit]Muslim Acehnese from the Aceh Sultanate performed suicide attacks known as parang-sabil against Dutch invaders during the Aceh War (1873–1904).[verification needed] It was considered part of personal jihad in Islam. The Dutch called it Atjèh-moord, (lit. Aceh murder).[120][121][122] The Acehnese work of literature the Hikayat Perang Sabil provided the background and reasoning for the Atjèh-moord as Acehnese suicide attacks upon the Dutch.[123][124][125][verification needed] The Indonesian translations of the Dutch terms are Aceh bodoh, Aceh pungo, Aceh gila, or Aceh mord.[126]
Aceh in WWII
[edit]Atjèh-moord was also used against the Japanese by the Acehnese during the Japanese occupation of Aceh.[127] The Acehnese Ulama (Islamic Scholars) fought against both the Dutch and the Japanese, revolting against the Dutch in February 1942 and against Japan in November 1942. The revolt was led by the All-Aceh Religious Scholars' Association (PUSA). The Japanese suffered 18 dead in the uprising while they slaughtered either up to 100 or over 120 Acehnese.[128][129] The revolt happened in Bayu and was centred around Tjot Plieng village's religious school.[130][131][132][133] During the revolt, the Japanese troops armed with mortars and machine guns were charged by sword wielding Acehnese under Teungku Abduldjalil (Tengku Abdul Djalil) in Buloh Gampong Teungah on 10 November and Tjot Plieng on 13 November.[134][135] In May 1945 the Acehnese rebelled again.[136]
Disposable use of troops during WWI and WWII
[edit]Supreme Allied Commander Lord Mountbatten claimed high casualties were justified during the Dieppe Raid, "For every man that died at Dieppe, ten were saved on D-Day".[93][137] From one frito of twelve (11 Canadians and one British), only two returned alive, the others were killed or captured.[92] One of the survivors was a British radar expert, who had been given a cyanide pill to take if he was captured.[92]
Suicide by cop
[edit]Suicide by cop, also known as suicide by police or law-enforcement-assisted suicide,[138] is a term used to define a death, intended as suicide, for which a person attempts to provoke police. The phenomenon, as described in some sources, involves an allegedly suicidal person deliberately behaving in a threatening manner with intent to provoke law enforcement to kill them.[139] The concept arose in the United States.[140] The terminology has now spread to other places such as Canada, Australia, and non-English-speaking countries such as Austria.[141][142]
First suicide attacks (attackers who killed themselves)
[edit]Several different events have been described as the first suicide attack in different sources.[143][144]
The oldest story that is widely described as a suicide attack in modern sources is the biblical story of Samson's destruction of the Philistine temple in Gaza in Judges 16:30.[145][146][147][148] A study by German scholar Arata Takeda analyzes analogous behavior represented in literary texts from the antiquity through the 20th century, these being Ajax, Samson Agonistes, The Robbers, and The Just Assassins. The study concluded "that suicide bombings are not the expressions of specific cultural peculiarities or exclusively religious fanaticisms. Instead, they represent a strategic option of the desperately weak who strategically disguise themselves under the mask of apparent strength, terror, and invincibility".[148][147] Other writers have also interpreted Samson's death as a suicide attack.[149][150][151]
An article in BBC Arabic claimed the Sicarii were the first group to carry out suicide attacks. In September 2023 the BBC responded to a complaint, deleted the Sicarii and reworded the second example so that the revised article called the Order of Assassins (Ismaeli Shia) the first.[102][103] However, both groups were killed by their opponents (see above).
Arnold von Winkelried (1386 in Switzerland)
[edit]Arnold von Winkelried was considered a hero in the Swiss struggle for independence for sacrificing himself at the Battle of Sempach in 1386.[citation needed]
Kuyili (1780 in India)
[edit]In 1780, an Indian woman named Kuyili applied ghee and oil onto her body and set herself ablaze. She then jumped into an armoury of the East India Company, causing it to explode. This suicide attack helped to secure victory for her queen, Velu Nachiyar, in the battle.[152][143][144][153][154] Historical evidence about her life is scarce, relying primarily on folk songs and oral histories due to her marginalized Arunthathiyar or Sambavar background.[155]
17th- and 19th-century Dutch
[edit]In the late 17th century, Qing official Yu Yonghe recorded that injured Dutch soldiers fighting against Koxinga's forces for control of Taiwan in 1661 would use gunpowder to blow up both themselves and their opponents rather than be taken prisoner.[156] However, Yu may have confused such suicidal tactics with the standard Dutch military practice of undermining and blowing up overrun positions, which almost cost Koxinga his life during the Siege of Fort Zeelandia.[157]
On 5 February 1831, during the Belgian Revolution, a gale blew a Dutch gunboat under the command of Jan van Speyk into the quay of the port of Antwerp. As the ship was stormed by Belgians, van Speyk refused to surrender, instead igniting the ship's gunpowder with either his gun or cigar, blowing up the ship. The explosion killed 28 out of the 31 crewmen and an unknown number of Belgians.[158][additional citation(s) needed]
Ignaty Grinevitsky (1881) and others in Russia
[edit]A Russian man named Ignaty Grinevitsky (also spelled: Ignacy Hryniewiecki) is sometimes described as the first known suicide bomber.[159][160] The invention of dynamite in the 1860s presented revolutionary and terrorist groups in Europe with a weapon nearly 20 times more powerful than gunpowder. However, using dynamite required overcoming the technical challenges of detonating it at the right time. One solution was to use a human trigger, which was the technique used to assassinate Tsar Alexander II of Russia in 1881.[159][161] A would-be suicide bomber killed Russian Minister of the Interior Vyacheslav von Plehve, in St Petersburg in 1904, but survived with major injuries.[162]